AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent (a broadcasting corporation) and the appellant/defendant entered into an agreement dated 26.6.1990 (effective 1.7.1990) under which the defendant was obliged to pay certain charges. The plaintiff claimed default and asserted a right to recover Rs.22,58,670/-. Notices were served; the defendant did not respond to the demands but did appear through counsel in the suit. No written statement was filed for a prolonged period (a delay of 1,338 days is recorded), and the matter came up before the trial court under the heading "undefended board".

While these circumstances obtained, the defendant filed an application under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act seeking rejection of the plaint (invoking Clause 5 of the agreement containing an arbitration clause). The learned Single Judge dismissed that application on the basis that (a) there was no dispute/difference that could be referred to arbitration and (b) the application under Section 8 should have been filed before the filing time for the written statement, so the right to refer had been lost. The defendant appealed that dismissal (O.S.A.No.378 of 2006).

Separately, the defendant challenged an order (in Application No.2355/2005) which had set aside an ex parte decree on the condition that the defendant deposit 50% of the claimed amount; that appeal was filed as O.S.A.No.319 of 2006. The trial court had passed an ex parte decree after initially declining to refer the matter to arbitration, and later allowed the application to set aside the ex parte decree subject to the 50% deposit condition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 should be entertained and the suit referred to arbitration where an arbitration clause exists, even though the defendant did not file its written statement within the normal time and the application invoking Section 8 was filed after that time.
  2. Whether the trial court was correct in holding that there was no dispute or difference between the parties capable of referral to arbitration.
  3. Whether the condition imposed by the trial court (deposit of 50% of the claim) as a term for setting aside an ex parte decree is reasonable and should be sustained in the circumstances where a Section 8 referral has been directed.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / Defendant's Arguments

  • There was a valid agreement dated 26.6.1990 containing Clause 5 providing that disputes shall be referred to arbitration.
  • Although the defendant did not file a written statement within time (delay of 1,338 days), the right to invoke the arbitral clause survives and the Court should have referred the matter to arbitration under Section 8.
  • The application under Section 8 was filed while the suit was pending; the defendant sought condonation for the delay in filing the written statement, and the Section 8 application and the condonation application were before the court.
  • The Single Judge's dismissal — reasoning that the written statement should have been filed in time or else the right to refer to arbitration was lost — is contrary to settled decisions of the Supreme Court (as relied upon by the appellant).
  • Concerning the setting aside of the ex parte decree, the imposition of a condition to deposit 50% of the claim is asserted to be unreasonable and unjust in view of the defendant's denial of liability and the entitlement to refer the dispute to arbitration.

Respondent / Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that repeated demands were made and ignored, and the defendant's long failure to file a written statement despite appearing through counsel is indicative that there was no bona fide dispute; hence, the arbitral clause could not be invoked.
  • Because the defendant allowed the matter to drift to the "undefended board" stage and did not file its written statement for years, it had lost the right to seek a reference to arbitration; the Section 8 application was an evasive tactic.
  • The Single Judge was correct in dismissing the Section 8 application; consequently, the later order setting aside an ex parte decree subject to deposit should be sustained.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
2004(3) Arb.LR 82 — Everest Electric Works v. Himachal Futuristics Comm. Ltd. Relied on by the appellant to support the contention that an arbitration clause should be invoked even if the written statement was not filed in time. The opinion records that this decision was relied upon by the appellant; the text does not state any specific way in which the Court applied or distinguished this precedent.
(2006) 7 SCC 275 — Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. & another v. Verma Transport Co. Relied on by the appellant as authority for referring disputes to arbitration despite procedural delay in filing a written statement. The opinion notes reliance on this Apex Court decision by counsel, but does not set out any detailed discussion of or explicit application of the case law in its reasoning.
2008 (4) Arb.LR 105 — Kaiser Lands vs. Ethel Robin Relied on by the appellant in support of the proposition that the arbitral clause should be enforced and the matter referred to arbitration. The opinion records that this decision was cited by counsel; the judgment does not expressly indicate how the Court applied the ratio of this decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory framework of Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and reproduced the text of Section 8 in the opinion. From the text the Court distilled the conditions necessary to trigger the duty to refer:

  1. There must be an arbitration agreement;
  2. A judicial authority must have before it an action in a matter which is the subject of that agreement;
  3. The subject matter of the action must be the subject matter of arbitration;
  4. The party seeking referral must apply not later than when submitting his first statement on the substance of the dispute (i.e., the first statement on the merits).

The Court then examined Clause 5 of the parties' agreement (which it reproduced). The clause expressly provides that any question, dispute or difference arising under or in connection with the agreement shall be referred to sole arbitration appointed by a named authority, and that the arbitrator's award shall be final and binding.

Addressing the respondent's factual contention that the absence of replies to pre-suit notices showed there was no dispute, the Court rejected that inference: the issuance of notices and the lack of reply are factual matrix that do not themselves conclusively establish the absence of a dispute.

On the timing objection — that the Section 8 application was filed after the time for filing the written statement and therefore could not be entertained — the Court held that inordinate delay in filing the written statement does not oust or dilute the statutory mandate of Section 8. The Court reasoned that provisions of the Civil Procedure Code regarding filing written statements cannot be allowed to defeat Section 8 which goes to the jurisdictional core by depriving the tribunal of matters agreed to be decided by arbitration. Even if under CPC the right to file a written statement might be lost, that cannot operate to dilute Section 8 where no first statement on the merits has actually been made.

Applying these legal principles to the facts, the Court concluded that (a) there was an arbitration agreement covering the subject-matter, (b) the Section 8 application was meritorious notwithstanding the delay in filing the written statement, and (c) therefore the trial court's dismissal of the Section 8 application was incorrect.

On the connected issue of the ex parte decree and the condition to set it aside (deposit of 50% of the claim), the Court explained that once it set aside the trial court's dismissal and directed referral to arbitration, the question of that deposit condition did not require independent consideration — the referral rendered the earlier order on the ex parte decree unnecessary to be examined further.

Holding and Implications

Holding: O.S.A.No.378 of 2006 is allowed. The order passed by the learned Single Judge in Application No.628 of 2005 (dismissing the Section 8 application) is set aside, and the parties are directed to proceed to arbitration in accordance with Clause 5 of the agreement.

As to the related appeal, O.S.A.No.319 of 2006 is disposed of because, having directed reference to arbitration in the primary appeal, the condition-imposing order for setting aside the ex parte decree does not require further consideration. The Court ordered no costs and closed the connected miscellaneous petitions (M.P.Nos.2 & 2 of 2006).

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The suit is to be referred to arbitration as per the contractual clause; the trial court's dismissal of the Section 8 application is reversed, and the defendant's challenge to the deposit condition is rendered academic by the referral order.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a broader new precedent beyond applying Section 8 to the facts; it does not announce novel principles beyond the Court's conclusion that delay in filing a written statement does not, by itself, defeat an otherwise prima facie invocation of Section 8 where no first statement on the substance of the dispute has been made.

No other findings, remedies or costs were awarded beyond those stated above in the opinion.

    Ragavendra Advertising v. Prasar Bharati, (Broadcasting Corporation Of India)

    These appeals have been preferred under Order XXXVI Rule 9 of O.S. Rules r/w Clause 15 of Letters Patent as against the order passed by the learned single Judge in Application Nos.2355 of 2005 and 628 of 2005 dated 21.6.2005 and 23.2.2005 respectively.

    The respondent/plaintiff Corporation is conducting a Broadcasting service and the plaintiff Corporation is also having another ancillary wing for broadcasting on commercial basis. The plaintiff and the defendant entered into an agreement on 26.6.1990 which was given effect from 1.7.1990. Under the terms of agreement, the defendant agreed to pay necessary charges as stipulated therein but there was default in payments. The plaintiff is entitled to get Rs.22,58,670/- from the defendant. Despite service of notice, there was no response from the defendant. Hence, the plaintiff has filed a suit. The suit summons were served and the defendant entered through counsel but they have not filed the written statement and the matter appeared under the caption 'undefended board' on 22.12.2004. Thereafter, the matter was adjourned on number of occasions. While the matter stood thus, the defendant filed an application under section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act seeking that the plaint has got to be rejected by invoking Clause 5 of the agreement. The respondent was given opportunity to file his counter. The Court heard the learned counsel on either side and after hearing the submissions made and looking into the available materials, the Court took the view that the application for rejection of the plaint is not maintainable since it is not a fit case where arbitral clause could be invoked, therefore, dismissed the application. Hence, this appeal at the instance of the appellant.

    3. Advancing the arguments on behalf of the appellant/defendant, the learned counsel would submit that in the instant case, it was an agreed position that there was an agreement entered into between the parties on 26.6.1990 and clause 5 of the Agreement would clearly indicate that whenever dispute arose between the parties, it should be referred to arbitration. A very reading of the said clause would indicate the same. It is true the defendant did not file the written statement and there was delay of 1338 days in filing the written statement. When the matter was taken up for enquiry, at that time, the application was actually filed with an application to condone the delay in filing the written statement but it remained unnumbered and the same was also brought to the notice of the Court. There is an arbitral clause in the agreement and there was actually a dispute between the parties. When the claim was made by the plaintiff, there was denial on the part of the defendant and the arbitral clause also pave the way for solving the dispute before the arbitration. Hence, it is mandatory and the Court, after putting on notice, should have referred the matter to arbitration but the learned Single Judge has dismissed the application stating that the written statement was not filed in time and that before the defence was actually putforth, the application should have been taken and that would also mean that the written statement should be filed within the time stipulated under the procedural code and since it was not done so, the defendant has lost its right to seek reference to arbitration. That is the view taken by the learned Single Judge which is contrary to the settled decisions of the Apex Court. So long as the written statement was not filed, as the substantial defence, the defendant is entitled to invoke the arbitral clause. It is quite clear that there is dispute between the parties and the finding given by the learned single Judge regarding the liability is not correct. Since it was a claim made by the plaintiff, the defendant should be allowed to file its defence and the question of liability can be decided only after the trial of the suit. The learned single Judge has pointed out as if the collection made by the defendant was not paid to the plaintiff at all. This is also not correct. The defendant has putforth a plea denying the liability. The finding recorded by the trial Court is that there is no difference or dispute between the parties is also not correct. Under such circumstances, it is a fit case where it has got to be referred to arbitration. Hence, the order of the learned single Judge has got to be set aside. In support of his contention, the learned counsel relied on the following decisions.

    i) 2004(3) Arb.LR 82 (Everest Electric Works v. Himachal Futuristics Comm.Ltd. )

    ii) (2006) 7 SCC 275 ( Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. & another v. Verma Transport Co.)

    iii) 2008 (4) Arb.LR 105 (Kaiser Lands vs. Ethel Robin)

    4. Contrary to the above contention, the learned counsel for the respondent would submit that it is a case where no reply was given by the appellant/defendant when there was many a demand made through notices. Thereafter, the suit was filed. Even though the defendant appeared through counsel, the written statement was not filed for number of years when the matter appeared before the Court under the caption ' undefended board'. Under such circumstances, having lost the right to refer the matter to arbitration, the application for rejection of the plaint is only an evasive process. The arbitral clause could be invoked if there was dispute or difference between the parties. In the instant case, no such dispute was ever shown. Once, there is no dispute, no question of referring the matter to arbitration would arise. Hence, the learned single Judge is perfectly correct in dismissing the application. Hence, the order of the learned single Judge has got to be affirmed.

    5. Another Appeal viz., Appeal No.319/2006 was filed by the appellant/defendant challenging the order passed in Application No.2355/2005 seeking to set aside the exparte decree passed in C.S.No.245 of 2001. The Court heard the learned counsel on either side and observed that it was a suit for recovery of Rs.22,58,670/- along with interest made by the respondent/plaintiff on the ground that the defendant as an agent has collected amount from different companies which amount was actually payable to the plaintiff but the same was not paid; that the written statement was not filed for a long time, despite appearance through counsel; that when, the matter came before the Court on 22.12.2004 under the caption 'undefended board', the application was filed under section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act. The learned single Judge after hearing the counsel on either side and looking into the materials pointed out that it is a case where an exparte decree was passed and this exparte decree has got to be set aside and opportunity should be given to the defendant to prosecute the case by imposing a condition. Hence, passed an order imposing a condition to deposit 50% of the claim on or before 21.7.2005. Under such circumstances, Appeal No.319/2006 has arisen.

    6. The learned counsel for the appellant/defendant would submit that the condition to deposit 50% of the entire claim was not only unreasonable but also unjust and it is a case where the learned single Judge has taken a view that the defendant should be given opportunity to putforth the defence. There was denial of liability. Under such circumstances, ordering condition to deposit 50% of the claim amount has got to be set aside.

    7. The learned counsel for the respondent made his sincere attempt to sustain the order passed by the learned single Judge.

    8. The Court paid its anxious consideration on the submissions made on either side and looked into the material available on record.

    9. It is not in controversy the respondent has filed a suit for recovery of money and the defendant has not filed the written statement when the matter appeared under the caption "undefended board" despite the counsel was on record. There was also a delay of 1338 days delay in filing the application to condone the delay to receive the written statement. Even before filing that application, the instant application for rejection of the plaint was made stating that it is a fit case where the parties should be directed to place the matter before the arbitral proceedings since there was agreement between the parties. The agreement would stipulate arbitral clause. Originally, the agreement was not filed before the Court and subsequently, the same came to be placed before the Court. Clause 5 of the agreement would refer to, whenever there is dispute or difference between the parties, it could be referred to arbitration. Insofar as the instant application was concerned, opportunity was given to the plaintiff to putforth the counter. The learned Single Judge took a view that since there was no dispute or difference between the parties, it cannot be referred to arbitration. Secondly an application invoking section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 should have been filed even before filing of the written statement In the instant case, the written statement was not filed and the application under section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation was filed beyond the filing time available for the written statement which would mean that invoking arbitral clause was lost, hence, could not invoke section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act and recording such finding, the application was dismissed. Hence, this appeal has arisen.

    10. It is apt and appropriate to reproduce section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

    "8. Power to refer parties to arbitration where there is an arbitration agreement -(1) A judicial authority before which an action is brought in a matter which is the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a party so applies not later than when submitting his first statement on the substance of the dispute, refer the parties to arbitration.

    (2) The application referred to in sub-section (1) shall not be entertained unless it is accompanied by the original arbitration agreement or a duly certified copy thereof.

    (3) Notwithstanding that an application has been made under sub-section (1) and that the issue is pending before the judicial authority, an arbitration may be commenced or continued and an arbitral award made."

    11. From the very reading, it would be quite clear that the condition which are specified to invoke section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (1) there should be an arbitration agreement (2) the party to the agreement should bring action to the Court against the other party (3) the subject matter of action should be the subject matter of arbitration (4) the other party who moves the Court should submit his first statement on the substance of the dispute. If all these conditions are satisfied, there cannot be any impediment in directing the parties to go for arbitration.

    12. In the instant case, admittedly, there is arbitral clause and clause 5 of the agreement reads as follows.

    "5. In the event of any question, dispute or difference arising under these presents or in connection therewith (except as to any matters the decision of which is specially provided for by these presents), the same shall be referred to the sole arbitration of an officer appointed to be the arbitrator by the Director General, All India Radio. It will be no objection that the arbitrator is a Government servant that he has to deal with the matters to which these presents relate or that in the course of his duties as a Government Servant, he has expressed views on all or any of the matters in dispute or difference. The award of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties to these presents."

    From the very reading of the above clause it would be quite clear that whenever there is dispute or difference arises between the parties, they have to go for arbitral proceedings. In the instant case, the contention put forth by the respondent is that originally notices were issued and the same were received and despite receipt of notices, there was no reply which could be inferred that there was no dispute or difference. The contention putforth by the respondent cannot be countenanced since issuance to notices can be taken as a relevant fact and the non reply of the notice can be said to be proved contents of the notice.

    13. So far as the first contention that since the application under section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 was not filed by the defendant before the time available for filing the written statement and hence that application cannot be entertained is concerned, this Court is of the considered opinion that this contention cannot be accepted.

    14. It is true that the defendant did not file the written statement in time and the matter also appeared before the Court under the caption 'undefended board', at the same time, it should not be forgotten that merely because there is inordinate delay in filing the written statement it cannot in any way take away the rigor of section 8 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act. The law mandates whenever it is brought to the notice of the court before filing the written statement that there is arbitral clause and the subject matter of the suit is actually be decided by the arbitrator, it has got to be referred to arbitration. It can be well stated that the provisions pertaining to the filing of the written statement however, cannot be applied to the initiation of an application under section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 which, in essence, hits at the root of the jurisdiction of the Court to continue a civil action where the parties have themselves compacted to go to Arbitration. Even if the C.P.C. were to apply the right to file a written statement would stand closed. However, this would in no manner dilute the provisions of Section 8 of the said Act since there is indubitably no first statement on the merits of the case. Even though there is inordinate delay, in the considered opinion of the Court, the rigor of section 8 of the said Act cannot be diluted. Once, it is brought to the notice that it is a case where it has to be referred to arbitration as understood between the parties and there was also an arbitration clause in the agreement entered into between the parties it has got to be referred to arbitration. Therefore, the order passed by the learned single Judge in Application No.628 of 2005 is set aside. The parties are directed to approach the Arbitrator as understood between them under clause 5 of the agreement. Accordingly, O.S.A.No.378 of 2006 is allowed.

    15. The other appeal viz.,O.S.A.No.319 of 2006 arises from the order of the learned single Judge allowing the application to set aside the exparte on condition to deposit 50% of the suit claim. The respondent filed a suit for recovery of money and the defendant appeared through counsel did not file the written statement and it appeared under the caption 'undefended board.' The written statement was not filed and an application to condone the delay of 1338 days in filing the written statement filed was also relied on and it remained unnumbered. Under such circumstances, even before that application under section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation was filed for rejection of the plaint, this application was taken up for consideration and the plaintiff was given an opportunity to file the counter. The court after looking into the materials available took the view that the application could not be maintained and dismissed the same.

    After doing so, the defendant was set exparte and the same was recorded and the exparte decree came to be passed. This instant application was filed to set aside the exparte decree. The learned single Judge was of the view that the exparte decree has got to be set aside on imposing a condition. Hence, imposed a condition to deposit 50% of the suit claim.

    16. So far as OSA.No.378 of 2006 filed against the order of dismissal of the application for rejection of plaint by invoking section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,1996 is concerned, this Court has set aside the judgment of the trial Court and allowed the appeal and the parties are directed to be referred to arbitration. Since this Court has taken a view in that appeal, the application to set aside the exparte decree imposing condition does not arise for consideration at all. Accordingly O.S.A.No.319 of 2006 is disposed of. No costs. Consequently, connected M.P.Nos.2 & 2 of 2006 are closed.

    vsi

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ragavendra Advertising v. Prasar Bharati, (Broadcasting Corporation Of India)
    (Oct 6, 2009)