Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a contractor, executed work involving the strengthening of an existing runway and construction of a taxi track and apron at Bakshi-ka-Talab (Lucknow) pursuant to a contract agreement dated 1962-63. Disputes arose under this contract, leading to the appointment of Mr. N. K. Aggarwal as arbitrator. The arbitrator issued an award on 2nd February 1971, awarding Rs. 7,12,459.97 to the contractor. Respondent No. 1 challenged parts of this award relating to specific claims amounting to Rs. 5,78,624.96. The Court framed issues based on the parties' pleadings and proceeded to hear objections against the award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the objections to the award are within the prescribed time, and if not, whether delay can be condoned.
  2. Whether there exist any disputes or differences between the parties.
  3. Whether the arbitrator had jurisdiction to decide the matters referred.
  4. Whether the award is liable to be set aside based on the objections raised, and if so, with what effect.
  5. Whether the petitioner is debarred from claiming the disputed amounts.
  6. What relief should be granted.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M/S. Bindra Builders v. Delhi Development Authority, AIR 195 Delhi 370 Distinction between arbitration jurisdiction in cases of substitution versus reduction in contract claims. Used to illustrate that the arbitrator’s jurisdiction depends on the interpretation of contract terms and the nature of the claim; claims 11(a) and (b) were not extra items and thus arbitrable.
The Chief Administrator, Dandakaranya Project, Koraput, Orissa and another v. M/s. Prabartak Commercial Corporation Ltd, AIR 1975 Madhya Pradesh 152 Matters left to the decision of the Superintending Engineer under certain contract clauses are excepted from arbitration and not subject to review. Applied to hold that disputes under clause 12 fall outside arbitration jurisdiction and awards on such matters must be set aside.
M/s. Jagan Nath Phool Chand v. Union of India and others, 20 (1981) Delhi Law Times 280 Arbitrator’s jurisdiction is derived from and limited by the arbitration agreement; no jurisdiction beyond contract terms. Supported the conclusion that arbitrator lacked jurisdiction over claim No. 15, which was governed exclusively by clause 12.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first addressed the timeliness of objections, relying on a prior Division Bench judgment to condone the delay. It then analyzed the nature of the disputed claims in light of the contract clauses. The arbitration clause (clause 25) generally covers disputes arising from the contract, except where otherwise provided. Clause 12 provides a specific dispute resolution mechanism for altered, additional, or substituted works, making the decision of the Superintending Engineer final and excluding such disputes from arbitration.

The court examined claims 2(i) to (v), 11(a), and 11(b) and found they did not fall under clause 12 and were therefore arbitrable. The arbitrator’s award on these claims was upheld as free from error or misconduct. Conversely, claim No. 15 related to extra items of work governed by clause 12, which expressly excludes arbitration. The court relied on precedent from the Madhya Pradesh High Court and this Court’s own Division Bench to conclude that the arbitrator lacked jurisdiction over claim No. 15. Consequently, the award on claim No. 15 was set aside while awards on other claims were confirmed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court set aside the arbitrator’s award only in respect of claim No. 15 amounting to Rs. 1,89,913, holding that this claim fell outside the arbitrator’s jurisdiction under clause 12 of the contract. The award in respect of all other claims was upheld and made a rule of the Court, with a decree passed accordingly.

Implications: This decision clarifies that disputes expressly covered by a contract clause providing a final decision by a designated official (here, the Superintending Engineer under clause 12) are excluded from arbitration. The ruling enforces strict adherence to the arbitration agreement’s scope, limiting arbitrator jurisdiction to matters not otherwise provided for. The parties bear their own costs, and no new precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties was established.

    C. Lyall & Co v. Union Of India

    Y. K. Sabharwal, J.:— The petitioner (for short ‘contractor’) executed the work of strengthening of existing runway and construction of Taxi track and Apron at Bakshi-ka-Talab (Lucknow) pursuant to agreement No. 2.EE of 1962-63. As some disputes arose out of the said contract Mr. N. K. Aggarwal, respondent No. 2 was appointed as an arbitrator. The arbitrator made and published his award on 2nd February, 1971 awarding a sum of Rs. 7,12,459.97 to the contractor. The award and proceedings were filed in this Court and respondent No. 1 has filed objections challenging the award in respect of claims No. 2(i) to (v), 11 (a) and (b) and 15 to the extent of Rs. 5,78,624.96 particulars whereof are as under:—

    “Claim No. The amount awarded.
    No.2(i) Rs. 1,22,626.00
    No. 2(ii), (iii), (iv) & (v) Rs. 21,650.00
    No. 11 (a) Rs. 11,500.00
    No.11(b) Rs. 2,32 935.00
    No. 15. Rs. 1,89,913.00
    Total: Rs. 5,78,624.96”
    2. On pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed.
    1. Whether the objections are within time? If not, is the objector entitled to condonation of delay?
    2. Whether there are no disputes or differences between the parties?
    3. Had the arbitrator no jurisdiction in the matter?
    4. Is the award liable to be set aside for reasons given in the objection petition. If so, with what effect?
    5. Is the petitioner debarred from claiming the amounts in dispute?
    6. Relief.
    3. I have heard learned counsel for the respondent/objector in support of the objections. None appeared for the contractor. My findings on issues are as under:—
    FINDINGS:
    ISSUE NO. 1:
    4. Issue No. 1 stands answered in favour of the objector by judgment of Division Bench in FAO (OS)-14 of 1973 dated 13th November, 1980 holding that the objectors are entitled to delay being condoned. Issue No. 1 is decided accordingly.
    ISSUES NO. 2 to 5:
    5. Issues No. 2 to 5 can be conveniently taken up together. The substance of the objection to the award is that disputes in regard to claims No. 2(i) to (v). 11 (a), 11(b) and 15 cannot be arbitrated upon under clause 25 of the agreement containing arbitration clause as these disputes are covered by clause 12 which itself provides the machinery for decision of disputes falling under the said clause whereunder decision of the Superintending Engineer is final. Learned counsel for the objector submits that award in respect of these claims is liable to be set aside as the arbitrator has exercised jurisdiction in respect of the matters outside the reference and that disputes and differences, if any, pertaining to the said claims fall in the category of ‘Excepted matters’ and could not be referred to arbitration as the decision of the Superintending Engineer there upon is final. It is submitted that arbitrator exceeded his jurisdiction in proceeding to give his award in respect of the said claims. As the bone of contention depends upon the interpretation of arbitration clause No. 25, it would be appropriate to produce the said clause which reads as under:
    “Except where otherwise provided in the contract all questions and disputes relating to the meaning of the specifications, designs drawings and instruction hereinbefore mentioned and as to the quality of workmanship or materials used on the work or as to any other question, claim, right, matter or thing whatsoever, in any way arising out of or relating to the contract, designs, drawings, specifications, estimates, instruction, or the execution or failure to execute the same whether arising during the progress of the work or after the completion or abandonment thereof shall be referred to the sole arbitration of the person appointed by the Additional Chief Engineer, Central Public Works Department, Incharge of the work at the time of dispute or if there be no Additional Chief Engineer, the administrative head of the said Central Public Works Department at the time of such appointment. It will be no objection to any such appointment that the arbitrators so appointed is a Government servant, that he had to deal with the matters to which the contract relates and that in the course of his duties as Government servant he had expressed views on all or any of the matters in dispute or difference. The Arbitrator to whom the matter is originally referred being transferred or vacating his office or being unable to act for any reason, such Additional Chief Engineer or administrative head as aforesaid at the time of such transfer, vacation of office or inability to act, shall appoint another person to act as arbitrator in accordance with the terms of the contract. Such person shall be entitled to proceed with the reference from the stage at which it was left by his predecessor. It is also a term of this contract that no person other than a person appointed by such Additional Chief Engineer or administrative head of the Central Public Works Department as aforesaid should act as abitrator and, if for any reason, that is not possible, the matter is not to be referred to arbitration at all.”
    6. The submission of learned counsel is that clause 12 of the agreement provides for complete machinery for decision of disputes in regard to matters relating to rates for the altered, additional or substituted works etc. and in the event of a dispute the decision of the Superintending Engineer of the Circle is final under the said clause. Clause 12 reads as under:—
    “The Engineer-in-Charge shall have power to make any alterations in, omissions from, additions to, or substitution for, the original specifications, drawings designs and instructions, that may appear to him to be necessary or advisable during the progress of the work, and the contractor shall be bound to carry out the work in accordance with any instructions which may be given to him in writing signed by the Engineer-in-Charge, and such alterations, omissions, additions or substitution shall not invalidate the contract, and any altered, additional or substituted work which the contractor may be directed to do in the manner above specified as part of the work shall be carried out by the contractor on the same conditions in all respects on which he agreed to do the main work. The time for completion of the work shall be extended in the proportion that the altered, additional or substituted work bears to the original contract work, and the certificate of the Engineer-in-Charge shall be conclusive as to such proportion. The rates for the altered, additional or substituted work shall be worked out in accordance with the following provisions in their respective order:—
    I. If the rates for the additional altered or substituted work are specified in the contract for the work, the contractor is bound to carry out the additional altered or substituted work at the same rates as are specified in the contract for the work.
    II. If the rates for the additional, altered or substituted work are not specifically provided in the contract for the work the rate will be derived from the rates for similar class of work as are specified in the contract for the work.
    III. If the rates for the altered, additional or substituted work cannot be determined in the manner specified in sub-clause (I) and (II) above, then the contractor shall within 7 days of the date of receipt of order to carry out the work, inform the engineer-in-charge of the rate which it is his intention to charge for such class of work, supported by analysis of the rate or rates claimed, and the engineer-in-charge shall determine the rate or rates on the basis of prevailing market rates and pay the contractor accordingly. However, the engineer-in-charge by notice in writing, will be at liberty to cancel his order to carry it out in such manner as he may consider advisable, but, under no circumstances, the contract shall suspend the work on the plea of non-settlement of rates of items falling under the clause.
    In the event of a dispute the decision of the Superintending Engineer or the Circle shall be final.”
    Firstly I will take up award in respect of claims No. 2(i) to (v), 11 (a) and 11(b). Under clause 2(i) to (v) the contractor challenged the reduction made by the objector in rates in various items and claimed refund and also challenged certain deductions made due to the rough surface in runway, inadequate roiling, joints not filled with mortar in french drain and due to inadequate curing on the masonery work. The objectors/Union of India justified the reductions and deductions made by it. The amount awarded is as under:—

    CLAIMS AWARD “2 (I). The claimants submit that recovery of Rs. 1,39,066.38 on account of alleged over-sized ballast is not acceptable and the The claim is partly justified. An amount of Rs. 122.626 (Rs. one hundred & twenty-two thousand and six

    amount recovorable on this account is only Rs. 183.82 Refund of the amount recovered in excess is claimed. hundred and twenty-six) be refunded to the claimants. 2. (II), (III), (IV) & (V). The claimants submit that recovery for so-called rought finish of concrete, inadequate during etc. is not justified and refund of the amount of Rs. 38,392.06 recovered on this ground is claimed. The claims are partly justified. An amount of Rs. 21,650 (Rs. Twenty-one thousand & six hundred and fifty) be refunded to the claimants.”

    It does not appear from the aforesaid that claims 2(1) to (V) relate to extra items of work as contended on behalf of the objector. It cannot be said from the reading of the aforesaid claims that they fall under clause 12 of the agreement. Even in their counter statement, no objection was taken by the objector that these claims fall under clause 12 and are not arbitraable, although such an objection was taken in regard to claim No. 15. It is not possible to accept the contention of the objector that the petitioner is debarred from claiming the amounts in respect of these claims or that the arbitrator had no jurisdiction to decide these claims. There is no error apparent on the face of the award nor is there any misconduct justifying setting aside of the award in regard to these claims.
    The next challenge is to award in respect of claims No. 11(a) and 11(b). The claim and the award in respect of these claims read as under:—
    CLAIMS AWARD 11(a) It is stated that a quantity of 574,728 c.ft earth-work was executed under agrreement item No. 1 or 2 which carries a rate of Rs. 70 per% oc ft., and it is not just to treat it as extra item of work as no such orders were The claim is partly justified. An amount of Rs. 11,500 (Rs. eleven thousand and five hundred) be paid to the claimants in addition to amounts already paid to them.
    given. Payment made at Rs.40.15 is, therefore, not acceptable and payment of the balance amount Rs. 17,156 is claimed. 11(b) It is stated that a total quantity of 1,50,000 c. ft. of extra concrete was done for which the correct rate payable is Rs. 595.73 % c. ft., but payment has been made for 16,397 c. ft. at Rs. 547.07 % c.ft and no payment has been made for the balance quantity. Thus, an additional payment of Rs. 813,370 is claimed. This claim includes claim for refund of Rs. 14,639 recovered on account of rejection of a slab. The claim is partly justified. An amount of Rs. 232,935.96 (Rupees two hundred and thirty-two thousand and nine hundred and thirty-five and paise ninety-six only) be paid to the claimants by the respondents in addition to the payments already made.
    A perusal of the statement of claim in regard to aforesaid two items shows that there was dispute between the parties as to whether work in respect of these claims was an extra item or not. The case of the contractor was that earth-work paid under item No. 48/37 which was alleged to be an extra item, was not an extra item as it was covered by items 1 or 2 of the agreement. On the other hand, the Union of India was claiming it to be an extra item. Undoubted if it was not in extra item, it could be arbitrated upon. It is not for this Court to sit over the judgment of the arbitrator as a Court of appeal.
    11. In M/S. Bindra Builders… v. Delhi Development Authority…. AIR 195 Delhi-370(1), the facts were that a claim could be arbitrated upon if it was a case of substitution and if it was one of ‘reduction’, the arbitrator was to be bound by the decision of the Chief Project Engineer. A learned Single Judge left it for the arbitrator to decide and said that “if he and that the case was of substitution, he would naturally adjudicate upon the same. If, however, he comes to the view that the case is one of reduction, then to that extent he will be bound by the decision of the Chief Project Engineer in terms of clause 25 B.” Learned Judge observed that “the case was not one of the determining the jurisdiction of the arbitrator, but that of interpreting the terms & conditions of the contract in the context of the facts ascertained.” In case in hand it cannot be said that claims 11(a) and (b) are extra items covered by clause 12 and in any case, it cannot said that there is any error apparant on the face of the award or there is any misconduct justifying setting aside of the award in respect of these items. The arbitrator did not treat it as extra items of work. It is also not apparent from the award that the contractor was stopped from claiming the amount under these items. The objection to this part of the award also fails.
    12. This takes me to the last item of challenge, namely, claim No. 15 which reads as under:—
    CLAIM AWARD 15. The claimants submit that for certain extra items of work, payment has been made at less rates and for certain items, no payment has been made as per details given in the statement ‘C’, part I & II of the statement of quantities, etc. filed by the claimants. An additional amount of Rs. 981,411.10 is, claimed for full quantity at correct rates. The claim is partly justified. An amount of Rs. 189,913 (Rs. one hundred and eighty-nine thousand and nine hundred and thirteen) be paid to the claimants by the respondents in addition to payments already made.
    13. The claim petition filed before the arbitrator also shows that claim under this item was under clause 12 of the agreement. It has been stated in the statement of claim that, “the rates of the extra items have not been determined as per the terms of the contract as under the terms of the contract clause 12 of the agreement we had to inform the rate of the extra items within 7 days of the receipt of the order to carry out the work and we did accordingly in our various letters which are mentioned below along with the analysis, so these rates are not acceptable to us and should be revised as demanded in our letter as referred below in each item.”
    14. Clause 12 expressly states that the decision of the Superintending Engineer with regard to the aforesaid matters, in the event of a dispute, shall be final. Clause 25 containing arbitration clause starts with the words “except where otherwise provided in the contract”. The machinery to determine disputes having been expressly provided for under clause 12 excludes the operation of the arbitration clause in relation to disputes covered under clause 12. Specific objection was taken by the objector/Union of India before the arbitrator that the rate for extra items have been derived strictly in accordance with the provisions contained in clause 12 of the agreement and as per clause 12 of the agreement if any dispute arises regarding the rates for any altered, additional or substituted item of work the decisions of the Superintending Engineer for rates is final, and hence this dispute is beyond the purview of the arbitration. On such an objection being taken the arbitrator determined the disputes subject, however, to the plea of want of jurisdiction of the arbitrator raised by the respondents in the counter statement of facts and it has been so specifically recorded in the recital of the award. Clauses similar to clause Nos. 12 and 15 came up for consideration before a Division Bench of Madhya Pradesh in re: The Chief Administrator, Dandakaranya Project, Koraput, Orissa and another v. M/s. Prabartak Commercial Corporation Ltd, A.I.R 1975 Madhya Pradesh—152(2), The Division Bench on the construction of the said clauses came to the conclusion that the matters left to the decision of the Superintending Engineer were not subject to review despite the arbitration clause and observed:—
    “On the proper construction of the contract, the matters left to the decision of the Superintending Engineer under Clause 13A, were not subject to review despite the arbitration clause. Clause 14. The matters left by the contract to the decision or determination of the Superintending Engineer were expressly excepted from the arbitration clause. The reference of the alleged dispute, when there was none, to the arbitrator under Section 20 of the Arbitration Act, was, therefore, clearly invalid. Consequently, the entire proceedings before the arbitrator, including the resultant awards and the preliminary decree based thereon, were null and void.”
    15. Clause 12 is similar to clause 13A and clause 15 is similar to clause 14 which came up for consideration before the Madhya Pradesh High Court. I am in complete agreement with the view expressed in M/s. Prabartak Commercial Corporation Ltd. case (supra). This case was also cited with the approval in a Division Bench judgment of this Court in case of M/s. Jagan Nath Phool Chand v. Union of India and others 20 (1981) Delhi Law Times 280(3) holding that the jurisdiction of an arbitrator to hear and decide the disputes springe from and circumscribed by the agreement of arbitration itself and he cannot assume jurisdiction which does not vest in him thereunder. It is clear that the disputes in respect of claim No. 15 could be arbitrated upon in view of combined reading of clauses 12 and 15 and as such are outside the jurisdiction of the arbitrator. In view of above, my answer to issues No. 2 to 5 is as under:—
    ISSUE NO. 2:
    16. Disputes or differences in respect of claim No. 15 are not covered by arbitration clause.
    ISSUE No. 3:
    17. The arbitrator had jurisdiction to decide all claims except claim No. 15.
    ISSUE No. 4:
    18. The award is liable to be set aside only in regard to claim No. 15.
    ISSUE No. 5
    19. The contractor is not debarred from claiming the amount in dispute except the amount under claim No. 15.
    ISSUE No. 6:
    RELIEF:
    20. For the reasons above mentioned, award dated 2nd February, 1971 in respect of claim No. 15 amounting to Rs. 1,89,913 is set aside. The award in respect of all other claims is made a rule of the Court and decree is passed in terms thereof. Parties are left to bear their own costs.
    M.B.L. Ordered accordingly
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C. Lyall & Co v. Union Of India
    (Nov 8, 1988)