AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This dispute arose out of a contract titled "Fabrication of R.C.C Channel Units for School Building Project, C.B.R.I, Aligarh." Differences between the parties were referred to a sole arbitrator (respondent No. 2). The arbitrator received evidence, heard the parties and published an award on 30.6.1984 awarding Rs. 28,930 to the petitioners and Rs. 13,890 to respondent No.1 (in respect of its counter-claim). The arbitrator also awarded simple interest @ 9% per annum from 1.4.1977 to 30.6.1984 on the net amount in favour of the petitioners and stipulated that if the respondents did not pay within 45 days of publication of the award, simple interest @ 12% per annum would be payable from the expiry of 45 days.

The petitioners petitioned this Court under Sections 14 and 17 of the Arbitration Act seeking a direction to the arbitrator to file the award and records and that the award be made a Rule of Court. The arbitrator filed the award in Court. Respondent No.1 filed objections under Sections 16, 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act. The Court heard the parties and delivered the opinion summarized below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this Court had territorial jurisdiction to entertain the petition to make the arbitral award a Rule of Court.
  2. Whether the arbitrator's non-speaking (reasons not given) award was vitiated by misconduct or violation of the principles of natural justice so as to warrant interference by the Court.
  3. Whether the arbitrator had the power to grant interest (pre-suit, pendente lite and future interest) and to stipulate a higher rate of interest in case of non-payment within a specified period.
  4. Whether the award lacked sufficient documentary proof such that the Court should examine and set aside the award despite it being non-speaking.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners filed a petition under Sections 14 and 17 of the Arbitration Act seeking an order directing respondent No.2 to file the award and the arbitration records and for making the award a Rule of Court.

Respondent No. 1's Arguments

  • Preliminary objection: This Court lacked territorial jurisdiction because respondent No.1's office was at Roorkee, tenders were invited, submitted and accepted at Roorkee, and the subject-matter was stated to be in the State of Uttar Pradesh.
  • Procedural/fairness objection: The arbitrator misconducted himself and violated principles of natural justice by not giving ample opportunities to respondent No.1, and by considering documents without conducting admission/denial procedures regarding those documents.
  • Evidentiary objection: The award was passed without any sufficient documentary proof.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd. v. State Of Jammu & Kashmir. Upheld the power and jurisdiction of the arbitrator to grant interest in respect of pre-suit, pendente lite and future interest. The Court relied on this decision to hold that the arbitrator's grant of interest @ 9% per annum from 1.4.1977 to 30.6.1984 was within his discretion and not erroneous, and that the arbitrator had power to direct a higher rate (12% per annum) after 45 days in case of non-payment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through the following reasoning, applying settled legal principles to the facts as recorded:

  1. Nature of the award: The award was a non-speaking award (no reasons given). The Court reiterated the settled principle that where no reasons are given the Court cannot speculate on the arbitrator's mental process; interference is permitted only within a narrow and restricted sphere, e.g., where an error is apparent on the face of the record.
  2. Territorial jurisdiction: The Court rejected respondent No.1's objection to jurisdiction. The Court observed that the Central Building Research Institute (CBRI) is a unit of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, a society with its registered office in Delhi; on that basis and because the arbitrator had filed the award in this Court, the Court concluded it had jurisdiction to try and decide whether the award could be made a Rule of Court.
  3. Alleged violation of natural justice / misconduct: The Court noted that an arbitrator may formulate his own rules for conducting proceedings and is not bound by technical rules. The award itself recorded that the arbitrator considered statements of both parties, oral and documentary evidence and written arguments, weighed and considered the facts and then passed the award. On that basis the Court found no merit in the contention that the arbitrator had violated principles of natural justice or otherwise misconducted himself.
  4. Grant of interest: Relying on the cited Supreme Court precedent (Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd. v. State Of Jammu & Kashmir.), the Court held that an arbitrator has power to grant pre-suit, pendente lite and future interest. Consequently, the arbitrator's award of interest at 9% from 1.4.1977 to 30.6.1984, and the stipulation of 12% after 45 days for non-payment, could not be characterized as error.
  5. Sufficiency of documentary proof / evaluation of evidence: The Court emphasised that in absence of reasons in a non-speaking award it was not open to the Court to probe the arbitrator's mental process or to act as a re-appraisal of evidence. The arbitrator is the sole judge of both the quality and quantity of evidence; thus the objection that the award was without sufficient documentary proof had no merit.
  6. Conclusion on objections: Applying these principles, the Court rejected respondent No.1's objections and concluded that none of them warranted setting aside the award.

Holding and Implications

The objection filed by respondent No.1 is rejected and the award is made a Rule of Court.

Direct consequences and orders given by the Court (as recorded in the opinion):

  • A decree shall be drawn up in terms of the arbitral award.
  • The petitioners are entitled to interest at the rate of 15% per annum from the date of the decree until realisation, in terms of Section 29 of the Arbitration Act (as applied by the Court).
  • The terms of the arbitrator's award remain effective: award of Rs. 28,930 to the petitioners and Rs. 13,890 to respondent No.1, interest awarded by the arbitrator (9% per annum from 1.4.1977 to 30.6.1984) and the arbitrator's stipulation of 12% per annum after expiry of 45 days for non-payment are part of the award made Rule of Court; the Court added the 15% per annum from decree until realisation.
  • No costs were awarded.

The opinion does not discuss or announce any broader legal precedent beyond applying existing authority; the effect described above is the direct consequence for the parties in this case.

Award made Rule of Court.

    Sthapati Engineers And Builders v. Central Building Research Institute And Another

    Dr. M.K Sharma, J.— Disputes having arisen between the parties to the Contract entitling “Fabrication of R.C.C Channel Units for School Building Project, C.B.R.I, Aligarh”, the same were referred to the sole arbitration of the respondent No. 2.

    2. The respondent No. 2 entered into the reference and on receiving evidence on record and on hearing the parties made and published his award on 30.6.1984 granting a sum of Rs. 28,930/- to the petitioners and Rs. 13,890/- to the respondent No. 1 in terms of their counter-claim. The Arbitrator further passed an award awarding simple interest @ 9% per annum from 1.4.1977 to 30.6.1984 on the net amount of the award in favour of the petitioners with the stipulation that if the respondents did not make the payment as awarded to the petitioners within 45 days from the date of publishing the award, a simple interest @ 12% per annum would be payable to the petitioners from the date of expiry of 45 days.

    3. The petitioners filed a petition in this Court under Sections 14 and 17 of the Arbitration Act praying for a direction to the respondent No. 2 to file the a ward and the records of the arbitration proceedings and also for making the award a Rule of the Court.

    4. On the aforesaid petition, notice was issued to the Arbitrator to file the award and upon filing of the a ward by the Arbitrator, notice was issued to the respondent No. 1 of filing of the award in the Court. The respondent No. 1 filed an objection under Sections 16, 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act on which I heard the learned Counsel appearing for the parties.

    5. The award is admittedly a non-speaking award and by the aforesaid award, the Arbitrator awarded a lump sum Rs. 28,930/- in favour of the petitioners against the various claims raised by the petitioners before the Arbitrator. In respect of the counter-claim filed by the respondent No. 1, the Arbitrator allowed the counterclaim in full awarding Rs. 13,890/-.

    6. The power and jurisdiction of the Court in respect of interfering with a non speaking award is well settled. It is not open to the Court to speculate, where no reasons are given by the Arbitrator, as to what impelled him to arrive at his conclusion. The fact that a lumpsum award has been given is no ground to declare the award bad. Therefore, in respect of a non-speaking award, the Court can set aside the award only under a very limited and restricted sphere. Keeping in mind the aforesaid legal proposition, let me examine the contention of the learned Counsel appearing for the parties.

    7. The first objection raised is with regard to the territorial jurisdiction of this Court to entertain the petition and try the same. It was submitted by Mr. A.K Sikri, Counsel appearing for respondent No. 1 that this Court has no jurisdiction to entertain this application inasmuch as, the respondent No. 1 has its office at Roorkee, where the tenders were invited and the tenders were also submitted at Roorkee and accepted at Roorkee and the subject-matter of the claim is also stated to be in the State of U.P

    8. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions made. However, I find myself unable to agree with the aforesaid submission. The Central Building Research Institute is admittedly a Unit of Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, which is a society having its registered office in Delhi. In that view of the matter, this Court shall have jurisdiction to try and decide the present petition. Besides, the Arbitrator has also filed the award in this Court. Accordingly there could be no objection to this Court trying and deciding as to whether the award passed by the Arbitrator could be made a Rule of the Court or not. The preliminary objection of the learned Counsel for the respondent No. 1 stands rejected.

    9. The next contention of the learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No. 1 was that the Arbitrator has misconducted himself in conducting the proceedings as there was violation of the principles of natural justice in not giving ample opportunities to the respondent No. 1. It was submitted that the Arbitrator took into consideration the documents filed by the parties without conducting any admission/denial in respect of the said documents. It is settled law that the Arbitrator can formulate his own rules regarding conduct of the arbitration proceedings and is not bound by the technical rules. The contents of the award disclose that the Arbitrator after considering the statements of both the parties and considering the oral and documentary evidence as also the written arguments produced before him by the parties and having heard and after duly weighing and considering the facts passed the award.

    10. In view of the aforesaid specific observations of the Arbitrator in the award, I do not find any merit in the contention of the learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No. 1.

    11. The next submission was with regard to grant of interest. It is by now well settled that the Arbitrator has power and jurisdiction to grant pre-suit pendente lite and future interest. In this connection, reference may be made to the decision of the Supreme Court in Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd. v. State Of Jammu & Kashmir., (1992) 4 SCC 217 : AIR 1992 SC 2192, in which the Supreme Court has upheld the power and jurisdiction of the Arbitrator to grant interest in respect of pre-suit, pendente lite and future interest. In that view of the matter, granting interest by the Arbitrator in the present case @ 9% per annum from 1.4.1977 to 30.6.1984 cannot be said to be an error, since the Arbitrator has discretion to grant interest. In my considered opinion, the Arbitrator also has the power and jurisdiction to issue a direction that in case the awarded amount along with the interest is not deposited within 45 days from the date of publishing the amount, the same would carry a future interest @ 12% per annum from the date of expiry of 45 days.

    12. The learned Counsel appearing for respondent No. 1 also submitted that the award passed by the Arbitrator is without any sufficient documentary proof. This Court in absence of reasons in the award cannot probe the mental process of the Arbitrator and speculate as to what impelled the Arbitrator to arrive at his conclusion.

    13. In the present case, the Arbitrator was under no obligation to give reasons in support of his decision and accordingly the Arbitrator has chosen not to give any reason in support of his decision. In absence of any reason for making the award, it is not open to the Court to interfere with the award unless it could be shown that there is an error apparent on the face of the records. In absence of any reason in a non-speaking award, it is not open to this Court to make an endeavour to infer or deduce reasons in the award or in the record accompanying the award and proceed to examine whether those were right or erroneous. The Arbitrator is held to be the Sole Judge of the quality as well as the quantity of the evidence and, therefore, it is not open to this Court to take upon itself the task of being a Judge of the evidence before the Arbitrator. Accordingly, the aforesaid objection raised by the respondent No. 1 has also no merit.

    14. In the result, the objection filed by the respondent No. 1 is held to be without any merit and the same stands rejected. The award passed by the Arbitrator is made a Rule of Court. Let a decree be drawn up in terms of the award. In addition the petitioners shall also be entitled to interest at the rate of 15% per annum from the date of decree till realisation, in terms of Section 29 of the Arbitration Act. No costs.

    Award made Rule of Court.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sthapati Engineers And Builders v. Central Building Research Institute And Another
    (Mar 6, 1997)