Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 (State Act) and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (Central Act)
  • Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956.2.
  • thereof.7. Section 21 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959
  • business.8. Sub-section (3) of Section 21
  • Rule 24(9) and 24(9-A). Rule 24(9)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 21
  • business.10. Rule 24(9-A)
  • sub-rule (9),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 (State Act) and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (Central Act)
  • Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956.2.
  • thereof.7. Section 21 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959
  • business.8. Sub-section (3) of Section 21
  • Rule 24(9) and 24(9-A). Rule 24(9)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 21
  • business.10. Rule 24(9-A)
  • sub-rule (9),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is a dealer in agro products and was registered under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 (State Act) and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (Central Act) from 23.6.1999. The registration certificate was renewed periodically until 31 March 2003. When the petitioner approached the respondent in the first week of July 2005 seeking Form-H declarations, the respondent informed the petitioner that its registration certificates had been cancelled with effect from 30.4.2003 for failure to renew the certificates in time, and therefore Form-H would not be issued. The petitioner paid renewal fees and applied for renewal on 7.7.2005; the respondent, by proceedings dated 11.7.2005, returned the fees on the ground that the last date for renewal (including the extended period with penalty) for the year 2003-04 was 30.4.2003 and therefore belated renewal could not be considered. The petitioner filed this writ petition seeking (a) issuance of a writ of certiorari and mandamus to quash the respondent's proceedings dated 11.7.2005 and (b) a direction to accept the renewal fees and renew the registration certificates under the State and Central Acts.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent's proceedings dated 11.7.2005 cancelling the petitioner's registration certificates and refusing to accept renewal fees and renew the certificates are illegal or violative of the principles of natural justice.
  2. Whether, under the statutory provisions and rules applicable at the relevant time (in particular Section 21(3) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 and Rules 24(9) and 24(9-A)), the petitioner was entitled to have its belated renewal application (submitted on 7.7.2005) accepted and the certificate renewed on payment of fees/penalty.
  3. Whether earlier judicial decisions relied upon by the petitioner (notably Fisher Pumps and related authorities) are binding or applicable to the present facts, particularly in light of statutory amendments and the particular factual matrix of those decisions.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted that it was a registered dealer since 1999, regularly filed returns, and had renewed certificates year after year by paying fees.
  • When seeking Form-H declarations in July 2005, the petitioner was informed its certificates had been cancelled; the petitioner then applied for renewal on 7.7.2005 and paid fees but the respondent returned the fees saying renewal could not be considered as the last date (30.4.2003) had passed.
  • The petitioner relied on the single-judge decision in Fisher Pumps (P.) Ltd. to argue that the respondent had to accept the renewal application and fees and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law, even after the prescribed period.

Respondent's Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The respondent treated the registration certificates as cancelled effective 30.4.2003 because the petitioner failed to apply for renewal within the statutory period (and the extended period up to 30 April with penalty) and therefore refused issuance of Form-H declarations.
  • On receiving the petitioner's application for renewal on 7.7.2005, the respondent returned the fees citing the statutory last date for renewal for 2003-04 as 30.4.2003 and stating that the petitioner's request at that point could not be considered.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sun Gas Pvt. Ltd. v. Registrar, Tamil Nadu Taxation Special Tribunal, 125 STC 496 The Division Bench held that no personal hearing is required when a certificate of registration is deemed cancelled for non-renewal; however, on special facts where the registration form misled the assessee about its validity the Revenue must give notice and opportunity before cancellation. The Court considered and distinguished Sun Gas because it was decided prior to the 2002 amendments and its relief was granted on peculiar facts (a misleading certificate that indicated validity "until cancelled"). The Court held those special facts are absent here.
Fisher Pumps (P.) Ltd. v. The Commercial Tax Officer, Avarampalayam Assessment Circle, Coimbatore, 2004-05 (10) TNCTJ 224 A single-judge decision said that under the proviso to Section 21(3) a dealer must be permitted to renew by paying renewal fee and penalty and that the respondent should accept belated renewal application and fees and pass orders. The Court reviewed this decision but concluded it did not properly consider the relevant rules prescribing the original and extended renewal periods (Rule 24(9) and 24(9-A)). The Court held Fisher Pumps to be per incuriam and declined to follow it.
Haryana Financial Corporation v. Jagadamba Oil Mills and another, 2002 (1) CTC 503 : JT 2002 (1) SC 482 Cited in the opinion in the context of distinguishing or supporting treatment of precedent (as authority on application of precedent/principles). The Court cited this authority when explaining why the Division Bench decision in Sun Gas could not be applied to the present facts. The opinion does not extract additional principles from it beyond referencing it in that context.
Padma Sundar Rao v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2002 AIR SCW 1156 Cited in the context of precedent comparison and distinguishing prior decisions. Referenced alongside other authorities to show that the Sun Gas decision was not applicable to the present facts; no further application beyond citation was made in the opinion.
Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka, 2003 (6) SCC 697 (Para 146) Principle that a court must consider the text and context of earlier decisions; a court cannot pick isolated sentences to determine intent—statutory and contextual considerations must be looked at when applying precedent. The Court relied on this Supreme Court guidance to support its approach of examining decisions in their full context and not treating orders rendered without reference to statutory provisions as binding ratio.
Furest Day Lawson Ltd. v. Jindal Exports Ltd., 2001 (6) SCC 366 Discusses the per incuriam doctrine and when a prior decision may not be binding because it overlooked a plain statutory provision or obligatory authority. The Court invoked the passage (and the earlier Mamleshwar Prasad authority extracted therein) to hold that the Fisher Pumps decision was rendered without considering relevant statutory provisions and therefore amounted to per incuriam; accordingly it was not followed.
Mamleshwar Prasad v. Kanhaiya Lal, 1975 (2) SCC 232 Authority on when a decision may be regarded as not binding for inadvertent omission or oversight of plain statutory provisions (quoted in Furest Day Lawson). Quoted via Furest Day Lawson to support the Court's conclusion that a prior decision may be disregarded if it failed to consider applicable statutory provisions, which the Court applied to Fisher Pumps.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in sequential, statutory-focused steps:

  1. Identification and reproduction of the relevant statutory framework: the court examined Section 21 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 (notably sub-sections (1), (2) and (3)), Rule 24(9) and Rule 24(9-A) (the renewal rules), and the Form-D1 certificate format. The court noted that Section 21(3) provides that the registration certificate shall be valid for one year (for dealers) and "shall be renewed in such manner and within such period as may be prescribed," and that the certificate "shall be deemed to have been cancelled unless it has been renewed." The proviso to Section 21(3) permits renewal within a further prescribed period on payment of renewal fee and penalty.
  2. The court set out the content of Rule 24(9) and Rule 24(9-A): Rule 24(9) requires annual renewal (Form-D) in March of the relevant financial year, and Rule 24(9-A) permits renewal up to 30 April of the year on payment of a penalty equal to the renewal fee where renewal was not obtained by the March date.
  3. The court summarized the conditions for renewal (as derived from the statute and rules): (a) certificate validity for one year for dealers; (b) filing Form-D; (c) proof of fee payment; (d) filing during March of the relevant financial year; (e) permissible renewal up to 30 April with penalty; and (f) the certificate being deemed cancelled unless renewed.
  4. Applying those provisions to the admitted facts, the court observed that the petitioner's certificate had been valid up to 31 March 2003 and that the petitioner did not apply for renewal for the 2003-04 year or for 2004-05 until 7.7.2005—well beyond the statutory and extended dates (March and the extended 30 April). On this admitted fact-pattern and the statutory wording, the certificate was properly deemed to have been cancelled and the respondent's action in returning fees and refusing renewal could not be faulted.
  5. The court then examined the authorities relied upon by the petitioner:
    • Sun Gas (Division Bench): the court acknowledged the principles in that decision (no personal hearing required where cancellation is by operation of law for non-renewal) but noted that the Division Bench granted relief on special facts—specifically, that the form of the certificate issued in that case misled the assessee into believing it was valid "until cancelled." The court held those special facts are absent here, and Sun Gas was pre-amendment, so its factual basis differs materially.
    • Fisher Pumps (single judge): although on its face directly relevant, the court concluded that the single-judge decision did not take the relevant renewal rules (distinguishing March deadline and the extended 30 April period with penalty) into account and therefore reached a result without proper statutory consideration. The court treated that decision as per incuriam.
  6. The court invoked higher-court guidance (Islamic Academy) about reading precedent in full context and the per incuriam doctrine (Furest Day Lawson and Mamleshwar Prasad) to justify not following the Fisher Pumps decision. The court explained that an order rendered without reference to the statutory provisions cannot be considered a binding ratio decidendi.
  7. Concluding application: given the statutory scheme and admitted facts, and after distinguishing and not following the precedents relied upon by the petitioner, the court found no fault with the impugned proceedings and dismissed the writ petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The connected writ miscellaneous petition (W.P.M.P.) is also dismissed. No costs were awarded.

Implications (direct consequences as described in the opinion):

  • The respondent's proceedings dated 11.7.2005 (which returned the fees and declined to renew the petitioner's registration certificates on the ground that renewal was not sought within the prescribed/extended period up to 30.4.2003) stand upheld by this judgment.
  • The petitioner, having failed to apply for renewal within the statutory period and the extended period, is not entitled to restoration of the registration or compelled acceptance of the belated renewal application and fees submitted on 7.7.2005 under the statutory scheme in force.
  • The court declined to follow the single-judge decision in Fisher Pumps on the ground that it was rendered without considering relevant statutory provisions (per incuriam). The court did not refer the matter to a larger Bench and did not treat the Fisher Pumps decision as binding. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new broad precedent beyond application of the statute to the present facts.

This summary is based exclusively on the contents of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond those stated in the text.

    Tvl. N.V.S Agro Derivatives, Rep. By Partner, Namperumal, 1327 And 1328, Periyakulam Road, Theni Petitioner v. The Commercial Tax Officer (Circle I), Commercial Tax Office, Theni

    1. The above writ petition is filed for issuance of a writ of certiorarified mandamus to call for the records on the file of the respondent in his proceedings in O.Mu.1977/2005 dated 11.7.2005 and quash the same as illegal and violative of the principles of natural justice and for further direction to the respondent to accept the renewal fees and renew the petitioner's registration certificate issued under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956.

    2. The case of the petitioner is that the petitioner is a dealer in Agro Products and an assessee on the file of the respondent both under the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 (State Act) and the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (Central Act) and doing business from the year 1999 after obtaining due Registration Certificate, under the provisions of the Act. The certificates were duly renewed year after year by paying the necessary fee by following the provisions for renewal. The petitioner is also very regular in filing its sales tax returns. While that being so, when the petitioner approached the respondent in the first week of July 2005 seeking for issuance of Form-H declarations, they were informed that the petitioner's registration certificates were cancelled under both Acts from 30.4.2003 as the petitioner failed to get the certificate renewed as per the provisions of the Act and on that score refused to issue Form-H Declaration to the petitioner. Thereafter, on 7.7.2005 the petitioner applied for renewal of the registration certificates by paying the necessary fees, but the respondent by the impugned proceedings dated 11.7.2005 returned the fees by stating that the last date for payment of fee for renewal of the registration certificates with penalty for the year 2003-04 was 30.4.2003 and since the petitioner did not pay the renewal fee and apply for renewal within the stipulated period the petitioner's request at this point of time could not be considered. The correctness of the said order is now put in issue in this writ petition.

    3. I heard the learned counsel on either side and perused the relevant statutory provisions and the materials placed on records.

    4. Reliance has been made by the learned counsel for the petitioner on the judgment of this Court in Fisher Pumps (P.) Ltd. v. The Commercial Tax Officer, Avarampalayam Asessment Circle, Coimbatore, 2004-05 (10) TNCTJ 224, in order to sustain his case that the respondent has to accept the application for renewal of the registration certificate along with the fees and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law.

    5. I perused the above order dated 16.12.2003 and also the judgment referred to in that order i.e Sun Gas Pvt. Ltd. v. Registrar, Tamil Nadu Taxation Special Tribunal, 125 STC 496. The judgment would be considered after considering the point whether the petitioner's request could be granted with reference to the statutory provisions in this regard obtaining at the relevant period.

    6. In this context, it is relevant to note the statutory provisions which govern the point of issuance of registration certificate and renewal thereof.

    7. Section 21 of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 requires consideration which reads as follows:

    21. Procedure for registration.— (1) An application for registration shall be made to such authority in such manner and within such period as may be prescribed and shall be accompanied by a fee of two thousand and five hundred rupees in respect of Public Limited Companies, one thousand rupees in respect of Private Limited Companies and five hundred rupees in respect of other dealers for the principal place of business, and in addition, a further fee of two hundred rupees in respect of Public Limited Companies one hundred rupees in respect of Private Limited Companies and fifty rupees in respect of other dealers in respect of each of the places of business other than the principal place of business.

    Sub-section (2) of the above provision reads as follows:

    (2) If the prescribed authority is satisfied that the application is in order and the condition, if any, imposed under sub-section (1-A) has been complied with, it shall register the applicant and grant to him a certificate of registration in the prescribed form specifying all his places of business with copies for each of his place of business other than the principal place of business.

    8. Sub-section (3) of Section 21 reads as follows:

    “The certificate issued under sub-section (2) shall be valid for one year or five years, as the case may be and shall be renewed in such manner and within such period as may be prescribed on payment of the fee specified in sub-section (1). The certificate shall be deemed to have been cancelled unless it has been renewed:

    Provided that a registered dealer who fails to renew the certificate of registration within the prescribed period shall be permitted to renew the certificate before a further period as may be prescribed on payment of renewal fee and also a penalty equal to renewal fee.”

    9. The relevant rule for renewal is Rule 24(9) and 24(9-A). Rule 24(9) reads as follows:

    “Every registered dealer shall, until his registration is cancelled, submit an application in Form-D and pay the fee as specified in sub-section (1) of Section 21 of the Act for every year subsequent to that in which he applied for registration, during the month of March of the Financial Year for which the registration is valid and in addition a further fee as in sub-section (1) of Section 21 in respect of each of his place of business other than the principal place of business……….”

    10. Rule 24(9-A) reads as follows:

    “Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (9), a registered dealer who fails to renew the certificate of registration on or before the date specified in that sub-rule shall be permitted to renew the certificate upto 30th of April of the year for which renewal is requested on payment of a penalty equal to the fee payable for the principal or additional place of business, as the case may be.

    11. The relevant Form-D1 under which the Certificate of Registration is issued contains 7 clauses. Clause 4 is relevant as it provides for the period of validity of the certificate as one year from 1st April to 31st March.

    12. The relevant Section and rules were amended with effect from 1.4.2002 As per the above provisions, the conditions or requirements for renewal of the Registration Certificate are as follows:

    (1) The Registration Certificate is valid for one year for dealers like the petitioner and Five Years for Companies.

    (2) The dealer has to submit renewal application in Form-D.

    (3) Along with the application, proof of payment of renewal fee as specified in Section 21(1) has to be sent.

    (4) Application for renewal and payment of fee as aforesaid in Clause (1) and (2) has to be made every year during the month of March of the financial year for which the Registration Certificate is valid.

    (5) The dealer who fails to renew the certificate of Registration on or before the month of March of the Financial year for which registration certificate is valid could renew the Registration Certificate upto 30th April of the year for which the renewal is requested on payment of registration fee as specified in Section 21(1) with the penalty equal to the Registration fees.

    (6) The Registration Certificate shall be deemed to have been cancelled unless it has been renewed.

    13. So far as the facts of the present case is concerned the petitioner has got his registration certificate from 23.6.1999 to 31.3.2000 Thereafter it was renewed upto 31st March 2003. There is o dispute about the above said facts. For the assessment year 2003-04, the Registration Certificate has got to be renewed on or before March 2003 or at least on or before the extended period of 30th April 2003. Admittedly in this case the petitioner did not apply for renewal for the year 2003-2004 and 2004-2005 till an application was made on 7.7.2005, that is well beyond the time prescribed by the statute.

    14. As per Section 21(3) the certificate issued under sub-section (2) is valid for one year which is also re-produced under clause 4 of the Form-D1 Certificate issued to the petitioner. The section further provides that the certificate shall be deemed to have been cancelled unless it is renewed as provided in the Act.

    15. In view of the above said statutory provision and on the admitted fact, that after 31st March 2003 the Registration Certificate of the petitioner has not been renewed as provided in the above said statutory provisions the order impugned cannot be found fault.

    16. Now let me consider the decisions relied on. First let me consider the Division Bench Judgment relied on by the learned Judge the Sun Gas Pvt. Ltd. v. Registrar, Tamil Nadu Taxation Special Tribunal, 125 STC 496. That was the case considered prior to amendment of the provisions in the year 2002. However, the observation made in that rule is very clear, which are as follows:

    (1) that the view of the Tribunal that no personal hearing is required when a certificate of registration is cancelled on the ground that the renewal had not been sought is correct. (Para 1 at 497)

    (2) Having regard to Rule 24(9) the certificate given is to be regarded as having been given for one year. That year being the financial year, its validity would be limited at the end of the financial year in which the certificate came to be issued. Renewal would then become necessary after the 1st April 1998. (Para 6 at page 498)

    (3) The certificate which is required to be renewed but has not been renewed is deemed by Section 21(3) of the Act to have been cancelled. A certificate which is deemed to have been cancelled does not require an order being made to that effect. The need for a hearing is only in relation to persons who apply for renewal and not to those who do not seek such renewal. There is no obligation on the authorities to provide a personal hearing to dealers who do not seek renewal of the certificates of registration in accordance with law. (Para 7 at page 499)

    17. The Division Bench, however, granted the relief taking into consideration of the peculiar fact of that case that the Certificate of Registration was given to the assessee only on March 27, 1998. It did not set out the exact period for which the certificate of registration was issued. That the form in which the certificate was issued does not correspond to the prescribed form. Clause (4) of the Certificate issued to the assessee in that case stated that the certificate was valid from March 2, 1998 (sic March 27, 1998) until cancelled. The certificate which was issued to the dealer and which he was required to exhibit in his place of business did not state as to when that certificate would expire. The assessee by reading the certificate would have no clue that he was required to seek renewal within two days after receiving the certificate. The assesse in that case has commenced the business newly and the assessee was given certificate which led him to believe that it was valid until it was cancelled. The authorities themselves being responsible for having misled the assessee, they were required to give him a notice and afford him an opportunity before proceeds to cancel the certificate.

    18. Those observations were made on the special facts and feature of that case with particular reference to the certificate, which has stated that the registration certificate issued on 27, March 1998 was valid until it was cancelled.

    19. On that special fact of the case, the Division Bench concluded that the Revenue when it commits errors of this nature which leads to the deprivation of a right in the assessee to seek renewal in time by misleading him about the need for such renewal must at the minimum put him on notice about the correct state of the law and give him an opportunity to seek renewal. The abrupt cancellation as done in that case was wholly impermissible.

    20. The Division Bench further gave a note of caution to make it clear that the relief granted to the assessee in that case was purely on account of the misleading form, which the Revenue chose to use to grant the certificate of registration.

    21. In the case on hand no such special feature is available. The certificate issued to the petitioner, which is annexed in page 3 of the typed set of papers makes it clear that the certificate was valid from 23.6.1999 to 31st March 2000 and is renewable from year to year on payment prescribed fee. The assessee understood the same correctly and got the renewal for the subsequent assessment year of 2000-01 and 2001-02 by complying with the statutory provisions.

    22. Even the special factor as referred to above makes a ocean of difference between the case cited and the case on hand. Hence the decision of the Division Bench cannot be made applicable to the facts of the present case (vide Haryana Financial Corporation v. Jagadamba Oil Mills and another, 2002 (1) CTC 503: JT 2002 (1) SC 482 and Padma Sundar Rao v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2002 AIR SCW 1156).

    23. The other case is rendered by a learned single Judge in Fisher Pumps (P.) Ltd. v. The Commercial Tax Officer, Avarampalayam Asessment Circle, Coimbatore, 2004-05 (10) TNCTJ 224. In that case after referring to Section 21(3) and its proviso as amended with effect from 1.4.2002 the learned Judge has come to the conclusion that it is very clear from the provision if a registered dealer fails to renew the certificate of registration, it cannot cancel the right to carry on business issued earlier. As per the proviso, the dealer must be given an opportunity to renew the certificate for further period on payment of renewal fee and penalty as provided in the proviso. The said recourse has not been followed by the respondent before cancelling the certificate.

    24. It is seen from paragraph 2 of the Judgment though the facts required for consideration have not been stated in detail that the revenue by its order dated September 30, 2003 cancelled the certificate of registration granted to the petitioner with retrospective effect from 1.4.2003 on the ground that the Registration certificate has not been renewed within the time. It is also seen from paragraphs 4, 5 and 6 only Section 21(3) and its proviso were brought to the notice of the learned Judge and on reading of the above provision, learned single Judge has come to the conclusion that the petitioner was entitled to apply even after the period prescribed in the statutory provision and directed the respondent therein to receive the application for renewal along with fee and pass orders in accordance with law. It is evident from the last paragraph which reads that in the light of the above referred statutory provision the impugned order of the respondent was quashed.

    25. Though the above said case is straight case with the point in issue in the case on hand, I am not able to follow the same as the relevant rules which prescribed the original period within which the renewal has to be obtained and the extended period within which the renewal of registration certificate can be obtained on payment of penalty has not been taken for consideration.

    26. As the petitioner has very much relied on the above decisions and argued that this Court has to follow the same as ratio decidendi in the absence of any other decision taking a contrary view, this Court is constrained to give the reason for not accepting for the course argued for by the petitioner. An order rendered without reference to the statutory provision cannot be considered as a ratio decidendi binding on the Court. In the latest Judgment of the Supreme Court in Islamic Academy of Eduction v. State of Karnataka, 2003 (3) CTC 719: 2003 (6) SCC 697 (Para 146), the larger Bench of the Supreme Court has ruled that the Court cannot read some sentences from here and there to find out the intent and purport of the decision by not only considering what has been said therein but the text and context in which it was said. For the said purpose the Court may also consider the constitutional or relevant statutory provisions vis-a-vis its earlier decisions on which reliance has been placed.

    27. In Furest Day Lawson Ltd. v. Jindal Exports Ltd., 2001 (6) SCC 366, while considering the plea of per incuriam raised therein the Supreme Court has referred its earlier decision in Mamleshwar Prasad v. Kanhaiya Lal, 1975 (2) SCC 232, and extracted the relevant portion in paragraph 19 of the judgment which reads as follows:

    “7. Certainty of the law, consistency of rulings and comity of Courts − all flowering from the same principle − converge to the conclusion that a decision once rendered must later bind like cases. We do not intend to detract from the rule that, in exceptional instances, where by obvious inadvertence or oversight a judgment fails to notice a plain statutory provision or obligatory authority running counter to the reasoning and result reached, it may not have the sway of binding precedents. It should be a glaring case, an obtrusive omission.”

    28. In this case also the decision was rendered without taking into consideration of the relevant provisions of the statute which were obtaining at the time of deciding the case. With great respect to the learned Judge, I am not able to follow the judgment as it comes within the meaning of per incuriam. For the very same reasons, I am of the view that the matter need not be referred to a larger Bench.

    29. In the result, the writ petition fails and the same is dismissed. Consequently, the connected W.P.M.P is also dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tvl. N.V.S Agro Deri... v. The Commercial Tax O...
    (Sep 14, 2005)