Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary (N. Paul Vasanthakumar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is the son of Late Palaniyandi, who was working as a Reading Inspector in the Tamil Nadu Electricity Board (TNEB) under the jurisdiction of the third respondent and died in service on 11.07.1998. The appellant's mother, being without other means of income, submitted an application on 09.08.2001 requesting appointment on compassionate grounds and followed it up with another representation on 27.05.2003. By proceedings dated 10.11.2003 the third respondent rejected her request on the ground that she had not applied within three years of her husband's death. A further representation was submitted on 03.08.2005; by proceedings dated 18.08.2005 the third respondent rejected that request on the grounds that the mother had not completed the eighth standard and that the appellant had not attained majority at the relevant time. The family's challenge to those decisions was instituted as W.P.(MD) No. 13980 of 2009, which the learned Single Judge dismissed by order dated 13.09.2010. This writ appeal was filed against that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application for compassionate appointment made by a widow within three years of the death of her husband, where appointment was not possible due to the widow's ineligibility (for example, lack of requisite educational qualification or minority of the dependent child), can be treated as a continuing application such that a subsequent application by the deceased employee's son (who was a minor at the time of death but applied within three years of attaining majority) should be considered notwithstanding the three-year bar.
  2. Whether appointment on compassionate grounds can be given beyond the limits or contrary to circulars and orders of the TNEB (i.e., whether TNEB circulars prevent compassionate appointment outside their terms).
  3. Whether providing appointment to a person on compassionate grounds after that person attains majority amounts impermissibly to keeping a post reserved for that person until majority is attained.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant's mother applied for compassionate appointment within three years of the death of her husband; she could not be appointed because she had not completed eighth standard, and at that time the son (the appellant) was a minor.
  • After the appellant attained majority he applied within three years of attaining majority; that subsequent application should be considered as continuation of the mother's application and hence be treated as within time for compassionate appointment.
  • There are contrary decisions of the Supreme Court and other authorities to the respondents' cited Division Bench decision, so the respondents' reliance on that Division Bench decision is misplaced.
  • The appellant relied specifically on J. Jeba Mary v. The Chairman, TNEB [2011 (3) LLN 405 (Mad)], where one of the presiding judges (NPVJ) directed TNEB to appoint the son of a deceased employee on compassionate grounds in similar circumstances.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Appointment on compassionate grounds must be given only in accordance with the circulars and orders of TNEB and cannot be given dehors (outside) those circulars and orders.
  • Providing appointment to a person on compassionate grounds after his attaining majority would amount to keeping a post reserved for him until he attained majority, which the respondents argued is impermissible.
  • The respondents relied upon a Division Bench decision of this Court in E. Ramasamy v. TNEB and others [2007 WLR 796] to support their position that the application could be rejected as beyond three years.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
E. RAMASAMY v. TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD AND OTHERS [2007 WLR 796] Division Bench negatived the request of a petitioner who was a minor at the time of his father's death and later applied within three years of attaining majority. The court noted the decision but observed that it has been overturned by the Apex Court and therefore cannot be treated as good law for the present matter.
J. JEBA MARY v. THE CHAIRMAN, TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD [2011 (3) LLN 405 (Mad)] In similar circumstances (minor at time of death; subsequent application), one of the present bench (NPVJ) directed TNEB to appoint the son of a deceased employee on compassionate grounds relying on Apex Court decisions. Relied upon by appellant's counsel and by the court as one of the authorities supporting the principle that a subsequent application by the son can be treated as continuation of the mother's earlier application.
T. MEER ISMAIL ALI v. TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD [2004 (3) CTC 120] Held that rejection of an application on the ground that it was not made within three years was not justified where the claimant had made a claim once and then immediately after attaining majority again claimed; such facts deserved consideration. The court relied on and followed this principle, citing that the decision was upheld on appeal and that the SLP was dismissed by the Apex Court.
Balbir Kaur v. Steel Authority of India Ltd [(2000) 6 SCC 493] Supreme Court precedent cited in support of treating later applications as continuation in appropriate circumstances (as referenced in the court's discussion of related petitions). Referenced as part of the body of Supreme Court authority that supports consideration of claims where initial application was impeded by incapacity (e.g., minority).
Indiraniammal (W.P. No. 21512 of 2003 and related appeals; Civil Appeal No. 2039 of 2006) Series of High Court and Division Bench decisions on similar issues of compassionate appointment; the Board's Civil Appeal No. 2039 of 2006 was dismissed by the Supreme Court on 30.3.2010 (as recorded in the opinion). The court cited the litigation history to show instances where relief was granted and where the Supreme Court intervened in some related matters; used to demonstrate the judicial treatment of similar facts.
MOHANAMBAL v. DIRECTOR, LAND AND SURVEY DEPARTMENT [2011 (2) MLJ 47] Referenced as noting that the Division Bench decision in E. Ramasamy has been overturned by the Apex Court. Used by the court to support the proposition that E. Ramasamy is no longer good law.
SYED KHADIM HUSSAIN v. STATE OF BIHAR [(2006) 9 SCC 195] Referenced alongside MOHANAMBAL for the proposition that the Division Bench decision (E. Ramasamy) has been overturned by higher authority. Relied upon to show higher court authority inconsistent with the reasoning in E. Ramasamy.
G. SARAVANAKUMAR v. THE CHAIRMAN TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD, CHENNAI [2011 (2) CWC 83] One of the cases in which Justice N. Paul Vasanthakumar analyzed similar issues concerning continuation of compassionate appointment applications. Listed among authorities analyzed by NPVJ to support the continuation principle applied in the present case.
R. PRASATH v. THE SECRETARY, LABOUR AND EMPLOYMENT DEPT., CHENNAI (W.P No. 3078 of 2006, dated 17.06.2010) One of several writ matters in which the judge analyzed the issue of compassionate appointment continuation. Included by the court as part of the body of decisions supporting the court's approach.
M. UMA v. THE CHIEF ENGINEER (PERSONNEL) CHENNAI (W.P(MD) No. 4050 of 2006, dated 29.06.2010) Another writ matter analyzed by the judge on the same issue. Relied upon as part of the consolidated jurisprudence supporting treatment of applications as continuing where the initial applicant (widow) applied within three years but could not be appointed due to disqualification.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the facts and rival submissions and conducted a precedent-based analysis. The analysis proceeded in the following steps, as reflected in the opinion:

  1. Review of factual chronology: the widow had applied within three years of the husband's death but could not be appointed because of disqualification (lack of eighth standard) and because the son was a minor at that time. The son subsequently applied after attaining majority.
  2. Examination of relevant authority: the court considered a number of High Court Division Bench and single judge decisions and Supreme Court decisions addressing whether a subsequent application by a minor's representative or by the dependent child, after attaining majority, can be treated as a continuation of the widow's timely application.
  3. Specific scrutiny of E. Ramasamy: though the respondents relied on the Division Bench decision in E. Ramasamy which negatived the claim of a minor who later applied within three years of attaining majority, the court noted that E. Ramasamy has been overturned by the Apex Court, as recorded in Mohanambal and Syed Khadim Hussain, and therefore could not be taken as authoritative against the appellant.
  4. Reliance on a consistent line of High Court decisions (including T. Meer Ismail Ali and a series of decisions where Division Benches ultimately allowed compassionate appointment where the widow had applied within three years and the child, who had been a minor, later applied after attaining majority): the court found that these authorities support treating the subsequent application as a continuation of the mother's earlier application and that rejection solely on the ground of delay beyond three years was not justified in such circumstances.
  5. Application to present case: because the mother had applied within three years and the subsequent application by the son is to be viewed as continuation of that application, and because the respondents did not contend that the family was not indigent as of the date of the judgment, the Single Judge's dismissal (based on the bar of three years and other stated grounds) was not sustainable.
  6. Consequent remedial directions: the court directed a limited and conditional procedure—requiring the appellant to produce a certificate from the competent authority that his family is in indigent circumstances within four weeks; upon receipt of that certificate and the appellant's representation dated 22.12.2009, the respondents were directed to appoint him in any suitable post within two weeks.

Holding and Implications

The writ appeal is allowed and the order of the learned Single Judge dated 13.09.2010 in W.P.(MD) No. 13980 of 2009 is set aside.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The appellant is directed to produce, within four weeks, a certificate from the competent authority confirming that his family is in indigent circumstances as of today, and to submit that certificate together with a copy of this judgment to the third respondent.
  • On receipt of that certificate and based on the appellant's representation dated 22.12.2009, the respondents are directed to appoint the appellant to any suitable post within two weeks.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader implications: The decision applies established High Court and Supreme Court authority construing compassionate appointment rules to permit treating a later application by a dependent who was a minor at the time of the original timely application by the widow as a continuation of that application. The opinion does not purport to set a novel precedent beyond applying and aligning prior authorities; it expressly treats the E. Ramasamy Division Bench decision as not authoritative in light of later higher court decisions.

    P. Sathiaraman v. Department Of Electricity

    :JUDGMENT

    (Judgment of the Court was made by N. PAUL VASANTHAKUMAR, J.)

    This writ appeal is filed against the order of learned Single Judge dated 13.09.2010, dismissing the writ petition in W.P(MD) No. 13980 of 2009, wherein the appellant herein prayed for issuance of a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to call for the order passed by the third respondent, rejecting the request for providing compassionate appointment, and to quash the same and also for a direction to provide suitable employment opportunity to him.

    2. The appellant herein is the son of Late Palaniyandi. According to the appellant, his father was working as Reading Inspector in Tamil Nadu Electricity Board under the jurisdiction of the third respondent at Vaiyampatti. He died on 11.07.1998, while he was in service. When his father died, he was a minor and his mother did not have any other source of income to maintain the family. His mother submitted an application to the respondents on 09.08.2001, requesting them to provide any appointment on compassionate ground. Since there was no response, she sent another representation on 27.05.2003 The third respondent, by proceedings dated 10.11.2003, rejected her request for compassionate appointment on the ground that she has not applied within three years from the date of death of her husband. Again, she submitted a representation on 03.08.2005, seeking to provide any suitable employment. The third respondent, by proceedings dated 18.08.2005, rejected her request on the ground that she has not completed eighth standard and that the appellant herein has not attained majority at that time. The said order was challenged in the writ petition.

    3. The learned Single Judge, by order dated 13.09.2010 dismissed the writ petition. Hence, this writ appeal.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the widow applied for appointment on compassionate ground and since she did not complete eighth standard, she was not appointed and the request for appointment was perused by the appellant herein, who had not attained majority at that time and subsequently applied within three years of his attaining majority and therefore, the request is to be considered for providing compassionate appointment.

    5. The learned counsel for the respondents contended that appointment on compassionate ground cannot be given dehors the circulars and orders of TNEB. Further, providing appointment to a person on compassionate ground after his attaining majority will amount to keeping a post reserved for him till he attains majority. In this respect, the learned counsel relied on a Division Bench decision of this Court in E. RAMASAMY v. TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD AND ORTHERS [2007 WLR 796].

    6. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that since there are contrary decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court, RAMASAMY's case (supra) is no longer good law. The learned counsel also cited J. JEBA MARY v. THE CHAIRMAN, TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD [2011 (3) LLN 405 (Mad)], where under in similar circumstances, one of us (NPVJ), relying on the decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court directed TNEB to appoint the son of a deceased employee on compassionate ground.

    7. We have carefully considered the rival submissions of either counsel and perused the materials available on record and the impugned order of the learned Single Judge.

    8. In T. MEER ISMAIL ALI v. The TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD, CHENNAI, (2004 (3) CTC 120) this Court held as under:-

    “I am, therefore, of the view that the petitioner's case deserve consideration inasmuch as he had diligently made a claim once in the year 1997 and thereafter, immediately after attaining the age of 18, in the year 2000 and in such circumstances, rejection of his application on the ground that it was not made within three years was not justified.”

    9. The decision of this Court in MEER ISMAIL ALI (cited supra) was upheld by a Division Bench of this Court in W.A No. 48 of 2004 dated 01.12.2004 Subsequently, the SLP filed against it was also dismissed by the Hon'ble Apex Court vide its judgment in C.A No. 6387 of 2004, dated 04.04.2005

    10. (a) Another Division Bench of this Court in SELVI R. ANBARASI v. CHIEF ENGINEER (PERSONNEL), T.N.E.B, CHENNAI [2006 (2) M.L.J, 200] held as follows:-

    “The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that a similar issue, rejecting the compassionate ground appointment on the ground that the application was submitted beyond three years and the same was rejected earlier on the ground that the petitioner therein has not completed 18 years of age, was considered by this Court in W.P No. 1584 of 2011 and this Court held that the applications having been made within a period of three yeas and the same having not been considered on the ground that the petitioner therein was not 18 years of age at that time, the subsequent application cannot be rejected on the ground that the application was submitted within three years. The learned Judge directed the respondents not to treat the second application as an application for compassionate appointment, but it is to be treated as continuation of the application originally submitted. The said judgment is reported in T. Meer Ismail Ali v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board through its Chairman,, (2004) 3 C.T.C 120. This Court, ultimately, directed the respondents to give compassionate appointment to the petitioner therein.”

    (b) In W.P No. 21512 of 2003 one Indiraniammal challenged the rejection of compassionate appointment on similar ground. The learned single Judge dismissed the writ petition by order dated 4.8.2003 against which the petitioner therein filed W.A No. 3050 of 2003 and the said writ appeal was allowed by the Division Bench (consisting of the Hon'ble Mr. Justice P. Sathasivam (as he then was) & S.K Krishnan, J) by order dated 8.3.2005 following the earlier judgments as well as the Supreme Court Judgment reported in (2000) 6 SCC 493 (Balbir Kaur v. Steel Authority of India Ltd). Against the said decision Civil Appeal No. 2039 of 2006 was filed by the respondent Board herein which was dismissed by the Honourable Supreme Court on 30.3.2010

    (c) Dismissal of another W.P No. 775 of 2004 by order dated 29.1.2005 on the ground of delay was considered by the Division Bench (F.M Ibrahim Kalifullah, J. (as he then was) & P. Murugesan, J) in W.A(MD). No. 29 of 2006 and by order dated 27.6.2006 the Division Bench allowed the writ appeal and directed to give compassionate appointment to the younger son of the deceased Board employee, who died on 15.11.1996 The said order of the Division Bench was also challenged by the Board in SLP(C) No. 15534 of 2007 which was also dismissed by the Apex Court on 8.4.2009

    (d) Three writ petitions were disposed of by one of us (NPVJ) i.e, W.P Nos. 19914 of 2004, 32409 of 2004 and 10577 of 2005 by common order dated 24.7.2006 wherein similar issue was considered. In respect of the above three writ petitions, which were allowed, writ appeal was filed against one writ petition in W.A No. 1206 of 2006 while implementing the order in respect of other two cases. The said writ appeal was allowed by the Division Bench on 29.9.2006 The respondent in the writ appeal viz., J. Karthick filed review application which was also rejected by the Division Bench on 25.8.2008 Against the dismissal of the writ appeal as well as rejection of review application, the said J. Karthick filed SLP(C) No. 2004-2005/2009 and on 23.2.2009 the SLPs were tagged along with Civil Appeal No. 2039 of 2006 viz., Indiraniammal case. Subsequently the said SLP was numbered as Civil Case Nos. 5068-5069 of 2009 which was allowed on 30.3.2010 and the said order reads as follows:

    “Leave granted.

    Heard learned counsel for the parties.

    These Appeals have been filed against the impugned judgment of the High Court of Madras dated 29th September, 2006 and subsequent order dated 25.8.2008 passed in the review application.

    The Division Bench of the High Court has reversed the judgment of the learned single Judge only on the ground of delay who directed compassionate appointment to the appellant. The appellant was a minor at the time of the death of his father and since the mother of the appellant applied within time, we are of the opinion that the appellant after becoming major should have been granted compassionate appointment.

    Accordingly, we allow these appeals, set aside the impugned judgment of the Division Bench and restore the judgment of the learned single Judge. No costs.”

    (Emphasis Supplied)

    From the perusal of the above order it is evident that the order passed by the Division Bench in writ appeal and in the review petition were set aside and the order of the single Judge dated 29.9.2006 was restored.

    (e) In W.P No. 18575 of 2006 one of us (NPVJ) had an occasion to consider similar issue and allowed the writ petition on 20.6.2006 by following earlier orders. The said order was also challenged by the respondent in W.A No. 42 of 2007 and the Division Bench (D. Murugesan, J & K. Venkataraman, J) dismissed the writ appeal on 2.7.2009 The Board filed SLP(C) No. 8305 of 2010 which was also dismissed by the Honourable Supreme Court on 6.7.2010 The said candidate viz., P. Venkatesan was given compassionate appointment by order dated 18.8.2010

    (f) Again similar matter was considered by one of us (NPVJ) in W.P No. 29059 of 2003 and relief granted by order dated 7.7.2006, against which also the Board filed W.A No. 1652 of 2006. The said writ appeal was dismissed by Division Bench (D. Murugesan, J. & S. Nagamuthu, J.) on 30.3.2009”

    11. In E. RAMASAMY's case (supra), as argued by the learned counsel for the respondents, the Division Bench negatived the request of the writ petitioner, who was a minor when his father died in harness and who subsequently, applied for appointment on compassionate ground, however, within 3 years of his attaining majority. It is pertinent to note that this decision has been overturned by the Hon'ble Apex Court. This has been noted in MOHANAMBAL v. DIRECTOR, LAND AND SURVEY DEPARTMENT [2011 (2) MLJ 47] [Also see SYED KHADIM HUSSAIN v. STATE OF BIHAR [(2006) 9 SCC 195].

    12. By relying upon various decisions of Division Bench and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the very same issue has been dealt with elaborately by one of us (N. Paul Vasanthakumar, J.) in the following cases:

    1. MOHANAMBAL v. DIRECTOR, LAND AND SURVEY DEPARTMENT [2011 (2) MLJ 47]

    2. J. JEBA MARY v. THE CHAIRMAN, TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD [2011 (3) LLN 405]

    3. G. SARAVANAKUMAR v. THE CHAIRMAN TAMIL NADU ELECTRICITY BOARD, CHENNAI [2011 (2) CWC 83]

    4. R. PRASATH v. THE SECRETARY, LABOUR AND EMPLOYMENT DEPT., CHENNAI (W.P No. 3078 of 2006, dated 17.06.2010)

    5. M. UMA v. THE CHIEF ENGINEER (PERSONNEL) CHENNAI (W.P(MD). No. 4050 of 2006, dated 29.06.2010)

    After analyzing the above said case laws, it was held that within 3 years of death of her husband, when the widow applied for appointment on compassionate ground, and due to bar of age etc., when she could not be appointed and the request for appointment has been followed by her son/daughter, who have then not attained majority and subsequently, applied within three years of their attaining majority, the request could be considered as continuation of their mother's application and the application given by him/her during the minority also could be considered as continuation of such earlier application and it cannot be denied on the ground that the application has been presented beyond 3 years of death of the father. It is not the case of the respondents that the family of the appellant is not in indigent status as on today.

    13. For the foregoing reasons, the order of the learned Single Judge made in W.P(MD) No. 13980 of 2009 dated 13.09.2010 is liable to set aside.

    14. Accordingly, this writ appeal is allowed and the order of learned Single Judge dated 13.09.2010 made in W.P(MD) No. 13980 of 2009 is set aside. The appellant herein is directed to produce a Certificate from the competent authority to the effect that his family is in indigent circumstances as on today, within four weeks and submit the same before the third respondent herein along with a copy of this Judgment. On receipt of the same, based on the representation of the appellant dated 22.12.2009, the respondents shall appoint him in any suitable post within two weeks therefrom. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Sathiaraman v. Department Of Electricity
    (Jul 23, 2013)