Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 13(2) read with 13(1)(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and section 109 of the Indian Penal Code read with section 13(2) read with section 13(2)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act
  • section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Code. Therefore, Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965
  • section 363(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Code, that section 363(6) of the of Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of the High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965,
  • Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965
  • Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Rule 339 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • rule 339 of the Criminal Rules
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Information Act, 2005
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 13(2) read with 13(1)(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and section 109 of the Indian Penal Code read with section 13(2) read with section 13(2)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act
  • section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Code. Therefore, Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965
  • section 363(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Code, that section 363(6) of the of Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of the High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965,
  • Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965
  • Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Rule 339 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • rule 339 of the Criminal Rules
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Information Act, 2005
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A criminal prosecution was registered as Special C.C.No.14 of 2004 against respondents 2 to 8 under provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act (including section 13(2) read with 13(1)(c) and section 13(2)(e)), and section 109 IPC read with the Prevention of Corruption Act, alleging acquisition of properties disproportionate to known sources of income. The accused were discharged from the proceedings by a common order dated 6.11.2006 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem.

The petitioner, a former Public Prosecutor for Salem District and a practising Advocate in the District and Sessions Court, Salem, filed Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007 before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem seeking certified copies of the First Information Report, charge sheet, docket endorsements, various petitions and counters, orders passed thereon, and statements recorded under section 161 Cr.P.C., for the purpose of preferring a revision against the discharge order before the High Court.

The learned Chief Judicial Magistrate dismissed Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007, observing (i) no substantive reason was assigned for seeking the certified copies, (ii) the petitioner was not an "affected person" as contemplated under section 363(5) Cr.P.C., (iii) section 363(6) Cr.P.C. can be invoked only before the High Court, and (iv) Rule 339 Cr.P.C. contemplates furnishing records only to the parties concerned and not to third parties. The petitioner challenged that dismissal in the present petition, seeking to set aside the order and obtain the certified copies.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a third party (the petitioner), who is not a party to the original criminal proceedings, can obtain certified copies of the trial court records—specifically, the FIR, charge sheet, docket endorsements, petitions and orders, and statements under section 161 Cr.P.C.—for the purpose of challenging the trial court's discharge order.
  2. Whether the right conferred by section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure to obtain copies of any judgment or order of a Criminal Court can be exercised by a third party notwithstanding that the High Court has not framed rules under that provision.
  3. Whether Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965, and Rule 339 of the Criminal Rules of Practice (Rule 339 Cr.P.C.) apply to documents still lying in the file of the trial court (i.e., before those records have reached the High Court), and whether those provisions permit a third party to obtain certified copies.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Section 363(6) Cr.P.C. contemplates supply of copies of any judgment or order of a Criminal Court to any person (including third parties) upon payment of fees as per High Court rules.
  • Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 permits granting certified copies of judicial records to persons who are not party to the proceedings; therefore, a third party can be granted certified copies.
  • Reliance on a Bench judgment of the High Court (later identified in the opinion as D. Jayakumar v. State) where the High Court held that even a third party is entitled to copies of records in a criminal court; hence, the impugned order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate is liable to be set aside.

Respondent / Government Advocate's Arguments

  • Section 363(6) Cr.P.C. only contemplates grant of copies of the judgment or order of a Criminal Court to a third party in terms of rules framed by the High Court; no such rule has been framed by the Madras High Court, so a third party is not entitled to copies under that provision.
  • Even if section 363(6) Cr.P.C. could be invoked absent High Court rules, it permits only a certified copy of a judgment or order and not other records sought by the petitioner.
  • Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 applies only to records that have come to the file of the High Court; it does not apply to records still lying with the trial court.
  • The Rules of the High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 were not framed under the specific power conferred by section 363(6) Cr.P.C., so Order XII Rule 3 cannot be read as filling the gap created by the absence of rules under section 363(6).
  • There is a risk of misuse of criminal court documents if such documents are furnished to third parties not entitled to them, potentially leading to miscarriage of justice or harm to innocent persons.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
D. JAYAKUMAR v. STATE rep by the Inspector of Police, Vigilance & Anti-Corruption Wing, Dindigul in Crl.O.P.(MD) No.10290 of 2007 (order dated 4.10.2007) Recognised that a third party is entitled to certified copies of all material documents in a criminal case. The court relied on and cited this earlier order in support of the proposition that the failure of the High Court to frame rules under section 363(6) Cr.P.C. does not extinguish the right of a third party to obtain certified copies; the earlier authority was treated as precedent in allowing the petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court identified the central statutory provision, section 363(6) Cr.P.C., which empowers the High Court to make rules to provide for the grant of copies of any judgment or order of a criminal court to any person who is not affected by such judgment or order, subject to fees and conditions. The court acknowledged that the Madras High Court had not framed any rules under section 363(6) Cr.P.C. since 1973.

The court addressed the question whether the absence of rules made by the High Court could defeat the right conferred by Parliament on third parties to obtain copies of judgments or orders. It held that failure by the High Court to make the contemplated rules cannot nullify a valuable right conferred by Parliament. The court described the provision as a "benevolent provision" which should be extended to those entitled to its benefits even where the High Court has not acted to complete the regulatory framework.

The court relied on its earlier order in D. Jayakumar (see Table of Precedents) for the proposition that a third party is entitled to certified copies of material documents in a criminal case. It also examined the nature of the documents sought and concluded they are public documents that do not constitute classified information. The State did not claim that disclosure would jeopardise State interests.

The court considered the Right to Information Act, 2005, noting that the Act prohibits disclosure only to the extent that information would impede investigation, apprehension or prosecution; otherwise, furnishing information from court records is not prohibited under the RTI Act. This supported the court's view that disclosure of the requested records did not run afoul of statutory confidentiality prohibitions.

Although section 363(6) Cr.P.C. by its terms refers to copies of judgments or orders, the court reasoned that when a party concerned can invoke Rule 339 of the Criminal Rules of Practice to obtain portions of the criminal record on payment of stamp duty, similar access should be extended to third parties. In other words, the concession afforded to parties under Rule 339 ought to be made available to third parties as well, notwithstanding the narrower wording of section 363(6).

The court further analysed Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 and agreed with the Government Advocate that that provision applies only to documents that have already reached the High Court file. Because the documents in this case were still on the trial court file, Order XII Rule 3 was inapplicable. Likewise, the court agreed that the Madras rules were not framed specifically under section 363(6) Cr.P.C., yet this lack of specific rulemaking did not, in the court's view, justify denying the petitioner's access to the material sought.

Balancing these considerations, and mindful of the public character of the records and the policy reflected in the RTI Act toward sharing information (subject to narrowly confined exceptions), the court concluded that the documents sought by the petitioner should be furnished.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court set aside the order passed in Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007 by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem, and directed issuance of the certified copies requested by the petitioner in Special C.C.No.14 of 2004. In short, the petition was allowed and the petitioner was directed to be supplied with the certified copies sought.

Direct Effect on the Parties: The Chief Judicial Magistrate's dismissal of the petition for certified copies is vacated; the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem, is directed to issue certified copies of all the documents specified in Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007 to the petitioner.

The opinion emphasised that the absence of rules framed by the High Court under section 363(6) Cr.P.C. does not deprive a third party of the right to copies; the court relied upon an earlier High Court order (D. Jayakumar) and construed statutory and policy considerations (including the Right to Information Act, 2005) in favour of disclosure. The opinion did not undertake an extended discussion of broader, systemic implications beyond the resolution of this petition.

    J.M.Arumugham v. State Rep By

    The petition is filed seeking to set aside the order in Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007 on the file of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem declining to grant certified copies of the documents pertaining to the Special C.C.No.14 of 2004 on his file.

    2. A case in Special C.C.No.14 of 2004 was filed against respondents 2 to 8 under section 13(2) read with 13(1)(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and section 109 of the Indian Penal Code read with section 13(2) read with section 13(2)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act for acquisition of properties disproportionate to the known source of their income. Later on, they were discharged from the proceedings in Special C.C.No.14 of 2004 by the common order dated 6.11.2006 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem.

    3. The petitioner, who is the former Public Prosecutor for Salem District and a practising Advocate from the District and Sessions Court, Salem, filed a petition in Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007 before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem seeking certified copy of the First Information Report, Charge Sheet, Docket Sheet endorsement, various petitions, counters and orders passed thereon and the statements recorded under section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for the purpose of preferring revision against the discharge of the accused from the aforesaid case before the High Court.

    4. The learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem, having observed that no substantive reason was assigned for seeking certified copies of these documents, that the petitioner was not an affected person as contemplated under section 363(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Code, that section 363(6) of the of Code of Criminal Procedure can be invoked only before the High Court and that Rule 339 of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates furnishing of the records of the Criminal Case only to the parties concerned and not to third parties, chose to dismiss the petition seeking copies of the aforesaid documents.

    5. The petitioner assails the aforesaid order rejecting his plea seeking certified copy of those documents for the purpose of preferring revision before this court challenging the discharge of respondents 2 to 7 in Special C.C.No.14 of 2004 on the file of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem.

    6. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates supply of copies of any judgment or order of a Criminal Court to any person for that matter on payment of fees as per the rules framed by the High Court. Referring to Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of the High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965, he would further submit that on the request of any party certified copies of judicial records can be granted to persons who are not party to the proceedings. Referring to the judgment pronounced by the Bench of our High Court, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that in a similar case, our High Court has taken a view that even a third party is entitled to copies of the records in the Criminal Court. Therefore, the impugned order passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem is liable to be set aside.

    7. Learned Government Advocate (Criminal Side) would submit that Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates only issuance of grant of copies of the judgment or order of a Criminal Court to a third party in terms of the rules framed by the High Court. No rule invoking the aforesaid law was framed by our High Court. Therefore, the petitioner being a third party is not entitled to copies of any judgment or order of a Criminal Court. Even assuming for the sake of argument that de hors any rule framed by the High Court, the petitioner can invoke Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, he can obtain only a certified copy of judgment or order passed by the Criminal Court and not other records not contemplated therein. He would further contend that Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 does not apply to the records still lying with the Trial Court and not reached the portals of the High Court. Further, the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 was not enacted drawing powers under Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure Code. Therefore, Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 does not apply to the fact situation. It is his vehement submission that if the copies of documents maintained by the Criminal Court is parted with to a third party, there is every chance for misuse of those documents which may land an innocent person into trouble at the hands of unscrupulous elements. There may also be miscarriage of justice if such documents are furnished to a third party who is not entitled to such documents and permit him to use it as a weapon to wreak vengeance against an innocent person. Therefore, he would submit that the petitioner, who is a third party, is not entitled to any of the documents maintained by the Criminal Court.

    8. As rightly pointed out by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem in the impugned order, section 363(5) will not apply to the facts of this case inasmuch as the petitioner who is neither a party to the proceedings nor a close relative to the parties to the proceedings, can be termed as persons "affected by the order". Likewise, Rule 339 of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates issuance of copies of the records of the Criminal Court to the parties concerned on payment of proper stamp duty. The petitioner, who is a third party cannot be considered as a party concerned in the aforesaid proceedings in Special C.C.No.14 of 2004 on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem.

    9. The question is whether the petitioner, being a third party aggrieved by the order of discharge passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate in a sensational case under the Prevention of Corruption Act can seek for certified copies of the material records therein. Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure reads as follows:-

    "The High Court may, by rules, provide for the grant of copies of any judgment or order of a Criminal Court to any person who is not affected by a judgment or order, on payment, by such person, of such fees, and subject to such conditions, as the High Court may, by such rules, provide."

    The Parliament, in its wisdom, has thought it fit to grant copies of any judgment or order of a Criminal Court even to a third party as per the terms and conditions of the rules framed by the respective High Court. Unfortunately, our High Court has not framed any rule right from the year 1973. The question that arises for consideration is whether the right of a third party conferred under Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure to seek certified copies of any judgment or order of Criminal Court can be taken away just because the High Court has not framed necessary rule therein.

    10. In the considered opinion of this court, the failure on the part of High Court in framing rules as indicated by the Parliament cannot take away the valuable right of a third party to obtain a copy of the judgment or order of a Criminal Court. Even when the Parliament has intended something and the High Court has not carried its intention to its logical end, the benevolent provision will have to be necessarily extended to the party entitled to enjoy the right recognised therein. This court has already held in D.JAYAKUMAR v. STATE rep by the Inspector of Police, Vigilance & Anti-Corruption Wing, Dindigul in Crl.O.P.(MD) No.10290 of 2007 by order dated 4.10.2007 that a third party is entitled to certified copies of all the material documents in a criminal case.

    11. There is no doubt that all the documents sought for by the petitioner/third party are only public documents. They do not fall under the classified information category. It is not the case of the first respondent State that supply of copies of the criminal records in C.C.No.14 of 2004 would jeopardise the interest of the State. After all the petitioner wants to challenge the order of discharge passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate as a citizen concerned with the criminal administration in the country. Further, the Right to Information Act, 2005 prohibits divulging of information which would impede the process of investigation or apprehension or prosecution of offenders. In other respects, furnishing of information from the court records are not prohibited under the Right to Information Act, 2005.

    12. It is true that Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure contemplates only copies of judgment or order of a Criminal Court to any third party. When a party concerned can invoke rule 339 of the Criminal Rules of Practice to obtain any portion of the record of a Criminal Case on payment of stamp duty, the court finds that such a concession also will have to be extended notwithstanding the scope of Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure to third parties also.

    13. Admittedly, the documents are still lying on the file of the Trial Court. It has not reached the portals of the High Court. Order XII Rule 3 of the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 will apply only in case where the documents have come to the file of the High Court. Further, as rightly pointed out by the learned Government Advocate (Criminal Side), the rules of the High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 have not been framed by the High Court empowered under Section 363(6) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Therefore, I find without any hesitation that the Rules of High Court Madras Appellate Side, 1965 does not apply to a case where a third party seeks certified copies of the records of the Trial Court which have not come to the High Court in connection with any case pending before this court.

    14. The Right to Information Act, 2005 created a dent in the so-called "privacy" being so far maintained by the authorities concerned. The courts also will have to be alive to the intendment of the Right to Information Act, 2005 to share vital information to the parties concerned. Any narrower interpretation of the law and imposition of any restriction on the right of the third party to know what is actually going on at the portals of the criminal justice system will not advance the interest of justice. For all these reasons, the court finds that the documents sought for by the petitioners in C.C.No.14 of 2004 will have to be granted to him.

    15. In view of the above, setting aside the order passed in Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007 in Special C.C.No.14 of 2004 on the file of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem, he is directed to issue certified copies of all the documents the petitioner has sought for in Crl.M.P.No.1116 of 2007 in Special C.C.No.14 of 2004. The petition stands allowed.

    ssk.

    To

    1. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Salem.

    2. The Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance and Anti-corruption Wing, Salem.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    J.M.Arumugham v. State Rep By
    (Feb 27, 2008)