The appellants/Accused stand convicted in the following manner:
Crl. A.No.
Accused
Conviction
Sentence
233/1997
A-6, A-9 and A-14
1.Section 5 of Explosives Substances Act, 1908 r/w 120-B IPC.
2.Section 3 r/w Section 25(1-B)(a) of Indian Arms Act
1.Two years rigorous imprisonment for each of the accused for the offence
mentioned in (1).
2.One year rigorous imprisonment for each of the accused and to pay a fine of
Rs.500/- each and in default to undergo one month simple imprisonment for the
offence mentioned in (2).
234/1997
A-10
Section 3 r/w Section 25(1)(A)(a) of Indian Arms Act
One year rigorous imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs.500/-.
268/1997 and 336/1997
A-1 and A-3
1.Sections 3,4&6 of Explosives Substance Act, 1908 r/w 120-B IPC.
2.Section 3 r/w Section 25(1-B)(a) of Indian Arms Act.
3.Section 4 of PPD Act and Section 427 IPC
Life Imprisonment for the offence under Section 3 of Explosives Substance Act
r/w 120-B IPC for each of the accused,
Since he has been awarded a maximum punishment of life imprisonment no separate
sentence for other offences.
284/1997
A-4
Section 3 of Explosives Substance Act, 1908 r/w 120(B) IPC
Life Imprisonment
402/1997
A-2
Sections 3 and 4 of Explosives Substance Act, 1908 r/w 120-B IPC
Life imprisonment
Against the said conviction and sentence, the appellants have preferred the
above appeals.
2.The brief facts of the prosecution are that during the month of March
1988, at door No.4, Walajah Raod, Chennai, all the accused criminally conspired
and in order to have separate Tamil Nadu, involved in unlawful activities along
with Tamil Nadu Viduthalai Padai, collected guns, cartridges and gun powders and
having ill-will against the Government and in order to embarrass the Government,
they decided to demolish Nehru Statue in Kathippara at Guindy and explode T.V.
Station at Kodaikanal by pasting posters, distributing pamphlets. In order to
complete the task, after describing about the criminal conspiracy to one Vadivel
@ Vadivel Ravanan @ Thennavanko [P.W.3] and Shamugavadivelu @ Suresh [P.W.4],
the accused persons during the months of March and April, 1988 had their
conspiracy discussions at chennai, Trichy, Kanchipuram and Kodaikanal. Both
P.Ws.3 and 4 helped the accused financially in order to make the task
successful.
(b)On 04.04.1988, in the residence of A-6 situate at door No.NHC-364,
Tamilnadu Housing Board, Anna Nagar, Navalpattu, Trichy, they prepared
explosives and Pozhilan [A-1], Ilango [A-2] and P.W.3 supported financially to
one Maran [since deceased] who involved in buying gun powders. On 14.04.1988,
at 7.45 p.m., Maran [since deceased] and A-2 made a bomb to explode at TV
Station at Kodaikanal and left the other bomb and pamphlets there and caused
damage to the TV Station to the tune of Rs.2,745/-. In order to successfully
complete the criminal conspiracy of causing damage to the public properties, A-1
financially supported A-2 and A-3. For that purpose, 25 Gelatin sticks, 4
detonators were purchased from Prabhakar on 07.04.1988 and at Rayapuram,
Chennai, they prepared explosive bombs and taking pamphlets [containing words
that will create difference among the united public] along with the bombs, on
10.04.1988, at 3.00 a.m., kept the bomb at the back side of the Nehru Statue at
Kathipara, Guindy and made it exploded, thus causing a damage to the tune of
Rs.3,806/-.
(c)On 05.04.1988, Maran [since deceased] gave to A-6 the following items
which were under the unlawful custody of A-6:
1.Carbon Machine 9 mm.-13810
2.Stengun rifle and 20 new cartridges
3.22-line cartridge-26 nos.
4.Black coloured Fuse Wire-6cm in length
5.Blackish blue coloured Fuse Wire-38cm in length
6.2 Sun brand Gelatin sticks
7.6-ordinary detonators
8.6-Electric Detonators
(d)A-14[Gunasekaran], A-10[Kundalakesi],A-9-Deivamani,A-11-Tamizhiniyan,
A-12[Bavanandi], and A-13[Suresh] were having the following items
unlawfully during the period of occurrence:
A-14 [Gunasekaran}:
1.0.38 brand cartridge-107 nos.
2.0.45 brand cartridge-33 nos.
3.0.555 brand cartridge-60 nos.
4.7.65 mm. Cartridge-14 nos.
5.Lapua-38 and Lapua-38 [special]-28 nos.
6.0.45 cartridge-48 nos. [short]
7.0.65 cartridge-14 nos. [length]
8.0.55 mm. Cartridge-57 nos.
9.0.7 rifle cartridge-29 nos.
10.0.10 cartridge-1 no.
11.1 1/2feet length Gun powder fuse wire.
A-10[Kundalakesi]:
1.Mark 23 type cartridge-135 nos.
2.Mark 10 type cartridge-214 nos.
3.0.32 Pistol cartridge-38 nos.
4.0.22 type new cartridge-84 nos.
5.0.380 special pistol cartridge-40 nos.
6.Super Special Cartridge-1
A-9-Deivamani:
[1]Country gun-1 no.
(2)SW-0.38 special round cartridge-2 and
(3)Lapua 0.38 special round cartridge-2
at door no.A/169,D.L.P.Colony, Block No.20, Vannarapettai, Chennai.
A-11-Tamizhiniyan:
[1]E.L.G.Pistol-1
[2] o.38 new cartridge-10 nos.
[3] 0.9mm new cartridge-1 and
[4]0.380 new cartridge-1
A-12 [Bavanandhi]:
[1]Gelatin sticks-4
[2]Electric Detonator-1
at Door No.17, Murugammal Street, Sengalvarayan Avenue, Kancheepuram.
A-13 [Suresh]:
[1]Electric Detonator-3
[2]Gelatin Sticks-6
3.The evidence let in by the prosecution i brief is as follows:
(a)P.W.1-Kannan, was working as Assistant Engineer at Kodaikanal TV
Station during the relevant period of time. On 11.04.1988, when he along with
one Premasankaran (S.E.A), Ravichandran, Selvaraj [Technician], Kanaiyah
[helper], Ganapathy [Van driver], Arulappan [Security Guard] and Raju were on
duty, at 7.45 p.m., they heard a bomb blast. When they came out, they saw smoke
coming from the North West side of the compound wall and the Glass windows in
the main Verandah were broken and the compound wall in the North western side
was broken to the extent of one metre. They informed the Station Master and the
police. When police came, they saw a dead body near the blasted area. On the
next day, when the police conducted inquest, they found that the dead body was
one Maran and the person who ran away during the blast with injuries was one
Ilango. The complaint given by P.W.1 to the police is Ex.P.1.
(b)P.W.2-Veerabadran is a resident of Chrompet, Chennai and he is working
as an Electrician in Public Works Department. At the time of occurrence, he was
working in the Maintenance Department of T.B.Hospital at Sanitorium and in-
charge of maintenance of the Nehru Statue. On 09.04.1988 at 8.00 p.m., the
light settings on all the four sides of the Nehru Statue and the light setting
in the stage were under the control of P.W.2. His duty time was between 5.00
p.m. and 6.00 a.m. One Vasu, gardener, was along with him that night. After
taking dinner and switching off the important lights at 8.30 p.m., he started
sleeping. The said Vasu was sleeping in the Eastern side of the statue. On
10.04.1988 at 4.30 a.m., they heard a blast sound. On hearing, they became
unconscious for five minutes. After getting conscious, when P.W.2 inspected the
statue, he saw the right side of the statue broken. He also saw some jute rope,
blue coloured cloth and some gunpowder. Four electric bulbs and main switch
were broken. He also saw the stone on the right side of the statue had moved a
little. P.W.2 went to St.Thomas Mount Police Station and lodged a complaint to
P.W.58, the Inspector of Police and Ex.P.2 is the said complaint.
(c)P.W.3-Vadivel Ravanan and P.W.4-Shanmugavadivel, who were the
participants in crime have turned as the prosecution witnesses. A-1 [Pozhilan]
and A-7 [Ilamurugan @ Balasubramanian] were the friends of P.W.3 between 1976
and 1979. A-4 [Thiruvalluvar @ Arivazhagan] and A-10 [Kundalakesi] were the
college friends of P.W.4. A-14 [Gunasekaran] became the friend of P.W.4 during
the processions and agitation conducted in order to support the Srilankan
Tamilians. During the first week of April 1988, A-3 [Mugilan} became the friend
of P.W.4. During 1981, P.W.3 while working as News Reader in All India Radio
and being an patriot of Tamil language, he attended the meeting "Ulaga Tamizhina
Munnetra Maanadu" as a spectator conducted by one Perunchithiranaar at Periyar
Thidal, Chennai and later he was appointed as District Secretary of Ulaga
Thamizhina Munnetra Kazhagam, Tirunelveli District. During the month of May,
1984, in the camp held at Nilakottai, A-1 and A-6 became the friends of P.W.4.
(d)During February 1987, due to difference of opinion with his father
Perunchithiranaar, A-7 [Ilamurugan], joined with P.W.3 who financially helped
him to start a printing press at Trichy and stayed at P.W.10's house as a
tenant. A-2 [Ilango] and A-15 [Sivadass] were introduced to P.W.3 at that time.
On 20.12.1987 a Meeting was convened at Periyar Thidal, Chennai, where A-16
[Kaliyaperumal] and A-5 [Veeramani] were introduced to P.W.3. On 20.12.1987 A-1
[Pozhilan] criminally conspired to blast the Nehru Statue at Kathipara, Chennai
and asked P.W.3 to support that plan. On 30.03.1988, when P.W.3 was on duty at
Trichy Radio Station, A-1, A-6, Maran, A-7, A-16 and A-5 jointly planned to
explode Nehru Statue and Kodaikanal TV Station by keeping Bombs and for that
purpose it was decided that P.W.3 should help them by providing money. On
04.04.1988 at 8.00 a.m., Maran went to P.W.3's residence and gave some books and
received Rs.200/- from P.W.3 and informed him that he gave Stengun and gun
powder to A-6.
(e)A-1 introduced A-3 to P.W.4 who is a patriot of Tamil language during
the month of April 1988 and told that A-4 and P.W.4's help for exploding the
Nehru statue may be sought for. On 07.04.1988, at a residence at Kasimedu,
Chennai, A-9, A-1 and Maran met and A-3 brought Gelatin sticks out of which A-1
and A-3 prepared bombs. Later, in order to protest against Hindi speaking
people, Maran took M.Os.4 and 5-pamphlets containing words against Hindi
speaking people. On 09.04.1988, as per the plan, A-1, A-3,A-4, P.W.4 and Maran
met in a Lodge and slept there. On 10.4.1988, at about 2.30 a.m., P.W.4 went in
a motor cycle belonging to A-1 and others went in cycles to the scene of
occurrence [Nehru statue] and A-3 kept the time bomb in such a way that it gets
exploded in half an hour. After keeping the bomb, he kept two pamphlets in a
grassy place leading to Ekkatuthangal road. When they were returning near Kasi
theatre, after hearing the blast sound, all the five assembled at P.W.4's lodge
and A-1 informed Maran to go to Trichy and execute the other plan successfully.
A-1 and P.W.4 went to Velachery and gave the motor cycle to A-1's friend from
whom A-1 had borrowed the vehicle. Later, P.W.4 took his cycle and went away.
P.W.3, on 11.04.1988, came to know after reading the newspaper about the
explosion at Nehru statue. After a week, he came to P.W.4's college and
informed him that police are in search of A-14 and that he should go to some
other place.
(f)P.W.2 after witnessing the occurrence as narrated above, on 10.04.1988
at 4.50 a.m., went to St.Thomas Mount Police Station and lodged a complaint,
Ex.P.2 to the Inspector of Police based on which a case came to be registered
in Crime No.250 of 1988 under sections 5(3) of the Explosives Substance Act,
1908 and 427 IPC and Ex.P.71-printed First Information Report was sent to the
Court concerned and to the higher officials. At 5.30 a.m., he went to the scene
of occurrence, in the presence of P.W.33-Rajendran, Village Administrative
Officer and one Santhanakrishnan, he prepared Observation Mahazar-Ex.P.25 and
Ex.P.-72-rough sketch. He also recovered, M.O.1 series-five broken stone
pieces, M.O.37 series-broken glass pieces of electric lights, M.O.2 series-four
twine pieces, M.O.3 series-blue coloured cloth piece, M.O.32-torn newspaper
pieces, M.O.36-match box, M.O.33 series-metal pieces of melted battery, M.O.90-
four inch rod, M.O.91-one inch rod, M.O.34-thread bundle, M.O.35-five inch
rubber piece, M.O.38-burnt metal plates and M.O.39 series-three electric wires,
under the cover of Mahazar Ex.P.26.
(g)P.W.1 working as an Assistant Engineer at Kodaikanal after witnessing
the damages to the TV Station, informed over telephone on 11.04.1988 at 8.00
p.m., the Inspector of Police of Kodaikanal Police Station and on receiving
complaint from P.W.1, Ex.P.1, he registered a case in Crime No.70 of 1988 under
section 286, 427 IPC and section 9(b) of Explosives Substance Act, 1908 and
Section 2 of PPD Act Ex.P.74-printed First Information Report was sent to the
Court concerned and to the higher officials. P.W.61 went to the scene of
occurrence at 9.15 a.m. and arranged for security to that place.
(h)P.W.29, Dr.Mary Karkada, the doctor attached to Van Alan Hospital, when
she was in her house, at 7.45 p.m., on hearing the blast sound coming from TV
Station, came out. At that time, her neighbour one Rajanvarma told her that
somebody has fallen down and she went and saw A-2 lying with injuries all over
the body. She took him to the hospital and treated him. A-2 had informed her
that when he went to keep bomb in the TV Station, the person who accompanied him
had died due to the blast and he had escaped with injuries and that he belongs
to Viduthalai Padai Iyakkam. He also deposed to P.W.29 that one Tamizharasan is
the leader of the said Iyakkam and that it was they who had exploded the Nehru
statue at Chennai. P.W.29 informed the Kodaikanal Police Station at about 10.00
p.m. P.W.61, the Investigating Officer, on information, went to the hospital at
11.30 p.m., and arrested A-2. He sent A-2 to Kodaikanal Government Hospital
along with a memo for further treatment at 00.45 hours. At 1.00 a.m., near
the house of Rajanvarma, in the presence of P.W.34-Revenue Inspector Mothilal
and one Barathan-Village Administrative Officer, he recovered M.O.42-Burnt
shirt, M.O.43-blood stained shirt, M.O.44-blood stained banian, M.O.45-brief
under the cover of Mahazar Ex.P.28.
(i)P.W.61, the Investigating Officer, at 7.30 a.m., on 12.04.1988, in the
presence of the same witnesses, at the scene of occurrence prepared Ex.P.29-the
Observation Mahazar and Ex.P.75-the rough sketch. He also recovered in the
presence of the same witnesses at 9.00 a.m., M.O.24-Polyester shirt, M.O.98-
burnt portion of a cloth bag, M.O.49-a twenty rupees note, M.O.51-a two rupees
note, M.O.50-a five rupees note and he recovered from the place where the dead
body was lying, M.O.99-a portion blood stained pant, M.O.47 series-a pair of
chappals, M.O.100-bag which was hanging on the compound wall, M.O.48-burnt
lungi, M.O.53-damaged cement piece, M.Os.4 and 5-two posters respectively under
the cover of Mahazar Ex.P.76. He also held inquest upon the body of the
deceased between 10.00 a.m. and 1.00 p.m., in the presence of witnesses and
panchayatdars through Ex.P.77-the Inquest Report. He sent the dead body for
postmortem through the constable.
(j)P.W.49, the doctor attached to Kodaikanal Government Hospital during
the relevant period, examined A-2 on 11.04.1988 who came with a medical memo and
treated him. Ex.P.47-is the Accident Register wherein he had found the
following injuries:
"1.Blast injuries over the right temporal area.
2.Blast stained seen right ear (clotted).
3.Abrasion on right temporal area.
4.Contusion over both upper arm.
5.Contusion over the hip.
6.Blast (multiple) injuries over the back."
The doctor had opined that the injuries are grievous as per the
Radiologist report (Ulnar nerve Paralysis (Right)) and the same is also
grievous. He also sent the patient to Madurai Rajaji Government Hospital for
further treatment. P.W.49, on the same day at 1.30 p.m., conducted autopsy on
the dead body of Maran and Ex.P.49-the Postmortem Certificate wherein he found
the following external injuries:
"EXTERNAL INJURIES:
Head is not found above the lower jaw some part of tongue and 3 teeth are
present and on the back the portion of occipital bone is present. Blast deep
injury is seen on the throat above the supra sternal notch. A big bomb blast
collapsed injury over the left whole part of the chest. Crushed injuries seen
on the left inguina area. Scrotum is not found except a piece of skin of
scrotum. A blast deep crushed injury on the left thigh. A blast injury on
right upper arm below the elbow taken away the rest of arm. A cut deep blast
collapsed injury below the knee taken the rest part. No external injuries on
the abdomen."
The doctor had opined that the deceased would appear to have died of
extensive multiple blast injuries to the vital organs and head injuries, vessels
crushed and haemorrhages due to explosives. He also opined that injury No.1,2
and 6 are possible due to bomb blast."
(k)P.W.61, the Investigating Officer continued the investigation and
recovered M.O.52-bag, M.O.54-the urea bag collected from inside M.O.52, M.Os.55
and 56- two tins containing gelatin detonators, M.O.101 series-white cloth used
to cover M.Os.55 and 56, M.O.57-a plastic box containing battery cell, M.O.102-
broken alarm time piece, M.O.58-a three pin plug, M.O.10-box, M.O.59-torch,
M.O.60-blood stained earth and M.O.61-sample earth, under the cover of Mahazar
Ex.P.30. He also recovered M.O.62 series-broken glass pieces from the Assistant
Engineer Room of the TV Station under a cover of Mahazar Ex.P.31. He placed the
records before P.W.68, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, CBCID, Madurai for
further investigation.
(l)In the mean time, P.W.66-the Deputy Superintendent of Police, CBCID,
Chengalpattu, on getting oral instructions from Deputy Inspector General, took
up the investigation in Crime No.250 of 1988. On 15.04.1988, he recorded the
statements of P.Ws.45 and 40. On 26.05.1988 and 01.06.1988, he received the
statements given by A-6 and P.W.3 before the Court concerned. P.W.42, learned
Judicial Magistrate No.1, Madurai, on 12.04.1988 at 10.15 a.m., went to Madurai
Rajaji Government Hospital to record the dying declaration-Ex.P38 of A-2
[Ilango] on receiving Ex.P.37-requisition. P.W.41, the learned Judicial
Magistrate No.2, on getting instructions from the learned Principal District
Judge, on 31.05.1988 at 4.30 p.m., recorded the statement of P.W.3 under
Ex.P.35. P.W.44, the learned Principal District Judge sent summons to P.W.3 who
appeared before him and accepted the confession given before the learned
Judicial Magistrate NO.2, Nilakottai and P.W.44 issued orders stating to treat
the said Vadivel Ravanan as prosecution witness.
(m)P.W.66, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, On 26.05.1988, at 3.15
p.m., sent P.W.59, the Inspector of Police to Esplanade Police Station to arrest
A-8 in the presence of P.W.47. The accused/A-8 voluntarily came forward to give
a confessional statement, the admissible portion of which is marked as Ex.P.44,
pursuant to which at 6.30 p.m., M.O.68-book was recovered under the cover of
Mahazar Ex.P.45. On the next day, A-8 was produced before the Saidapet Court
and all the materials were sent to the Court concerned. On 06.06.1988, on
receiving information, sent P.W.52 to arrest A-5, who after arrest was produced
before the Saidapet Court on 07.06.1988.
(n)P.W.66, on 04.07.1988, at 5.00 p.m., arrested P.W.4 in the presence of
P.W.46 and one Mohammed. P.W.4 gave a statement pursuant to which M.O.65-Silver
Plus Motor cycle belonging to P.W.37, bike keys-2, R.C.Book were recovered under
Ex.P.43-Mahazar. P.W.4-Shanmugavel sent a requisition Ex.P.68 to concerned
learned Judicial Magistrate to give a confessional statement. The Investigating
Officer sent a petition under Ex.P.89 to District Collector, Chengalpattu, to
register a case against A-4, A-5 and A-8 under the Explosives Substance Act,
1908 and received the Collector's order under Ex.P.63. P.W.57, the learned
Judicial Magistrate followed the proceedings and recorded the confessional
statement-Ex.P.70, of P.W.4.
(o)P.W.60, the Inspector [Special Branch], CBCID, on 10.05.1988, on
getting instructions from the Deputy Superintendent of Police, CBCID, Madurai to
investigate upon the deceased Maran and A-6 who was one of the associate of the
Movement run by Maran, went to C-364, Housing Board Colony, Anna Nagar along
with the Village Administrative Officer Ramalingam and one Thiyagarajan, to
recover the material objects in Exs.P.92,6,73,70,93,94,7,5,8,9,96,10,12,11 and
97 under Ex.P.4-Mahazar. Then P.W.60 prepared a printed First Information
Report under Ex.P.73 against A-6 under the Explosives Substance Act, 1908.
P.W.62-the learned Judicial Magistrate, Chengelpattu, on 23.091.988 tendered
pardon to P.W.4 under section 306, Cr.P.C. through Ex.P.80. P.W.67 states that
the learned Judicial Magistrate No.1, Trichy, recorded the confessional
statement of A-6 by following the procedures contemplated under the law through
Exs.P.91 and 92.
(p)P.W.48-T.A.Ravindran, rented a portion of his house to
Perunchithiranaar and his son A-1 under an agreement, Ex.P.46. P.W.56, the Sub
Inspector of Police, on 03.07.1988 at 12.30 p.m., registered a case against one
Arputharaj in Crime No.441 of 1988 under section 3 of Indian Arms Act when he
was handed over to him by P.W.68-the Deputy Superintendent of Police and
prepared Ex.P.67 the printed First Information Report and sent it to the Court
concerned. In the presence of P.W.30, A-1 gave the pistol to the police which
was recovered under a cover of Mahazar-Ex.P.24. P.W.55-the Sub Inspector of
Police of Ammapet Police Station, Salem, on 05.06.1988 at 2.45 p.m., registered
a case in Crime No.453 of 1988 under section 9(b) of Explosives Substance Act,
based on the material objects handed over by P.W.68 and Ex.P.66 is the printed
First Information Report. P.W.5, the Sub Inspector of Police of
Tiruvanandapuram Airport Police Station, on 12.04.1988, gave the details about
A-15 [Balachandran] who traveled to Srilanka and also verified his passport
bearing No.054927. P.W.64 gave Ex.P.83-Chemical Analyst Report after examining
the articles sent to him. P.W.66, the Investigating Officer on 15.3.1991 at 6.15
p.m., arrested A-15 at Tambaram Bus Stand, Chennai in the presence of witnesses
and recovered M.Os.109,110 and 11 through Ex.P.90-Mahazar.
(q)P.W.68-the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Madurai, on 14.04.1988, on
getting instructions from P.W.66, took up investigation in Crime NO.70 of 1988
and examined the witnesses. On 17.04.1988, he met P.W.66 with regard to the case
registered in Crime NO.70 of 1988 and continued his investigation in Vellore and
Pothanoor as regards A-2. On 28.04.1988, he enquired A-6 and examined the
material objects recovered on 12.04.1988 by P.W.60. On 12.05.1988 between 4.00
p.m. and 5.00 p.m., based on the statement given by A-6 regarding the Tamil Nadu
Viduthalai Paadai Movement headed by A-1 and the participants Maran [since
deceased], A-15, A-2, P.W.3 and A-7, the Investigating Officer conducted a
search in A-7's residence and recovered
M.Os.13,112,11,23,14,16,115,17,116,19,21,22,20 in the presence of P.W.13 through
Ex.P.5. He also took up the investigation in Crime No.144 of 1988 and on
10.04.1988, he went to Trivandrum Airport; examined P.W.5-P.K.R.Nair and
recovered Exs.P.3 and 93. On 18.05.1988, at 2.00 p.m., he arrested P.W.3 and he
showed the photograph of the deceased Maran to P.W.3 and the witness and
confirmed that it was Maran who died in the occurrence that had taken place on
11.04.1988. He also sent a petition to the Magistrate Court concerned to record
the statement of P.W.3 and he also received the statement given by A-6 under
section 164 Cr.P.C. Since the cases in Crime Nos.144 of 1988 and 70 of 1988 are
connected ones, the Investigating Officer sent a requisition to the learned
learned Judicial Magistrate No.3, Trichy, to send all the documents to
Nilakottai Judicial Magistrate Court.
(r)P.W.68, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, on 30.05.1988 at 11.00
p.m., he arrested A-7 at Kajamalai, Trichy in the presence of P.W.10 and one
Balasubramanian. He also sent a requisition to the Court concerned to record
the statement of A-7 under section 164 Cr.P.C. On 04.06.1988, as per the
directions of Nilakottai learned Judicial Magistrate, he took A-2 for police
custody and based on the confessional statement given by A-2 in the presence of
P.Ws.16 and 18, A-2 identified P.W.19-Shanmugam's house from where gelatin
sticks-140 nos.,Electric Detonators-17, Two Fuse Thread bundles were recovered
through Ex.P.8-Mahazar in the presence of P.W.17. P.W.63-learned Magistrate
recorded the confessional statement-Ex.P.82, of A-7. P.W.68 handed over the
material objects recovered from P.W.19's house to P.W.55-the Inspector of
Police, Ammapet Police Station, based on which a case came to be registered
against P.W.19 in Crime N0.463 of 1988 under section 9(b) of the Explosives
Substance Act, the printed First Information Report of which is marked as
Ex.P.66.
(s)P.W.68, the Investigating Officer on 06.06.1988 at 11.00 a.m., went to
Kodaikanal and enquried P.Ws.21 and 22 who were employed under P.W.20-Mustafa's
lodge and recovered Exs.P.13 and 6-the Lodge Register and bill pertaining to
the purchase of the alarm time piece. On 08.06.1988 at 6.00 p.m., A-2 was sent
for judicial remand. On the same day P.W.12 was enquired and his statement was
recorded. On 21.06.1988, he enquired and recorded the statement of P.W.49-the
doctor who treated A-2 and conducted postmortem of the deceased Maran. On
27.06.1988 A-2 was directed to be kept under custody under the National Security
Act as per the direction of the District Collector, Dindigul. On 28.06.1988,
the Investigating Officer arrested A-1 and A-3 in the Palladam A.P.Sheik lodge
in the presence of P.W.23 and on Songoda Kounder. A-1 gave a confessional
statement, the admissible portion of which is marked as Ex.P.20, pursuant to
which on 30.06.1988 at 10.00 a.m., A-1 identified the house of A-14 from where
in the presence of P.W.65 and the said Songoda Kounder, M.Os.104,80,81 series,82
series, 83 series, 84 series, 85 series, 86 series, 87 series,
89,117,118,18,119,20 were recovered through Ex.P.84-Mahazar. He also arrested
A-14. Later, the Investigating Officer went to Triplicane at 12.00 noon and
arrested A-10 in pursuance of the identification of A-10 by A-1 and recovered
M.Os.105, 72,71,74,75,76,106 through Ex.P.85-Mahazar in the presence of the same
witnesses. At 1.30 p.m., he recovered M.O.108 from the office of Ulaga Tamizh
Munnetra Kazhagam situate at Walajah Road through Ex.P.86-Mahazar. At 3.00
p.m., he arrested A-7 and recovered M.Os.17,77,78 series and 79 series through
Ex.P.87-Mahazar in the presence of the same witnesses. All the arrested accused
[A-14, A-7, A-10 and A-1] were produced before the learned II Metropolitan
Magistrate, Saidapet.
(t)A-3 identified the house to P.W.68, the Deputy Superintendent of Police
where the bombs were prepared. On 01.07.1988 at 10.00 a.m., A-1 identified A-12
[Bavanandhi] at Kancheepuram and recovered from A-12's house, four gelatin
sticks, one electric detonator through Ex.P.22-Mahazar in the presence of
P.W.28. At 12.30 p.m., A-3 identified A-11 and A-11 was arrested and from his
house M.Os.25, 26 series, 27 series, 28 and 29 through Ex.P.23-Mahazar in the
presence of the same witnesses. A-11 and A-12 were produced before the learned
Judicial Magistrate, Kancheepuram and got their remand extended. On the same
day, at 4.30 p.m., he came to Aarani and pursuant to the identification of A-3,
the Investigating Officer recovered from the shop of the witness Prabakaran,
gelatin sticks-89, detonators-76, Ordinary fuse wire of detonator-19, another
fuse wire 284 through Ex.P.18-Mahazar in the presence of P.W.25-Kumar. On
identification of P.W.25, the Investigating Officer recovered material objects
through Ex.P.19-Mahazar from one Vanitha's house. All the material objects
recovered were submitted to P.W.54-the Inspector of Police along with a separate
Report, based on which P.W.54 registered a case in Crime No.384 of 1988 under
section 9(b) of Explosives Substances Act and prepared Ex.P.64-printed First
Information Report. He also registered a case against Vanitha in Crime No.394
of 1988 under section 9(b) of the Explosives Substance Act and Ex.P.65 is the
printed First Information Report.
(u)P.W.68, in continuation of his investigation, on 02.07.1988 went to
Kanchipuram and recorded the statements of P.W.27 and one Thanigaiarasu. On the
same day, he recovered Ex.P.94 from P.W.15. Then, A-3 identified the house of
A-13 at Pondicherry pursuant to which M.Os.121,125 series, 12 series and some
gelatin sticks and electric detonators-3 were recovered through Ex.P.95-Mahazar.
He also arrested A-5 [Veeramani] whose remand was extended till 04.07.1988 after
getting approval from the learned Magistrate concerned. On From the house of
V.N.Arasu, material objects were recovered through a Mahazar pursuant to the
identification of A-1. On 04.07.1988 the Investigating Officer came to Madurai
and A-1 and A-3 were sent for judicial custody. A-13 was kept under police
custody. On 21.07.1988, the Investigating Officer went to Kodaikanal and
enquired P.Ws.1 and 31 and one Vijayan and recorded their statement with regard
to the damages to the TV Station.
(v)P.W.50 examined the cartridges and pistols and gave Exs.P.52 and 54-
Reports respectively. P.W.51 compared the signatures of A-1 and A-2 in M.Os.1
to 4 and gave a report through Ex.P.57 opining that the signatures in the
material objects well suits the signatures of A-1 and A-2. P.W.68, on
12.09.1988 sent Vadivel Ravanan to Court concerned who was willing to turn as a
prosecution witness. On 21.09.1988, P.W.44-the learned Principal District
Judge, Madurai, tendered pardon to P.W.3 and he accepted Vadivel Ravanan as
Prosecution witness through Ex.P.42. On 13.10.1988, he sent a requisition under
Ex.P.96 to the Forensic Lab to examine the pistol recovered from A-14. He also
sent Ex.P.97-requisition to the District Collector, Dindigul, to register cases
against the accused persons under the Explosives Substance Act and Indian Arms
Act to which course the District Collector gave orders through Exs.P.39 and 40.
On 14.12.1988, P.W.68, the Deputy Superintendent of Police came to Chennai and
since the crime committed in both the crime Nos.250 of 1988 and 70 of 1988 are
by one and the same group, he along with P.W.66 were instructed to file a common
First Information Report to which course, the examined the orders issued by the
District Collector. On 15.03.1991 at 6.30 p.m., A-15-Sekar was arrested and he
was sent for judicial remand on the next day. On 25.04.1991, a petition was
filed to keep A-15 in custody under National Security Act. One Sundaram, the
accused in this case remained absconding. On completing the investigation, the
Investigating Officer filed the final report against all the accused persons
including Sundaram under sections 120(b) and 427 IPC read with Section 3,4,5 and
6 of the Explosives Substance Act; Section 4 of PPD Act and Section 3 read with
25(1)(b)(a) and section 27 of Indian Arms Act. Since the said Sundaram was
absconding, a separate case in Crime No. 03 of 1993 was taken up for
investigation.
4.Before the Trial Court, the prosecution examined 68 witnesses, marked 99
exhibits and produced 125 material objects. On the side of the defence, 6
exhibits were marked.
5.The accused were questioned under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., as to the
incriminating circumstances found in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
against them. They denied them as false. On considering the oral and
documentary evidence, the learned Trial Judge framed charges against the accused
as mentioned supra.
6.Learned Senior counsel appearing for A-1 [Pozhilan @ Mani] submitted
that the first accused conviction under section 120-B IPC is not maintainable
since for conspiracy except the evidence of the approvers [P.Ws.3 and 4], no
other evidence is available. The approvers' evidence is only a tainted evidence
and as such, the evidence of one tainted witness cannot corroborate the evidence
of another tainted witness. It is the rule of prudence though not rule of law,
corroboration of material particulars connecting accused is necessary and such
corroboration should be by way of reliable evidence. Reliance was placed by
learned Senior Counsel on the decisions reported in YASH PAL MITAL Vs. STATE OF
PUNJAB [AIR 1977 SUPREME COURT 2433], CHONAMPARA CHELLAPPAN AND OTHERS Vs. STATE
OF KERALA [1979 (4) SUPREME COURT CASES 312], RAM NARAIN Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN
[1973 SCC (CRI.) 545], MOHD.HUSAIN UMAR KOCHRA ETC. Vs. K.S.DALIPSINGHJI AND
ANOTHER ETC. [1969 (3) SCC 429] and RENUKA BAI ALIAS RINKU ALIAS RATAN AND
ANOTHER Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [2006 (3) SCC (CRI.) 290].
7.It was submitted by learned Senior Counsel that no single material of
explosive substance is marked in this case. He also submitted that no property
was directly recovered from the first accused, though according to prosecution
in pursuance of his confession, property was recovered from other accused. The
recovery would not connect the first accused with the alleged crime. The
recoveries made from other accused cannot be said to be within the knowledge of
the first accused. Placing reliance on the decisions reported in PULUKURI
KOTTAYA AND OTHERS Vs. EMPEROR [AIR (34) 1947 PRIVY COUNCIL 67], learned Senior
Counsel submitted that under section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, the
discovery of fact alone is admissible and not the discovery of the properties.
Even otherwise, the recoveries made by the prosecution are suspectable. The
recoveries are made in several places and the same mahazar witness had been
taken and was kept by the police officer for nearly two months.
8.It was further submitted by learned Senior Counsel that the learned
Trial Judge was prejudiced by the descriptions made by the prosecution in
certain documents as offences under section 121 and 124(a) ipc and describing as
waging war. Even the first charge describes of such allegations, but there was
no specific charge under section 121 or 124 ipc. He also submitted that there
was malafide on the part of the investigating authorities and there was no act
of terrorism by the first accused. Mere taking part in a meeting and speaking
is not aiding terrorism. He also placed reliance on the decision reported in
P.NEDUMARAN AND FIVE OTHERS VS. STATE REP. BY DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE, Q
BRANCH CID, CHENNAI CITY CHENNAI 600 005] [2004 (1) CTC 721].
9.Learned Senior counsel Mr.R.Shamughasundaram, appearing for A-6,A-9,A-10
and A-14 submitted that in Ex.P.20, the confession given by the first accused,
the names of six accused were mentioned. But, A-12, A-13 and A-15 were
acquitted by the Trial Court whereas only A-9, A-10 and A-14 were convicted
which is not proper.
10.Learned counsel appearing for the second and the third accused
submitted that P.W.3 had not stated anything about the third accused. Learned
counsel appearing for the fourth accused submitted that no recovery was made
from the fourth accused and there is no corroborating materials to convict the
fourth accused.
11.Learned Additional Public Prosecutor was also heard and he had
submitted that the approvers, P.Ws.3 and 4 speak about the part taken by A-1 to
A-4 and the deceased Maran. The evidence of P.Ws.3 and 4 is corroborated by the
fact that after conspiracy, the incident has taken place in which the deceased
Maran had died and the second accused had sustained injury. The statement from
the second accused is also recorded by the learned Magistrate while he was in
the hospital and further the arms and ammunitions were recovered in pursuance of
the confession statement given by the first accused. P.W.29, the doctor, who
treated the second accused after he was being injured in the incident, also had
given evidence about what was narrated to her by the second accused about the
incident.
12.We have carefully gone through all the evidence and materials available
in this case and the rival submissions made by either of the parties.
13.This is a case of bomb blast occurred at TV relay station at Kodaikanal
in which one Maran had died on the spot and the second accused Ilango sustained
injuries while they were planting the time devised bomb. The case of the
prosecution is that in pursuance of the conspiracy among the accused on
10.04.1988, a time bomb was planted and set at Nehru statue at Kathippara,
Madras and the said bomb was exploded causing damage to the pedestal of the
statue and the electric lamps. After this occurrence, the bomb was planted at
the TV relay station at Kodaikanal on the next day.
14.At the outset, before discussing the evidence available in the case, it
is not understandable as to why no charge was made against the accused under
section 121, 121-a and 124-a ipc. As submitted by learned Senior Counsel,
Ex.P.89, the requisition letter from the Deputy Superintendent of Police to the
District Collector for obtaining sanction mentions the word tht the accused had
entered into criminal conspiracy to damage public property and to wage war
against the Government of India by blowing of the Nehru statue at Kathippara
junction, Chennai. Even the first charge framed against the accused contains
substance of accusation to the extent that the accused had conspired together to
act against the Government and for which they collected the arms and
ammunitions.
15.Secondly, we are also unable to understand why the accused No.1 to 4
alone were convicted by the Trial Court with the aid of section 120-B IPC. The
learned Trial Judge, had observed in paragraph 49 of his Judgment that the
accused No.1 to 4, 6,9, 10 and 14 have conspired together and in pursuance of
that conspiracy, acts were committed. But, to our surprise the accused
No.6,9,10 and 14 were not convicted under section 120-B IPC along with A-1 to A-
4. The state also has not preferred any appeal against them though there had
been a favourable finding in favour of the prosecution in the judgment. Anyhow,
it is for us now to consider the available evidence and on that basis, to decide
whether the conviction made against the appellants are sustainable.
15.As submitted by learned Senior Counsel that the evidence of the
approvers, P.Ws.3 and 4, is a tainted evidence and therefore, unless there is a
corroboration on material particulars, it should not have been acted upon. Also
the evidence of one approver which is tainted cannot corroborate the evidence of
another approver. The corroboration of the approver's evidence must be from
other independent sources. In CHONAMPARA CHELLAPPAN AND OTHERS Vs. STATE OF
KERALA [1979 (4) SUPREME COURT CASES 312], the Hon'ble Supreme Court has
observed in paragraph 4 as follows:
"4.........
The law is well settled that the Court looks with some amount of suspicion
on the evidence of an accomplice witness which is a tainted evidence an even
section 133 of the Evidence Act clearly provides that the evidence of an
accomplice witness should not be accepted unless corroborated. At the same
time, it must be remembered that corroboration must be in respect to material
particulars and not with respect to each and every item however minor or
insignificant it may be. Actually the requirement of corroboration is a rule of
prudence which the courts have followed for satisfying the test of the
reliability of an approver and has not been crystalized into a rule of law. It
is equally well settled that one tainted evidence cannot corroborate another
tainted evidence because if this is allowed to be done then the very necessity
of corroboration is frustrated."
16.In RENUKA BAI ALIAS RINKU ALIAS RATAN AND ANOTHER Vs. STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA [2006 (3) SCC (CRI.) 290], the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed in
paragraph 31 as follows:
31.The prosecution thus succeeded in proving that these appellants have
committed a series of murders. The learned counsel for the appellants strongly
urged before us that the evidence of the approver should not have been accepted
by the Court as it is a tainted evidence. It was argued that there is no
satisfactory corroboration of the evidence of the approver and unless there is
a corroboration, it should not have been acted upon. It is true that the
evidence of the approver is always to be viewed with suspicion especially when
it is seriously suspected that he is suppressing some material facts.....
17.With the above observations of the Apex Court, it is to be seen how far
the evidence of P.Ws.3 and 4 are acceptable and whether there is any
corroboration connecting each one of the accused to the crime. According to
P.W.3, approver, on 30.03.1988 at 11.00 a.m., the first accused and Maran
[deceased accused] came to his office and the first accused spoke over the phone
to the sixth accused. The first accused informed P.W.3 that on 20.03.1988, A-2,
A-5, A-6 and A-16, all joined together and taken a decision to set up a time
bomb at Nehru Statue and Kodaikanal TV Station. P.W.14 had stated that during
the first week of April 1988, the first accused introduced him the third accused
and he had told the third accused that the fourth accused and P.W.4 can be
utilised by the third accused for demolishing the Nehru statue. P.W.4 also
speaks about manufacturing of time bomb by the first and the third accused. He
further deposed that on 10.04.1988 at about 2.00 a.m. or 2.30 a.m., A-1, A-3, A-
4 and the deceased Maran all of them went to Nehru Statue and the third accused
set the time bomb near the statue. A-1, A-4 and the deceased Maran and P.W.4
were keeping a watch. Here both P.Ws.3 and 4 speak about the first accused.
But, P.W.3 do not speak about A-3 and A-4. P.W.4 did not speak about the second
accused. In the said position, now it is to be seen whether there is any other
corroboration to each one of A-1 to A-4. As far as A-2 is concerned, he
sustained injury in the occurrence and after sustaining injury, he had been seen
by P.W.29-doctor lying on the road and thereafter, he was taken to the hospital
and was given treatment. While he was enquired by P.W.29-doctor, he had
accepted to him that while he and the deceased Maran went to set up a bomb at TV
Station tower, it had exploded and then the deceased had died at the spot and he
had escaped. This part of the evidence of P.W.29 amounts to the Extra-judicial
Confession from A-2. Absolutely there is no reason to reject the evidence of
P.W.29 who is a respectable and independent witness.
18.Apart from that, while A-2 was in Government Rajaji Hospital, Madurai,
his statement was recorded by the learned Judicial II Class Magistrate No.1,
Madurai, which is marked as Ex.P.38. Though Ex.P.38 cannot be treated as a
dying declaration at this stage, it can be treated as a statement given under
section 164 Cr.P.C., which may be used only as a piece of corroboration.
19.As far as A-1 is concerned, apart from both the approvers referred to
A-1, the sixth accused who had given a judicial confession in Ex.P.91 to the
learned Judicial II Class Magistrate No.1, Trichy, in which he had spoken about
the first accused and about the decisison taken to blast the Nehru Statue. A-6
had given confession implicating himself and also A-1 and A-2. The judicial
confession of A-6 is inculpatory in nature. The judicial confession of the
accused cannot be treated as a weak piece of evidence.
20.Section 30 of the Indian Evidence Act reads as follows:
"30.Consideration of proved confession affecting person making it and others
jointly under trial for same offence:-
When more persons than one are being tried jointly for the same offence,
and a confession made by one of such persons himself and some other of such
persons is proved, the Court may take into consideration such confession as
against such other person as well as against the person who makes such
confession."
Learned Magistrate who recorded the judicial confession of A-6 had
followed the procedures and as such the confession of A-6 stands proved and
therefore, can be taken into consideration against the first and the second
accused.
21.Apart from the above materials, the confession of the first accused to
police which led to recovery of arms and ammunitions from other co-accused also
stands as a circumstance against him. Though there may not be any recovery
directly from the first accused, Ex.P.20-the confession recorded by the police
officer reveals the fact that a revolver and two box of bullets are available
with the accused A-9, A-10 and A-14.
(i)M.O.77-country made gun, M.O.78-Special cartridge and M.O.79-Special
cartridge-2 nos. were recovered from A-9 under Ex.P.87.
(ii)M.O.71-Automatic Rifle ball amunsation mark 10, M.O.72- Automatic
Rifle ball amunsation, M.O.73-Pistal ball amunsation-38, M.O.74-0.22 Ball KF-4
nos., M.O.75-Special ball silver amunsation and M.O.76-Super special cartridge
were recovered from A-10 under Ex.P.85.
(iii)M.O.80-0.38 ball amunsation 107, M.O.81-0.450 ball amunsation 33,
M.O.82-0.555 ball amunsation 60, M.O.83-0.765mm ball 14, M.O.84-Laguva 38 spl-
28, M.O.85-0.45 ball amunsation 48 short, M.O.86-0.65 ball amunsation 14 long
and M.O.87-0.55mm ball amunsation-57 were recovered from A-14 under Ex.P.84.
22.The question is whether the recoveries made from those accused can be
used as an incriminating circumstance against the first accused. Section 27 of
the Indian Evidence Act reads as follows:
"27.How much of information received from accused may be proved:-
Provided that, when any fact is deposed to as discovered in consequence of
information received from a person accused of any offence, in the custody of a
police officer, so much of such information, whether it amounts to a confession
or not, as relates distinctly to the fact thereby discovered, may be proved."
23.Here, the disclosure of statements made by the first accused is to the
effect that arms and ammunitions are available with the other accused. The
information furnished by the first accused leads to the discovery of a fact that
arms and ammunitions are available with A-9, A-10 and A-14 and subsequently, it
led to recovery of those articles. Therefore, the information furnished by the
first accused is a discovery of fact as admissible under section 27 of the
Indian Evidence Act. It can be said only to the extent that the first accused
had knowledge that arms and ammunitions were available with the other co-accused
and not more than that. In PULUKURI KOTTAYA AND OTHERS Vs. EMPEROR [AIR (34)
1947 PRIVY COUNCIL 67], which is the landmark decision under section 27 of the
Indian Evidence Act, wherein it is held in paragraph 10 that:
"10.Section 27, which is not artistically worded, provides an exception to
the prohibition imposed by the preceding section and enables certain statements
made by a person in police custody to be proved. The condition necessary to
bring the section into operation is that discovery of a fact in consequence of
information received from a person accused of any offence in the custody of a
police officer must be deposed to, and thereupon so much of the information as
relates distinctly to the fact there by discovered may be proved. The section
seems to be based on the view that if a fact is actually discovered
inconsequence of information given, some guarantee is afforded thereby that the
information was true and accordingly can be safely allowed to be given in
evidence; but clearly the extent of the information admissible must depend on
the exact nature of the fact discovered to which such information is required to
relate. Normally the section is brought into operation when a person in police
custody produces from some place of concealment some object, such as a dead
body, a weapon, or ornaments, said to be connected with the crime of which the
informant is accused. Mr.Megaw, for the Crown, has argued that in such a case
the fact discovered is the physical object produced, and that any information
which relates distinctly to that object can be proved. Upon this view
information given by a person that the body produced is that of a person
murdered by him, that the weapon produced is the one used by him in the
commission of a murder, or that the ornaments produced were stolen in a dacoity
would all be admissible. If this be the effect of section 27, little substance
would remain in the ban imposed by the two preceding sections on confession made
to the police, or by persons in police custody. That ban was presumably
inspired by the fear of the legislature that a person under police influence
might be induced to confess by the exercise of undue pressure. But, if all that
is required to lift the ban be the inclusion in the confession of information
relating to an object subsequently produced, it seems reasonable to suppose that
the persuasive powers of the police will prove equal to the occasion, and that
in practice the ban will lose its effect. On normal principles of construction
their Lordships think that the proviso to Section 26 added by section 27 should
not be held to nullify the substance of the section. In their Lordship's view
it is fallacious to treat the 'fact discovered' within the section as equivalent
to the object produced; the fact discovered embraces the place from which the
object is produced and the knowledge of the accused as to this, and the
information given must relate distinctly to this fact. Information as to past
user, or the past history, of the object produced is not related to the
discovery in the setting in which it is discovered. Information supplied by a
person in custody that "I will produce a knife concealed in the roof of my
house" does not lead to the discovery of a knife. Knives were discovered many
years ago. It leads to the discovery of the fact that a knife is concealed in
the house of the informant to his knowledge, and if the knife is proved to have
been used in the commission of the offence, the fact discovered is very
relevant. But, if to the statement the words be added "with which I stabbed A"
this words are inadmissible since they do not relate to the discovery of the
knife in the house of the informant."
24.With regard to the accused No.3 and 4, the approvers P.Ws.3 and 4 do
not refer them at all. Though P.W.4 refers A3 and A4, there is no other
corroboration supporting the evidence of P.W.4 with regard to A-3 and A-4.
Nothing about A-3 and A-4 either in the Extra-judicial Confession of A-2 or in
his statement to the learned Magistrate in Ex.P.38 or in the judicial confession
given by A-6 in Ex.P.91. No recovery is made either from A-3 or A-4 or in
pursuance of the confession of A-3, no property has been recovered and
ultimately there is no corroboration in the evidence of P.W.4 to connect A-3 and
A-4. As far as A-6, A-9, A-10 and A-14 are concerned, the arms and ammunitions
recovered from them, which are not the properties ordinarily transferable and
mere possession itself being an offence, establish their guilt. As far as the
sixth accused is concerned, apart from the recovery, there is judicial
confession given by him before the learned Magistrate. The contention of learned
Senior Counsel Mr.Shanmugasundaram, that A-6, A-9, A-10 and A-14 are convicted
under the arms act and explosives substance act and their trial along with the
other accused would amount to mis-joinder of charges or mis-joinder of persons,
cannot be accepted. Though A-6, A-9, A-10 and A-14 are not convicted along
with A-1 and A-2 under section 120-B IPC, the case of the prosecution is that
there had been a conspiracy among all the accused. Subsequent acquittal of some
of the accused on some of the charges do not give a right to raise an objection
as a case of mis-joinder of charges or mis-joinder of persons. Considering the
totality of the case, the trial is not vitiated.
25.Therefore,
(a)we confirm the conviction and sentence imposed on the sixth accused by
the Trial Court.
(b)In respect of A-9 an A-14, their conviction under section 5 of the
Explosives Substance Act read with 120-B IPC is set aside. But their conviction
under section 3 read with 25(1-B)(a) of Indian Arms Act and sentence imposed by
the Trial Court is confirmed.
(c)The conviction of A-10 under section 3 read with section 25(1)(A)(a) of
Indian Arms Act and the sentence imposed by the Trial Court is confirmed.
(d)The conviction of A-1 and A-2 under sections 3,4 and 6 of Explosives
Substance Act, 1908 read with 120-B IPC is confirmed, but the sentence of life
imprisonment, which is the maximum sentence provided under the section is
modified to a period of ten years rigorous imprisonment. The period already
undergone shall be given set off.
(e)The convictions of A-1 under section 3 read with Section 25(1-B)(a) of
Indian Arms Act and section 4 of PPD Act and the sentence imposed by the Trial
Court are confirmed.
(f)The conviction and sentence imposed by the Trial Court on A-3 and A-4
are set aside.
26.In the result,
Criminal Appeal Number
Preferred by
Allowed/Dismissed
233 of 1997
A-6
A-9 and A-14
Dismissed
Partly Allowed
234 of 1997
A-10
Dismissed
268 of 1997
A-1
Partly Allowed
336 of 1997
A-3
Allowed
284 of 1997
A-4
Allowed
402 of 1997
A-2
Partly Allowed
ap
To
1.The Principal Sessions Judge,
Dindigul.
2.The Deputy Superintendent of Police,
CBCID, Madurai.
3.The Inspector of Police,
St.Thomas Mount Police Station,
Chennai 600 016.
(Crime No.250 of 1988)
4.The Inspector of Police,
Kodaikkanal Police Station,
Kodaikkanal.
5.The Additional Public Prosecutor,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, Madurai.