The learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the petitioners have come forward with this petition
seeking the relief of quashing the proceedings initiated
against them for the alleged offences under Sections 323,
406 and 498-A I.P.C. r/w 34 I.P.C. and Section 4 of Dowry
Prohibition Act.
2. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that even on an earlier occasion the petitioners moved a
petition for quashing the proceedings at the stage of
F.I.R. This Court dismissed such petition in
Crl.O.P.No.18381 of 2005 by the order dated 18.08.2005
holding that it is for the petitioners to raise all the
points at the time of trial and the points are to be
considered and decided only after recording evidence.
The learned counsel now submitted that so far, five
witnesses have been examined in this case and four more
witnesses yet to be examined. It is contended by the
learned counsel for the petitioners that even as per the
evidence of five witnesses recorded, there is absolutely
no implication of these petitioners in their depositions.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
proceedings initiated by the de-facto complainant pending
against the petitioners is liable to be quashed.
3. Per contra, the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor submitted that so far, the prosecution
examined five witnesses and the witnesses implicated the
petitioners herein and the prosecution is going to
examine four more witnesses to substantiate its case. It
is submitted by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
that having faced the trial and having cross-examined
witnesses, it is not open to the petitioner to seek the
relief of quashing the proceedings at this stage.
4. I have carefully considered the rival
contentions put forward by either side and also perused
the materials available on record.
5. It is fairly submitted by the learned counsel
for the petitioner that even on earlier an occasion when
the petitioners moved a petition for quashing the
proceedings at the F.I.R. stage, this Court clearly
observed while dismissing their petition that, the points
raised by the petitioners were to be considered only
after recording the evidence at the appropriate time by
the Trial Court. Now, it is not disputed by both sides
that the prosecution examined so far five witnesses and
the points pointed out by the learned counsel for the
petitioners are relating to the appreciation of evidence
and as such those points cannot be considered at this
stage for quashing the proceedings.
6. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held in
AMAR CHAND V. SHANTI BOSE reported in AIR 1973 SC 799
that,
Where the accused moved the High Court at
the time when the trial was almost coming
to a close and what remained to be done was
the examination of two prosecution and one
Court witnesses and the High Court quashed
the charge and the entire proceedings on
the grounds that the complainant suppressed
material facts and that the evidence on
record did not establish the alleged
offence, the order was liable to be set
aside. The proper course at that stage to
be adopted by the High Court was to allow
the proceedings to go on and to come to its
logical conclusion, one way or the other,
and decline to interfere with those
proceedings. The questions whether there
was suppression and whether the evidence
established the alleged offence were
matters to be considered by the trial Court
after an appraisal of the entire evidence.
7. It is also held by the Apex Court in yet
another decision in STATE OF DELHI V. GYAN DEVI reported
in 2000 SCC (Cri.) 1486 that,
.... The High Court has erred in its
approach to the case as if it was evaluating
the medical evidence for the purpose of
determining the question whether the charge
under Sections 304/34 IPC framed against the
accused-Respondents 1 and 2 was likely to
succeed or not. This question was to be
considered by the trial Judge after recording
the entire evidence in the case. It was not
for the High Court to pre-judge the case at
the stage when only a few witnesses (doctors)
had been examined by the prosecution and that
too under the direction of the High Court in
the revision petition filed by the accused.
The High Court has not observed that the
prosecution had closed the evidence from its
side. There is also no discussion or
observation in the impugned order that the
facts and circumstances of the case make it
an exceptional case in which immediate
interference of the High Court by invoking
its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482
CrPC is warranted in the interest of justice.
On consideration of the matter we have no
hesitation to hold that the order under
challenge is vitiated on account of erroneous
approach of the High Court and it is clearly
unsustainable.
8. Therefore, in view of the settled principle of
law laid down by the Apex Court, as per the decisions
cited supra, this court cannot exercise the power under
Section 482 of Cr.P.C. to quash the proceedings at this
stage, viz., after the examination of five witnesses and
further all the points raised by the learned counsel for
the petitioners has to be raised only after the
conclusion of the trial before the learned Trial Judge.
It is open to the petitioners to raise all the points at
that time.
9. With these observation, this petition is
dismissed. However, the learned Trial Judge is directed
to expedite the trial as expeditiously as possible and
more particularly before 12.04.2007.
19.02.2007
gg
Index : Yes/No
Internet:Yes/No
To
1. The Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
Egmore, Chennai - 8
2. The Inspector General of Police
W-5, All Women Police Station,
Chennai. - 600 040.
3. The Public Prosecutor,
Madras High Court,
Madras.