| Bachharaj Factories Ltd. v. Hirjee Mills Ltd., AIR 1955 Bombay 355 |
Petitioner's motive irrelevant if petition supported by creditors and in interest of company; mala fide petitions can be rejected. |
Distinguished as involving creditor's petition; emphasized importance of bona fide motive in member's petition. |
| Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. v. M.W. Pradhan, AIR 1966 Bombay 4 |
Support for winding up where petition is bona fide and in interest of company and shareholders. |
Referred to in context of bona fide petitions and interest of company overriding motive. |
| Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd., 35 CC 351 |
Petitions filed for ulterior purposes (e.g., to gain control) may be dismissed as abuse of process. |
Applied to reject winding up petition filed with oblique motive and extortion. |
| Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P) Ltd. v. A.C.K. Krishnaswami, 35 CC 456 (Supreme Court) |
Petitions used as pressure tactics will be dismissed and may be stigmatized as abuse of process. |
Supported dismissal of mala fide petition. |
| National Conduits (P) Ltd. v. S.S. Arora, 37 CC 786 |
Unbona fide petitions may be set aside to avoid harassment and blackmail. |
Supported rejection of petition motivated by extortion. |
| Madhusudan Gordhandas & Company v. Madhu Woolen Industries Pvt. Ltd., AIR 1971 SC 2600 |
Petitions not filed for legitimate purpose may be dismissed with costs. |
Reinforced importance of bona fide purpose in winding up petitions. |
| In re Furrier's Alliance Ltd., (1907) 51 Sd. J. 172 |
Deadlock or impracticability of carrying on business justifies winding up analogous to partnership dissolution. |
Discussed as early authority on deadlock and winding up. |
| In re Yenidje Tobacco Company Limited, (1916) 2 Ch. 426 CA |
Partnership principles apply to private companies with deadlock or irreconcilable differences; "just and equitable" grounds for winding up. |
Extensively relied upon to analyze applicability of partnership principles. |
| In re Davis and Collett Ltd., (1935) 1 Ch. 693 |
Justice and equity require winding up where management irregularities and exclusion occur, even without deadlock. |
Considered in relation to mismanagement and exclusion from management. |
| In re Lundie Brothers Ltd., (1965) 35 CC 827 |
Unjustified exclusion and incompatibility of temperament justify winding up on just and equitable grounds. |
Applied to cases involving exclusion and incompatibility. |
| In re Westbourne Galleries Ltd., (1971) 1 All E.R. 561 |
Power to remove director bona fide exercised by majority is not ground for winding up; partnership principles limited to deadlock cases. |
Rejected broad application of partnership principles absent deadlock. |
| In re Loch v. Blackwood Ltd., (1924) AC 783 |
Justifiable lack of confidence in company management grounded on probity issues justifies winding up of domestic/family companies. |
Applied to family/domestic companies with lack of confidence due to mismanagement. |
| In re Cuthbert Cooper and Sons Ltd., (1937) 1 Ch. 392 |
Rights of parties determined by articles; absence of mala fides and compliance with articles may defeat winding up petition. |
Emphasized contractual rights under articles and rejected winding up where no breach. |
| Charles Forte Investments Ltd. v. Amanda, (1964) 34 CC 233 |
Threat to present winding up petition to force transfer of shares may be abuse of process; alternative remedies preferred. |
Supported dismissal of petitions used as pressure tactics. |
| In re Expanded Plugs Ltd., (1966) 36 CC 497 |
Partnership analogy limited; winding up not justified without proof of lack of probity or mismanagement affecting company. |
Rejected winding up absent mismanagement or deadlock. |
| In re Anglo-Continental Produce Co. Ltd., (1939) 1 All E.R. 99 |
Wrongdoing by majority shareholders depriving company of remedies may justify winding up. |
Considered for mismanagement and oppression. |
| Elder v. Elder and Watson Ltd., (1952) SLT 112 |
No winding up where no mismanagement or injury to shareholders' rights. |
Applied to reject winding up absent injury to shareholder rights. |
| Veeramachineni Seethiah v. Bode Venkata Subbiah, AIR 1949 Madras 675 |
Just and equitable clause not invoked merely for difference of views or incompatibility without misappropriation or malversation. |
Rejected winding up on mere differences without proven mismanagement. |
| S.S. Raj Kumar v. Perfect Castings Pvt. Ltd., (1968) 38 CC 187 |
Winding up requires proven malversation or serious mismanagement; mere bickerings insufficient. |
Applied to reject winding up absent substantial mismanagement. |
| In re Bilasrai Juharmal and another, AIR 1962 Bombay 133 |
Majority right to manage company; differences alone do not justify winding up. |
Emphasized difference between partnership and company management rights. |
| Maharani Lalita Rajya Lakshmi v. Indian Motor Company (Hazaribagh) Ltd., AIR 1962 Calcutta 127 |
Denial of access to books or dividend declaration discretion not grounds for winding up. |
Rejected winding up on such grounds in flourishing company. |
| Raghunath Prasad Jhunjhunuwala v. Hind Overseas Pvt. Ltd., (1971) 31 CC 279 |
Partnership principles apply to private companies with equal shareholding and persistent mismanagement; absence of deadlock or equal holdings negates application. |
Disagreed with appellate view; emphasized company as separate entity with distinct remedies. |
| In re Atul Drug House Ltd., (1971) 41 CC 352 |
Partnership principle for winding up applies only in cases of complete irresolvable deadlock without alternative remedies. |
Rejected winding up petition due to absence of deadlock and availability of remedies. |
| Kalinga Tubes Ltd. v. Shanti Prasad Jain, AIR 1963 Orissa 189 |
Contractual obligations govern shareholder relations; partnership principles lose effect on conversion to public company. |
Reinforced contractual nature of company and limits of partnership analogy. |
| Scottish Cooperative Wholesale Society Ltd. v. Mayer, (1958) 3 All E.R. 66 |
Share valuation for buy-out generally fixed as on date of petition. |
Noted but value fixed as on date of judgment due to peculiar circumstances. |