R.SUBBIAH,J
This writ petition is filed by the petitioner as a public interest
litigation to issue a writ of mandamus, for a direction to the first respondent
to take all necessary preventive measures to stop forthwith all unlawful
registration through out the State of Tamil Nadu by considering his
representation dated 09.10.2009.
2.The main grievance of the petitioner is that without verifying the right
of the ownership and other records the registering authorities registered
documents which had caused great prejudice to the petitioner. Hence he lodged a
complaint to the Inspector General of Registration, the first respondent herein
on 29.07.2006 for which a reply from 1st respondent, dated 18.08.2006 was
received stating that the registration department cannot stop accepting any
document presented for registration unless there is a specific stay from the
Courts. Hence, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition for the relief
set out earlier.
3.The circumstances which made the petitioner to approach this Court for
filing the present writ petition is evident from the application filed by the
respondents 4 and 5 who are none other than the brothers of the petitioner to
implead themselves as party respondents to the writ petition. It is stated
that their parents left behind four sons and two daughters and during the life
time of their father, he founded a Trust known as "Gomathi Trust" and he had
purchased certain properties in the name of the said trust. After the demise of
their father, the properties were partitioned orally among themselves and they
are in enjoyment of their respective shares.
4.In the said situation, the writ petitioner started to send false
complaints against them disputing their rights over the property left by their
father. Further, the respondents 4 and 5 had also come to know that the writ
petitioner had made an application before the Tahsildar, Sivagangai to effect
transfer of patta for all the properties in his name claiming that their father
executed a will on 08.02.2002 bequeathing entire property in his name. But on a
perusal of a copy of the will, the respondents 4 and 5 came to know that the
writ petitioner had created the said will by forging the signature of their
father. When the same was brought to the notice of the Tahsildar, the Tahsildar
rejected the said application for transfer of patta submitted by the writ
petitioner.
5.That apart a compliant was also lodged by the respondents 4 and 5 as
against the writ petitioner for the alleged forgery. The writ petitioner is now
attempting to settle his private dispute by abusing the process of court.
6.Though the application filed by the respondents 4 and 5 was vehemently
opposed by the writ petitioner by filing elaborate counter, this Court has
allowed the application for impleading by order dated 19.01.2010.
7.Opposing the prayer of the writ petitioner, the official respondents
have also filed their counter affidavit stating that the Registrars and Sub
Registrars are appointed by the State Government by virtue of the provisions
contained in Section 6 of the Registration Act 1908. The powers and duties of
the Registrars and Sub Registrars are enumerated under Sections 34 to 38,
52,55,57,58,59,60,61,63, 63,64,65,66,68,70,72,73,74,75 and 83 of the Act.
8.The power of the Registrar/Sub Registrar, while examining a document
presented for registration, is spelt out under Sections 34 and 52 of the Act.
The Registering Officer can only examine the document presented for registration
under the provisions of the Registration Act, 1908 and the rules framed
thereunder. Particularly, Rule 55 speaks about what is not the duty of the
Registering officer. Hence, by covering all the legal position, the petitioner
cannot expect the Registering Officer to examine the fact whether the seller of
the property in any sale deed is a rightful and lawful owner. The Registering
Officer can initiate action only under Section 83 of the Act and by invoking
Section 82 of the Act for offences like false personation alone and examining of
ownership of the seller is beyond the jurisdiction and competence of the
Registering Officer.
9.We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties
and perused the materials available on record.
10.It is the main grievance of the petitioner that registering authorities
are indiscriminately registering the documents without making proper enquiry
with regard to the rights and ownership of the seller. Therefore, Mandamus has
to be issued to the respondents to stop all unlawful registration through out
the State of Tamil Nadu by considering his representation, dated 09.10.2009.
According to the respondents 1 to 3, the Registering Officer is expected to
enquire into the document brought before him and he can make enquiry only within
the frame of provisions of the Registration Act and the Rules framed thereunder,
particularly with reference to Rule 55 relating to enquiry before the
registration speaks about what is not the duty of the Registering Officer. Rule
55 is extracted hereunder:
"55.It forms no part of a registering officer's duty to enquire into the
validity of a document brought to him for registration or to attend to any
written or verbal protest against the registration of a document based on the
ground that the executing party had no right to execute the document; but he is
bound to consider objections raised on any of the grounds stated below:-
(a)that the parties appearing or about to appear before him are not the
persons they profess to be;
(b)that the document is forged;
(c)that the person appearing as a representative, assign or agent, has no
right to appear in that capacity;
(d)that the executing party is not really dead, as alleged by the party
applying for registration; or
(e)that the executing party is a minor or an idiot or a lunatic".
11.A close reading of the said Rule would show the registering
authority is bound to consider the objection only on the ground which is stated
in the said Rule. Rule 55 does not provide enquiry by the Registering Officer
with regard to the right and ownership of the seller. Thus, the authorities
concerned are bound to act only in accordance with the Act and Rules framed
thereunder. The authorities cannot be directed to act contrary to the provisions
of the statute. We also find that the writ petition is filed only to settle the
family dispute between the petitioner and the respondents 4 and 5. Hence, we do
not find any merit in the writ petition.
12.The writ petition is dismissed. No costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petition is closed.
sms
To
1.Inspector General (Registrations),
The Appellate Authority,
Government of Tamil Nadu,
120, Santhome High Road,
Chennai.
2.The Chief Secretary,
Government of Tamil Nadu,
Fort St., George,
Chennai.
3.The Sub Registrar,
Kalaiyar Kovil,
Sivagangai District,