Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 198 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898,
  • Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.6.
  • Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • sub-section (1) of Section 199 of the Code.12.
  • sub-section (1) of Section 199 of the Code,
  • Section 500, Indian Penal Code.7.
  • Section 500, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 119(1) of the Code
  • Section 99 of the Code.(2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 198 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898,
  • Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.6.
  • Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • sub-section (1) of Section 199 of the Code.12.
  • sub-section (1) of Section 199 of the Code,
  • Section 500, Indian Penal Code.7.
  • Section 500, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 119(1) of the Code
  • Section 99 of the Code.(2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion, delivered by Charanjit Talwar, J., concerns an application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. by the accused, Ganesha Nand Chela (applicant), seeking quashing of a criminal complaint for an offence under Section 500, Indian Penal Code, filed by Swami Divyanand (respondent). By an order dated 29 May 1976 the Metropolitan Magistrate, Delhi, summoned the accused to stand trial on the complaint alleging that the accused had made false and malicious imputations against the complainant's Guru, Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj, and against one Shrimati Pritma Devi, and that those imputations had the effect of bringing the Guru, his Dharam and his chelas (including the complainant) into contempt and ridicule. The accused applied for discharge on 12 July 1978. The learned Magistrate dismissed the discharge application by a detailed order dated 19 March 1979, concluding that the complainant was a "person aggrieved" under Section 199 Cr.P.C. and that the accused could not at that stage challenge the allegations. The accused then moved the present application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeking quashing of the complaint inter alia on the ground that the complainant was not a person aggrieved within Section 199 Cr.P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Swami Divyanand (the complainant) was a “person aggrieved” within the meaning of Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure so as to enable the Court to take cognizance of an offence under Section 500 IPC.
  2. Whether, if the alleged defamatory imputations were directed at the Guru and the Guru's institutions (Ashrams) or at an indeterminate class, a private complaint by Swami Divyanand would be maintainable.
  3. Whether the allegations in the complaint made out a case requiring summoning of the accused under Section 500 IPC (i.e., whether the allegations supported taking cognizance and proceeding to trial).

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's (Accused's) Arguments — Mr. K.K. Sud

  • The complainant, by his own averments and as found by the Magistrate, had not been personally defamed and therefore was not a "person aggrieved" within the meaning of Section 199 Cr.P.C.
  • Even if defamatory imputations existed, they were directed at Sri Krishna Ashram or at an indeterminate collection/class of persons (other disciples), and thus the complaint by Swami Divyanand was not maintainable as it did not show a grievance personal to him.
  • The allegations, in any event, did not make out a case warranting summoning the applicant under Section 500 IPC.
  • Authorities relied upon by the applicant included Dhirendra Nath Sen v. Rajat Kanti Bhadra (Calcutta High Court, 1970) and G. Narasimhan v. T.V. Chokkappa (AIR 1972 S.C. 2609), cited in support of the submissions above.

Respondent's (Complainant's) Arguments — Mr. N.K. Jaggi

  • A preliminary objection to the Section 482 application was raised: the accused had not earlier challenged the Magistrate's order summoning him (by way of revision), and therefore the present application was not maintainable.
  • On the merits, it was submitted that Swami Divyanand — admittedly a chela (disciple) of Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj — had also been defamed because the imputations had brought him and other disciples down in public estimation; consequently he was a person aggrieved and the complaint was maintainable.
  • Authorities cited by the respondent in support of his contention that he was a person aggrieved included Chhotalal Lallubhai v. Nathabhai Bechar (I.L.R. 25 Bombay 151 (1901)) and Deobrat Shastri v. Rang Bahadur Singh (AIR 1950 Patna 545).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dhirendra Nath Sen and another v. Rajat Kanti Bhadra (1970 Cri. L.J. 662) Holds that where a defamatory statement is made against the spiritual head of a community, the mere fact that a disciple's feelings are injured does not make that disciple a "person aggrieved" entitled to prosecute for defamation; cognizance on such a complaint by the disciple is illegal. The Court treated the ratio as fully applicable to the present facts and relied upon it to conclude that Swami Divyanand was not a person aggrieved within Section 199 Cr.P.C.
G. Narasimhan and others v. T.V. Chokkappa (AIR 1972 S.C. 2609) Cited by the applicant in support of the submission that the alleged defamation concerned an indeterminate class/collection of persons (i.e., not a complaint by a person personally aggrieved). Relied upon by the applicant for his second submission; the Court noted the reliance but did not build its decision upon this authority in the opinion's reasoning.
Chhotalal Lallubhai v. Nathabhai Bechar and another (1901 I.L.R. 25 Bombay 151) Held that (prima facie) a husband may be entitled to complain of imputation of unchastity on his wife's part, but a fanciful or sentimental grievance does not make one a "person aggrieved." The Court observed that this authority did not support the respondent's contention that he was a person aggrieved in the present circumstances.
Deobrat Shastri v. Rang Bahadur Singh (AIR 1950 Patna 545) Held that an individual (e.g., manager) who is primarily responsible for and concerned with the subject matter (e.g., the Bank) may be a person aggrieved when imputations are made against the institution he manages. The Court held that this authority did not assist the respondent; it did not support the contention that Swami Divyanand was a person aggrieved as against the Guru.
Raj Kapoor and others v. State (Delhi Administration and others) (AIR 1980 SC 258) Recognises that the High Court may exercise its inherent powers where proceedings pending in a lower court are an abuse of the process of the court; there is no total ban on such exercise. The Court invoked this principle to justify exercising inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash proceedings where cognizance was taken in breach of the mandatory provision of Section 199 Cr.P.C.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by analysing the content of paragraph 4 of the complaint, which set out four specific instances (sub-paras (a)–(d)) alleging defamatory acts by the accused directed at Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj and Shrimati Pritma Devi and stating that those imputations made the Guru, his Dharam and his chelas (including the complainant) a subject of contempt and ridicule.

The Court examined the Magistrate's conclusion that the disciples stood degraded and defamed by the allegations and reviewed the ratio of Dhirendra Nath Sen's case. That ratio, as stated in the opinion, holds that an individual's feelings of injury occasioned by defamation of his religious head do not, by themselves, make him a person aggrieved under the law; cognizance taken on a complaint by such an individual is illegal. The Court found that the imputations in the present complaint were directed at the Guru and the lady alleged to have had illicit relations — not at Swami Divyanand personally. The complainant's allegation that he was ridiculed by other sanyasis, the Court observed, was a feeling that other disciples would share as well and therefore did not establish a personal grievance.

The Court further noted that the Guru allegedly owned property (four Ashrams) and nowhere was it stated that he had renounced the world; there was no explanation why the Guru himself or the lady could not have filed the complaint. On that basis the Court concluded that the complainant had not proved that the imputations were aimed at him personally and hence he was not a person aggrieved within sub-section (1) of Section 199 Cr.P.C. The Court held the learned trial Court was wrong to distinguish Dhirendra Nath Sen's case and to hold that the complainant was a person aggrieved.

The Court declined to consider in detail the second submission of the applicant and refrained from addressing the merits of the alleged imputations so as not to prejudice parties later; it described the third submission as premature at the present stage.

Addressing the preliminary objection to maintainability of the Section 482 application, the Court referred to Raj Kapoor (AIR 1980 SC 258) which permits exercise of the High Court's inherent powers where proceedings in a lower court are an abuse of process. The Court concluded that because cognizance had been taken on a complaint by a person who was not a person aggrieved (contrary to the mandatory provisions of Section 199 Cr.P.C.), the taking of cognizance was illegal. Ignoring that breach would disregard the public policy embodied in Section 199 Cr.P.C. that protects accused persons. On that basis the Court held it was appropriate to exercise its inherent jurisdiction to quash the complaint.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court ordered the following outcome:

The complaint (Case No. 17 of 1977) under Section 500, Indian Penal Code, filed by Swami Divyanand is quashed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The criminal complaint pending in the Metropolitan Magistrate's Court (Mr. K.S. Khurana) was quashed; the proceedings founded on that complaint are therefore terminated as a result of this order.
  • Grounds: The quashing was based on the legal conclusion that the complainant was not a "person aggrieved" within the meaning of Section 199(1) Cr.P.C., and that cognizance taken in breach of that mandatory requirement was illegal and could be struck down by the High Court under its inherent powers.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion applied existing precedent (notably Dhirendra Nath Sen) in reaching its conclusion. The Court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle; it applied established principles to the facts and quashed the complaint on that legal basis.
Result: Complaint Quashed.

    Ganesh Anand Chela v. Swami Divyanand

    Charanjit Talwar, J.:— The applicant herein, Ganesha Nand Chela, was summoned by Mr. S.M Gupta, metropolitan magistrate, Delhi, by his order dated may 29, 1976, for an offence under Section 500, Indian Penal Code, on a complaint filed by Swami Divyanand (respondent herein).

    2. The complainant's case was that he was a Sanyasi and disciple of Swami Purna Nand Ji Maharaj. His Guru owned an Ashram known as Sri Krishna Ashram in Delhi and three other Ashrams situate in Haridwar. Ahmedabad etc. According to the complainant, the accused Ganesha Nand had also been a chela (disciple) of his guru but he had been retnoved from the chelaship in the years 1974. It was alleged that with a view to grab the property of the Guru, the accused had made false and malicious accusations against the said guru and his Dharam, and also against one Shrimati Pritma Devi. The gravamen of the allegations are contained in paragraph 4 of the complaint which reads as under:

    “4. That in order to defame the Guru and his Dharam he has done many acts by mouth and in writing and some of them are detailed as under as they are patent falsehood done with malice and makes the Dharam and Gurau and his chelas including the complainant a subject of contempt and ridicule amongst the Sanyasis as well as among the right thinking members of the society.

    (a) He gave a statement through affidavit in Roorkee Court to the effect that Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj worships we like other Mahatmas although he was himself once a chela of Shri Purnanand Ji. How can a Guru worship his chela? In the eyes of the sanyasis and the casual public his vistically degrades the Guru and also speaks these words every now and then, the thus condemns and humiliate his own once Guru which is forbidden by Dharama.

    (b) He imputes immoral character to the complainant's Guru Swami Purnanand Ji by making false accusation of illicite relations with one Shrimati Pritma Devi who is a Woman of about 60 years of age and is an old follower of Swami Purnanand Ji and has 4 married sons and is a respectable civilian lady. He repeatedly gives publication to this imputation by words of mouth and has also got obscene photographs prepared of the Guru Ji and Shrimati Pritma Devi and shows them to the public in Delhi as well as to the Sadhus and thus injure the reputation of the Guru, the sect and the Sanyasis including the complainant who are laughed at by the receivers of the imputation. She is a very learned woman and a renowned speaker and has many times delegated Ganeshanand in declamation contest and won many honours and prizes from various or ganisations. Because of jealously and illwill and malice he makes, propagates this false accusation. He started this imputation after his removal from the chelaship and from the honour of Mahamandleshwar in April, 1974.

    (c) He also accused the Guru of squandering his property after this lady and also imputes inchastity and immoral character to her and also imputes that the Guru has stopped practising religion and is just a wordly manner having illicit connections with Shmt. Pritma Devi.

    (d) He got some photographs prepared through one Shri Khosla from mehta Photographers Saddar Bazar. Delhi, which have no relation to reality or truth but are simply got prepared with a view to defame and spoil the image of the Guru as well as his chelas among it the public and the priests.”

    3. On the basis of the evidence led by the complainant (respondent herein) the learned Magistrate came to the conclusion that a prima-facie case had been made out against the petitioner and, as noticed above, summoned him to stand his trial for an offence under Section 500, Indian Penal Code. After appearing, the accused filed an application on July 12, 1978 seeking discharge on the grounds that the complaint was not maintainable as the complainant was not the “person aggrieved” with the ambit of Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and further that the allegations were groundless.

    4. The learned Magistrate vide his detailed order dated March 19, 1979, dismissed the application holding that from the facts disclosed in the complaint the complainant was the aggrieved person within the meaning of section 199 of the code, and that in any case the accused not having challenged the legality of the earlier order summoning him, the Court had no jurisdiction to review that order. On merits of the accusations, it was observed that at that stage when the complainant had still to lead evidence, it was not open to the accused to challenge the same.

    5. In this application moved under section 482 of the code, the applicant (accused) is seeking quashing of the complaint, inter-alia, on the ground that cognizance of the offence under Section 500, Indian Penal Code, could not be taken as the complaint was not an aggrieved person within the ambit of Section 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

    6. Mr. K.K Sud, learned counsel for the applicant, has raised the following contentions in support of the plea for quashing of the complaint:

    (1) Swami Divyanand, the complaint, according to his own showing in the complaint and as per the finding of the learned Magistrate in the impugned order, had not been personally defamed and, therefore, was not the aggrieved person as postulated under Section 99 of the Code.

    (2) That even if it is held the there are defamatory imputations against Sri Krishna Ashram in Delhi or against three other Ashrams belonging to the said Purnanad Ji Maharaj, the defamation is of the indefinite, indeterminate collection of persons or class of persons and, therefore, the present complaint by Swami Divyanand is not maintainable.

    (3) that the allegations do not make out a case of summoning the applicant under Section 500, Indian Penal Code.

    7. Mr. Sud, in support of his first submission, has relied on a decision of the Calcutta High Court reported in Dhirendra Nath Sen and another v. Rajat Kanti Bhadra, 1970 Cri. L.J 662(1), and on a decision of the Supreme Court reported in G. Narasimhan and others etc. etc., v. T.V Chokkappa, AIR 1972 S.C 2609 (2), in support of his second submission.

    8. Mr. N.K Jaggi, learned counsel for the respondent, has raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of this application under Section 482 of the Code. He submits that the accused not having challenged by way of a revision petition the order of summoning him to stand his trial for an offence under Section 500, Indian Penal Code, which order had been passed on May 29, 1976, the present application does not lie. On merits he submits that Swami Divyanand, admittedly a chela of Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj, had also been defamed as he had been brought down in the estimations of the public and was, therefore, a person aggrieved. The complaint was thus maintainable. In support of his contention that the complainant is an aggrieved person he has cited two decisions, namely, (1901) I.L.R 25 Bombay 151, Chhotalal Lallubhai v. Nathabhai Bechar and another, and AIR 1950 Patna 545, Deobrat Shastri v. Rang Bahadur Singh.

    9. The details of the imputations are given in para 4 of the complaint which I have noted above. The complainant's allegation appears to be that the four specific instances given in sub-paras (a) to (d) of the said para “are patent falsehood done with malice and makes the Dharam and Guru and his chelas including the complainant a subject of contempt and ridicule, ………” The learned Magistrate, while keeping in view the above allegations, has observed in paragraph 9 of the impugned order that serious allegations having been levelled against the spiritual head of the Ashram, the Court while summoning the accused had come to the conclusion that disciples of the Guru also stood degraded and defamed by those allegations. It was further observed that as such the decision of the Calcutta High Court in Dhirendra Nath Sen's case (supra) was distinguishable. At this stage I may note the ratio of the said decision. It was observed therein that the mere fact that the feelings of the complaint have been injured in consequence of a defamatory statement made against his religious head, afforded no ground under the law to the complainant to prosecute the accused for defamation. It was, therefore, held that where the defamation was that of a spiritual head of a certain community, and individual person of that community was not the person aggrieved and as such the congnizance of offence taken on a complaint by that individual person, was illegal. I am of the view that the law laid in that case is fully applicable to the facts of the present case. The imputations, as quoted above, clearly show that those relate to Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj and Shrimati Pritma Devi. According to para 4 of the complaint, because of those imputations the complainant also become a subject of contempt and ridicule among the sanyasis. This allegation, in fact, shows that the complainant feels injured in consequence of the said defamatory statement. However, this feeling that he is being ridiculed by the “other sanyasis and right thinking members of the Society” must be the one being shared by the other disciples of the said Guru.

    10. The authorities cited by Mr. Jaggi to show that Swami Divyanand Ji is the person aggrieved within the ambit of section 199 of the code, may now be noticed. In Deobrat Shastri's case (supra), the Manager of a Cooperative Bank had filed the complaint under Section 500, Indian Penal Code. It was held by Sarjoo Prasad, J. that the Manager was a person who was primarily concerned with day to-day management of the Bank, and it was he who was responsible for any lapse or mismanagement of its affairs. Therefore, it could not be said that he was not the person aggrieved when the defamatory imputations were against the Bank. In Chhotalal Lallubhai's case, decided on August 7, 1900, prior to the 1923 amendment brought in Section 198 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, it was held that a husband complaining of an imputation of unchastity on his wife's part would prima-facie be entitled to file a complaint for defamation. It was, however, held that any fanciful or sentimental grievance of a person would not make him a person aggrieved to bring him within the meaning of section 198 of the code. These two authorities do not support the contention of the respondent.

    11. In the Facts and circumstances of the present case, the complainant has not been able to prove that the above imputations are against him personally or that he is the person aimed at. It can, therefore, be held that he is not an aggrieved person within the ambit of Section 119(1) of the Code which reads as follows:

    “199. Prosecution for defamation.—(1) No Court shall take cognizance of an offence punishable under Chapter XXI of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860) except upon a complaint made by some person aggrieved by the offence:

    Provided that where such person is under the age of eighteen years, or is an idiot or a lunatic or is from sickness or infirmity unable to make a complaint„ or is a woman who, according to the local customs and manners, ought not to be compelled to appear in public, some other person may, with the leave of the Court, make a complaint on his or her behalf.”

    The learned trial Court, in my view, was wrong in holding that the law laid in Dhirendra Nath Sen's case (supra) was not applicable to the facts of the present case. The defamatory allegations, even according to the learned trial Court, are that Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj, who was a spiritual head of the Ashram, was leading an immoral life. The said Swami Purnanand Ji Maharaj, according to the complainant's own showing, owns property, namely, four Ashrams—one at Delhi and the others at Haridwar and Ahmedabad. It is no where stated that he has renounced the word. There is no explanation as to why the Guru or the lady with whom he is alleged to have illicit relations, cannot file the complaint. The maximum that one can say about the complainant is that he has a grievance about his Guru being defamed. But that grievance, which the other members of the Ashram must also be sharing, cannot make him the aggrieved person within the meaning of sub-section (1) of Section 199 of the Code.

    12. In the view which I have taken, it is not necessary to deal with the second submission of Mr. Sud. I do not wish to dilate on the merits of the imputation which may prejudice the interests of the parties or other persons at a later stage. The third submission of Mr. Sud appears to me to be premature at this stage.

    13. Now dealing with the preliminary objection raised by Mr. jaggi, I may refer to the law laid on this proposition by their lordships of the Supreme Court in Raj Kapoor and others v. State (Delhi Administration and others), AIR 1980 SC 258 (5). It has been held that when it is shown that the proceedings pending in the lower Court are an abuse of the process of the Court, there is no total ban on exercise of the inherent powers by the High Court.

    14. In the present case, the cognizance of the offence has been taken on a complaint of a person who is not an aggrieved person within the moaning of sub-section (1) of Section 199 of the Code, the cognizance of the offence, therefore, was illegal, being against the mandatory provisions of the Code. To ignore such a breach of law, would amount to ignoring the grounds of public policy which have been enunciated in sub-section (1) of Section 199 of the Code, for the benefit of an accused.

    15. In the result I quash the complain (Case No. 17 of 1977) under Section 500, Indian Penal Code, filed by Swami Divyanand under Section 500, Indian Penal Code, pending in the Court of Mr. K.S Khurana, Metropolitan Magistrate I class, Delhi.

    S.VComplaint Quashed
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ganesh Anand Chela v. Swami Divyanand
    (Feb 29, 1980)