Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government of Tamil Nadu, at the request of the Tamil Nadu Housing Board, initiated land acquisition proceedings under the Land Acquisition (Central) Act, 1962 for construction of houses under the Ganapathi Neighbourhood Scheme Phase II. Multiple writ petitions (W.P.Nos.12029, 12030 and 12031 of 1996) challenged aspects of those acquisition proceedings. A learned single Judge (C. Nagappan, J.) in W.P.No.12029 of 1996 allowed the writ petition dated 08.08.2003, quashing the acquisition proceedings on the ground that the Section 4(1) and Section 6 notifications were not published in a single English daily. In W.P.Nos.12030 and 12031 of 1996, a different learned single Judge (D. Murugesan, J.) dismissed the writ petitions, rejecting the challenges in those matters.

Aggrieved, the Tamil Nadu Housing Board filed W.A.No.1289 of 2004 against the order dated 08.08.2003. The legal heirs of the original writ petitioner A.P. Damodarasamy filed W.A.Nos.4162 and 4163 of 2004 against the orders dated 17.04.2004 dismissing W.P.Nos.12030 and 12031 of 1996. Following the death of A.P. Damodarasamy, his legal heirs (Andal Ammal and D. Jayachandran) sought and obtained impleadment as parties by WAMP.No.67 of 2007. The appellants in W.A.Nos.4162 and 4163 of 2004 were permitted to raise additional grounds by WAMP.Nos.68 and 69 of 2007 (order dated 29.03.2007).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether actions taken in the acquisition proceedings were void for want of statutory authorisation where the notification under Section 4(1) of the Act authorised Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit III to perform functions under Section 3(c), but the enquiry and subsequent proceedings under Section 5-A and award proceedings were conducted by Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II.
  2. Whether the declaration under Section 6 of the Act was invalid because the Government did not consider the Collector's report and instead relied on a report of the Special Commissioner (as contended by the land owners).
  3. Whether the awards were invalid on the ground that they were not duly approved by the Government or an authorised authority.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants / Land Owners (represented by Mr. R. Muthukumarasamy, Senior Counsel)

  • The Section 4(1) notification authorised Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit III to perform functions under Section 3(c); but the notice and proceedings under Sections 5-A and 5-A(2) show the proceedings were conducted by Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II. In the absence of amendment to the notification, Unit II lacked jurisdiction and the proceedings are liable to be quashed.
  • The Government did not consider the Collector's report and instead relied on a report of the Special Commissioner; therefore the declaration under Section 6 is not valid.
  • The awards were not duly approved by the Government or an authorised authority; hence the awards and acquisition proceedings are liable to be interfered with.

Respondents / State and Housing Board (represented by Mr. P.S. Raman, Additional Advocate General-I, and Mr. K. Elango, Special Government Pleader)

  • Conceded that the notification specifically authorised Unit III while Unit II conducted the proceedings and that Unit II had no statutory authorisation on the record.
  • Contended that Units I, II and III had been merged and that Unit II performed the functions after merger; however, no documentary evidence (errata, amendment to Section 4(1) notification, or an order) was produced to show formal authorisation of Unit II to act under Section 3(c).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
1992 (2) Law Weekly 275 (A. Vijayarangam & another vs. State of Tamil Nadu) Holds that Section 3(c) defines "Collector" to include an officer specifically appointed by the appropriate Government; only an officer specially appointed by the appropriate Government can conduct enquiry under Section 5-A; any enquiry by an officer without such authorisation is without jurisdiction and void. The court followed this authority to conclude that an officer not duly authorised by notification or order cannot perform the statutory functions under Section 3(c) and that enquiries and subsequent proceedings conducted by such an officer are void. This principle was applied to quash the acquisition proceedings conducted by Unit II when the notification authorised Unit III.
Unreported judgment of a learned single Judge in W.P.Nos.10268, 10269 and 13956 of 1996 dated 16.04.2004 Followed the principle that an officer authorised in the notification alone may perform the functions; where Unit III was authorised but Unit II conducted the enquiry, acquisition proceedings were quashed. The court relied on this similar, later judgment (which followed the 1992 decision) as further support for the view that proceedings conducted by an officer other than the one authorised by the notification are liable to be quashed; the instant court applied the same reasoning to the present matters.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded principally on the statutory-authorisation point:

  1. The court observed that authorisation to perform the Collector's functions under Section 3(c) is a statutory matter effected by notification or order of the appropriate Government (i.e., the Section 4(1) notification). Such authorisation is pre‑requisite to an officer's jurisdiction to conduct enquiries under Section 5-A and to exercise the statutory functions.
  2. The court examined the record and found that the Section 4(1) notification authorised Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit III to perform functions under Section 3(c), whereas the notice under Section 5-A and the proceedings under Section 5-A(2) showed that Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II alone had conducted those proceedings.
  3. Relying on the precedent in 1992 (2) Law Weekly 275 and a later single-Judge decision, the court treated the absence of any amendment, errata or formal order authorising Unit II as determinative: an officer without such statutory authorisation lacks jurisdiction, and actions taken by that officer are void (non est in the eye of law).
  4. The court held that the enquiry under Section 5-A and the subsequent award proceedings were conducted by an officer who was not duly authorised; therefore those proceedings and the awards were liable to be quashed for want of jurisdiction.
  5. The court noted the submission by the Additional Advocate General that the units had been merged and that rectification might be possible by retaining the notification and permitting the Government to rectify the mistake. However, the court recorded that as on the date of hearing there was insufficient time (only one or two days) available for the Government to complete the acquisition proceedings under the statutory time-limits prescribed by the Act, so rectification could not realistically be accomplished within the permissible period.
  6. Given the foregoing and because the primary contention (lack of statutory authorisation) was dispositive, the court declined to consider the other contentions (relating to the Collector's report and award approval) and quashed the entire acquisition proceedings including the Section 4(1) notification in all three cases.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court quashed the entire acquisition proceedings (including the Section 4(1) notification) in all three matters. Consequential orders were:

  • Writ Appeal No.1289 of 2004 (filed by the Tamil Nadu Housing Board) is dismissed.
  • W.A.Nos.4162 and 4163 of 2004 (filed by the land owners / legal heirs of A.P. Damodarasamy) are allowed.
  • No costs were imposed.

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the acquisition proceedings and awards in these matters are set aside for lack of jurisdiction because the officer who conducted the enquiry and proceedings (Special Tahsildar, Unit II) was not the officer authorised by the Section 4(1) notification (Unit III). The court expressly stated that if the Government so desires, it remains free to initiate acquisition proceedings afresh and to proceed in accordance with law. The opinion does not pronounce the creation of any new binding principle beyond application of existing precedents addressing statutory authorisation under the Land Acquisition Act.

Sources: This summary is confined to and derived exclusively from the content of the provided opinion text.

    Tamil Nadu Housing Board v. A.P. Damodrasamy (Died)

    order of Court dt.29.03.2007 made in WAMP.No.67/07.) ..Respondents in WA.1289/04

    1.Andal Ammal

    2.Jayachandran ..Appellants in WA.4162 & 4163 of 2004 Vs

    1. The State of Tamil Nadu rep. By its Secretary Housing and Urban Development Department Fort St. George Madras.

    2. The Special Tahsildar Housing Board Scheme No.2 Office of the Collector Coimbatore.

    Writ Appeals filed under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the order of His Lordship Mr. Justice C. Nagappan and D. Murugesan made in W.P.No.12029 of 1996, 12030 and 12031 of 1996 dated 08.08.2003 and 17.04.2004 respectively.

    Aggrieved by the order of the learned single Judge dated 08.08.2003 made in W.P.No.12029 of 1996, allowing the writ petition and quashing the acquisition proceedings, the Tamil Nadu Housing Board has filed W.A.No.1289 of 2004.

    2. Challenging the order dated 17.04.2004 made in W.P.Nos.12030 and 12031 of 1996, dismissing the said writ petitions, the legal heirs of original writ petitioner, A.P. Damodarasamy have filed W.A.Nos.4162 and 4163 of 2004.

    3. In view of death of the original writ petitioner, viz., A.P. Damodarasamy, his legal heirs, viz., wife Andal Ammal and son D. Jayachandran, filed WAMP.No.67 of 2007 to implead them as respondents 4 and 5 in W.A.No.1289 of 2004. In view of the reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of the above petition, we ordered the said petition.

    4. In W.A.Nos.4162 and 4163 of 2004, the appellants have filed WAMP.Nos.68 and 69 of 2007, seeking permission to raise additional grounds in the appeals. By order dated 29.03.2007, we allowed both the said applications.

    5. At the request of the Tamil Nadu Housing Board, Government of Tamil Nadu initiated acquisition proceedings under the Land Acquisition (Central) Act, 1962, for construction of houses under Ganapathi Neighbourhood Scheme Phase II. As stated earlier, in WP.No.12029 of 1996, the learned single Judge (C. Nagappan,J.), quashed the acquisition proceedings on the ground that publication of Notification under Sections 4 (1) and 6 of the Act was not published in one English daily. In the other two writ petitions filed by Late Damodarasamy, the learned single Judge (D. Murugesan,J.), rejecting all the contentions, refused to interfere with the acquisition proceedings and dismissed both the said writ petitions.

    6. We heard Mr. R. Muthukumarasamy, learned senior counsel for the land owners, Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Additional Advocate General-I for the Tamil Nadu Housing Board and Mr. K. Elango, Special Government Pleader for the State.

    7. Mr. R. Muthukumarasamy, learned senior counsel appearing for the land owners has raised the following contentions:

    (i)The notification issued under Section 4(1) of the Act by the Government of Tamil Nadu, authorised the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit III to perform the functions under Section 3 ( c ) of the Act, but the notice and proceedings under Sections 5-A and 5-A(2) of the Act show that the same had been conducted by the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition) Housing Scheme Unit II. In the absence of amendment to the notification, the action taken by the Special Tahsildar, (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II cannot be sustained; as such the entire acquisition proceedings are liable to be quashed;

    (ii)The Government has not considered the report of the Collector, instead declaration was passed on the basis of the report of the Special Commissioner, who has no role in the present acquisition proceedings; hence, the declaration made under Section 6 of the Act is not a valid one and on this ground the acquisition proceedings are liable to be interfered; and

    (iii)The award passed in all these cases were not duly approved by the Government or the authority authorised; hence, on this ground also the acquisition proceedings are liable to be interfered.

    8. With regard to first contention, it is brought to our notice that in the notification issued under Section 4(1) of the Act, the Government of Tamil Nadu, authorised the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit III to perform the functions under Section 3(c) of the Act. A perusal of the notice issued under Section 5-A as well as the proceedings under section 5-a (2) show that the entire proceedings under Section 5-A of the Act had been conducted only by the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II. As rightly pointed out by Mr. R. Muthukumarasamy, learned senior counsel for the land owners, the authorisation given by the State Government for issuing notification under Section 4(1) of the Act is a statutory one. Unless and until the amendment to the notification is issued by the Government, authorising the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition) Housing Scheme Unit II, to perform the functions under Section 3( c ) of the Act, he has no jurisdiction to exercise the statutory functions. In those circumstances, as rightly pointed out, the proceedings initiated by him under Section 5-A of the Act is void, as the same is done without jurisdiction. Similarly, the award proceedings had also been conducted by the very same Officer without any statutory authorisation, as such the awards are also liable to be quashed.

    9. Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Additional Advocate General-I, submitted that, it is true that as per the notification, it was Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit III was authorised to perform the functions of Collector under Section 3 ( c ) and the entire proceedings under Section 5-A and thereafter, it was conducted by the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II. Admittedly, the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II had no such statutory authorisation. However, the learned Additional Advocate General submitted that Unit I, II, and III were merged and only the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition) Housing Scheme Unit II performed the functions under the Act. But, there is no evidence by way of errata or amendment to 4(1) notification or an order empowering the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II to perform the functions under Section 3( c )of the Act.

    10. In this regard, Mr. R. Muthukumarasamy, learned senior counsel for the land owners has pressed into two decisions of this Court;

    (i)1992 (2) Law Weekly 275 (A. Vijayarangam & another vs. State of Tamil Nadu); and

    (ii)An unreported judgment of the learned single Judge rendered in W.P.Nos.10268, 10269 and 13956 of 1996 dated 16.04.2004.

    11. In the first case, K.S. Bakthavatsalam,J. has observed that Section 3(c) of the Act defines the "Collector" including the Deputy Collector and officer specifically appointed by appropriate Government to perform the functions of Collector under the act. relying on sections 4, 5-a has concluded that, an officer specially appointed by the appropriate Government under the Land Acquisition Act alone can conduct enquiry under Section 5-A of the Act and any enquiry conducted by any other officer will be without jurisdiction, illegal and the same will be non-est in the eye of law. In the case before him, in the notification issued under Section 4(1) of the Act, the Special Tahsildar (ADW) Gudiyatham alone was specially appointed to conduct the enquiry under Section 5-A of the Act. No other notification was brought to the notice of the learned Judge authorising the Special Tahsildar (ADW), Tirupatthur to perform the functions of a Collector and to conduct the enquiry under Section 5-A of the Act. After finding that in the absence of proper authorisation by the appropriate Government, the learned Judge quashed the proceedings of the Special Tahsildar (ADW) Gudiyatam and allowed the writ petition. In the later decision, Prabha Sridevan,J. following the decision of K.S. Bakthavatsalam,J. in 1992 (2) Law Weekly 275 (cited supra), after finding that the officer authorised to perform the functions was Special Tahsildar Unit III, Coimbatore, but the records show that the enquiry was conducted by the Special Tahsildar, Unit II, quashed the acquisition proceedings.

    12. As discussed earlier, the authorised person is to perform functions under Section 3 ( c ) of the Act, the same being a statutory one, we hold that unless the officer is duly authorised by way of notification or order by the Government, he cannot perform the functions as provided in the Act. In the cases on hand, admittedly, the Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition), Housing Scheme Unit II, who performed the functions under Section 3 (c) and the proceedings issued under Section 5-A, was not duly authorised by way of notification or order by the Government; hence, the action taken by him in all the subsequent proceedings are liable to be quashed.

    13. As rightly pointed out by the learned Additional Advocate General, even if we accept the above argument, there would not be any impediment in retaining the very same notification and permitting the Government to proceed further by rectifying the mistake. However, even according to him, as on date (i.e., on the date of hearing), only two days/one day available for the Government for completion of the entire acquisition proceedings as per the provisions of the Act. In such circumstances, even if this Court permits, the same cannot be completed. Accordingly, we have no other option except to quash the entire acquisition proceedings, including 4(1) notification in all the three cases.

    14. In view of our conclusion in respect of the first contention raised by the learned senior counsel for the land owners, we are of the view that there is no need to consider the other two contentions.

    In these circumstances, the entire acquisition proceedings are quashed. Consequently, the Writ Appeal No.1289 of 2004 filed by the Housing Board is dismissed; W.A.Nos.4162 and 4163 of 2004 filed by the land owners are allowed. No costs. It is made clear that, if the Government so desires, they are free to proceed afresh in accordance with law.

    kh To

    1. The Chairman Tamil Nadu Housing Board Anna Salai Madras 35.

    2. The Secretary State of Tamil Nadu Housing and Urban Development Department Fort St. George Madras.

    3. The Special Tahsildar Housing Board Scheme No.2 Office of the Collector Coimbatore.

    [PRV/10122]

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tamil Nadu Housing Board v. A.P. Damodrasamy (Died)
    (Apr 4, 2007)