Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Legal Opinion Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, M/s. Fixopan Engineers (P) Limited, was awarded a rate contract by the defendants for the supply of high density polythene pipes for potable water for the period 1 October 1983 to 30 September 1984. The contract contained Clause 24 providing for arbitration, and stated that if the value of claims in a reference exceeded Rs. One lakh the arbitrator "shall give reasoned awards."

Disputes under the contract were referred to a sole arbitrator (Sh. S.B. Sharan). The arbitrator passed an award dated 23 April 1998. That award was filed in the court (registered as Suit No. 1828/1998). Prior to the filing of the award, the objector (the plaintiff in the review context) had instituted Suit No. 1048/1998 under Sections 14 and 17 of the Arbitration Act seeking a direction that the sole arbitrator file the award in court. Both suits were listed together for hearing and disposed of by the judgment summarized here.

The objector served notice of filing (allegedly on 8 October 1998) and filed objections to the award within the stipulated time. The objections alleged, broadly, that the arbitrator did not give reasons required by the contract for claims exceeding Rs. 1 lakh, that the officer who placed supply orders lacked financial competence, that the award was not reasoned and conflicted with the terms of reference and agreement, that the arbitrator misconducted proceedings by mischaracterizing correspondence, that respondents who accepted advantages could not deny validity of the agreement, and that the award suffered from errors of law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the arbitrator complied with Clause 24 of the contract which required a reasoned award for claims exceeding Rs. One lakh, and if not, whether the award (or part of it) should be set aside or remitted for proper reasoning.
  2. Whether the court may or should re-appraise evidence or otherwise interfere with the arbitrator's findings given the limited scope of judicial review of arbitral awards.
  3. Whether the Executive Engineer (the officer who placed the supply orders) had financial competence to place those orders so as to bind the Kerala Water Authority, and whether contracts/orders placed by that officer could be invalidated on that ground.
  4. Whether any part of the award is severable (i.e., capable of being set aside while leaving the rest intact) and, if so, what the appropriate remedial step should be.

Arguments of the Parties

Objector's Arguments (Plaintiff challenging the award)

  • The arbitrator was obliged by the contract to give reasons for granting or refusing any claim in excess of Rs. 1 lakh, but no such reasoning was recorded.
  • The Executive Engineer who awarded and placed orders lacked financial competence to place such orders; the arbitrator should have taken into account Instruction No. 2 issued for "Direct Demanding Officers" which the department regularly followed.
  • The award was not a reasoned award and conflicted with the terms of reference and the contract.
  • The arbitrator mischaracterized a letter dated 8 March 1984, treating it as a cancellation order rather than a declaration that orders were placed illegally and were null and void.
  • Respondents having received advantages under the agreement could not later challenge the validity of the agreement; the arbitrator erred in law by not giving the objector the advantage of this position.
  • The award suffered from errors of law generally.
  • On jurisdiction and principle, reliance was placed (for the proposition that contracts beyond authority cannot bind Government) on Article 299 of the Constitution and various precedents (these were cited to argue the contract might be invalid if placed beyond authority).

Respondents' / Union's Arguments

  • The Union of India (respondents) contended that the court's jurisdiction to re-appraise evidence and substitute its view for the arbitrator's is limited; the learned counsel relied on the Supreme Court's decision in The Upper Ganges Valley Electricity Supply Co. Ltd. v. U.P. Electricity Board and a prior decision of this Court (Anand Brothers Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India) to support the proposition that interference should be circumspect and limited.
  • Kerala Water Authority contended that the claims had been allowed by the arbitrator without recording any reasons, and therefore the award (or part of it) was vulnerable to challenge.
  • The respondents (as represented in argument summarized by the court) did not provide record evidence to show the contractor was or should have been aware of any financial limit on the demanding officer's authority; respondents' counsel could not point to arbitrator's record establishing that limitation was known to the contractor.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
The Upper Ganges Valley Electricity Supply Co. Ltd. v. The U.P. Electricity Board, (1973) 1 SCC 254 : AIR 1973 SC 683 Limits on the court's jurisdiction to re-appraise evidence in arbitration matters; principle of severability of parts of an award. The court relied on this decision to explain restricted review jurisdiction and to hold that the award was severable — permitting the court to set aside the unreasoned part (damages) while leaving the remainder intact.
Anand Brothers Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 71 (1998) DLT 698 : 1998 (1) Arb. LR 290 (Del.) Used in support of the proposition that courts should be cautious in setting aside arbitral awards and that review power is limited. Cited by respondents' counsel and noted by the court as supportive of the proposition that judicial interference should be circumspect.
Jajodia (Overseas) Pvt. Ltd. v. Industrial Development Corporation of Orissa Ltd., (1993) 2 SCC 106 : 1993 (1) Arb. LR 334 (SC) Definition/requirement of a "speaking" or reasoned award — mere answers to issues without reasons do not constitute a reasoned award; guidance on setting aside awards that lack required reasoning. The court relied on Jajodia to hold that the arbitrator's limited statements did not amount to a speaking award and therefore the part of the award without reasoning merited interference (set aside and remitted for reasons).
Raipur Development Authority v. Chokhamal Contractors, (1989) 2 SCC 721 : 1989 (1) Arb. LR 430 (SC) Consistent authority on requirement of reasoned awards and circumstances when awards may be set aside. Referenced by the court as part of the consistent jurisprudence underscoring that an award required to be reasoned cannot merely state conclusions.
Union of India v. V.K. Bahri, AIR 1980 Delhi 265 Referenced as part of consistent authority related to awards and reasoning. Cited in the cluster of cases relied upon by the objector to show that lack of reasoning invalidates an award required to be reasoned.
Brijpal Singh v. State of Gujarat, (1984) 4 SCC 59 Authority relied upon by the arbitrator in computing or supporting the damages awarded. The arbitrator expressly referred to this decision as the basis for the damages claim; the court recorded that the arbitrator cited this judgment when awarding damages.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Murari Lal and Brothers Ltd., (1971) 2 SCC 449 Authority cited in connection with the proposition that a contract entered into without authority may not bind the Government (Article 299 implications). Relied upon by the objector in arguing that contracts beyond the officer's authority cannot bind the Government; the court considered this line of authority but found it not applicable on the facts.
Chatturbhuj Vithaldas Jasani v. Moreshwar Parashram, AIR 1954 SC 236 Authority cited in support of the Article 299/agency/authority proposition. Cited by the objector; the court analysed this line of authorities but concluded they did not support setting aside the awards on the facts before it.
Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. The State of Uttar Pradesh, (1979) 2 SCC 409 : AIR 1979 SC 621 Authority on contracts entered without authority and related principles. Referred to by objector's counsel; court examined applicability and found the facts did not sustain the argument that the contractor knew of any limitation on the officer's authority.
Union of India v. India Tobacco Company Ltd., (1985) 4 SCC 369 Authority cited in support of Article 299 principles (limits on binding the Government by unauthorized agents). Cited by the objector; the court considered the citation but concluded the circumstances did not bring the case within those precedents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the central objection that the arbitrator had not given adequate reasons for allowing claims in excess of Rs. 1 lakh, contrary to Clause 24 of the contract which required a reasoned award in such cases. The arbitrator had allowed damages (Rs. 18,59,150) and other claims, and the only substantive explanation in the operative part of the award for allowing damages was that "the contentions of the respondents denying the claim of the claimants are not legally tenable."

The court emphasized the legal significance of a contractual or statutory requirement for reasons: where "reason" is required, it is the soul of the decision and must provide the grounds for proper adjudication. A bare conclusion without explanation does not satisfy the contractual requirement of a reasoned award. The court explained that absence of reasoning will vitiate the conclusion unless, on the facts and circumstances, no other view was possible. The court found that the arbitrator's terse conclusions did not constitute proper reasoning: the arbitrator had merely referred to facts and the contentions of the parties without discussing how the evidence and law led to the specific monetary award for damages and how those damages were computed or mitigated.

The court relied on established authorities (including Jajodia and others) which hold that merely answering issues does not make an award "speaking" or reasoned; a reasoned award must discuss or set out the reasons that led the arbitrator to make the award. Applying that principle, the court concluded that the arbitrator had not given adequate reasons for the damages award, thereby rendering that part of the award vulnerable to interference.

On the separate contention that the Executive Engineer lacked authority (financial competence) to place the orders and thereby the contract was not binding on the Kerala Water Authority, the court examined the contract terms and documents known to the contractor. The arbitrator's record included an "official use only" instruction indicating (inter alia) that there was no monetary limit for single supply orders against the rate contract and that delivery was to be effected as per supply orders (clause 10 referred to minimum monthly commitment). The Director General of Supplies and Disposal had issued a list identifying Direct Demanding Officers; the Executive Engineer, Public Works, Health Division, was included as the appropriate Demanding Officer for such supplies.

The court found that at no point did the general or specific terms of the contract make it known to the contractor that the Demanding Officer's authority was financially limited. The instruction relied upon by the objector was described as a restrictive circular for internal management, not a term of the contract that would be imputed to the contractor. The court observed that all orders placed exceeded Rs. 25 lakhs and had been executed and accepted by the objector in earlier instances; in that factual matrix the court considered the relevance of Section 65 of the Contract Act (party who accepted advantage cannot later deny the contract) and concluded the objector could not be deemed to have knowledge of any internal financial restriction on the demanding officer. The court therefore held that the Article 299 line of authorities relied upon by the objector did not, on the facts, apply.

Combining these analyses, the court held that the award was severable: the part of the arbitral award awarding damages (Rs. 18,59,150) was unreasoned and contrary to the terms of the agreement and the arbitrator should have given proper reasons after due deliberation. That portion was set aside and remitted to the arbitrator to record proper reasons after hearing the parties. The remainder of the award — including the balance payment claim, interest allowance on that sum, and disallowance of interest on damages — required no interference and was left intact. The court explicitly accepted the arbitrator's reasoning on other points to the extent they were supported by contract terms and known instructions.

Holding and Implications

Partial setting aside and remittal of the award.

Holding (core ruling): The court set aside the arbitrator's award insofar as it allowed damages of Rs. 18,59,150 on the ground that this part of the award was unreasoned and not supported by deliberative reasoning as required by Clause 24 of the contract; that portion was remitted to the arbitrator to give proper reasons after affording the parties an opportunity of hearing. The remaining parts of the award were upheld and the objections (other than to the unreasoned damages component) were rejected as without merit.

Implications: The direct effect is that the damages component (Rs. 18,59,150) is vacated and the arbitrator must re-consider that claim and record reasoned findings after hearing the parties; the rest of the award remains enforceable. The court applied the doctrine of severability to avoid setting aside the entire award. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new, sweeping precedent beyond applying existing principles concerning reasoned awards, limited judicial review, severability, and the effect of a contracting party's acceptance of benefits; it resolves the dispute on the facts and established authorities cited in the judgment.

Disposition

Both petitions were disposed of in accordance with the above findings: the award is set aside insofar as it allows damages of Rs. 18,59,150 and remitted to the arbitrator for reasoned determination; the remaining portions of the award are left undisturbed and the objections are otherwise dismissed.

    Fixopan Engineers (P) Ltd. v. Union Of India And Anr.

    Swatanter Kumar, J.:— The plaintiff, M/s. Fixopan Engineers (P) Limited, was awarded a rate contract by the defendants. This contract was awarded for the supply of high density polythene pipes for supply of potable water for the period 1st October, 1983 to 30th September, 1984. In terms of the Clause 24 of the agreement executed between the parties, the matter was referred to arbitration of an arbitrator. According to the plaintiff, in terms of the same clause, the award of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties. After reference to the arbitrator in relation to the disputes between the parties, the arbitrator passed an award dated 23rd April, 1998. This award was filed in this court and notice of the filing of the award was issued to the parties. According to the plaintiff/objector, the notice was served on 8th October, 1998 and the plaintiff filed objections to the award.

    2. Before the award could be filed in this court, the objector had filed a suit under Sections 14 and 17 of the Arbitration Act praying that the sole arbitrator Sh. S.B Sharan, Additional Legal Advisor, Ministry of Law, Government of India, New Delhi, be directed to file the award in this court. This was registered as Suit No. 1048/1998. Notice in this suit was issued vide order dated 23rd November, 1993. It was noticed that the award has been filed in this court and was registered as Suit No. 1828/1998. As such, both these suits were listed together for hearing from time to time. Thus, it would be appropriate to dispose of both these suits by this judgment. The objections were filed by the objector within the stipulated time. The objections taken by the objector/plaintiff can broadly be stated as under:

    (1) Under the terms of the contract, the arbitrator was obliged to give reasons for granting or refusing any claim of a party in excess of Rs. 1 lakh. No such reasoning has been recorded by the arbitrator.

    (2) The Executive Engineer, who awarded the works to the plaintiff and placed the order for further work was not having the financial competence to place such an order. It is also argued that the arbitrator ought to have taken note of Instruction No. 2, issued for ‘Direct Demanding Officers’ which was regularly followed by the department to the knowledge of the others.

    (3) Even otherwise, the award by the arbitrator is not a reasoned award and thus, is in conflict with the terms of reference and the agreement entered into between the parties.

    (4) The arbitrator had misconducted himself and the proceedings by not appreciating the fact that the letter dated 8th March, 1984 was not a cancellation order, but in fact, a declaration that orders were placed illegally and were, therefore, null and void.

    (5) The respondents having received advantages under the terms of the same agreement, could not have questioned the validity of the said agreement. The arbitrator has fallen in error of law. in not giving advantages to the respondents in this regard.

    (6) The award of the arbitrator is suffering from errors of law.

    3. The essence of the objections raised on behalf of the objector relates to non-application of mind, giving a finding which is not based on reasoning and the findings are also contrary to the record and terms of the agreement. The court cannot re-appraise the evidence produced before the arbitrator and the jurisdiction of the court in examining the reasons given by an arbitrator is a very limited one. In support of this contention, the learned counsel appearing for the Union of India relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of The Upper Ganges Valley Electricity Supply Co. Ltd. v. The U.P Electricity Board, (1973) 1 SCC 254 : AIR 1973 SC 683, and a judgment of this court in the case of Anand Brothers Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 71 (1998) DLT 698 : 1998 (1) Arb. LR 290 (Del.).

    4. It would be appropriate to examine the merits of the contentions raised by the respective parties in regard to the point that arbitrator has given no reason in support of the findings. Clause 24 of the agreement admittedly executed between the parties, reads as under:

    “In the event of any question, dispute or difference arising under these conditions or any special conditions of contract or in connection with this contract (except as to any matter the decision of which is specially provided for by these or the special conditions) the same shall be referred to the arbitration of an officer in the Ministry of Law, appointed to be the arbitrator by the Director General of Supplies and Disposal. There will be no objection that the arbitrator is a government servant and that he had to deal with the matters to which the contract relates or that in the course of his duties as a government servant he has expressed views on all or any of the matters in dispute or differences. The award of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties to this contract.

    If the value of the claims in a reference exceeds Rs. One lakh, the arbitrator shall give reasoned awards.”

    5. The arbitrator has allowed the claims of the Union of India in excess of Rs. 1 lakh. After noticing the facts of the present case and the written submissions submitted by the parties, the operative part of the award reads as under:

    “After having gone through the pleadings of the case as well as other documents on record and also after hearing arguments from all the parties it appears that the contract between the claimants and the respondents was a valid and concluded contract. The fact that the Executive Engineer who had placed the four supply orders was not having the financial capacity to do so was not the concern of the claimants as it was the internal matter of the respondent no. 2 and the claimants were perfectly right in procuring the raw materials and for taking all other necessary steps for timely and due execution of the contract. The cancellation of the contract was not in accordance with the terms and conditions of the contract. According to the Break Clause, three months' notice was necessary. Without giving such notice the contract was cancelled by respondent no. 2 within the delivery period despite the fact that there was no lapse on the part of the claimant-contractor. The respondent no. 2 had no jurisdiction to cancel the purchase order as the respondent no. 1 only had the authority to do so and that could be done only in accordance with the terms and conditions applicable to the contract. This was, thus, a total breach of contract by respondent no. 2. As the claimants have suffered heavy losses on account of cancellation of the contract due to no fault on their part, they are entitled for the damages as claimed by them. The contentions of the respondents denying the claim of the claimants are not legally tenable. The reduced amount of Rs. 18,59,150 claimed on account of damages after mitigating the loss to the extent as far as possible is justified, as the same is duly supported by documents and has been claimed on the basis of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Brijpal Singh v. State of Gujarat, (1984) 4 SCC 59. In the circumstances, the following award is made:

    ‘Award

    (1) The claim of the claimants against the respondent nos. 1 and 2 for Rs. 17,890.84 as balance payment for stores supplied is allowed.

    (2) The claim of the claimants for interest on the amount mentioned at Serial No. 1 above, @ 18% per annum from the date amount was due till realisation of the payment is allowed.

    (3) The claim of the claimants for Rs. 18,59,150 on account of damages is allowed.

    (4) The claim of the claimants for interest on the amount mentioned at Serial No. 3 above, is disallowed being not justified.

    (5) Parties to bear their own costs.

    Signed under my hand this twenty third day of April, 1998.

    (S.B Sharan)

    Sole Arbitrator’.”

    6. It is the contention of Kerala Water Authority that the claims have been allowed without recording any reasons. The bare reading of the above findings of the arbitrator shows that the only reason given for allowing the damages and claim of the contractor is “the contention of the respondents denying the claim of the claimants are not legally tenable”. The reasoning given by the arbitrator is certainly not in consonance with the terms of the contract entered into between the parties. The obligation is placed upon the arbitrator in terms of Clause 24 that if the value of the claim in a reference exceeds Rs. 1 lakh, the arbitrator shall give reasoned award. ‘Reason’ wherever contractually or statutorily is explicitly or impliedly required, then it is the soul of the final decision. Reasoning would be an expression of mind which shall provide before the appellate or other forum, the grounds for proper adjudication. Absence of such reasoning normally would vitiate the conclusion, unless in the facts and circumstances of the case, no other view was possible. What is the evidence in support of the claim allowed by the arbitrator, how the said claim and particularly the damages, were computed, is a matter which required, if not a detailed, then at least some deliberation by the arbitrator in that regard. It may not be extensive deliberation on the issue, but it should certainly be somewhat akin to the concept of proper reasoning.

    7. Learned counsel appearing for the objector has rightly placed reliance upon the cases of Jajodia (Overseas) Pvt. Ltd. v. Industrial Development Corporation of Orissa Ltd., (1993) 2 SCC 106 : 1993 (1) Arb. LR 334 (SC); Raipur Development Authority v. Chokhamal Contractors, (1989) 2 SCC 721 : 1989 (1) Arb. LR 430 (SC); and Union of India v. V.K Bahri, AIR 1980 Delhi 265. A consistent view has been taken in these judgments and particularly in the case of Jajodia (Overseas) Pvt. Ltd. where the Supreme Court held that mere giving of answers to the issues in the award would not show that it is a speaking award. Of course, it was also stated in the same judgment that court should be very circumspect in setting aside an award, but where an award was required to be a speaking award and in terms of the contract, it had no reasons, the Supreme Court in the above judgment held as under (para 8 of Arb. LR):

    “A speaking or reasoned award is one which discusses or sets out the reasons which led the arbitrator to make the award. Setting out the conclusions upon the questions or issues that arise in the arbitration proceedings without discussing the reasons for coming to these conclusions does not make an award a reasoned or speaking award. In the award in this case the arbitrator only answered the issues that were framed without discussing or setting out the reasons for the answers. The award is, therefore, not a speaking or reasoned award.”

    8. In the present case, the arbitrator has hardly recorded any reasons, and has merely made reference to the facts of the case and the contentions raised on behalf of either side. It is the appreciation of such contention by the arbitrator which is the essence of proper reasoning, and total lack of discussion by the arbitrator on this aspect, would certainly call for interference by this court, and to that extent the award would be liable to be set aside and remitted to the arbitrator for giving proper reasoning after hearing the parties in accordance with law.

    9. The other contentions raised on behalf of the objector is that the concerned officer had no authority (financial competence) to place orders upon the contractor and as such the contract is not binding upon the Kerala Water Authority, and the claim based upon supply of such stores is liable to be set aside. While supporting this contention, the learned counsel also relied upon Article 299 of the Constitution of India to say that a contract beyond authority, cannot bind the Government. In this regard, he relied upon judgments in the cases of State of Uttar Pradesh v. Murari Lal and Brothers Ltd., (1971) 2 SCC 449; Chatturbhuj Vithaldas Jasani v. Moreshwar Parashram, AIR 1954 SC 236; Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. The State of Uttar Pradesh, (1979) 2 SCC 409 : AIR 1979 SC 621; and Union of India v. India Tobacco Company Ltd., (1985) 4 SCC 369.

    10. To examine the merits of this contention, reference to the clauses of the agreement between the parties and instructions issued to the contractor by the respondents, would be necessary. The terms of the contract have to be read along with such documents which were known to the contractor in normal course of business. At Page C-11 of the arbitrator's record, a document has been placed which is issued ‘for official use only’ and it indicates certain instructions which were issued to the Direct Demanding Officer. Even under Clause 4 of this letter, it is stated that there is no monetary limit for single supply order against this rate contract. Clause 10 of the same instructions read as under:

    “10. Delivery— As per delivery required and stipulated in the supply orders to be placed against the rate contract. You have to effect supplies against supply orders received against this rate contract @ 30 M/Ts. per month which is the minimum quantity you have committed against this rate contract.”

    11. Furthermore, the Director General of Supplies and Disposal had issued a list of Direct Demanding Officers for Polythene pipes/PVC pipes at Serial No. 32 of the said instructions, which was given to the contractor for his information. Executive Engineer, Public Works, Health Division was stated to be the proper Demanding Officer for such supplies for the concerned department. In other words, at no point of time, the general terms and conditions or the specific terms of the contract executed between the parties made it known to the contractor that the said Demanding Officer had limited financial powers or could not place orders in excess. The instructions relied upon by the objector are primarily of a restrictive nature and it was termed as a restrictive circular. This would show that the contractor had no knowledge nor could he be deemed to have such a knowledge on any principle that the authority of the officer who was fully competent as per terms of the contract and instructions issued to place orders upon the plaintiff, was in anyway limited by financial implications. The arbitrator ought to have taken notice of the provisions of Section 65 of the Contract Act wherein a party who had taken advantage of the terms of the contract and accepted the supplies on earlier occasions, could not be permitted to alter its stand in this regard to the prejudice of the other side. All the orders placed in the present case were in excess of Rs. 25 lacs and no such protest or objections were raised by the respondents and the supplies earlier made by the respondents were duly accepted by the objector. The learned counsel for the respondent could hardly refer to any record of the arbitrator which could even demonstrate, much less establish the fact that the alleged financial restriction on powers of the Demanding Officer was a fact known to the contractor and the parties intended to implement such a circular, which in any case was a restricted circular, meant for internal management of the respondents. It is also not in dispute that no action has been taken by the concerned authorities against the said Demanding Officer. In these circumstances, the objector can hardly rely upon the provisions of Article 299 of the Constitution of India and the judgments relied would have no application. Thus, the claim allowed in favour of the contractor on such premises would hardly call for any interference. In view of my above reasoning, the award is severable in terms of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of The Upper Ganges Valley Electricity Supply Co. Ltd. The claim of damages of Rs. 18,59,150 is unreasoned and is not relatable to the record of the arbitrator. Furthermore, it is contrary to the terms of the agreement. The arbitrator should have given proper reasons upon due deliberation for allowing or disallowing this claim. Consequently, the award insofar as it allows the claim in favour of the contractor for a sum of Rs. 18,59,150 is set aside and remitted to the arbitrator who shall, after giving opportunity of hearing to the parties, record proper reasons in support or otherwise of his decision now to be taken. The remaining award calls for no interference. The objections raised by the objector are without any merit and the same are not accepted.

    12. Both the petitions are, accordingly, disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Fixopan Engineers (P) Ltd. v. Union Of India And Anr.
    (Aug 11, 2005)