Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 119 of the Limitation Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 119 of the Limitation Act.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Vikramajit Sen, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns applications and a review petition arising from an Arbitration Award dated 28.6.1995 which, by an order dated 22.4.1997, was made Rule of the Court. A Review Petition (R.P. 27/97) was filed seeking recall of the orders of 22.4.1997 on the ground that the Applicant had no notice of the filing of the Award and therefore was unable to file objections. Several interlocutory applications are recorded: I.A. 11627/97 (delay in filing the Review Petition) and I.A. 3058/98 (which was later declared infructuous). The record shows there was correspondence about who represented the Union of India in the arbitration proceedings and whether the relevant official (the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P. Bhawan, New Delhi) was given notice or properly impleaded. The court also records dates relevant to the delay: a petitioner's letter dated 5.5.1997, nomination of Government Advocate on 28.5.1997, application for a certified copy on 5.6.1997, an absence of nominated counsel from 8.7.1997 to 1.12.1997, and the filing of the review application on 17.12.1997.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay of seven months and 23 days in filing the Review Petition (I.A. 11627/97) should be condoned.
  2. Whether the orders dated 22.4.1997 (making the Award of 28.6.1995 rule of the Court) should be recalled on the ground that proper notice of the filing of the Award was not given to the officer actually dealing with the arbitration (notably, the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P. Bhawan, New Delhi), and whether failure to give such notice violated principles of natural justice.

Arguments of the Parties

Learned Counsel for the Union of India

  • Submitted that the proper office/division concerned in the arbitration was the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P. Bhawan, New Delhi — the officer who had represented the Union of India in the arbitration proceedings.
  • Argued that there was a variance in nomenclature: the Claimant in arbitration appeared as "M/s. R.P Builders" while in the present proceedings the petitioner was styled "Shri R.P Arora, Sole Proprietor M/s. R.P Builders", and that this variance prevented the notice issued by the Court from being linked to the relevant Award.
  • Contended that the notice in question had been addressed to a broader office (e.g., the Chief Engineer or Secretary), making it difficult or impossible for the relevant official to identify the arbitration matter; therefore, objections could not be filed in time.
  • Imputed that the variance in nomenclature and failure to array the Executive Engineer was a deliberate and dishonest attempt by the Petitioner to obtain an ex parte decree.
  • Stated that the Respondent first became aware of the pendency of proceedings being sought to be reopened when the legal notice dated 5.5.1997 was received.

Learned Counsel for the Petitioner

  • Pointed to the arbitration record showing correspondence addressed to "M/s. R.P Builders" and to the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P. Bhawan, New Delhi, indicating that that officer was the person representing the Union of India in the arbitration.
  • Noted that notice issued by the Advocate of the petitioner was addressed to the Executive Engineer (though a copy shown to the court also appeared to have been addressed to the Chief Engineer (NDZ-III), Delhi Central Circle-3).
  • Contended that the correct manner of describing the petitioner in the present proceedings was as adopted herein (i.e., Shri R.P. Arora, Sole Proprietor M/s. R.P Builders), implying that any variation in the cause title could be explained by the manner of description in the current proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union Of India v. Surinder Kumar…, 61 (1996) DLT 42 (DB) The notice of filing of an arbitration award must provide sufficient particulars to enable the recipient to identify the arbitration case (Article 119 of the Limitation Act and s.14(2) of the Act). Sending notice to a high-level official (e.g., Secretary) without particulars is ineffective service; the Executive Engineer who actually dealt with the contract and arbitration should be served. Failure to serve the proper officer violates principles of natural justice and prevents the running of the time for filing objections. The court held that the precedent applies "to all fours" to the present facts: the notice sent in the instant case lacked the necessary particulars and the Executive Engineer ought to have been served/impleaded. This supported recalling the earlier order making the Award rule of the Court.
B.P. Sharma v. Union Of India, 1995 (34) DRJ 536 Government functions through an officer-in-charge for particular litigation (often the Executive Engineer). Notice of filing the award should therefore be given to that officer or should accompany particulars sufficient to identify the arbitration; sending an inadequate notice to a Secretary does not satisfy the requirement. The court relied on this decision for the proposition that where the Executive Engineer was the officer in charge of the arbitration, notice to the Secretary without particulars did not satisfy legal requirements. The ratio reinforced the conclusion that proper notice had not been given and the orders dated 22.4.1997 should be recalled.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in distinct parts corresponding to the interlocutory applications and the review petition.

(1) I.A. 11627/97 (Delay in filing Review Petition):

  • The application acknowledged a delay of 7 months and 23 days in filing the Review Petition.
  • The court examined the sequence of events: the petitioner’s letter dated 5.5.1997 gave knowledge of the Award being made rule of the Court; the Government Advocate was nominated on 28.5.1997; a certified copy was applied for on 5.6.1997; nominated counsel was reportedly unwell and absent from 8.7.1997 to 1.12.1997; the review application was filed on 17.12.1997.
  • Finding that the respondents had not prosecuted the matter with diligence, but weighing the interest of justice, the court exercised its discretion to condone the delay while imposing a cost of Rs. 2,000/- to be paid by the Respondents to the Petitioner.

(2) Review Petition (recall of orders dated 22.4.1997 making Award rule of the Court):

  • The court examined whether proper notice had been given under the legal regime governing filing of awards and objections (referenced identification with Article 119 of the Limitation Act and s.14(2) principles as articulated in cited precedents).
  • Applying the ratios of Union Of India v. Surinder Kumar… and B.P. Sharma v. Union Of India, the court concluded that a notice lacking case particulars cannot serve the purpose of informing the appropriate officer and triggering the limitation period for objections.
  • The court found plausible confusion arising from variance in the cause title (Claimant in arbitration being "M/s R.P Builders" while in the present proceedings the petitioner was styled as "Shri R.P Arora, Sole Proprietor M/s R.P Builders"), and that such variance could have contributed to failure to link the notice to the arbitration file in the offices of the Union of India.
  • Even if Respondent No. 2 was an appropriate respondent, the court reasoned there was no justification for not also impleading the Executive Engineer (the officer who had been dealing with the arbitration). The absence of that impleadment likely caused or contributed to the involuntary mischief (even if inadvertent) complained of.
  • On this basis the court concluded that a case had been made out for recalling the orders dated 22.4.1997 and for permitting effective notice to be deemed given to the concerned Executive Engineer from the date of the order in these proceedings.

(3) Consequential order on I.A. 3058/98:

  • Because the orders dated 22.4.1997 were recalled, I.A. 3058/98 became infructuous and was dismissed on that basis.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • The Review Petition (R.P. 27/97) is accepted and allowed. The court recalled the orders dated 22.4.1997 that had made the Award dated 28.6.1995 rule of the Court.
  • The Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P. Bhawan, New Delhi is ordered to be included in the Memorandum of Parties as Respondent No. 4 and is deemed to have notice of the filing of the Award with effect from the date of the court’s order.
  • I.A. 11627/97: The delay of 7 months and 23 days in filing the Review Petition is condoned in the interest of justice, subject to the Respondents paying Rs. 2,000/- as costs to the Petitioner.
  • I.A. 3058/98: Dismissed as infructuous because the orders of 22.4.1997 have been recalled.

Implications:

  • The direct practical consequence is that the prior decree/order making the Award rule of the Court has been set aside for want of proper notice to the officer who had been handling the arbitration (Executive Engineer). The Executive Engineer is now formally added as a party and is treated as having notice from the date of this order, enabling the office to take steps (including filing objections) as permitted by law.
  • Costs were ordered only for the delay application (Rs. 2,000/-) but the recall order itself was made with "no order as to costs."
  • The court relied upon established precedents concerning adequate particulars in notices of filing arbitration awards and the necessity of serving the officer-in-charge; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle or broader precedent beyond applying those existing authorities to the facts of this case.

This summary is limited to the information expressly contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or law beyond that text.

    R.P Arora v. Union Of India & Ors

    Vikramajit Sen, J. (Oral)— In I.A 11627/97 it is stated that there is a delay of 7 months 23 days for filing of the Review Petition. It appears that knowledge of the Award being made Rule of the Court was obtained by the Respondents through the petitioner's letter dated 5.5.1997 Keeping in view the facts of the case it was to be expected that the respondents would react with immediacy. Instead, it appears that the Government Advocate was nominated on 28.5.1997 and a certified copy was applied for on 5.6.1997 It has been stated in the application that the nominated counsel was unwell and had not attended Court from 8th July, 1997 to 1st December, 1997 and on her rejoining, the review application was filed on 17.12.1997

    There is no doubt that the respondents had not prosecuted the case with diligence. However in the interest of justice, the delay in filing of the Review Petition is condoned subject to the Respondents paying a sum of Rs. 2000/- as costs to the Petitioner.

    The application is disposed of accordingly. R.P 27/97

    By order dated 22.4.1997 the Award dated 28.6.1995 was made Rule of the Court. This petition has been filed for a review of those orders on the ground that the Applicant had no notice of the filing of the Award and hence was unable to file Objections to it.

    In support of this Review Petition it has been contended by learned counsel appearing for the Union of India that it is the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P Bhawan, New Delhi which is the concerned office/division. It is submitted that it was this Officer who was representing the Union of India in the Arbitration Proceedings in which the impugned Award has been passed. To buttress her argument the learned counsel for the Applicant has drawn my attention to the fact that in the proceedings before the Arbitrator, all correspondence was addressed to M/s. R.P Builders on the one hand and the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P Bhawan, New Delhi on the other. She has further canvassed that on the passing of the Decree in terms of the Award the notice issued by the Advocate of the petitioner was addressed to this particular. Officer, i.e the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P Bhawan, New Delhi. All these facts are not in dispute, except in respect of the last submission that the said letter, a copy of which was shown to me at the time of arguments, was also addressed to the Chief Engineer (NDZ-III), Delhi Central Circle-3, C.P.W.D, Sewa Bhawan, R.K Puram, New Delhi. It was further submitted by learned counsel for the Union of India that in the arbitration proceedings the Claimant was mentioned in the name and style of M/s. R.P Builders whereas in these proceedings the petitioner has been styled as Shri R.P Arora, Sole Proprietor M/s. R.P Builders. It is argued that because of this variance in the nomenclature adopted, the notice issued by the Court could not be linked to the concerned Award. Her argument proceeds that the Office of the Chief Engineer, who has been arrayed as Respondent No. 2 in these proceedings, is so widespread and like an ocean that it was virtually impossible for the notice to be linked with the appropriate arbitration proceedings and the Award. Learned Counsel for the Union of India has imputed and contended that the change in the nomenclature of the Petitioner and the failure to array the Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P Bhawan, New Delhi was a deliberate and dishonest effort/attempt of the Petitioner to obtain an ex parte decree. It is for these reasons that Objections could not be filed within time. It is a case of the Union of India that the learnt of the passing of the pendency of the proceedings now sought to be reopened by way of this review petition only when the legal notice dated 5.5.1997 was received by the Applicant.

    Reliance has been placed on a decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Union Of India… v. Surinder Kumar…S, 61 (1996) DLT 42 (DB). I have perused this decision and in my view it applies to all fours to the facts of the present case. The grievance in the decided case was similar to that put forth by learned counsel for the Applicant in the instant case. It was observed as follows:

    “We have considered the submission of learned Counsel for the respondent but we are of the opinion that there was no proper service of the notice of the filing of the award on the appellant. The object of giving notice under Section 14 (2) of the Act is to provide an opportunity to a party to submit objections to the award filed by an Arbitrator within a period of 30 days of the receipt of a notice in respect of filing of the award as per Article 119 of the Limitation Act. What is essential is that notice should post him with the knowledge of the award filed by the Arbitrator in a particular matter. Notice should therefore, specify such details as would enable a party to identify the arbitration case, otherwise the notice will not serve the purpose for which it was given and will not meet the requirements of law. In the instant case the notice does not specify the name of the work, the division or department to which the matter pertained or even the contract number. It is needless to point out that Ministry of Urban Development has a very large area of operation covering several departments of the Government including C.P.W.D, which itself has several divisions spread all over the country. Therefore, unless the notice of filing of the award gives the details of the arbitration matter in which award is given, it cannot be considered as a proper notice in accordance with law. Besides, it was not enough to direct notice of the filing of the award to the Secretary to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Urban Development particularly when the notice failed to disclose the material particulars of the matter. In the circumstances, the notice ought to have been sent to the Executive Engineer, who was Engineer-in-charge of the work, and was the person who had signed the contract on behalf of the Union of India and was dealing with the matter. Therefore, it was necessary that he should also have been arrayed as a party respondent in the matter. Merely arraying Union of India and sending the notice to the Secretary, Ministry of Urban Development would not be effective service as the Secretary to the Govt. of India was not aware of the case nor he was furnished with the particulars thereof. He would also be ignorant of the proceedings before the Arbitrator which culminated in the award. Moreover in the present case as already noted it would be difficult for the Secretary to the Govt. of India to link up the notice of the filing of the award to the matter which was subject matter of the Arbitration proceedings as the notice does not give any details except that the award was rendered by Mr. S.S Juneja. Since no particulars of the case were given, the office of the Secretary, Govt. of India, Ministry of Urban Development made an endorsement on the notice itself to the effect that full particulars of the case were not given and the notice was received without enclosures. Even a letter was written to the Registrar by the office of the Secretary, Ministry of Urban Development, Govt. of India for seeking particulars of the matter. In these circumstances, therefore, failure to serve a notice of the filing of the award on the Executive Engineer amounts to violation of the principles of natural justice. It is well settled that where the principles of natural justice have been violated in passing an order by the Court, the same can be set aside under the inherent powers. It is also well settled that no person can be prejudiced by the act of the Court. Therefore, when the notice of the filing of the award was not given to the Executive Engineer and no proper notice was given to the Secretary to the Government of India. Ministry of Urban Development, the time for filing the objections did not commence and could not have therefore, expired. In such an event the Court will have inherent jurisdiction to set aside the ex-parte decree.”

    Reliance was also placed, and correctly so, by learned counsel appearing for Union of India on a decision of this Court delivered by R.C Lahoti, J (as he then was) in B.P Sharma. v. Union Of India., 1995 (34) DRJ 536 in which, again in almost identical circumstances, the following observation was made:

    “It is well known that the government in the very nature of its functioning, acts through some one, commonly known as officer-in-charge in a particular litigation. In the case at hand, it was the Executive Engineer (Civil) who was the in-charge of the case and was throughout conducting the proceedings before the Arbitrator which had pended for about three years. The covering letter filed by the Arbitrator along with the award and record of arbitration proceedings contained details of the contract out of which the disputes and arbitration proceedings had arisen as also a brief indication of arbitration case, the Executive Engineer (Civil) Telecom Civil Division-I, Chanakayapuri, Post Office Building New Delhi was shown in the covering letter as a party likely to be effected by the proceedings or a party interested in the award. Notice of the filing of the award should have been given to the Executive Engineer abovesaid. The notice could have been accompanied by a copy of the covering letter filed by the Arbitrator or else the notice should have given the requisite particulars already stated hereinabove. That having not been done the notice issued on the address of the Secretary, Ministry of Communication did not satisfy the requirement of the notice of the filing of the award. The receiving clerk in the Secretariat was justified in refusing to accept the notice unless it gave particulars of the case or was accompanied by some petition or application to give an idea of the case. In fact the notice tendered to the clerk was not at all a notice of filing of the award.”

    Applying the ratios of those two judgment to the facts of the present case it is my considered opinion that a case has been made out for recalling the orders dated 22.4.1997 It is quite plausible that a confusion had been occasioned because of the difference in the cause title viz-a-viz. the petitioner; as observed above the Claimant in the arbitration proceedings was M/s R.P Builders and not Shri R.P Arora, Learned counsel for the petitioner has stated that the correct manner of describing the petitioner is that which has been adopted in these proceedings. That may be correct; but it would undoubtedly have caused some confusion in the offices of the Union of India. Further more, even if the Respondent No. 2 was the persona designate and, therefore, an appropriate party as a respondent, there was no reason why the concerned official i.e Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P Bhawan, New Delhi should also not have been impleaded as a respondent. Had this been done involuntary mischief which has resulted in the present case even if inadvertently would have been avoided.

    The Review petition is, therefore, accepted and allowed. The Executive Engineer, Construction Division II, CPWD, I.P Bhawan, New Delhi is ordered to be included in the Memorandum of Parties as Respondent No. 4. The said Officer shall be deemed to have notice of the filing of the Award effective from today. There shall be no order as to costs.

    I.A 3058/98

    Since the orders dated 22.4.1997 have been recalled, this application has become infructuous, and is dismissed as such.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    R.P Arora v. Union Of India & Ors
    (Aug 31, 1999)