Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Regulation as Appendix-II. Rule 7-B
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Regulation as Appendix-II. Rule 7-B
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was enrolled in the Indian Air Force on 22.3.1991 as an Airman in the Trade "Photo Technician." A pre-enrolment Board of Medical Officers declared him fit. He completed initial training in November 1992, was posted to No. 2 Squadron, and in May 1993 was sent to E & I.T.I, Jalahalli East, Bangalore for a conversion course.

On 23.7.1993 the petitioner received routine TAB and cholera vaccinations at the Station Sick Quarters, Jalahalli East. Soon after, he developed fever, headache, frequent urination and weakness. On 2.8.1993 blood and sugar tests revealed sugar in his urine. He was given glucose saline at the Station Sick Quarters, developed diabetic ketoacidosis, lapsed into a coma and was transferred to Command Hospital A.F., Bangalore, where he was treated for approximately three months. Subsequent medical examination diagnosed him as suffering from insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) 250. An Invaliding Medical Board placed him in category EEE (permanently unfit) and assessed 40% disability for two years. He was invalided out of service effective 31.12.1993.

The petitioner claimed disability medical pension; the Chief Controller of Defence Accounts (Pension), Allahabad (CCDA(P)), rejected the claim on 16.11.1994 on the ground that the disability was "neither attributable to, nor aggravated by Air Force Service," and communicated the decision to the petitioner on 13.12.1994 with advice to prefer an appeal, which the petitioner did not do. The petitioner was, however, paid invalid gratuity of Rs. 3,000 and Rs. 33,000 under the A.F. Group Insurance Scheme.

The petitioner filed the present writ petition seeking (a) quashing of the order of discharge dated 3.12.1993 with direction to reinstate him with full back wages and consequential benefits, and (b) in the alternative, a writ of mandamus directing award of disability medical pension.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of discharge (invaliding out) dated 3.12.1993 was illegal or arbitrary and should be quashed, with consequent reinstatement and back wages.
  2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to disability pension for the diabetes (IDDM) diagnosed during service — specifically, whether the disability was attributable to or aggravated by Air Force service such that pension must be granted.
  3. Procedural issue: whether the decision of the Chief Controller of Defence Accounts (Pension), Allahabad to reject the pension claim could stand in the face of the Medical Board's opinion and applicable Pension Regulations (Appendix-II, Rule 7-B).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Prior to enlistment the petitioner was examined by a Board of Doctors and declared fit; no note of any disease or disability was recorded at enlistment.
  • The petitioner became a victim of wrong treatment at Station Sick Quarters and Command Hospital (specifically that administration of glucose saline without pre-diabetic precautions caused diabetic ketoacidosis and coma).
  • The Medical Board's opinion is alleged to be based on a wrong diagnosis; discharge based on that opinion is therefore illegal and arbitrary and violates Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
  • Despite the Medical Board assessing 40% disability for two years, the CCDA(P) Allahabad arbitrarily refused medical pension.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioner was found unfit for further service by a Medical Board (diagnosed as Diabetes Mellitus (IDDM) 250), which recommended 40% disability for two years; he had rendered two years and 255 days of service.
  • Routine vaccination/inoculation was administered at the Station Sick Quarters; this is a periodical feature administered to all Airmen; no other airman developed the petitioner's symptoms.
  • Station Sick Quarters cannot undertake pre-diabetic checks in unknown cases; IV fluid is given as an immediate life-saving requirement when necessary.
  • The petitioner was appropriately transferred to and treated at Command Hospital for diabetic ketoacidosis and coma; he was placed on the dangerous ill list and treated by specialists.
  • Cases of early-onset diabetes requiring insulin therapy are handled under existing Air Force rules by invaliding and medical boarding; a Classified Specialist (Medicine and Nephrology) opined the petitioner had IDDM with ketoacidosis and recommended invaliding out; a duly constituted Invaliding Medical Board assessed 40% disability for two years.
  • The CCDA(P) adjudicated the pension claim and concluded the disability was neither attributable to nor aggravated by Air Force service and rejected pension; the decision and appeal route were communicated to the petitioner, and no appeal was preferred.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ex. Sapper Mohinder Singh v. Union of India (CA. No. 164 of 1993 decided on 14.1.1993) Authority for the proposition that the Chief Controller of Defence Accounts (Pension), in the absence of any other medical opinion, could not ignore or rule out the opinion of the Medical Board upon whose opinion a service member was invalided out. The court relied on this precedent to conclude that CCDA(P) Allahabad could not have lawfully ignored the Invaliding Medical Board's assessment of 40% disability when rejecting the petitioner's claim; the CCDA(P)'s decision was therefore held to be arbitrary and unsustainable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in two main parts: assessment of the discharge and assessment of entitlement to disability pension.

First, regarding the discharge, the court noted that the petitioner had been examined by an Invaliding Medical Board which opined that he was not medically fit for further service because of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus with ketoacidosis, and this opinion had not been rebutted by the petitioner. For that reason, the court found no basis to interfere with the order of discharge: the discharge was founded on the Medical Board's opinion and the invaliding proceedings had been considered by the competent authority.

Second, on entitlement to disability pension, the court applied the Pension Regulations for the Indian Air Force, 1961 (Appendix-II, Rule 7-B). Rule 7-B provides that a disease which has led to discharge will ordinarily be deemed to have arisen in service if no note of it was made at the time of acceptance, unless medical opinion explains that it could not have been detected prior to acceptance. In the petitioner's case, no note of the disease was made at enrolment and the Medical Board did not record any reason that the disease could not have been detected on pre-enrolment examination. Consequently, under Rule 7-B the disease is to be deemed to have arisen during service.

The court then considered the CCDA(P)'s rejection of pension on the ground that the disability was neither attributable to nor aggravated by service. Relying on the ratio in Ex. Sapper Mohinder Singh v. Union of India, the court held that, in the absence of any other medical opinion, the CCDA(P) could not ignore the Medical Board's opinion which had recommended 40% disability. Given that the Medical Board's opinion stood unrebutted and Rule 7-B applied to deem the disease to have arisen during service, the CCDA(P)'s decision to deny disability pension was found to be arbitrary and unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Writ petition allowed.

Direct consequences ordered by the court (as stated in the opinion):

  • The respondents are directed to sanction and grant disability pension to the petitioner as per the Invaliding Medical Board's recommendation treating the disability at 40% for two years.
  • The disability pension shall continue to be paid until the disability is varied on re-assessment by a properly constituted Medical Board.
  • Arrears of pension shall be worked out and paid within four months.
  • The petitioner is awarded costs of the petition quantified at Rs. 3,000/-.

Implications:
The decision's immediate effect is to require the respondents to grant disability pension to the petitioner in accordance with the Medical Board's assessment and to pay arrears and costs as directed. The opinion did not state any broader precedent-setting intent beyond applying the Pension Regulations (Appendix-II, Rule 7-B) and the cited Supreme Court authority; therefore, no new legal principle beyond the court's application of existing rules and precedent was announced in the text of this opinion.

    Deepak Kumar Singh v. Union Of India.

    Devinder Gupta, J.— The petitioner has sought the quashing of order of discharge dated 3.12.1993 with direction to the respondents to reinstate him with full back wages and all consequential benefits. In the alternative, the petitioner has prayed for issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to award disability medical pension to him

    2. The petitioner was enrolled in the Indian Air Force on 22.3.1991 as Airman in the Trade - ‘Photo Technician’. According to the petitioner, a board of Medical Officers, which conducted medical examination before his entry to the Air Force declared him fit in all respects and made no note of any disease or disability in the documents of his enrolment. In November, 1992, the petitioner completed initial training and was qualified as Aircraftsman and was posted in No. 2 Sqn. Air Force. In May, 1993 he was sent on posting to E & I.T.I, Jalahalli East, Bangalore for conversion course from Photo Technician to Photo Filter Trade. It is further stated that on 23.7.1993 routine vaccines of TAB and Cholera administered to the petitioner at Station Sick Quarters, Jalahalli East, Bangalore. Such vaccines are administered in routine medical course. The petitioner developed fever and headache and frequent urination where after he started feeling weakness. On 2.8.1993 the petitioner's blood and sugar tests were conducted, which revealed that his urine had sugar contents. In Station Sick Quarters, he was given Glucose Saline without pre- diabetic precautions, which caused Diabetic KETO ACIDOSIC and the petitioner went in Coma. He was sent to Command Hospital A.F Bangalore and was kept there for three months under treatment. As a result of further medical check up, the petitioner was declared a patient of Diabetic Mellitus (IDDM) 250 and was placed in Category EEE (Permanent) with 40% disability. Relying upon the medical opinion, the petitioner was invalided out of service. His claim for medical pension was also turned down by the Controller of Defence Accounts (P) Allahabad. Appeal was also preferred but of no avail.

    3. The petitioner has challenged the order of discharge and non-grant of disability pension on the ground that discharge is illegal, unwarranted and is in violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Before enrollment, he was examined by a Board of Doctors, who had declared him fit. He became a victim of wrong treatment given at Station Sick Quarters and Command Hospital, Bangalore. Opinion of Medical Board at Command Hospital is wrong and is based upon wrong diagnosis. Because of the opinion of the Medical Board he was invalided out. The discharge based upon such wrong medical opinion is illegal. Though the percentage of disability was found to be 40% for 2 years, yet CCD(P), Allahabad, in an arbitrary manner, took a decision not to grant medical pension.

    4. The respondents in reply filed on the affidavit of Group Captain V. Pradhan, Oficer-in- Charge, Legal Cell, Air Force Record Office, New Delhi have stated that the petitioner was discharged from service on being found unfit for further service in Air Force being a case Diabetes Mellitue (IDDM) 250. The Medical Board recommended 40% disability for two years at the time of discharge. He had put in a total of two years and 255 days. The case for grant of disability pension was taken up with the Chief Controller of Defence Accounts (Pension), Allahabad for adjudication of disability pension. Through letter dated 16.11.1994 a decision was taken by CCDA(P) Allahabad that the petitioner's disability, from which he suffered during service, is neither attributable to, nor aggravated by Air Force Service. As such the claim for disability pension was rejected. Decision was conveyed to the petitioner through letter dated 13.12.1994 with an advise to prefer an appeal but no appeal was preferred. On rejection of disability pension, the petitioner was granted invalid gratuity of Rs. 3,000/- and a sum of Rs. 33,000/- towards A.F Group Insurance Scheme only.

    5. It is also stated that upon completion of training, the petitioner was posted to 25 Squadron, Air Force whereafter he was posted to E&ITI, Air force w.e.f 17.2.1993 for undergoing conversion course. Respondents have not denied that routine vaccination/inoculation along with others was done on petitioner, which is a periodical feature and is administered to all Airmen. No other airman developed weakness or frequent urination, which are symptom of diabetes. Glucose Saline was administered to the petitioner. The respondents, however, explained that in unknown cases of diabetes, pre-Diabetice check up cannot be undertaken in Station Sick Quarters. However, as an immediate requirement, IV fluid is given to keep patient alive and to treat him when required. Due to the petitioner's condition, which was serious at that time, he was rightly transferred to Command Hospital. The petitioner needed treatment in hospital as he had Diabetic Keto Acidosis and was in coma. He was placed in dangerous ill list and his relatives were also called. He was duly treated.

    6. It is further stated that cases of diabetes mellitus occuring at a young age and requiring insuline therapy are dealt with according to existing rules on the subject in the Air Force. Such patients are invalided and medically boarded out of service by a duly constituted Invaliding Medical Board. In the instant case, on 3.11.1993, Classified Specialist (Medicine and Nephrology) opined that the petitioner was a case of insulin dependent diabetes mellitus with keto acidosis and recommended him to be invalided out of service in medical category EEE (Unfit for further Air Force Service) and, accordingly, the petitioner was brought before a duly constituted Invaliding Medical Board on 10.11.1993 at Command Hospital, Air Force, Bangalore. The said medical board assessed 40% disability for two years.

    7. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. The very fact that the petitioner was examined by a Medical Board, which gave an opinion that he was not medically fit for further service in Air Force because of the disease, as noticed above, which opinion has not been rebutted by the petitioner makes it a case for no interference with the order of discharge. The order of discharge is based upon the opinion of the Medical Board, which also assessed disability to the extent of 40%. As such it cannot be said that the order of discharge is arbitrary or is not based upon material. Invaliding proceedings were duly considered by the Competent Authority on 3.12.1993 and relying thereupon the petitioner was invalided out from service w.e.f 31.12.1993, as is reflected from the certificate dated 10.11.1993 issued to the petitioner.

    8. The question to be examined now is about the petitioner's entitlement to disability pension, which claim was turned down by the Chief Controller of Defence Accounts Pension, Allahabad. It has not been disputed by the respondents that at the time of enrolment no mention was made on the petitioner's service record that he was suffering from any ailment muchless the disease in question, which resulted in the petitioner's discharge. It is also not disputed, rather it is stated in reply that “the Medical Board recommended 40% disability for two years at the time of discharge.” Based upon this opinion of the Medical Board, the petitioner was discharged. Claim for medical pension on being referred to the Chief Controller of Defence Accounts, Pension, Allahabad was negatived on the ground that the disability which the petitioner suffered during his service in the Indian Air Force is found neither attributable to, nor aggravated by Air Force Service.

    9. Needless to add that the question whether disability is attributable to or aggravated by Air Force Service is, as per the Pension Regulations for Indian Air Force, 1961, is required to be determined under the Rules, which are annexed to Regulation as Appendix-II. Rule 7-B thereof says:—

    “A disease which has led an individual discharge or death will ordinarily be deemed to have arisen in service, if no note of it was made at the time of individual's acceptence for the Air Force Service. However, if medical opinion holds, for reasons to be stated that the disease could not have been detected on medical examination, prior to acceptance for service, the disease will not be deemed to have arisen during service.”

    10. Admittedly no note of the disease was made at the time of petitioner's enrolment. The Medical Board had also in its opinion not recorded any reason that the disease suffered by the petitioner could not have been detected on medical examination prior to the petitioner's acceptance for service. Thus in view of Para 7 of the Entitlement Rules, the disease, which led to the petitioner's discharge will be deemed to have arisen during Air Force Service and it is also not disputed that during the entire service of more than 2 years the petitioner was not hospitalised or treated for the said disease except, after he was administered the vaccine. In view of the ratio of the decision of the Supreme Court in Ex. Sapper Mohinder Singh v. Union of India (CA.No 164 of 1993 decided on 14.1.1993) Chief Controller of Defence Accounts (P), Allahabad, in the absence of any other medical opinion could not have ruled out or ignored the opinion of the Medical Board upon whose opinion the petitioner was invalided out. The said Board recommended 40% disability for two years. In these circumstances, the decision of the respondents not to grant disability pension to the petitioner being arbitrary is unsustainable and is liable to be set aside.

    11. Consequently, the writ petition is allowed. Respondents are directed to sanction/grant disability pension to the petitioner as per the recommendation of the Medical Board treating the disability at 40% for two years. The same will be continued to be paid till the disability is varied on re-assessment by a properly constituted Medical Board. Arrears will be worked out and paid within four months. The petitioner will also be entitled to costs of the petition quantified at Rs. 3,000/-.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Deepak Kumar Singh v. Union Of India.
    (Aug 22, 1997)