AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 37 Rule 3 read with Section 151 of the CPC
  • sub-Rule 3 of Rule 2 of Order 37 of the CPC
  • Sub-rule (3) of Rule 3 of Order 37 of the CPC
  • Order 37 sub-Rule 3 of Rule 22.
  • Order 37 Rule 3 (7) of the CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 37 Rule 3 read with Section 151 of the CPC
  • sub-Rule 3 of Rule 2 of Order 37 of the CPC
  • Sub-rule (3) of Rule 3 of Order 37 of the CPC
  • Order 37 sub-Rule 3 of Rule 22.
  • Order 37 Rule 3 (7) of the CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit to recover Rs. 5,51,071/- from the defendant under Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). Summons were issued to the defendant on 19th August 1999 for service on 1st December 1999, and the defendant was served on 16th September 1999. The summons required the defendant to enter appearance within ten days, failing which the plaintiff could obtain a decree for the suit amount. Instead of entering appearance within the stipulated period, the defendant filed an application under Order 37 Rule 3 read with Section 151 of the CPC seeking leave to appear and defend the suit, along with an application for condonation of delay under Order 37 Rule 3(7) of the CPC. The defendant did not enter appearance as required.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applications filed by the defendant seeking leave to appear and defend the suit without entering appearance and without service of summons of judgment are maintainable under Order 37 of the CPC.
  2. Whether the absence of the suit number on the summons served on the defendant affects the validity of service and the defendant's ability to enter appearance.
  3. Whether the defendant's application for leave to appear and defend can be treated as entering appearance in the absence of a prescribed form for appearance under Order 37 of the CPC.
  4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for the suit amount under sub-Rule 3 of Rule 2 of Order 37 of the CPC due to the defendant's failure to enter appearance within the prescribed time.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The defendant's applications for leave to appear and defend are not maintainable without an appearance being entered.
  • The defendant had not been served with summons for judgment.
  • Under sub-Rule 3 of Rule 2 of Order 37 of the CPC, the plaintiff is entitled to obtain a decree for the suit amount with interest and costs due to the defendant's failure to enter appearance.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The summons served on the defendant did not mention the suit number, preventing the defendant from entering appearance within the prescribed period.
  • After receiving the brief, the defendant sought to ascertain the correct suit number from the registry to file the appropriate application.
  • The initial application was filed with an incorrect suit number (1809/99) and was later corrected to the actual suit number (1801/99) upon further inquiry.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harayana Breweries Ltd. v. The Aluminium Manufacturing Co. Ltd. & Anr, AIR 1980 Delhi 311 Clarification on the requirements of entering appearance and notice thereof under Order 37 Rule 3 CPC. Used to explain the mandatory nature of entering appearance within ten days and the directory nature of notice to the plaintiff.
Shri Pal Jain & Anr v. Shri Mulakh Raj, AIR 1987 Delhi 21 Interpretation of the procedural requirements for appearance and notice under Order 37 CPC. Supported the court's view on the mandatory and directory parts of Rule 3 of Order 37 CPC.
Shamim Ahmed v. Kanhaiya Lal Seth, 82 (1999) DLT 219 Consideration of delay in entering appearance and the effect of late communication on procedural timelines. Distinguished on facts; not applicable because the summons in the present case lacked the suit number, unlike in Shamim Ahmed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the procedural requirements under Order 37 of the CPC, emphasizing that the defendant must enter appearance within ten days of service of summons. The summons served on the defendant did not mention the suit number, which made it impossible for the defendant to identify the suit and enter appearance as mandated. The court found that this omission rendered the service ineffective, equating it to no service at all.

The court noted that while entering appearance is mandatory, no specific form is prescribed for it, and giving notice of appearance to the plaintiff is directory. The defendant's application for leave to appear and defend the suit was therefore treated as an effective entry of appearance. The court rejected the plaintiff's preliminary objection that the defendant's applications were not maintainable without prior appearance or service of summons for judgment.

The court distinguished the cited Shamim Ahmed case on the basis that the facts were different, particularly because the summons there contained the suit number and the delay was caused by other reasons. The court concluded that the plaintiff could not claim a decree under sub-Rule 3 of Rule 2 of Order 37 CPC due to improper service of summons lacking the suit number.

Holding and Implications

The court declined the preliminary objection raised by the plaintiff and held that the defendant's application for leave to appear and defend constituted valid entry of appearance despite the delay and procedural irregularities.

The applications filed by the defendant were disposed of accordingly, and the plaintiff was permitted to proceed with issuing summons for judgment in accordance with law. There was no order as to costs. No new precedent was established; the decision primarily affected the procedural posture of the parties in this suit.

    Hi-Rise Builders (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Alpha Woven Labels (India) Pvt. Ltd.

    S.K Agarwal, J. (Oral)— The plaintiff filed a suit for the recover of Rs. 5,51,071/- against the defendant under Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short the CPC). On 19th August, 1999/-, summons on the prescribed form under Order 37 of the CPC for service on the defendant were issued for 1st December, 1999. The defendant was served with the summons on 16 September, 1999, whereby he was informed that he has been summoned to cause appearance to be entered within ten days from the service thereof; in default whereof the plaintiff would be entitled to obtain a decree for the suit amount after the expiration of the said period and that after he enters appearance, the plaintiff would thereafter serve summons for judgment at the hearing of which defendant would be entitled to move the court for leave to defend the suit on merits. In this case, however, instead of entering appearance within the period of ten days on 15/10/1999 defendant filed an application under Order 37 Rule 3 read with Section 151 of the CPC seeking leave to appear and defend the suit along with an application under Order 37 Rule 3 (7) of the CPC for condonation of delay in filing the application seeking leave to defend. Admittedly no appearance was entered by the defendant.

    2. Learned counsel for the plaintiff raised a preliminary objection and argued that said applications moved by the defendant are not maintainable without entering appearance and even without service of summons of judgement and therefore the same are liable to be dismissed and under sub-Rule 3 of Rule 2 of Order 37 of the CPC and the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for the suit amount with interest and costs.

    3. Learned counsel for the defendant argued that summons served on the defendant did not mention the “suit number” and in the absence of the same appearance could not be entered, after the brief was entrusted to him he tried to enquire from the concerned branch about the numbers of the suit so as to enable him to file an appropriate application. It was further argued that the accompanying application was filed on 15th October, 1999, after the suit number was made available, initially the applications were filed showing the suit number as 1809/99, which was furnished by the registry and was found to be incorrect. Further enquiries revealed that actual suit number was 1801/99, and thereafter the suit number was corrected on said applications for leave to appear and defend and for condonation of delay.

    4. Perusal of the record shows that even on the copy of the summons, which was sent by the processing agency after the service, “suit number” is not mentioned. In the absence of the suit number it is impossible for any defendant to locate the suit or to enter appearance as envisaged under Order 37 of the CPC. It is as good as no service at all. In this case the defendant instead of entering appearance has moved applications seeking leave to appear and defend the suit, obviously under an erroneous advice. Since no appearance was entered, notice of the same was also not given to the plaintiffs. Sub-rule (3) of Rule 3 of Order 37 of the CPC consists of two parts, namely (a) it requires the defendant to enter appearance, within ten days of service of summons on him and (b) therefore it requires the defendant to inform the plaintiff or his advocate of his having entered the appearance, with proper address etc. First part of this rule i.e entering appearance is mandatory and if there is violation plaintiff becomes entitled for a decree of the suit amount under sub-rule (3) of Rule 2 of Order 37 of the CPC. However, no particular form for entering appearance is provided. Second part of this rule i.e giving notice of such appearance to the plaintiff is directory. Reference in this regard can be made to Harayana Breweries Ltd. v. The Aluminium Manufacturing Co. Ltd. & Anr.; AIR 1980 Delhi 311 and Shri Pal Jain & Anr.… v. Shri Mulakh Raj…. AIR 1987 Delhi 21.

    5. In this case, as suit number on the summons served on the defendant was not mentioned, the day he was informed of the “suit number” by the registry can at best be taken to be the date of service of summons on him. The purpose and intent behind this rule is only to expedite the hearing and to prevent unreasonable obstruction by a defendant who has no defence Under the circumstances, I am of the considered view that the application filed by the defendant seeking leave to appear and defendant the suit constitutes as entering appearance as no particular form is prescribed for the same.

    6. Learned counsel for the plaintiff placed reliance on Shamim Ahmed…Plaintiff; v. Kanhaiya Lal Seth…Defendant. 82 (1999) DLT 219 where the facts were entirely different. In that case, defendant was in jail and he had sent a letter to the Joint Registrar of this court which was received along with the affidavit. Admittedly in that case the service was effected on 11th December, 1998 and the defendant was required to enter appearance by 22 December, 1998 whereas the letter was received by the Joint Registrar only on 5th, 1999. It was not a case where the “suit number” was not mentioned on the summons served on the defendant. Therefore any observation made in that case cannot help the defendant. As noticed above, in the absence of any “suit number” on the summons served under Order 37 in form 4, the plaintiff cannot take advantage and seek a decree under Order 37 sub-Rule 3 of Rule 22. This would come into operation when there is a proper service of summons not otherwise. Under the circumstances the application filed by the defendant for leave to appear and defend has to be taken as the applications for entering appearance. These application are supported by the affidavit having full address and are accompanied by the Vakalatnama of a counsel.

    7. For foregoing reasons the preliminary objection raised by the plaintiff is declined.

    8. The plaintiff may now take steps for issuing of summons for judgement in accordance with law. The applications stand disposed of. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hi-Rise Builders (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Alpha Woven Labels (India) Pvt. Ltd.
    (Jan 17, 2000)