Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 21 Rule 29 of C.P.C.,
  • Order 21 Rule 29 C.P.C.
  • Order 21 Rule 29
  • Order 21 Rule 35
  • Order 21 Rule 32
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 21 Rule 29 of C.P.C.,
  • Order 21 Rule 29 C.P.C.
  • Order 21 Rule 29
  • Order 21 Rule 35
  • Order 21 Rule 32

    O.Chinnasamy v. S.Niraikulathan

    The defendant in O.S.No.476 of 2006 on the file of the District Munsif Court, Theni, is the revision petitioner herein. O.S.No.476 of 2006 was filed by the respondents for recovery of possession of the properties mentioned in the suit, suit was decreed and the decree has become final. The decree holders/ respondents herein filed E.P.No.34 of 2007 under Order 21 Rule 35 for delivery of the suit properties and remove the constructions as per the provisions under Order 21 Rule 32 and that petition was contested by the revision petitioner on the ground that the revision petitioner has filed a suit in O.S.No.103 of 2003 on the file of the District Munsif, Periyakulam for injunction against the second respondent herein in respect of the same property and in that suit it was contended by the revision petitioner that he is the owner of the suit property and his possession was sought to be interfered by the second respondent herein and therefore he filed the said suit for injunction and that injunction suit was dismissed and against the same the revision petitioner filed in A.S.No.26 of 2006 on the file of the Subordinate Court, Periyakulam and that appeal is pending and therefore when that appeal is pending the lower Court should not have proceeded with the execution application and the execution application is to be stayed as per Order 21 Rule 29 and the lower Court without considering the same ordered delivery in the petition filed by the respondents decree holder in E.P.No.34 of 2007 in O.S.No.476 of 2006 and hence this revision is filed against that order.

    2. It is contended by Mr.R.Surya Narayanan, learned counsel for the revision petitioner that as per Order 21 Rule 29 where a suit is pending in any Court against the holder of the decree of such Court, the Court may, on such terms as to security or otherwise, stay execution of the decree until the pending suit has been decided. Therefore the learned counsel for the revision petitioner contended that his suit namely O.S.No.103 of 2003 is pending in the first appellate Court and therefore during the pendency of A.S.No.26 of 2006 on the file of the Subordinate Court, Periyakulam, the proceedings in E.P.34 of 2007 in O.S.No.476 of 2006 should be stayed. He further contended that he has filed a suit for injunction in O.S.No.103 of 2003 and in the event of appeal being allowed in A.S.No.26 of 2006 he is entitled to injunction and the said decree would be binding on the defendant in that suit namely the second respondent herein and therefore the decree passed in O.S.No.476 of 2006 cannot be executed and only for that purpose a provision has been made under Order 21 Rule 29 and hence the Court should have stayed all further proceedings in O.S.No.476 of 2006 and should not have allowed the E.P.No.34 of 2007. In support of his contention he also relied upon the Judgment reported in 1997(1) CTC page No.265(Diamond Sea Foods Exports. v. A.M.Nicholas).

    3. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents Mr.S.Ramachandran submitted that the decree in O.S.No.476 of 2006 has become final and the revision petitioner is bound by the decree and the decree would operate as resjudicata in A.S.No.26 of 2006. He further contended that as decree holder is entitled to apply for delivery of the property and suit filed by the revision petitioner is one for injunction and even assuming that he is entitled to injunction decree it is subject to the decree passed in O.S.No.476 of 2006 as the decree passed in O.S.No.476 of 2006 is one for recovery of possession and in that suit, the Court granted the decree of recovery of possession against the defendant, and hence the defendant cannot insist that he is entitled to injunction and he is not liable to deliver possession.

    4. Therefore, the learned counsel for the respondents Mr.S.Ramachandran contended that the Rev-petitioner is not entitled to the benefit of Order 21 Rule 29 and the lower Court has correctly passed the order. He further submitted that in O.S.476 of 2006 there are two plaintiffs and in O.S.No.103 of 2003 there is one defendant who is the second plaintiff in O.S.No.476 of 2006 namely second respondent herein and therefore there is no suit pending against the first respondent, the 1st plaintiff in O.S.No.476 of 2006 and therefore that provision will not be applicable to the facts of this case.

    5. I have given anxious consideration to the submissions made by both counsel.

    6. As per the judgment of the Supreme Court reported in 1972(2)SCC 731 in the matter of Shaukat Hussain v. Bhuneshwari Devi, two conditions are prescribed to invoke Order 21 Rule 29 C.P.C. and the first condition is there must be simultaneous proceedings, the second condition is, execution by the decree holder must be pending against the judgment debtor and judgment debtor must have filed a suit against the decree holder and same must be pending.

    7. In this case admittedly, the first respondent is not a party to O.S.No.103 of 2003 which is the subject matter of A.S.No.26 of 2006 filed by the revision petitioner. Therefore, there is no bar for the first respondent herein to proceed with the E.P. Further, as rightly contended by the learned counsel for the 1st respondent that he has got a decree for recovery of possession which has become final and the revision petitioner is bound by the same. According to Order 21 Rule 29 of C.P.C., the discretion is given to the Court to stay the proceedings till the disposal of the suit. Further in the Judgment reported in 1997(1) CTC page No.265 (Diamond Sea Foods Exports. v. A.M.Nicholas) the learned Judge of this Court relied upon the judgment reported in 1943 (2) M.L.J.452 (S.A.Ramanathan Chettiar v. M.P.Kashi Chettiar @ Meyappa Chettiar) and held that the word "suit" in Order 21 Rule 29 means the suit and not the appeal or appeals therefrom to the appellate Court and therefore when there is no suit pending and the appeal is pending, Order 21 Rule 29 will not be applicable. As a matter of fact, the facts of the case in the reported Judgment is similar to the facts of this case. In the reported Judgment, there was a decree for the delivery of possession of the car in favour of the decree holder and some reliefs prayed for by the decree holder in that suit were rejected and against the same the decree holder filed an appeal and the appeal is pending. The judgment debtor filed another suit for recovery of money and decree was granted in favour of the Judgment debtor. The decree holder who obtained decree for recovery of the car filed E.P. proceedings in that suit.

    8. The Judgment debtor who obtained money decree filed an application under Order 21 Rule 29 stating that the appeal filed by the decree holder against the refusal of certain relief is pending and therefore during the pendency of appeal, the decree cannot be executed and that was negatived by the Court relying upon the Judgment reported 1943 (2) M.L.J.452 (S.A.Ramanathan Chettiar v. M.P.Kashi Chettiar @ Meyappa Chettiar).

    9. In this case also there is a decree in favour of the respondents and the first respondent herein was not a party to the other suit filed by the revision petitioner and hence Order 21 Rule 29 will not be applicable to the facts of the case and the trial Court has correctly ordered the delivery of possession and there is nothing illegal in that order.

    10. Hence, the revision petition is dismissed. No costs. consequently, the connected M.P.No.1 of 2009 is also closed.

    SKN/KR To The District Munsif, Theni

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    O.Chinnasamy v. S.Niraikulathan
    (Nov 12, 2009)