Structured Summary of the Opinion (S.N. Andley, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from two questions referred to the Court by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (Delhi Bench ‘B’) under section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. The reference relates to the assessment year 1958-59.
The assessee is a firm carrying on business as forest contractors. Prior to formation of the firm, the same business was carried on by a Hindu undivided family (HUF). The HUF was disrupted on 22 March 1956 and on that date the assessee firm came into existence. On disruption the assessee firm took over all the assets and liabilities of the HUF as standing in the books of the HUF "as a running concern." The Tribunal recorded that “the business was taken over by the assessee firm as a running concern from the Hindu undivided family.”
Two specific questions were referred by the Tribunal:
(1) whether a sum of Rs. 5,556 is an admissible charge against the income of the previous year; and
(2) whether a sum of Rs. 24,252 realised by sale of three trucks is an item taxable in the previous year under the provisions of section 10(2)(vii) of the Act.
The first question arises from a claim by the assessee firm to deduct legal and professional expenses totaling Rs. 5,556 (composed of three specified payments). The Income-tax Officer, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal disallowed that deduction under section 10(2)(xv).
The second question arises from the sale proceeds of three trucks (total Rs. 24,252) which had belonged to the HUF and became property of the assessee firm when the firm took over the business. The written down value of those trucks had been exhausted while they belonged to the HUF; the Tribunal treated the entire sale proceeds as taxable profit in the assessee's hands under section 10(2)(vii).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the sum of Rs. 5,556 is an admissible charge against the income of the previous year (i.e., deductible under section 10(2)(xv) as expenditure wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the business)?
- Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the sum of Rs. 24,252 realised by sale of three trucks is an item taxable in the previous year under the provisions of section 10(2)(vii)?
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee's Arguments
- The assessee firm claimed legal expenses and professional fees totalling Rs. 5,556 comprising:
- Rs. 2,483 paid to M/s. P.R. Mehta and Co. for representation to the Central Board of Revenue and other appeal expenses;
- Rs. 2,758 paid to M/s. Khanna and Annadhanam in connection with settlement of old assessment with the Directorate of Inspection (Investigation);
- Rs. 315 paid to Sh. K.N. Rajagopal Shastri.
- With respect to the three trucks sold for Rs. 24,252, the assessee contended that because it took over the business as a running concern, the cost of the trucks to it in the assessment year was the same as the written down value in the HUF's books (which was zero); therefore the proviso to section 10(2)(vii) would not bring any part of the sale price to tax as profits of the previous year.
Revenue's Arguments
- The Income-tax Officer, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal disallowed the Rs. 5,556 deduction under section 10(2)(xv) on the view that such legal and accountancy expenses incurred to satisfy tax authorities are not expenditure laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business.
- Mr. Sharma for the Revenue contended that the Supreme Court in the cited Birla Cotton case did not take into consideration certain points, namely:
- The requirement that the purpose of the expenditure must have a direct nexus with carrying on the business, since business would be carried on even if an income-tax demand were contested.
- The proposition that income, after being earned, becomes capital and income-tax merely depletes capital; therefore income-tax paid is not deductible in computing taxable income.
- That expenditure to reduce levy of income-tax preserves capital assets and is therefore capital expenditure, which section 10(2)(xv) prohibits as a revenue deduction.
- That the expenditure was incurred by the assessee in the capacity of owner of capital and not in his capacity as a trader.
- That allowing such expenditure as a revenue deduction for persons carrying on business, but denying it to persons with other heads of income (e.g., salary or property), would lead to discrimination between taxpayers.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| J. K. Cotton Manufacturers Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, U.P. (reported 46 I.T.R. 1970) |
Holds that legal and accountancy expenses incurred with a view to satisfying tax authorities with regard to statements and accounts is not expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business. |
The Tribunal had felt bound to follow this decision and disallowed the deduction; the Court noted the Tribunal followed it (erroneously, as explained later in the opinion). |
| Binodiram Bal Chand v. Commissioner of Income-tax, M.P. (reported 48 I.T.R. 548) |
Holds that sums paid by an assessee by way of professional fees to an income-tax adviser for services rendered during and for the conduct of assessment proceedings before the Income-tax authorities are deductible under section 10(2)(xv). |
The Tribunal did not follow this decision; the Court records the existence of this contrary authority but relies on the Supreme Court decision discussed below. |
| Commissioner of Income-tax, West Bengal v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Ltd. (reported 82 I.T.R. 166) |
Holds that legal expenses incurred to preserve and protect the assessee's business from proceedings which might reduce its income and profits, or which are incidental and justified by commercial expediency to safeguard the business (including opposing coercive government action), are allowable under section 10(2)(xv). |
The Court treated this Supreme Court decision as settling the controversy and relied on its principle to hold the Rs. 5,556 legal expenses admissible as business expenditure; the Court answered the first question in the affirmative on this basis. |
| Decision of the Calcutta High Court (reported 64 I.T.R. 568) |
Was the decision from which the Birla Cotton case reached the Supreme Court (exact principle in this summary is the subject of appeal to the Supreme Court). |
The Court notes that the Supreme Court decision was on appeal from this Calcutta High Court decision; the Supreme Court's ruling was treated as authoritative for the issues in question. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court dealt with the two referred questions separately.
First question — Rs. 5,556 legal and professional expenses
The Court observed that the Tribunal disallowed the deduction under section 10(2)(xv) and had relied upon the Allahabad High Court decision in J.K. Cotton. The Court held that the controversy was settled by the Supreme Court decision in Commissioner of Income-tax, West Bengal v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Ltd. (82 I.T.R. 166). The Supreme Court had held that such legal expenses were incurred for the preservation and protection of the assessee's business from processes or proceedings that might reduce income and profits, and that the expenditure was incidental to business and justified by commercial expediency. The Supreme Court had stated that steps taken to reduce tax liability, when reasonably and honestly incurred to promote business interest, are laid out for the purpose of trade and are therefore deductible under section 10(2)(xv).
The Court noted that Mr. Sharma for the Revenue raised several contentions as to why the Supreme Court decision had not considered particular points (listed in the Arguments section). The Court declined to call on the assessee's counsel to reply to those points because it assumed the Supreme Court had considered all aspects when giving its judgment. On the basis of the Supreme Court's reasoning, the Court answered the first question in the affirmative (i.e., the Rs. 5,556 was admissible).
Second question — Rs. 24,252 realised on sale of three trucks
The Court set out the facts: three trucks sold for Rs. 24,252; the written down values of the trucks had been exhausted while they were the property of the HUF (zero written down value). The Income-tax Officer had treated the entire sale proceeds as profit under section 10(2)(vii). The Tribunal held that because the business was taken over by the firm as a running concern, the written down value in the hands of the firm must be taken as that in the hands of the HUF, and the surplus realised on sale over written down value was rightly subjected to tax in the firm's hands.
The Court reviewed the statutory provision: clause (vii) of sub-section (2) of section 10 provides for an allowance in respect of building, machinery or plant sold, equal to the amount by which written down value exceeds sale price; the second proviso deals with the case where sale price exceeds written down value, deeming so much of the excess as does not exceed the difference between the original cost and the written down value to be profits of the previous year in which the sale took place. The Court also referred to the definition of written down value in sub-section (5) of section 10 (in the case of assets acquired before the previous year, written down value means the actual cost to the assessee less all depreciation actually allowed to him).
The Court observed (from the assessment order for 1956-57 annexure 'D') that although disruption occurred on 22 March 1956, accounts for the full year up to 31-3-56 were examined and income was allocated proportionately between the HUF and the newly formed firm. The Court concluded that there was merely a change in the style and nature of the business; the same persons continued to carry on the same business but with defined shares after forming the firm. Given the Tribunal's finding that the business was taken over as a running concern, the Court held that the original cost of the trucks to the firm would be the same as in the hands of the HUF (i.e., not zero for the purpose of applying the proviso). Therefore the Tribunal was correct to treat the surplus realised on sale as taxable under section 10(2)(vii).
On this basis, the Court answered the second question in the affirmative.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
Both referred questions are answered in the affirmative.
Specifically:
- The sum of Rs. 5,556 was held to be an admissible charge against the income of the previous year (deductible under section 10(2)(xv) on the basis of the Supreme Court decision in Commissioner of Income-tax, West Bengal v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Ltd.).
- The sum of Rs. 24,252 realised by sale of the three trucks was held to be taxable in the previous year under the provisions of section 10(2)(vii), because the firm had taken over the business as a running concern and the original cost in the hands of the firm is to be taken as that in the hands of the Hindu undivided family.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: the assessee is allowed the Rs. 5,556 deduction for legal/professional expenses, and the sale proceeds of Rs. 24,252 are taxable in the assessee's hands under section 10(2)(vii) as held by the Tribunal and affirmed by this Court.
- The Court applied existing Supreme Court authority (the Birla Cotton decision) to resolve the first issue; the opinion does not purport to create a new precedent beyond the application of that authority.
- Costs: in view of the partial success of the assessee, there was no order as to costs of the reference.
Order accordingly.
Show full summary ...