Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 readwith Section 151 CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 readwith Section 151 CPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This order disposes of the plaintiff's application under Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 read with Section 151 CPC for an injunction restraining Dr. Vinod Kumar (owner, publisher, editor and proprietor of "RUPEE TIMES") from using the trademark "RUPEE TIMES" in respect of a journal/newspaper or any other trademark identical with or deceptively similar to the plaintiff's alleged trademark "RUPEE GAINS", and from passing off the defendant's journal as that of the plaintiff.

The plaintiff (originally R.B.G. Freelancers Private Limited, later renamed Rupee Gains Tele Times Private Limited) published a bimonthly financial journal under the name "RUPEE GAINS" since 1986 and stated that the name was registered (Registrar of Trademarks / RNI Registration No. RNI-45792/86) and in continuous use for about nine years. The plaintiff alleged that "RUPEE GAINS" and the prominence of the word "RUPEE" had acquired goodwill and that the defendant's use of "RUPEE TIMES" (launched by Dr. Vinod Kumar, who had been associated with the plaintiff as Chief Consultant Editor until 14 June 1995) was calculated to deceive readers and to trade upon the plaintiff's goodwill, amounting to passing off.

Along with the suit, the plaintiff filed an application for an ad-interim injunction restraining the defendant from publishing "RUPEE TIMES" or otherwise passing it off as the plaintiff's journal. The defendant filed a written statement after service, denying deception and asserting registration and differences of get-up, logo and style; the defendant relied on a prior 1988 order (concerning "CORPORATE RUPEE") where the court allowed that publication to continue subject to logo change. The court heard submissions and proceeded to consider the injunction application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff was entitled to an interim injunction restraining the defendant from using the name "RUPEE TIMES" on the ground that such use amounted to passing off the defendant's journal as that of the plaintiff.
  2. Whether the plaintiff could claim exclusive trademark rights in the descriptive word "RUPEE" in the context of financial journals, thereby preventing the defendant's use of a name containing that word.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The plaintiff had been publishing "RUPEE GAINS" since 1986, had registered the name (RNI-45792/86) and had built substantial goodwill and reputation in the market over about nine years.
  • The trademark "RUPEE GAINS" predominantly consists of the word "RUPEE", which imparts financial significance, and the plaintiff had adopted "RUPEE" as a trademark in respect of its financial journal.
  • The defendant (formerly associated with the plaintiff as Chief Consultant Editor until 14 June 1995) started publishing "RUPEE TIMES" and advertised it in a manner allegedly projecting that the experienced team of "RUPEE GAINS" had come out with "RUPEE TIMES", which was sent to the plaintiff's customers.
  • The defendant was therefore attempting to trade upon and benefit from the plaintiff's reputation, causing deception and confusion among readers and amounting to passing off.

Defendant's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The defendant stated that a prior dispute (1988) involving the plaintiff and another publisher ("CORPORATE RUPEE") resulted in an order allowing "CORPORATE RUPEE" to continue after suitable logo changes; the defendant relied on that history.
  • "RUPEE TIMES" was published in a totally different style and setting, with a totally different logo and get-up from "RUPEE GAINS".
  • The defendant's journal was registered with the R.N.I., which had granted registration after due verification with the D.C.P. (Licensing) Delhi.
  • The market for financial journals is articulate and capable of distinguishing between different publications; many financial publications use descriptive words (business, financial, money, rupee) and similar-sounding titles coexist (examples were produced in categories A, B and C).
  • There was no attempt or intent to deceive purchasers or readers; consequently no passing off or confusion would result.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Habib Bank Ltd. v. Habib Bank AG Zurich, 1980 AELR 650 The five characteristics (as approved by the Court of Appeal) necessary to establish a valid cause of action for passing off: (i) a misrepresentation; (ii) made by a trader in the course of trade; (iii) to prospective customers or ultimate consumers; (iv) which is calculated to injure the business or goodwill of another trader; and (v) which causes actual damage or is likely to do so. The court recited these five characteristics and applied them to the facts, concluding that none of these characteristics were available to the plaintiff on the material before the court; thus the requirements for passing off were not met.
Judgment dated 10th May 1991 in Suit No. 2751/89 (Apple leasing-company matter) Example where use of an identical/famous name ("Apple") by a leasing company caused confusion with an established international company (Apple Computers) and resulted in a stay because the defendant could not justify choice of the name. The court distinguished this case as inapplicable: the judge held that unlike "Apple", the word "RUPEE" is descriptive of financial publications and common to the trade; therefore the rationale of the Apple case did not apply to the present context of financial journals using descriptive words.
(48) 1992 DLT 390 Relied upon by the plaintiff as authority that where a defendant started a similar business and adopted a trade name similar to the plaintiff's, confusion and passing off might arise. The court noted the plaintiff's reliance on this decision but held that in the specific context of financial journals (where descriptive words are commonly used) the reasoning did not support injunctive relief on the facts; the court effectively distinguished the precedent.
AIR 1982 Delhi 482 Relied upon by the plaintiff for the proposition that similar trade names in similar business can cause confusion amounting to passing off. The court acknowledged reliance but again distinguished the authority on the ground that financial journals routinely use descriptive terms like "rupee" and there was no evidence here of the requisite misrepresentation or likelihood of confusion.
(56) 1994 DLT 304 Relied upon by the plaintiff in support of the contention that similar trade names can lead to confusion and passing off. The court recorded the reliance and distinguished the decision for reasons explained in the judgment—primarily the descriptive nature of "RUPEE" in the financial-journal context and absence of other indicia of confusion.
(42) 1990 DLT 397 Relied upon by the plaintiff as an instance where similarity of trade names gave rise to passing off concerns. The court stated that this authority was not directly applicable to the present facts and that the circumstances of the financial-journal market made the comparison inapposite; the court therefore did not apply it to grant relief.
1988 Delhi 134 (reported / referenced decision) Relied upon by plaintiff as an example of a decision addressing similarity and possible confusion between trade names. The court referred to such citations relied on by plaintiff but concluded they did not support the grant of an injunction in the present case for reasons stated in the judgment (descriptive word, no misrepresentation, different get-up).
Earlier April 1988 order in suit between R.B.G. Freelancers (predecessor) and Wg. Cdr. Ravi Kapoor (concerning "CORPORATE RUPEE") An earlier order in which this Court held that "CORPORATE RUPEE", having been registered with R.N.I. after verification with licensing authorities, could continue publication provided its logo was changed to dispel confusion. The defendant relied on this earlier order to show that the Court had previously allowed a different publisher to use "RUPEE" in a title subject to logo modification; the present court treated that history as relevant context and used it to support the proposition that descriptive use of "RUPEE" in financial publications had not previously attracted an injunction on identical facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, staying strictly to the material before it:

  1. Descriptive nature of "RUPEE": The court observed that the word "RUPEE" is synonymous with money and is a descriptive word commonly used by financial journals and publications (similar to "business", "financial" or "money"). The court held that mere prior use of a descriptive term by one party does not confer exclusive trademark rights in that word for all time.
  2. Framework for passing off: The court relied on the five characteristics for passing off as approved in Habib Bank Ltd. v. Habib Bank AG Zurich (1980 AELR 650) and set out those elements (misrepresentation; made in the course of trade; to prospective customers; calculated to injure another's goodwill; and causing or likely to cause actual damage).
  3. Application of passing-off criteria to the facts: Applying the Habib Bank characteristics, the court concluded that the plaintiff had not demonstrated the presence of those factors on the material before the court. In particular, there was no adequate evidence of a misrepresentation by the defendant that would cause readers to believe the defendant's journal originated from the plaintiff.
  4. Distinguishing authorities invoked by plaintiff: The court considered the Apple decision (May 10, 1991, Suit No. 2751/89) and several reported Delhi Law Times and AIR decisions relied on by the plaintiff. The court distinguished those authorities on the ground that the present case involved financial journals where the use of descriptive words like "RUPEE" is widespread and inherent to the subject-matter; therefore those precedents did not warrant injunctive relief here.
  5. Consideration of market and get-up: The court noted factual indicators militating against a finding of likely confusion: the readership of financial journals is "well-educated" and "articulate"; the writing styles, get-up and logos of the two journals were different; and the defendant's publication had been registered with the R.N.I. after examination by licensing authorities. The court regarded these facts as reducing any likelihood of deception or passing off.
  6. Conclusion on misrepresentation and passing off: On the basis that "RUPEE" is descriptive and that there was no prima facie misrepresentation or evidence that the defendant was trading on the plaintiff's goodwill to cause confusion, the court concluded there was no prima facie case for grant of an injunction.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court found no merit in the plaintiff's application for an interim injunction and accordingly DISMISSED the application.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The plaintiff's application for ad-interim injunction restraining the defendant from publishing "RUPEE TIMES" or from passing it off as the plaintiff's journal was refused; the defendant was not restrained by this order.
  • No broader precedent announced: The court's reasoning focused on the descriptive nature of the word "RUPEE" in the context of financial journals and the absence of misrepresentation in the specific facts; the court distinguished other authorities relied upon by the plaintiff. The opinion does not claim to lay down a new sweeping rule beyond its reasoning that descriptive words commonly used in a trade are less likely to attract exclusive trademark protection in that context. The decision therefore resolves the injunction application on its particular facts rather than establishing a broad new principle.

    Rupee Gains Tele-Times Private Ltd v. Rupee Times.

    S.K Mahajan, J.— This order will dispose of the application of the plaintiff under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 readwith Section 151 CPC for the grant of an order of injunction restraining Dr. Vinod Kumar, owner, publisher, editor and proprietor of “RUPEE TIMES” from using the trademark “RUPEE TIMES” in respect of journal, newspaper or any other trademark which is identical with and/or deceptively similar to the trademark “RUPEE GAIN” allegedly belonging to the plaintiff. Further injunction is sought against the defendant from using the trademark “RUPEE TIMES” so as to pass off its journals as that of the plaintiff.

    2. The facts of this case in short are that R.B.G Freelancers Private Limited were engaged in the publication and sale of a bimonthly financial journal under the name and style of “RUPEE GAINS” since 1986; the name of the said company was subsequently changed to Rupee Gains Tele Times Private Limited; this journal is reported to have been registered with the Registrar of Trademarks under Registration No.RNI- 45792/86 and the said name is in continuous use by the plaintiff for the past about 9 years in respect of financial journal and is stated to be sold throughout India. According to the plaintiff, the said trademark “RUPEE GAINS” predominently consists of the word “RUPEE” so as to impart a financial significance to the journal and the plaintiff is alleged to have adopted and conceived the word “RUPEE” as a trademark in respect of a financial journal. The aforesaid trademark “RUPEE GAINS” used in the financial journal allegedly indicate to the readers and intending readers as a journal originating from the plaintiff and none other. The said trademark is alleged to be the exclusive property of the plaintiff. The word “RUPEE also forms, according to the plaintiff, an important feature of the corporate name of the plaintiff. The said name is alleged to have acquired valuable and substantial goodwill and reputation in the market. Dr.Vinod Kumar was associated with the plaintiff as Chief Consultant Editor, till 14th June, 1995, of the journal “RUPEE GAINS”. It is alleged that the defendant has started publishing a journal by adopting the trademark “RUPEE TIMES” in respect of its financial journal. According to the plaintiff, the use by the defendant of the trademark “RUPEE TIMES” in connection with and in relation to a financial journal is intended, calculated and likely to deceive purchasers and intending readers and lead them into the belief that the said journal was that of the plaintiff or an organisation associated with the plaintiff. Dr.Vinod Kumar has alleged to have advertised for “RUPEE TIMES” allegedly projecting an impression to the public that all the experienced and acknowledged team of the “RUPEE GAINS” have come out with another financial fortnight “RUPEE TIMES” and this advertisement was sent to the customers of the plaintiff company. It is alleged that the defendant is trying to trade upon the goodwill of the plaintiff company putting it to irreparable loss. The defendant by deliberately adopting the trademark “RUPEE TIMES” is trying to create a confusion in the market and is trying to deceive the intending readers. A deception and confusion, according to the plaintiff, will be caused amongst the readers in believing that the said journal “RUPEE TIMES” has come from the organisation of the plaintiff. The said adoption of the trademark “RUPEE TIMES” is stated to be dishonest and fraudulent and the defendant is alleged to be trying to pass off its goods as that of the plaintiff.

    3. Alongwith the suit, an application for ad-interim injunction was also filed for restraining the defendants from publishing the financial journal “RUPEE TIMES” or to pass off its journal under the trademark “RUPEE TIMES” as and for that of the plaintiff company.

    4. After summons of the suit and notice of the application had been served upon the defendant, written statement was filed. In the written statement, it has been stated that in March 1988 after some disputes had arisen between the then owners of “RUPEE GAINS”, one of the erstwhile owners, Wg.Cdr Ravi Kapoor started another paper under the name of “CORPORATE RUPEE” after getting the same registered with R.N.I.M/s. R.B.G Freelancer Private Limited predecessor company of the plaintiff then filed a suit in this Court against Wg.Cdr.Ravi Kapoor, inter alia, seeking restraint order against the use of the word “RUPEE” in the title of the newspaper “CORPORATE RUPEE”. This Court by an order passed in April, 1988, held that since the said “CORPORATE RUPEE” was registered with R.N.I after due verification with D.C.P (Licensing) Delhi and in case logo is changed suitably of said “CORPORATE RUPEE so as to dispel the confusion which may be caused by the similarity in the logos, the said newspaper can continue to be printed and published. The said journal “CORPORATE RUPEE is still continuing uninterruptedly and is stated to be having a very wide circulation. It is also stated that the defendant had started “RUPEE TIMES” in a totally different style and setting and has a totally different logo than “RUPEE GAINS”. A bare look at the two newspapers would show that no attempt has been made by the defendant to deceive and confuse the intending purchasers or intending readers. The newspaper is aiso stated to have been registered with R.N.I, which had granted its registration after due verification with D.C.P (Licensing) Delhi. It is stated that there is no question of any phonetic similarity between these two newspapers nor there is any question of any deception or confusion being caused in the mind of the general public. It is stated that the market which reads these financial journals is very articulate and intelligent and can easily make out the difference in the contents and substance of the news items appearing in the newspapers. Examples of various newspapers/journals/magazines have been given to show that many financial newspapers and journals are being circulated and published in the market with almost similar names. Some of such names are:—

    1.—Category “A”

    i) Financial Pulse

    ii) Financial News

    iii) Financial Wizard

    iv) Financial Times (E T)

    v) Financial Times (London)

    vi) Financial Express

    2. Category “B”

    i) Money Media

    ii) Money Times

    iii) Money Opportunities

    iv) Money Tech

    3. Category “C”

    i) Business India

    ii) Business Today

    iii) Business World

    iv) Business Standard

    v) Business Line

    5. The main thrust of argument of Mr. Malhotra is that the defendant wants to take benefit of gains and reputation of the plaintiff which reputation has been developed by the plaintiff during the last 9 years. People are bound to be misled by use of the word “RUPEE TIMES” as the word “RUPEE is predominantly displayed both on the newspaper Of the plaintiff as well as on the newspaper of the defendant. The defendant is, therefore, trying to trade upon the reputation of the plaintiff.

    6. The word “RUPEE, in my opinion, is synonymous with money. It has been noticed that almost all the financial journals and publications have been using either the word business or financial or money for their journals and newspapers. Merely because one of the company has used the word “RUPEE to name its financial journal will not mean that the said word cannot be used by any other journal nor it can mean that the journal first using the said word “RUPEE has acquired trademark in the said word. “RUPEE” is a descriptive word not a distinctive word. Everything connected with trade and business is described by money, finances & rupee and it is for this reason that these words are repeatedly used by all the financial journals and it appears to be the reason that this Court had not given a stay against the publication of the journal “CORPORATE RUPEE in a suit filed by the present plaintiff. In Habib Bank Ltd. v. Habib Bank AG Zurich reported as 1980 AELR 650, the Court of appeal, while deciding the question of passing off, had approved five characteristics which must be present in order to create a valid cause of action for passing off and they were:—

    i) a misrepresentation;

    ii) made by a trader in the course of trade;

    iii) to prospective customers of his or ultimate consumers of goods or services supplied by him;

    iv) which is calculated to injure the business or goodwill of another trader (in the sense that this is a reasonably foreseeable consequence); and

    v) which causes actual damage to a business or goodwill of the trader by whom the action is brought or (in a quia timet action) will probably to do.

    7. The main principle, therefore, which may be taken into consideration while deciding the question as to whether the defendant is passing off its goods for that of the plaintiff is that such passing off is on account of mis-representation made by the trader on the course of his trade to a perspective customer and the same is calculated to injure the business and goodwill of any other trader. In my opinion, none of the said characteristics are available to the plaintiff in the present case. Mr. Malhotra has relied upon a judgment dated 10th May, 1991 in Suit No. 2751/89 to justify that when a leasing company had tried to use the word “Apple” for its company which name was already being used by a well-known international company, it created a confusion in the mind of the general public that the said company is an organisation of Apple Computers. Consequently, a stay was granted because the leasing company was not able to satisfy the Court as to why the word “Apple” had been chosen by it for its company. In my opinion, the said judgment has no applicability to the facts of the present case, in as much as the present case is a case where a financial journal is being published by both the parties and the said financial journal has necessarily to be associated with the words business, money, finance and rupee. It cannot be said that because one of the parties has started using the word “RUPEE prior to the second party, the second party cannot, for all times to come, use the said word “RUPEE. In my opinion, there cannot be any trademark in the word “RUPEE. Reliance has also been placed by Mr. Malhotra upon (48) 1992 DLT 390, AIR 1982 Delhi 482, (56) 1994 DLT 304, (42) 1990 DLT 397 and 1988 Delhi 134 in support of his plea that where the defendant had started business similar to that of the plaintiff and the trade name adopted by the defendant is also similar to that of the plaintiff, if was likely to cause confusion to the general public and can amount to passing off goods by the defendant as that of the plaintiff. As I have already held above that in case of a financial journal, the situation may be different than in any other competitive trade. In case, two persons are carrying on business of the same nature, naturally the person who has started the business first will be aggrieved by the subsequent person using similar name, as the same may amount to passing off the goods of the first trader by the second trader and it can also create a confusion in the mind of the general public. However, in the present case, the people who read financial journals are well-educated, writing style of both the newspapers is different and there is no similarity even in the get up or logo of the two journals. To my mind, there cannot be any confusion or deception that can be caused in the mind of general public when they purchase the journal of the defendant and I do not see any possibility of the defendant's journal being passed off as that of the plaintiff.

    8. In the present case, the word “RUPEE GAIN” under which the plaintiff is publishing its journal clearly means that the plaintiff is trying to inform the general public about the gains which they may be getting by making investment in rupee. The word is not invented by the plaintiff but only a descriptive one. Every person who deals in money will speak about rupee. Prima facie, I am of the opinion that there has been no mis-representation by the defendant in taking out its journal “Rupee Time” nor the defendant is trying to pass off its journal as that of the plaintiff.

    9. I, therefore, do not see any merits in the application and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rupee Gains Tele-Times Private Ltd v. Rupee Times.
    (Sep 1, 1995)