Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act is directed against the judgment dated 27 January 1984 of the Additional District Judge on a reference made under Section 18 of the Act. The land in dispute is situated in Village Jasola. Notification under Section 4 and declaration under Section 6 were both issued on 31 December 1976. The Collector's award dated 2 February 1979 fixed the market value at Rs. 7,060 per bigha. On reference, the Additional District Judge fixed the market value at Rs. 10,000 per bigha. The appellants appealed. Initially the appellants' memo of appeal stated a market value of Rs. 30,000 per bigha; during the pendency of the appeal they applied to amend the memo to claim Rs. 55,000 per bigha (application C.M.I 08/92), and that application was allowed after no response was received to the notice. The Court heard the matter on 12 July 1993 and again later; there was no appearance on behalf of the respondent/Union of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the correct market value per bigha of the land in Village Jasola for the purposes of compensation under the Land Acquisition Act?
  2. Whether the appellants' application to amend the memo of appeal to claim Rs. 55,000 per bigha should be permitted (as a procedural matter during the appeal)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellants sought to amend the memo of appeal to claim Rs. 55,000 per bigha (application C.M.I 08/92), and the application was allowed after no response was received to the notice.
  • Appellants' counsel (Mr. Atul Kumar) relied on the Court's decision in RFA 51/83 (Union of India v. Nand Kishore) dated 6 March 1984, wherein the market price of land in Village Bahapur was upheld at Rs. 55,000 per bigha by a bench of this Court; appellants argued for a similar valuation for the adjacent Village Jasola.

Respondent's Arguments

  • There was no appearance on behalf of the respondent/Union of India to oppose the appeal; no arguments by the respondent are recorded in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
RFA 51/83 entitled Union of India v. Nand Kishore Upheld fixation of market price of land in Village Bahapur at Rs. 55,000 per bigha (value arrived at by the Additional District Judge on a reference under Section 18); notification under Section 4 in that case was of the year 1972. The Court, "keeping in view" this decision, fixed the market value of land in Village Jasola at Rs. 55,000 per bigha despite noting a four-year difference in the date of notification between the two cases.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the prior decision in RFA 51/83 (Union of India v. Nand Kishore) in which the market price for adjacent Village Bahapur had been fixed at Rs. 55,000 per bigha. The Court noted the factual difference that the Section 4 notification in RFA 51/83 was of 1972, whereas in the present case the notification was of 31 December 1976, and explicitly stated it was not the Court's view that identical valuation must follow solely because the villages are adjacent given the four-year difference in notification dates.

Procedurally, the Court allowed the appellants' application to amend the memo of appeal to claim Rs. 55,000 per bigha after issuing notice on the application and receiving no response. The Court also observed no appearance from the respondent/Union of India at the hearings. Balancing these considerations and "keeping in view" the RFA 51/83 decision, the Court concluded that the appropriate market value for the land in Village Jasola is Rs. 55,000 per bigha.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is allowed and the market value of the land in question is fixed at Rs. 55,000 per bigha.

Implications and direct consequences for the parties:

  • There will be an enhancement of Rs. 45,000 per bigha over the value fixed by the Additional District Judge (i.e., Rs. 55,000 minus Rs. 10,000).
  • The appellants are entitled to interest and solatium as provided by Section 23-B and Section 28 of the Land Acquisition Act.
  • The decree will be drawn up after the deficiency in court fee is made good; the court fee may be paid within four weeks.
  • The appellants are entitled to costs limited to court fees only.

The opinion does not discuss broader legal implications or purport to establish a new principle beyond the decision in the cited precedent; no further precedent-setting analysis is stated in the text.

    Sh. Bijay Singh v. Union Of India .

    D.P Wadhwa, J. (Oral):— This appeal filed under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act (for short the Act) is directed against the judgment dated 27th January 1984 of the Additional District Judge in a reference made to him under Section 18 of the Act. The land in question is situated in Village Jasola. Notification under Section 4 and declaration under Section 6 of the Act were both issued on 31st December 1976. The Land Acquisition Collector made his award on 2nd February 1979 fixing the market value of the land at Rs. 7,060/- per bigha. On a reference under Section 18 of the Act, the learned Additional District Judge fixed the market value of the land at Rs. 10,000/- per bigha. Still not satisfied, the appellants have filed this appeal.

    2. When the appeal was originally filed, it was stated that the market value of the land was Rs. 30,000/- per bigha. However, during the pendency of the appeal, the appellants have sought amendment of the memo of appeal now claiming Rs. 55,000/- per bigha as the market value of the land. This is by an application (C.M.I 08/92). We had issued notice of this application but there has not been any response to the same. The application, therefore, is allowed.

    3. Mr. Atul Kumar, learned counsel for the appellants, has referred to a decision of this Court in RFA 51/83 entitled Union of India v. Nand Kishore wherein a bench of this Court, by judgment dated 6th March 1984, upheld the fixation of market price of theland in Village Bahapur at Rs. 55,000/- per bigha. This value had been arrived at by the Additional District Judge on a reference made to him under Section 18 of the Act. We may, however, note that in this case, the notification under Section 4 of the Act was of the year 1972. In the present case, as noted above, the notification under Section 4 of the Act is of the year 1976. It is not our opinion that same value is to be arrived at in this case just because two villages are adjacent to each other but there is a difference of four years in issue of notification in the present case and that in RFA 51/83.

    4. We had heard thismatteron 12th July 1993 and again today. There has been no appearance on behalf of respondent/Union of India to oppose this appeal.

    5. Keeping in view the decision of this Court in RFA 51/83, we are of the opinion that the market value of the land in Village Jasola, village adjacent to that of Village Bahapur, in the present case should be fixed at Rs. 55,000/- per bigha. We order accordingly.

    6. The appeal is allowed. The market value of the land in question is fixed at Rs. 55,000/- per bigha. There will be an enhancement of Rs. 45,000/- per bigha on the value as fixed by the Additional District Judge. The appellant will be entitled to interest and solatium as per Section 23-B and Section 28 of the Act. The decree will be drawn up after the deficiency in court fee is made. The court fee may be paid within a period of four weeks. The appellants will be entitled to costs limited to court fees only.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sh. Bijay Singh v. Union Of India .
    (Jul 19, 1993)