Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These two Civil Miscellaneous Appeals (MD) Nos.1165 and 1166 of 2007 were filed by the Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (Appellant) under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act challenging awards made by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Second Additional Subordinate Court, Madurai) in M.C.O.P. Nos.995 and 996 of 2004 dated 30.8.2006.

The underlying accident occurred on 26.1.2003 at about 10:15 a.m. On that date, the first claimant (PW.1) was riding a two-wheeler (Kinetic Honda Regn. No. TNJ 5087) with his wife, Palaniammal, as pillion rider, on the Madurai–Ramnad (East–West) main road near Puliyangulam, Madurai South Taluk. A transport bus driven by the corporation (registration TN-59-J-5087 / TN-63-N-0738 in witness evidence) struck the two-wheeler. The pillion rider, Palaniammal, sustained fatal crush injuries and died immediately; the first claimant sustained multiple injuries.

A criminal case (Crime No.20/2003) was registered against the bus driver. The claimants (husband, daughters and parents of the deceased) filed M.C.O.P. No.995 of 2004 claiming compensation (claimed Rs.42,80,500, restricted to Rs.36,00,000). For his injuries the first claimant filed M.C.O.P. No.996 of 2004 claiming Rs.6,87,500 (restricted to Rs.5,00,000). The Tribunal found the bus driver responsible and awarded compensation: in M.C.O.P. No.995 total compensation of Rs.21,04,760 (loss of dependency Rs.20,44,760 plus conventional damages) and in M.C.O.P. No.996 total compensation of Rs.77,500 for the injuries sustained by the first claimant.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that the Transport Corporation (through its bus driver) was responsible for the accident, i.e., whether the accident resulted from rash and negligent driving of the bus.
  2. Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal in M.C.O.P. No.995 (death of Palaniammal) and M.C.O.P. No.996 (injuries to the first claimant) is excessive or requires interference.
  3. Whether any deduction should be made towards income tax from the compensation awarded to the deceased's dependants.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Tribunal erred in finding that the accident was caused by rash and negligent driving of the bus; instead, the accident occurred because the first claimant (rider) lost balance while proceeding on the main road (i.e., the two-wheeler swerved and struck the bus).
  • The Tribunal failed to properly analyze the evidence of PW.1 and gave incorrect weight to the oral testimony.
  • Reliance was placed on Ex.P.3 (rough plan), which, the appellant submitted, shows the scene as on the main road and therefore supports the version that the two-wheeler lost balance rather than being struck by the bus.
  • The quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal is excessive and should be reduced.
  • The income tax payable by the deceased was not deducted by the Tribunal and an appropriate deduction should be made.

Respondents' (Claimants') Arguments

  • The consistent oral evidence of PW.1 and PW.4 establishes that the bus driver was responsible for the accident by driving rashly and negligently and hitting the two-wheeler from behind.
  • Documentary evidence (salary certificate Ex.P.6 and other documents) shows the deceased was a Post-Graduate Assistant receiving around Rs.17,123–Rs.18,000 per month; the Tribunal's approach to computing loss of dependency was reasonable.
  • The Tribunal did not account for future prospects, which would, if anything, increase compensation; the awards made are reasonable and should be upheld.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Sarla Verma & Others v. Delhi Transport Corporation and another [2009(2) TN MAC 1 (SC)] For a Government servant, future prospects must be taken into account when computing compensation (i.e., appropriate enhancement for prospective salary increases). The Court observed that the Tribunal did not take future prospects into account; had they been taken into account, compensation would have been higher. On this basis the Court rejected the appellant's contention that income tax should be deducted from the award (since future prospects were not considered, the Court found the appellant's tax-deduction argument unacceptable).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the oral and documentary evidence placed before the Tribunal and the contentions advanced on appeal. The key points of analysis were:

  1. On liability: The Court accepted the contemporaneous and consistent testimony of PW.1 (the first claimant) who stated that he was proceeding from East to West keeping left (southern side) when a Corporation bus came from behind, driven in a rash and negligent manner, dashed the two-wheeler, and the pillion rider (Palaniammal) fell and sustained fatal crush injuries (the bus's front left tyre ran over her head). This version was corroborated by PW.4, who said he was following at about 100 feet and saw the bus hit the two-wheeler and drag it for about 100 feet. The Tribunal's finding that the bus driver was responsible was held to be justified on the basis of these consistent witness accounts.
  2. On the appellant's contrary evidence: The Court evaluated the appellant's reliance on RW.1 (the bus driver) who claimed the two-wheeler swerved and lost balance, and on Ex.P.3 (rough plan). The Court observed that Ex.P.3 depicted vehicle positions after impact and therefore could not conclusively reflect positions at the time of collision. RW.1 was regarded as an interested witness and his version was given no weight in the face of consistent eyewitness testimony. Therefore, the contention that the two-wheeler lost balance was rejected.
  3. On computation of dependency in M.C.O.P. No.995 (death): The Tribunal adopted a monthly income of Rs.17,123 (based on Ex.P.6 salary certificate), calculated annual income at Rs.2,05,476, applied multiplier 15 (age 44 as per Schedule II), arrived at total income Rs.30,72,140, deducted one-third for personal expenses to compute loss of dependency at Rs.20,44,760, and after adding conventional damages awarded total compensation of Rs.21,04,760. The Court found this computation reasonable and did not interfere.
  4. On income tax deduction: Relying on Smt. Sarla Verma (Supreme Court), the Court noted that for a Government servant future prospects should be included. The Tribunal had not taken future prospects into account; had it done so the award would have been higher. In that factual matrix, the appellant's plea to deduct income tax payable was rejected as unacceptable.
  5. On compensation for injuries in M.C.O.P. No.996: The Tribunal had awarded Rs.77,500 in total (including Rs.20,000 towards disability). The Court held that the Tribunal's approach in awarding Rs.20,000 as disability on the ground of loss of amenities could not be sustained; the Court modified that component into Rs.10,000 for transportation and Rs.10,000 for pain and suffering. After this modification the total of Rs.77,500 was nevertheless regarded as reasonable and was confirmed. The Tribunal's award of interest at the rate of 7.5% was also maintained.

Holding and Implications

FINAL DISPOSITION: Both Civil Miscellaneous Appeals (MD) Nos.1165 and 1166 of 2007 are dismissed.

Consequences and direct effects:

  • The Tribunal's finding that the Transport Corporation (through its bus driver) is liable for the accident is upheld.
  • The compensation awarded in M.C.O.P. No.995 of 2004 (death of Palaniammal) in the sum of Rs.21,04,760 is confirmed as reasonable.
  • The compensation awarded in M.C.O.P. No.996 of 2004 (injuries to the first claimant) in the sum of Rs.77,500 is confirmed, with the Tribunal's award of Rs.20,000 in one component being recast as Rs.10,000 for transportation and Rs.10,000 for pain and suffering; interest at 7.5% is maintained.
  • No order as to costs; connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

The opinion did not purport to lay down any new precedent; it applied existing authority (Smt. Sarla Verma) to reject the appellant's tax-deduction plea and to note that future prospects, had they been considered by the Tribunal, would have increased compensation.

    Tamilnadu State Transport v. M.Sekar

    [Minor 2nd respondent is represented by his father/ guardian 1st respondent herein] [3rd respondent was declared Major and discharged R1 from her guardianship vide order dated 6.8.2010 made in M.P.

    (MD)No.2 of 2010 in the Appeal] C.M.A.No.1166 of 2007:

    Tamilnadu State Transport Corporation, Karaikudi, Sivagangai District, rep. by its Managing Director. ... Appellant vs.

    M.Sekar ... Respondent Civil Miscellaneous Appeal(MD)No.1165 of 2007 filed under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act against the award made in M.C.O.P. No. 995 of 2004 dated 30.8.2006 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal [2nd Additional Subordinate Court] Madurai.

    Civil Miscellaneous Appeal(MD)No.1166 of 2007 filed under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act against the award made in M.C.O.P. No. 996 of 2004 dated 30.8.2006 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal [2nd Additional Subordinate Court] Madurai.

    (Judgment of the Court was delivered by R.BANUMATHI,J) Being aggrieved by fastening of liability and quantum of compensation awarded for the death of the deceased Palaniammal and injuries sustained by the first claimant Sekar, the Transport Corporation has filed these two Appeals.

    2. The brief facts of the case are as follows:-

    (i) On 26.1.2003 at about 10.15 a.m., the first claimant was driving his Kinetic Honda Two Wheeler bearing Regn.No.TNJ 5087 along with his wife Palaniammal as the pillion rider on the Madurai to Ramnad, East - West main road near S.P.M.Bricks Chamber, Puliyangulam, Madurai South Taluk. While he was proceeding so from the East to West, a Transport Bus bearing Regn.No.TN-59-J- 5087 was driven in a rash and negligent manner from East to West and hit against the moving Kinetic Honda and caused instantaneous death of the pillion rider and the first claimant had also sustained injuries. On his complaint, a criminal case was registered against the bus driver in Crime No.20/2003 in Silaiman Police Station. The deceased Palaniammal was aged 43 years and she was a Post- Graduate Teacher having M.Sc. (Chemistry), M.Phil and M.Ed and she was earning Rs,18,000/- per month. Alleging that the accident was due to rash and negligent driving of the bus driver, the claimants who are husband, daughters and parents of the deceased Palaniammal have filed a claim petition in M.C.O.P.No.995 of 2004 claiming compensation of Rs.42,80,500/- but restricted the claim to a sum of Rs.36,00,000/-. In the same accident, the first claimant has sustained injuries i.e. fracture on the right shoulder, right frontal and cut injury over right thigh. For the injuries sustained by the first claimant, he filed claim petition M.C.O.P.No.996 of 2004 claiming compensation for Rs.6,87,500/- but restricted his claim to Rs.5,00,000/-.

    (ii) Before the Tribunal, the first claimant examined himself as PW.1 and Doctor Muthusamy, who treated him was examined as PW.3 and one Selvamani, who was the eye-witness, was examined as PW.4. Exs.P1 to P.22 were marked. The driver of the transport bus was examined as RW.1. Upon consideration of the oral and documentary evidence, the Tribunal held that the first claimant was riding his Two Wheeler keeping left and only the bus was driven in a rash and negligent manner without sounding horn. Pointing out that the road is 28 feet breadth and that the scene of accident was on the left extremity, the Tribunal held that RW.1 was responsible for the accident and held that the appellant Corporation is liable to pay compensation to the claimants.

    (iii) Based on Ex.P.6 Salary Certificate, the Tribunal has taken the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.17,123/- and adopted multiplier 15 and after deducting 1/3rd for personal expenses, the Tribunal has calculated loss of dependency at Rs.20,44,760/-. Adding conventional damages, the Tribunal has awarded total compensation of Rs.21,04,760/-. Insofar as the injuries sustained by the claimant in M.C.O.P.No.996 of 2004, the Tribunal has awarded compensation of Rs.77,500/-.

    3. The learned counsel for the appellant Corporation contended that the Tribunal erred in holding that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the appellant Corporation was driven. Drawing our attention to the evidence of PW.1 and RW.1, the learned counsel would further contend that the Tribunal failed to take note of the evidence of the respondents/PW.1 who has stated that the accident took place because of the loss of balance by the respondent and while so, the Tribunal erred in holding that the accident was due to rash and negligent driving of the bus by the driver. It was further contended that the tribunal failed to analyse the evidence of PW.1 in proper perspective. Insofar as the quantum of compensation is concerned, the learned counsel would submit that the quantum of compensation already awarded by the Tribunal is very much on the higher side.

    4. Drawing our attention to the evidence of PW.1 and PW.4, the learned counsel for the claimants/respondents submitted that the consistent evidence of PW.1 and PW.4 would clearly show that the bus driver was responsible for the accident and the finding of the Tribunal is well considered based upon the evidence and the same cannot be interfered. Drawing our attention to Ex.P.6 Salary Certificate and other documents, the learned counsel would contend that the deceased Palaniammal was a Post-Graduate Assistant and that she was getting salary around Rs.18,000/- and future prospects by way of revision of salary was not, in fact, taken into account by the Tribunal and that the quantum of compensation awarded is very much reasonable.

    5. The main defence plea of the appellant Corporation is denial of the manner of the accident and its liability of paying the compensation. Drawing our attention to the evidence of PW.1 (as recorded in paragraph 10 of the judgment), it was contended that while he was proceeding in the main road on the southern side by the Two Wheeler bearing Regn.No.TNJ 5087, PW.1 lost his balance and in that process, the Two Wheeler hit against the bus and Palaniammal had fallen down and sustain fatal injuries. Laying emphasis upon the answers elicited from PW.1, the learned counsel would submit that PW.1 himself has admitted that the accident had taken place in the main road and therefore, the bus driver cannot be held responsible.

    6. The learned counsel has placed reliance on the evidence of RW.1. In his defence, RW.1, bus driver has stated that while he was proceeding from Mudugalathur to Madurai, while he was nearing Silaiman, he was carefully driving the bus and the Two Wheeler rider swerved to the left side of the main road, and as such, the rider of two wheeler lost his balance and due to which pillion rider had fallen down and sustained injuries and he was not responsible for the accident.

    7. The learned counsel for the appellant Corporation placed much reliance upon Ex.P.3 rough plan and submitted that in Ex.P.3, the scene of accident is shown only as the main road which makes it clear that at the time of the accident, the Two Wheeler was only proceeding in the main road and lost the balance resulting in the accident. Though the scene of accident is shown in the main road, in our considered view, Ex.P.3 could not have reflected the position of the vehicles at the time of the accident. Ex.P.3 was prepared mentioning the position of the vehicles after the impact. The position of the vehicles in Ex.P.3 cannot be taken as the conclusive evidence to hold that the bus driver was not responsible for the accident.

    8. As pointed out earlier, in his evidence, PW.1 has clearly stated that on 26.1.2003 after the Republic Day function in the School, he was taking his wife in the Two Wheeler and when he was proceeding from the East to the West keeping left i.e. on the southern side, the Corporation bus came in a rash and negligent manner from behind and dashed the Two Wheeler due to which his wife - pillion rider had fallen down and the front left tyre of the bus run over her head and his wife sustained crush injuries on the head and died on the spot.

    9. The evidence of PW.1 was amply strengthened by the evidence of PW.4. In his evidence, PW.4 has stated that on the date of the accident i.e. on 26.1.2003, after the Republic Day function, while he was proceeding in Ramnad - Madurai road, PW.1 Sekar was proceeding in front side and that he was following them in his two wheeler had a distance of about 100 feet and at that time, the bus bearing Regn.No.TN-63-N-0738 was driven in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against the Two Wheeler of PW.1 Sekar and stopped after dragging for about 100 feet. PW.4 has also stated that because of hit by the bus, the pillion rider, Palaniammal had fallen down and sustained crush injury and the front tyre of the bus ran over and Palaniammal sustained crush injury. Based upon the consistent evidence of PW.1 and PW.4, the Tribunal rightly held that the accident was due to rash and negligent driving of the bus by the driver. No weight could be attached to the interested version of RW.1. The contention of the appellant Corporation that the accident took place because of the loss of balance by the first claimant does not merit acceptance. We do not find any reason to interfere with the finding of the Tribunal holding the bus driver responsible for the accident and that the appellant Corporation is liable to pay compensation.

    10. Insofar as the quantum of compensation awarded in M.C.O.P.No.995 of 2004 (C.M.A.No.1165 of 2007) the deceased Palaniammal was working as the Selection Grade P.G.Assistant. As seen from Exs.P8, P9 and P10, Palaniammal had studied M.Sc., M.Phil and M.Ed. Ex.P.11 is the order giving her Selection Grade. In the Selection Grade, Palaniammal was getting the salary of Rs.17,123/-. From Ex.P.7, School Certificate, it is seen that the date of birth of the deceased Palaniammal is 2.8.1959 and on the date of the accident she was running 44 years. The Tribunal has taken the age as 44 and as per the Schedule II. Taking the income of the deceased at Rs.17,123/- per month, the Tribunal has calculated the annual income at Rs.2,05,476/- and adopted the multiplier 15 and thus, the Tribunal has calculated total income at Rs.30,72,140/-. After deducting 1/3rd for personal expenses, the total loss of dependency was calculated at Rs.20,44,760/-. Adding the conventional damages, the Tribunal has awarded total compensation of Rs.21,04,760/-, which in our considered view is very reasonable warranting no interference.

    11. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant Corporation has submitted that the income tax payable by Palaniammal was not deducted by the Tribunal and therefore, prayed for an appropriate deduction.

    12. As per the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Smt.Sarla Verma & Others v. Delhi Transport Corporation and another [2009(2) TN MAC 1(SC)], in respect of a Government servant, for future prospects necessary increase has to be made. In fact, the Tribunal has not taken into account the future prospects. Had the future prospects been taken into account, the compensation awarded would be still higher. In such view of the matter, the contention of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant Corporation prayed for deduction towards income tax payable is unacceptable.

    13. Insofar as M.C.O.P.No.996 of 2004(C.M.A.No.1166 of 2007), insofar as the injury sustained by the first claimant in the accident, he sustained multiple fracture on the right shoulder and cut injury. After the accident, PW.1 was admitted in the Government Hospital and thereafter, he was taking treatment in Madurai Meenakshi Hospital. PW.3 Doctor Muthusamy has examined PW.1 clinically and also with reference to the documents, assessed the disability at 45%. Having regard to the injuries sustained by the claimant, the Tribunal has awarded Rs.20,000/- for medical expenses, Rs.7,500/- for extra nourishment and for the pain and suffering Rs.10,000/-. The compensation for permanent disability was awarded Rs.20,000/-. The Tribunal has awarded that Rs.20,000/- towards disability on the ground that the claimant has lost amenities. However, such approach of the Tribunal in awarding compensation for the death of wife and resultant loss of amenities cannot be sustained. Having regard to the nature of the injuries, the amount of Rs.20,000/- is modified as Rs.10,000/- for transportation and the further sum of Rs.10,000/- for pain and suffering. The total compensation of Rs.77,500/- awarded to the first claimant for the injuries sustained by him is quite reasonable warranting no interference. The Tribunal has awarded interest at the rate of 7.5% and the same is maintained. The quantum of compensation awarded in M.C.O.P.No.996 of 2004 (C.M.A.No.1166 of 2007) is confirmed and the interest is also confirmed.

    15. The quantum of compenstion and the rate of interest awarded by the Tribunal in M.C.O.P.No.995 of 2004 and 996 of 2004 are confirmed and both the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal (MD)Nos.1165 and 1166 of 2007 are dismissed. No order as to costs. Connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.

    asvm To The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal [2nd Additional Subordinate Court], Madurai.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tamilnadu State Transport v. M.Sekar
    (Nov 10, 2010)