Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 17 (vi) in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act.
  • provisions of Section 7 (iv) (b) of the Court-fees Act
  • Article 7 (vi) in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 17 (vi) in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act.
  • provisions of Section 7 (iv) (b) of the Court-fees Act
  • Article 7 (vi) in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Late Lala Karam Chand Nagi was the owner of Shop Nos. 290 to 296, Bazar Ajmeri Gate, Near New Amar Talkies, Delhi, comprising shops on the ground floor and the first, second and third floors. After his death (intestate alleged by the plaintiff), the plaintiff (his daughter) filed a suit for partition against defendant No. 1 (her brother) and defendant No. 2 (her sister). The plaint alleged that the deceased died intestate and that each of the three legal heirs (the three children) was entitled to a one-third share.

Facts and relevant circumstances pleaded or admitted in the plaint include: the shops on the ground floor were under tenancy; a portion of the first floor was occupied by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi as a primary school; large parts of the first, second and third floors were in the exclusive possession of defendant No. 1; defendant No. 1 alone was recovering rents from the tenants and from the Municipal Corporation; and paragraph 4 of the plaint admitted that the entire property was in the possession of defendant No. 1.

Defendant No. 2 filed a written statement supporting the plaintiff. Defendant No. 1 contested the suit, denying the plaintiff's locus standi and raising a preliminary objection about improper valuation for Court-fee and jurisdiction. Defendant No. 1 alleged that the deceased had executed a registered Will dated 22 November 1984 bequeathing the property to defendant No. 1 alone.

The Court framed five issues on 11 August 1995 and proceeded to hear evidence and arguments before delivering issue-wise findings and a final order dismissing the suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant No. 1 proves that his father has made a valid and legal Will on 22nd of November, 1984?
  2. Whether the defendant No. 1 gets exclusive ownership of suit property on account of the Will executed by his father on 22-11-1984?
  3. Whether the plaintiff has got 1/3rd share in the suit property?
  4. Whether the Court-fee paid by the plaintiff is proper and correct?
  5. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get partition and separate possession of her share?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff claimed to be a legal heir and a one-third co-owner of the suit property inheriting from her father and sought partition.
  • The plaint stated the approximate value of the suit property as Rs. 21,00,000 for purposes of Court-fee and jurisdiction, but a fixed Court-fee of Rs. 20 was affixed on the plaint.
  • In paragraph 4 of the plaint the plaintiff admitted that defendant No. 1 was in possession of the property; she also stated that she sent notice claiming her share and that defendant No. 1 had refused to give her the share.
  • In her evidence the plaintiff denied any knowledge of the alleged Will and denied being disinherited; she made various factual denials under cross-examination as recorded in the opinion.

Defendant No. 1's Arguments

  • Defendant No. 1 contended that the deceased had executed a duly registered Will dated 22 November 1984 bequeathing the entire suit property to defendant No. 1 alone.
  • He raised a preliminary objection that the suit had not been properly valued for Court-fee and jurisdiction.
  • Defendant No. 1 led evidence (including attesting witness testimony and the Sub-Registrar) to prove execution and registration of the Will and that the deceased was of sound disposing mind when he executed the Will.

Defendant No. 2's Position

  • Defendant No. 2 filed a written statement supporting the claim of the plaintiff (the opinion records she supported the plaintiff).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagdish Pershad v. Joti Pershad, 1975 Rajdhani LR 203 Cited for the proposition that where the plaintiff claims to be in joint possession of the property of which partition is sought, the plaintiff is to pay only fixed Court-fee as per the relevant Article in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act. The Court distinguished the present case from Jagdish Pershad because the plaint did not allege that the plaintiff was in joint possession; instead paragraph 4 admitted exclusive possession by defendant No. 1. Therefore the fixed Court-fee rule described in Jagdish Pershad did not apply to the present plaint.
Prakasha Wati v. Dayawanti & Ors., (1990) 42 DLT 421 : AIR 1991 Delhi 1 Cited for the proposition (in conjunction with statutory provision) that where the plaintiff is not in joint possession, Court-fee must be paid on the value of the plaintiff's share when seeking partition. The Court relied on this precedent (together with provisions of the Court-fees Act cited in the opinion) to hold that the plaintiff was required to pay Court-fee on the value of her share and had not done so; hence the Court-fee paid was improper.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded issue-wise and relied on oral and documentary evidence produced at trial. The core analytical steps and findings were:

  1. Issue No. 1 (Validity of the Will): The Court evaluated testimony of the attesting witness (D1 W2 Mr. Sadruddin), who stated that both attesting witnesses signed the Will in the presence of the deceased and that the deceased signed in their presence. The attesting witness testified that the deceased was of sound disposing mind and that the contents of the Will were explained by an advocate before signing. The Sub-Registrar who registered the Will also gave evidence identifying the deceased and confirming the registration. No suspicious circumstances surrounding the Will's execution were brought to the Court's notice, and no one denied the signatures. Given these facts and the absence of suspicious circumstances, the Court concluded that defendant No. 1 discharged the onus of proof and that the Will Ex. D1 W1 is the last Will and testament of the deceased. Issue No. 1 was decided in favour of defendant No. 1.
  2. Issue No. 2 (Effect of the Will): Having held the Will valid, the Court applied the legal consequence that the Will bequeaths the property to defendant No. 1. Therefore defendant No. 1 obtains exclusive ownership of the suit property on the basis of the Will. Issue No. 2 was decided in favour of defendant No. 1.
  3. Issue No. 3 (Plaintiff's share): Because the entire property was validly bequeathed to defendant No. 1 by the Will dated 22 November 1984, the plaintiff did not obtain any one-third share in the suit property. The Court decided Issue No. 3 against the plaintiff.
  4. Issue No. 4 (Court-fee): The Court analyzed the pleadings and statutory provisions. The opinion notes Article 7 (vi) in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act (and also references Article 17 (vi) in Schedule II in connection with authority) permitting a fixed court-fee where the money value of the subject-matter cannot be assessed, and cites Jagdish Pershad which applies where the plaintiff claims joint possession. In this case, however, paragraph 4 of the plaint admitted exclusive possession by defendant No. 1 and showed the plaintiff was not in possession of any part of the suit property. Relying also on Section 7 (iv)(b) of the Court-fees Act and the authority of Prakasha Wati v. Dayawanti, the Court concluded the plaintiff was required to pay Court-fee on the value of her share when seeking partition and had not done so. Therefore the Court-fee paid was improper. Issue No. 4 was decided against the plaintiff.
  5. Issue No. 5 (Entitlement to partition and separate possession): In view of the prior findings — the Will's validity, exclusive ownership of defendant No. 1, and the improper Court-fee — the Court held that the plaintiff was not entitled to partition or separate possession of any part of the property. Issue No. 5 was decided against the plaintiff.

The Court also recorded ancillary factual findings in the analysis: the Will had been drafted on 22 November 1984 and registered on 12 December 1984; the deceased died on 5 November 1991 (about seven years after execution); and the property had been mutated in the name of defendant No. 1 on the basis of the Will.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Suit dismissed.

Implications and immediate consequences as stated in the opinion:

  • The plaintiff is not entitled to any relief in the suit and does not obtain a one-third share in the suit property because the property was validly bequeathed by the deceased to defendant No. 1 by a registered Will.
  • The plaintiff failed to pay proper Court-fee on the value of her claimed share; the Court held the fee affixed on the plaint was improper in the circumstances.
  • The plaintiff is not entitled to partition or separate possession of any part of the property; defendant No. 1 obtains exclusive ownership by virtue of the Will and related registration/mutation.
  • The suit is dismissed and, on the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, the Court directed that parties shall bear their own costs.
  • The opinion does not indicate that any new legal precedent was laid; the Court applied existing statutory provisions and cited existing case law in support of its decision.

This summary is confined to the matters explicitly stated in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or legal conclusions beyond the text.

    Smt. Rani Devi v. Ashok Kumar Nagi And Another

    Late Lal Karam Chand Nagi was the owner of the properties being Shop Nos. 290 to 296, Bazar Ajmeri Gate, Near New Amar Talkies, Delhi. The said property comprised of not only the shops on the ground floor but also comprised of the first, second and third floors. After the death of Lala Karam Chand Nagi, the plaintiff who is the daughter of the deceased Karam Chand Nagi, filed this suit for partition of the property against defendant No. 1 who is her brother and defendant No. 2 who is the other daughter of the deceased Karam Chand Nagi. It was alleged in the plaint that the deceased died intestate and as such parties to the suit being the legal heirs of the deceased were entitled to 1/3rd share each in the said property. While the shops on the ground floor are under the tenancy of the different persons named in the plaint, in a portion of the first floor, the Municipal Corporation of Delhi was running a primary school. The remaining portion of the first floor as well as the second floor and third floor were in exclusive possession of defendant No. 1. The rent from the shops on the ground floor as well as from Municipal Corporation of Delhi for its occupation on the first floor was being recovered by defendant No. 1 alone. In paragraph 4 of the plaint, the plaintiff has admitted that the entire property in suit was in possession of defendant No. 1 alone. The plaintiff is alleged to have demanded her 1/3rd share in the properties from defendant which he refused and this suit was, therefore, filed by the plaintiff for partition of the aforesaid properties. Though, it is mentioned in the plaint that the value of the suit for purposes of Court Fee and jurisdiction was Rs. 21,00,000/- which was the approximate value of the suit property, however, a fixed Court Fee of Rs. 20/- has been fixed on the plaint.

    2. Defendant No. 2 filed her written statement supporting the claim of the plaintiff while the suit is being contested only by defendant No. 1. In his written statement, defendant No. 1 besides raising a preliminary objection about the suit having not been properly valued for Court Fee and jurisdiction, also denied the locus standi of the plaintiff to file the suit. It was stated in the written statement by defendant No. 1 that the deceased had left a Will dated 22nd November, 1984 which was duly registered bequeathing the property in suit to defendant No. 1 alone. Plaintiff was alleged to be fully aware of the said will and as such, according to defendant No. 1, the plaintiff was not entitled to any share in the property and the suit was, therefore, alleged to be misconceived.

    3. After the replication was filed by the plaintiff, the Court framed the following issues on 11th August, 1995 :—

    1. Whether the defendant No. 1 proves that his father has made a valid and legal Will on 22nd of November, 1984?

    2. Whether the defendant No, 1 gets exclusive ownership of suit property on account of the Will executed by his father on 22-11-1984?

    3. Whether the plaintiff has got 1/3rd share in the suit property?

    4. Whether the Court-fee paid by the plaintiff is proper and correct?

    5. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get partition and separate possession of her share?

    4. After having heard learned counsel for the parties, my issuewise findings are as under :—

    ISSUE NO. 1

    5. Besides herself appearing as PW-1, plaintiff also produced one Mr. Kripal Singh as a witness. The plaintiff in her statement stated that after the death of her father she did not demand any share in the property from defendant No. 1 but had sent a notice Ex. P-1 claiming that she owned a share in the property. Reply Ex. P-2 to the said notice was received from defendant No. 1. She denied any knowledge of the Will alleged to have been executed by her father. In cross-examination she stated that she was married 2-3 years before partition of the country and the suit property was purchased by her grandfather partly from his claims of compensation and partly from his own earnings. She denied the suggestion that the property was purchased by her father and not by her grandfather. She, however, had not read the sale deed of this property. She denied that there was any dispute between her and her father or that she had stopped visiting her father. She denied that her father got her constructed rooms, kitchen, bathroom and latrine in her house for residence. She admitted that in connection with the murder of her son-in-law, her son and husband were arrested, however, she denied that because of this reason her father was not having good relations with her and had disinherited her from the property.

    6. Mr. Kripal Singh appeared as a witness in support of the case of the plaintiff and stated that the deceased was his cousin and he used to visit him quite often. He further stated that the deceased never told him about the execution of a Will. He, however, admitted that in 1978 a theft was committed in the house of the deceased and he was named as a thief. He, however, denied that he had broke open the house or had committed theft therein.

    Mr Sadruddin who is an attesting witness to the Will has appeared as D1W2 and stated that he had Mangat Ram, the other attesting witness, had signed the Will in the presence of the deceased and the deceased had signed the same in their presence. He has identified the signatures of the deceased on the Will as well as the signatures of other witness who has since died. It was further stated that the deceased Karam Chand Nagi was in sound disposing mind at the time of signing the Will and the contents of the Will were explained by an advocate in his presence and Karam Chand Nagi had signed the Will only after understanding the contents thereof. The Sub-Registrar of Assurances who had registered the Will also appeared as a witness and stated that D1W2 Mr. Sadruddin and Har Prakash, Advocate were present at the time of registration of the Will and that the deceased as identified to him by Mr. Har Prakash, Advocate. Defendant No. 1 also appeared as a witness and stated that on 12th December, 1984 the Will was registered but the same was drafted earlier on 22nd November, 1984 but was signed only on 12th December, 1984 on the date when it was registered before the Sub-Registrar. The deceased died on 5th November, 1991 almost seven years after the execution of the Will. The property has also been mutated in the name of defendant No. 1 on the basis of the Will.

    7. While D1 W2 has clearly stated that the Will was executed by the deceased in his presence at the time when he was of sound disposing mind, the other witness has proved the registration of the Will. Both the witnesses have stated that the Will was duly understood by the deceased before he had signed the same. No suspicious circumstances have been brought to the notice of the Court about the execution of the Will. Nobody has denied the signatures of Karam Chand Nagi on the Will. Both the daughters of the deceased were married and it is, therefore, neither unnatural nor improbable that the deceased has bequeathed the property to his only son by way of the Will. In the absence of suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the Will, in my view, defendant No. 1 has been able to discharge the onus of proving issue No. 1. In the light of relevant circumstances and in view of the evidence produced on record, I am satisfied that the Will Ex. D1 W1 is the last Will and testament of the deceased Karam Chand Nagi. Issue No. 1 is, therefore, decided in favour of defendant No. 1.

    ISSUE NO. 2

    8. In view of the fact that Issue No. 1 has been decided in favour of defendant No. 1 and it having been held that the deceased had executed a valid and legal Will on 22nd November, 1984, defendant No. 1 gets exclusive ownership of the suit property on the basis of the said Will. Issue No. 2 is, therefore, decided in favour of defendant No. 1 and against the plaintiff.

    ISSUE NO. 3.

    9. In view of the fact that the entire property has been bequeathed to defendant No. 1 by the deceased by way of a Will Ex. D.1 W1 dated 22nd November, 1984, the plaintiff does not get any share in the suit property. This issue is, therefore, decided against the plaintiff.

    ISSUE NO. 4.

    10. The plaintiff has filed this suit for partition of the property on the allegations that she was joint owner of the property having inherited the same from her father. In paragraph 4 of the plaint, it is stated by the plaintiff that the parties in suit are joint and co-owners of the entire property in suit and defendant No. 1 is partly in actual possession and enjoyment of the property on the first floor and whole of the second and third floors and symbolic possession of the property on the ground floor through the tenants. Only defendant No. 1 is recovering rent from all the tenants. Shop No. 294/2 is in occupation of Ashok Metal Stores. It is, therefore, clear from the pleadings that the plaintiff is not in possession of any part of the suit property.

    11. Under Article 7 (vi) in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act, where it is not possible to decide the money value of the subject-matter in dispute, the suit can be filed by affixing a fixed Court-fee on the plaint. In Jagdish Pershad v. Joti Pershad, 1975 Rajdhani LR 203, it is held that where the plaintiff claims to be in joint possession of the property of which partition is sought, he is to pay only fixed Court-fee as per Article 17 (vi) in Schedule II of the Court-fees Act. In the present case, however, it is not pleaded anywhere that plaintiff is in joint possession of the property and on the other hand in view of the allegations made in paragraph 4 of the plaint, it is clear that the property is in exclusive possession of defendant No. 1. Therefore, in view of the provisions of Section 7 (iv) (b) of the Court-fees Act and in view of the judgment of this Court in Prakasha Wati…Plaintiff; v. Dayawanti & Ors.…Defendant., (1990) 42 DLT 421 : (AIR 1991 Delhi 1) the plaintiff was required to pay Court-fee on the value of her share for seeking the relief of partition. The plaintiff has, therefore, not paid proper Court-fee on the suit. This issue is, accordingly, decided against the plaintiff.

    ISSUE No. 5

    12. In view of the above discussion, in my view, plaintiff is not entitled to get partition or separate possession of any part of the property. This issue is also decided against the plaintiff.

    13. In view of the above discussions, the plaintiff is not entitled to any relief in the suit and the suit is, accordingly, dismissed. However, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, I leave the parties to bear their own costs.

    Suit dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Rani Devi v. Ashok Kumar Nagi And Another
    (Sep 10, 1998)