Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Facts:

The parties involved in this case are real brothers. The plaintiff has initiated a suit for a declaration against the defendant, who has recently refused to acknowledge the plaintiff's claim. The specifics of the claim have not been detailed in the provided notes, but the refusal to admit the claim has prompted the plaintiff to seek judicial intervention.

Issue:

The primary issue at hand is whether the court fees paid by the plaintiff are appropriate for a declaratory suit under the provisions of the Suits Valuation Act, particularly Section 8, and whether the valuation for jurisdiction is determined by the real value of the property in question.

Legal Context:

In declaratory suits where no consequential relief is requested, Section 8 of the Suits Valuation Act does not apply, as court fees are not assessed ad valorem. This principle was affirmed in the case of *Shivsangappa Irsangappa v. Muchkhandeppa Irsangappa*, A.I.R 1932 Bombay 160, where the Bombay High Court established that the valuation for jurisdiction should be based on the real value of the property rather than a notional value.

Court Fee:

In this case, the plaintiff has paid a fixed court fee of Rs. 20, which is deemed appropriate and in accordance with the requirements for a simple declaratory suit.

Conclusion:

Given the nature of the suit and the precedent set by the Bombay High Court, the court fees paid by the plaintiff are valid. The plaintiff seeks a declaration regarding their claim against the defendant, and the court will need to consider whether the refusal to admit the claim warrants the relief sought by the plaintiff.

Recommendation:

It is recommended that the court proceed to hear the merits of the case, taking into account the established legal principles regarding the valuation and court fees applicable to declaratory suits. Further evidence and arguments from both parties should be solicited to resolve the dispute effectively.

Next Steps:

  • Schedule a hearing to address the merits of the plaintiff’s claim.
  • Allow both parties to present evidence and arguments regarding the declaration sought.

Date:

[Specify Date]

    Prem Nath Wadhawan v. Inder Raj Wadhawan

    S.C Jain, J.:— Shri Prem Nath Wadhawan, plaintiff herein, filed the Suit praying for a decree for declaration to be passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant to the effect that the plaintiff is the absolute and sole owner of property No. B-5/204 Safdarjung Residential Scheme, New Delhi (also known as Safdarjung Enclave) by way of adverse possession being in open, hostile and continuous possession and occupation of the same for more than 12 years.

    2. In brief the facts of the case as are apparent on the record are that plaintiff and defendant both are real brothers. A plot of land bearing No. B-5/204, Safdarjung Residential Scheme, New Delhi measuring 213 square metres was purchased in public auction on 27.6.1971 from the Delhi Development Authority and a residential house was constructed thereon. Since the very inception, the plaintiff alongwith his family has been exclusively living in the said house for the last more than 12 years i.e since November, 1975 in his own right. During all this period the plaintiff has been in sole and exclusive possession, occupation and enjoyment of the said property and the defendant was also well aware of the same and he had never asserted his ownership right therein. The possession of the plaintiff in the said property is open, hostile and continuous possession and enjoyment of the said property bearing No. B-5/204, Safdarjung Enclave, New Delhi and the plaintiff has been openly giving out and declaring himself to be the sole and exclusive owner of the said property. Recently the defendant refused to admit the claim of the plaintiff and hence this suit for declaration has been filed.

    3. The defendant was served, who has filed the written statement in which he has admitted that the plaintiff has been in continuous possession of property No. B-5/204, Safdarjung Residential Scheme, New Delhi from the very inception. His possession is more than 12 years old and that he never interfered with his possession of the property.

    4. During the course of the arguments a point regarding the payment of court fee cropped up and I have heard arguments of the learned counsel for the parties on this point. Admittedly, this is a simple suit for declaration and no consequential relief follows from it as the plaintiff is in exclusive possession of the said property claiming himself to the owner of the same. The provisions of Section 7(4)(c) of the Court Fees Act are not attracted in this case. The plaintiff can value the suit of his choice and in this case a fixed court fee of Rs. 20/- has been paid valuing the suit for the purposes of jurisdiction at Rs 2,00,000/-. A suit, where the relief prayed for is for declaration and a consequential relief, would fall under Section 7(4)(c) of the Court-fees Act, and the valuation for the purposes of court fees and for the purposes of jurisdiction would be the same under Section 8 of the Suits Valuation Act, 1887. The valuation for the purpose of court fee in a simple declaratory suit is governed by Schedule 2, Article 17, Clause (3) which prescribes a fixed court fee of Rs. 19.50 Under Section 8 of the Suits Valuation Act, where in suits other than those referred to in the Court-fees Act, 1870, Section 7, paras 5, 6, and 9, and para 10 clause (d) court fees are payable at ad valorem under the Court-fees Act, 1870, the value as determinable for the computation of court-fees and the value for the purposes of jurisdiction shall be the same. It would, therefore, follow that in a declaratory suit in which no consequential relief is asked Section 8 of the Suits Valuation Act would have no application as the court fees are not paid ad valorem. It has been held by the learned Judges of the Bombay High Court in Shivsangappa Irsangappa v. Muchkhandeppa Irsangappa (A.I.R 1932 BOMBAY 160) that in a simple declaratory suit it is the real value of the property and not the notional value that would determine the valuation for jurisdiction apart from the valuation for purposes of court fees.

    5. This case being a simple suit for declaration, a fixed Court fee of Rs. 20/- has been correctly paid.

    6. Regarding merits, let the documents and affidavits be filed within 6 weeks and matter be listed before the Deputy Registrar on 25.5.1993 for exhibiting the documents in view of the averments made in the affidavits and the case be listed for arguments before the Court on 4.8.1993

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prem Nath Wadhawan v. Inder Raj Wadhawan
    (Mar 4, 1993)