AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 16.2 (1) of the Punjab Police Rules and Rule 8 read with Rule 10 of the Delhi Police Punishment and Appeal Rules, 1980
  • provisions similar to Rule 16.2(1) of the Punjab Police Rules quoted above. Rule 8
  • Rule 16.2(1) of the Punjab Police Rules, Rules 8 and 10
  • SECTION 149 DELHI POLICE ACT
  • Rule 162(1) of the Punjab (Police Rules; 1934.
  • u/s 21 of the Delhi Police Act instead.4.
  • Rule 16.3 of the Punjab Police Rules
  • 6013.DAP u/s. 21 of D.P Act, 1978. You
  • SECTION 21 DELHI POLICE ACT
  • Section 378, I.P.C
  • service.9. Rule 10
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 16.2 (1) of the Punjab Police Rules and Rule 8 read with Rule 10 of the Delhi Police Punishment and Appeal Rules, 1980
  • provisions similar to Rule 16.2(1) of the Punjab Police Rules quoted above. Rule 8
  • Rule 16.2(1) of the Punjab Police Rules, Rules 8 and 10
  • SECTION 149 DELHI POLICE ACT
  • Rule 162(1) of the Punjab (Police Rules; 1934.
  • u/s 21 of the Delhi Police Act instead.4.
  • Rule 16.3 of the Punjab Police Rules
  • 6013.DAP u/s. 21 of D.P Act, 1978. You
  • SECTION 21 DELHI POLICE ACT
  • Section 378, I.P.C
  • service.9. Rule 10

    Sukhbir Singh (Petitioner) v. The Deputy Commissioner Of Police, New Delhi And Others (S).

    S.B Wad, J.:— The petitioner, a Constable Driver in Delhi Police was dismissed from service on 15-3-1982. A charge of stealing a brass utensil (Patila) was held to be proved against him. The enquiry was conducted under section 21 of the Delhi Police Act. In this petition the petitioner has challenged his dismissal from service. The charge against the petitioner was as under:

    “I, Inspector, Nirmal Singh, Company Commander ‘F’ Coy charge you const. Sukhbir Singh (Driver) No. 6013.DAP u/s. 21 of D.P Act, 1978. You const. Sukhbir Singh No. 6013.DAP on 3-2-80 while posted as driver in DAP list BN. went to Mess no. 2 of DAP III Bn. to witness a television film show in the evening. It is evident that you stole a brass patila from mess no. 2 and took the same to your tea shop run by your brother at Bhama Shah Marg. C. Ram Kumar, the mess Manager of mess no. 2 detected the theft and found brass patila lying in the tea shop at Bhama Shah Marg. It is further evident that you const. Sukhbir Singh no. 6013.DAP loaded that patila in truck no. DLL 6071 and unloaded it in mess no. 2 in the morning of 4-2-80.

    From the evidence your act, amounted to the commission of Criminal offence by a Public servant hereby charged u/s 21 of D.P Act.

    Sd/- Nirmal Sidgh

    INSPR. 1st Bn.”

    2. A criminal complaint was lodged against the petitioner under section 380 of I.P.C However, the same was not pursued. The Deputy Commissioner of Police (B.K Misra) Decided that instead of proceeding in the criminal court a departmental enquiry should be conducted. The relevant portion of his order reads:

    “The above said facts disclose the commission of criminal offence committed by const. Sukhbir Singh being Public Servant while he had visited No. 2 of III Bn. for witnessing a T.V Film show on the evening of 3-2-1980. However keeping in view the above said facts institution of departmental proceeding would be much better.”

    3. In the summary of allegations served on the petitioner it was also stated:

    The above???acts of const. Sukhbir Singh no. 6013.DAP amount the commission of a criminal offence by a public servant. However, mitigating circumstances in this case do not warrant criminal proceedings but domestic proceedings punishable u/s 21 of the Delhi Police Act instead.”

    4. The prosecution examined nine witnesses. The petitioner examined three witnesses in support of his case. His main plea was that the allegation was concocted and false. From the evidence it is clear that nobody had seen the petitioner actually removing the utensil from the mess. However, the prosecution witnesses as well as the defence witnesses had found the utensil in the truck of which the petitioner was the Driver. Two prosecution witnesses also stated to have seen the petitioner depositing the utensil in the mess. All this is after the discovery of the utensil in the shop belonging to the petitioner's brother. In the strict legal requirement of Section 378, I.P.C It may be. difficult to hold that the petitioner had committed a theft. The petitioner's misconduct however, can be reasonably inferred from the fact that the utensil was located in his brother's tea shop. The prosecution version that the tea shop is of both the brother's is not controverted. The utensil was returned to the mess by the petitioner. He did not do it on his own. It was done only after the utensil was discovered in the shop by the Offier-in-charge of the mess and some other employees. The conclusion in the departmental proceeding that the petitioner was guilty of misconduct is; therefore, reasonably correct. The petitioner, however, contends that at the time of the service of the charge-sheet the names of only four witneses were given to him but actually nine witness were examined on behalf of the presecution. I do not find much substance in this abjection. The petitioner had an opportunity of cross-examining) and had in fact cross-examined all the prosecution witnesses; There are no procedural defects in the enquiry.

    5. But the petitioners must succeed on the second ground of his challenge. He submits that the punishment awarded to him is disproportionately harsh and is not warranted by the rules in this regard. He relies upon Rule 162(1) of the Punjab (Police Rules; 1934. The said rule stated:

    “Dismissal shall be awarded only for the gravest acts of misconduct or as ???the cumulative effect of continued misconduct proving incorrigibility and complete unfitness for police service In making such an award regard shall be had to the length of service of the offender and his. claim to pension.”

    6. The submission of the respondents is that the punishment was not excessive. It is also their submission that the Punjab Police Rules have no applicability to the present case because they have ceased to be operative after coming into force the Delhi Police Punishment and Appeals Rules, 1980 with effect from 30-12-1980.

    7. The legal submission of the respondents is wrong. It has been held by this Court, in R.C Suga??? v. Delhi Administration (1) & in R.L Makkar v. Thakur Jagdish Singh (2) that the Punjab Police Rules have statutory force. It has been further laid dawn by this Court in Peter Samual Wallace v. Inspector General of Police, New Delhi (3), that section 149 of the Delhi Police Act specifically saves the operation, amongst others, of the Punjab Police Rules to the Union Territory of Delhi. Section 149 of the Act is very clear on this point. The Delhi Police Punishment and Appeals Rules, 1980 do not in terms repeal the Punjab Police Rules. It is, therefore, wrong to say that the Punjab Police Rules are not applicable. Of course,. Section 149 lays down that the said rules in so far as they are not inconsistent with the Act are applicable.

    8. In Delhi Police Punishment and Appeals Rules, 1980 there are two provisions similar to Rule 16.2(1) of the Punjab Police Rules quoted above. Rule 8 provides:

    “The punishment of dismissal or removal from service shall be. awarded for the act of grave misconduct rendering him unfit for police service.”

    9. Rule 10 looks to the disciplinary aspect of the punishment and provide:

    “The previous record of an officer, against whom charges have been proved, if shows continued, misconduct indicating incorrigibility and complete unfitness for police service, the punishment awarded shall ordinarily be dismissal from service. When complete unfitness for police service is not established, but unfitness for a particular rank is proved, the punishment shall normally be in reduction in rank.”

    10. If Rule 16.2 (1) of the Punjab Police Rules and Rule 8 read with Rule 10 of the Delhi Police Punishment and Appeal Rules, 1980 are compared it may be seen that there is no inconsistency between them. In fact, both the provisions state that the misconduct must be very ‘grave’ and continued, indicating incorrigibility and complete unfitness for Police service. It is thus seen that while awarding the sentence the Disciplinary Authority must apply its mind closely to the nature of the misconduct. It must be very grave. It cannot be said that the temporary mis-appropriation of a utensil from a mess is such a grave misconduct. But what is more important is that neither the Disciplinary Authority nor the Appellate Authority have applied their mind to the requirement of the statutory provisions before awarding the sentence of dismissal It was incumbent on the said Authorities to look to the past record of the petitioner and to find out whether there is any history of “continued misconduct.” Neither the order of the Disciplinary Autority nor the order of the Appellate Authority disclose any past record of the Petitioner. The requirement of the statutory provision is that it must be shown that the delinquent is incorrigible. A history of past record showing the proceedings or warnings to the petitioner would have thrown light on this aspect of the misbehaviour but the orders are silent. So also the rules require that a delinquent must be found “to be complete unfit” for working in the Police force. This is in contra-distinction to the unfitness to work “in a particular rank.” The Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority have not looked at this aspect of misconduct also. Considering the nature of the misconduct and the statutory requirements I hold that the discretion has not been properly exercised by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority and the punishment of dismissal is awarded in branch of the said statutory requirements. The punishment is too severe as compared to the misconduct. Recently in Civil Writ Petitions No. 1519 of 1979 and 1683 of 1979 I was called upon to decide whether in view of Rule 16.3 of the Punjab Police Rules a Departmental Proceeding held against two Police Officers after their aquittal by the Criminal Court was legal and valid. The two officers were found guilty of taking a young lady, who was stranger to the city, at night to quarters of another Officer in the Police lines for immoral purposes and for outraging her modesty. The punishment awarded to the said Officers was of foreiture of two years of approved service. This recent example which had come to my notice from the same department shows that for more grave misconduct more mild punishment of forfeiture of two years of service was awarded in the same department, namely, Delhi Police. This would also show that the punishment in the present case is too severe and is not commensurate with the misconduct. I, therefore, hold that the petitioner is guilty of the misconduct but the punishment of dismissal is illegal. The punishment is, therefore, set aside. The Disciplinary Authority shall re-consider the matter of punishment in the light of Rule 16.2(1) of the Punjab Police Rules, Rules 8 and 10 of The Delhi Police Punishment and Appeal Rules, 1980 and shall pass a fresh order of punishment. The Petition partly succeeds. No order as to costs.

    11. Petition partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sukhbir Singh (Petitioner) v. The Deputy Commissioner Of Police, New Delhi And Others (S).
    (Jan 24, 1984)