Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeks quashing of the charge against the petitioners in C.C. No. 18 of 2003 pending before the Judicial Magistrate III, Coimbatore. The respondent police filed a final report (taken on file as C.C. 18 of 2003) alleging that the petitioners, with common intention, committed offences of forgery of valuable securities and of using forged documents as genuine by presenting those documents before the Deputy Registrar of Chits, Coimbatore in ARC Nos. 309 to 314 (the opinion mentions both 2010 and 2001 in different places). The charge-sheet attributes offences under Sections 467 and 471 IPC (and for some accused also read with Section 34 IPC). According to the final report, proceedings before the Deputy Registrar of Chits in ARC Nos. 309 to 314 were pending as on 25.05.2002. The petitioners contend that because the alleged forgery relates to documents used or produced in those pending proceedings before the Deputy Registrar, the magistrate ought not to have taken cognizance under Section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C., and the criminal proceedings are therefore liable to be quashed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate could properly take cognizance of offences alleged in the final report (C.C. No. 18 of 2003) when the alleged offence of forgery relates to documents produced or given in evidence in pending proceedings before the Deputy Registrar of Chits (ARC Nos. 309–314), in the absence of a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned, under Section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C.?
  2. Whether a final report filed by the police (on the basis of a private party's complaint) is maintainable, and the subsequent criminal proceedings sustainable, where Section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C. requires that a complaint in respect of documents used in court proceedings be made by the public servant concerned (here, the Deputy Registrar of Chits)?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The offences alleged in the final report (forgery and use of forged documents) concern documents that were produced or intended to be used in proceedings before the Deputy Registrar of Chits in ARC Nos. 309–314, which proceedings were pending.
  • Section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C. bars any Court from taking cognizance of offences alleged to have been committed in respect of documents produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any Court, except on a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned (here, the Deputy Registrar of Chits) or his subordinate.
  • Because no complaint in writing was made by the Deputy Registrar of Chits, the learned Magistrate erred in taking cognizance on the basis of the police final report (registered on the complaint by K. Venkatachalam, a party to those proceedings), and entertaining the criminal complaint amounts to an abuse of process; accordingly, the criminal proceedings must be quashed.
  • The petitioners relied on precedents (Daulat Ram v. State of Punjab; Sachida Nand Singh v. State of Bihar and its reference to a Larger Bench) to support the submission that Section 195 requires a complaint by the public servant concerned in such situations.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Daulat Ram v. State of Punjab, 1963 M.L.J. (Crl.) 164; (1963) 1 SCC 330; A.I.R. 1962 S.C. 1206 The requirement under Section 195 that no Court shall take cognizance of certain offences except on a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned; a Court taking cognizance without such a complaint is without jurisdiction ab initio. The opinion cites Daulat Ram to demonstrate that Section 195 is explicit and that cognizance by a Court without the requisite complaint of the public servant is improper; the Court applies this principle to the present facts to show that cognizance should have awaited a complaint by the Deputy Registrar of Chits.
Sachida Nand Singh v. State of Bihar, (1998) 2 SCC 493; (1998) S.C.C. (Crl.) 660 Interprets Section 195(1)(b): (i) there must be an allegation of an offence (e.g., forgery); and (ii) such offence should have been committed in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any Court; stresses narrow/strict interpretation where a provision curbs court jurisdiction. The Court relies on the two-postulate reading from Sachida Nand Singh to reinforce that the bar in Section 195(1)(b) applies where forgery is alleged in respect of documents used or produced in court proceedings, thereby supporting the view that the Deputy Registrar (as the public servant concerned) should file the complaint.
S.L.P. (Crl.) No. 4111 of 2000 (reference to a Larger Bench pursuant to issues raised in Sachida Nand Singh) Raised the question whether the bar under Section 195 applies where the allegation relates to a document which is the subject-matter of a pending probate (or similar) proceeding; indicates the matter was referred to a Larger Bench and directs procedural steps re appearance, bail and possible stay. The opinion records the Larger Bench reference and its procedural direction (appearance, bail application, possible stay and expeditious conclusion of the civil/probate-like proceedings). The Court refers to this sequence to show continued judicial treatment of the precise question concerning Section 195's application to pending proceedings.
Abdul Wahed Khan v. Bhavania (cited in Sachida Nand Singh) Canon of interpretation: a statutory provision curbing the general jurisdiction of the Court must normally receive strict interpretation unless context demands otherwise. The opinion notes the reference to this principle (as cited in Sachida Nand Singh) to justify a strict or narrow construction of Section 195 where it curtails the general jurisdiction of magistrates to take cognizance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds by reference to Section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C. and the authorities explaining its scope:

  1. Statutory bar under Section 195(1)(b): The court identifies that Section 195(1)(b) bars a Court from taking cognizance of offences committed in respect of documents produced or given in evidence in any proceeding in a Court, except upon a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned (or his subordinate). The court treats this bar as mandatory in the circumstances envisaged by the Section.
  2. Application of precedents: The court summarizes and relies on the reasoning in Daulat Ram (which held that cognizance without the complaint by the appropriate public servant is jurisdictionally improper) and Sachida Nand Singh (which articulates the two postulates for the operation of the bar under Section 195(1)(b) and endorses a narrow/strict interpretation of a provision that curbs court jurisdiction).
  3. Factual application to the case: Even on the assumption that the petitioners allegedly committed offences under Sections 467, 468 and 472 IPC in the proceedings before the Deputy Registrar of Chits (ARC Nos. 309–314 of 2001), those proceedings were pending and therefore, if Section 195 applies, only the Deputy Registrar (the public servant concerned) ought to have filed the requisite complaint in writing to enable criminal cognizance.
  4. Absence of complaint by public servant: The court notes that no complaint was forwarded by the Deputy Registrar of Chits. Instead, the criminal case proceeded on the complaint of K. Venkatachalam, a party to the administrative/chit proceedings. Given the statutory bar and the authorities cited, cognizance taken by the learned Magistrate on the police final report (originating from that private complaint) is treated as not maintainable.
  5. Conclusion from combined law and facts: Because the statutory prerequisite (a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned) was not satisfied, the final report filed by the police and the magistrate's subsequent cognizance of the offences were improper; accordingly, the criminal proceedings were liable to be quashed.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The proceedings in C.C. No. 18 of 2003 pending before the Judicial Magistrate No. 3, Coimbatore, are quashed and the Criminal Original Petition is allowed.

Consequences and immediate implications:

  • The criminal complaint registered as C.C. No. 18 of 2003 stood quashed and the connected criminal miscellaneous petitions were closed.
  • The direct effect is that the magistrate's proceedings founded on the police final report (originating from the private complainant) were set aside because the statutory mechanism under Section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C.—requiring a complaint in writing by the public servant concerned where the alleged offence relates to documents produced or given in evidence in a proceeding—had not been complied with.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any novel legal principle beyond applying existing authorities on Section 195; it does not state that a broader precedent is being newly established. The decision operates to quash the specific criminal proceedings on the factual and legal basis described above.

    K.C Palanisamy And Others v. State, Rep. By Inspector Of Police, City Crime Branch, Coimbatore City, Coimbatore

    This petition has been filed under Sec. 482 to quash the charge against the petitioners pending in C.C.No 18 of 2003 pending on the file of the Judicial Magistrate-Ill, Coimbatore.

    2. The brief facts of the case are as follows: The respondent police filed charge sheet against the petitioners alleging that with the common intention of committing offences of forgery of valuable securities and using them as genuine they filed the same before the Deputy Registrar of Chits, Coimbatore in ARC.Nos 309 to 314 of 2010 and thus A1 committed an offence under Sec. 467, I.P.C, read with 471, I.P.C and A-2 to A-4 under Sec. 467, read with 471 and 34, I.P.C

    3. The final report filed by the respondent has been taken on file as C.C.18 of 2003 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate III Coimbatore. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners is that the charge against the petitioners/accused should be quashed on the ground that even as per the averments made in the final report, the accused are alleged to have committed an offence under Secs.467,468 and 472 and also read with 34, Indian Penal Code with intent to use the forged documents as genuine in the false claim petition filed by Cheran Chit Funds Private Limited, against the complainant K. Venkatachalam before the Deputy Registrar of Chits, Coimbatore in ARC.Nos 309 to 314 of 2001. As per the final report itself, on 25.5.2002 the proceedings before the Deputy Registrar of Chits in ARC.Nos 309 to 314 of 201 are pending. In such circumstances, the learned Magistrate ought not to have taken cognizance of the offences alleged in the final report since taking cognizance of the offences alleged to have been committed in respect of the document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any Court is barred under Sec. 195(1)(b) of Crl.P.C Further, such a complaint shall be given only by the Court where the alleged documents have been used. Therefore, the cognizance taken by the leaned Magistrate is against the provisions of the Court and entertaining the very complaint itself is abuse of process of Court and the proceedings are liable to be quashed.

    4. Learned counsel would rely upon the decision reported in Daulat Ram v. State Of Punjab, 1963 M.L.J (Crl.) 164: (1963) 1 SCC 330: A.I.R 1962 S.C 1206, wherein the Supreme Court has held as follows: (Paras 3, 4)

    “3. The only question in this case is whether a complaint in writing as required by Sec. 195 had been presented by the public servant concerned. The public servant who was moved by the appellant was undoubtedly the Tahsildar. Whether the appellant wanted this Tahsildar to take action or not, the fact remains that he moved the Tahsildar on what is stated to be a false averments of facts. He had charged Hans Raj and Kans Raj with offences under the Penal Code and he moved his superior officer for action even though he might have stated in the letter that it was only for his information. We are prepared to assume that he expected that some action would be taken. In fact his second letter that he had compromised the matter and the proceedings might be dropped clearly shows that he anticipated some action on the part of his superior officer. The question is therefore whether under the provisions of Sec. 195, it was not incumbent on the Tahsildar to present as complaint in writing against the appellant and not leave the Court to be moved by the police by putting in a charge sheet. The words of Sec. 195 of the Criminal Procedure Code are explicit. The Section reads as follows:

    “(1) No Court shall take cognizance— (a) of any offence punishable under Sees. 172 to 188 of the Indian Penal Code, except on the complaint in writing of the public servant concerned, or of some other public servant to whom he is subordinate;

    ………”

    The words of the Section, namely, that the complaint has to be in writing by the public servant concerned and that no Court shall take cognizance except on such a complaint clearly show that in every instance the Court must be moved by the appropriate public servant. We have to decide therefore whether the Tahsildar can be said to be the public servant concerned and if he had not filed the complaint in writing, whether the police officers in filing the charge sheet had satisfied the requirements of Sec. 195. The words “no Court shall take cognizance” have been interpreted on more than one occasion and they show that there is an absolute bar against the Court taking seisin of the case except in the manner provided by the Section.

    4. Now the offence under Sec. 182 of the Penal Code, if any, was undoubtedly complete when the appellant had moved the Tahsildar for action. Sec. 182 does not require that action must always be taken if the person who moves the public servant knows or believes that action would be taken. In making his report to the Tahsildar therefore, if the appellant believed that some action would be taken (and he had no reason to doubt that it would not) the offence under that Section was complete. It was therefore incumbent, if the prosecution was to be launched, that the complaint in writing should be made by the Tahsildar as the public servant concerned in this case. On the other hand what we find is that a complaint by the Tahsildar was not filed at all, but a charge sheet was put in by the Station House Officer. The learned counsel for the State Government tries to support the action by submitting that Sec. 195 had been complied with inasmuch as when the allegations had been disproved the letter of the Superintendent of Police was forwarded to the Tahsildar and he asked for “a calendar”, (sic) This paper was filed along with the charge sheet and it is stated that this satisfies the requirements of Sec. 195. In our opinion, this is not a due compliance with the provisions of that Section. What the Section contemplates is that the complaint must be in writing by the public servant concerned and there is no such compliance in the present case. The cognizance of the case was therefore wrongly assumed by the Court without the complaint in writing of the public servant namely the Tahsildar in this case. The trial was thus without jurisdiction ab initio and the conviction cannot be maintained.”

    Subsequently in the decisions reported Sachida Nand Singh v. State of Bihar, (1998) 2 SCC 493: (1998) S.C.C (Crl.) 660, wherein the Supreme Court has held as follows: (Paras 6, 7)

    “6. A reading of the clause reveals two main postulates for operation of the bar mentioned there. First is, there must be allegation that an offence (it should be either an offence described in Sec. 463 or any other offences punishable under Secs.471, 475, 476 of the I.P.C) has been committed. Second is that such offence should have been committed in respect of document produced or given in evidences in a proceeding in any Court. There is no dispute before us that if forgery has been committed while the document was in the custody of a Court, then prosecution can be launched only with a complaint made by that Court. There is also no dispute that if forgery was committed with a document, which has not been produced in a Court then the prosecution would lie at the instance of any person. If so, will its production in a Court make all the difference?

    7. Even if a clause is capable of two interpretations we are inclined to choose the narrower interpretation for obvious reasons. Sec. 190 of the Code empowers “any Magistrate of the first class” to take cognizance of ‘any offence’ upon receiving a complaint, or police report or information or upon his own knowledge. Sec. 195 restricts such general powers of the Magistrate, and the general right of a person to move the Court with a complaint is to that extent curtailed. It is well-recognised canon of interpretation that provision curbing the general jurisdiction of the Court must normally receive strict interpretation unless the statute or the context requires otherwise (Abdul Wahed Khan v. Bhavania).”

    Thereafter in S.L.P (Crl.) No. 4111 of 2000 the said case was referred to a Larger Bench by a Bench of Hon'ble three Judges wherein the Supreme Court has held as follows:

    “The question for consideration in this case is whether though the allegation in the complaint filed relates to an act of forgery of document which is the subject matter of a pending probate proceeding, bar under Sec. 195, Crl.P.C, for taking cognizance would apply or not. In Sachida Nand Singh v. State of Bihar, (1998) S.C.C (Crl.) 660: (1998) 2 SCC 493, the three Judge Bench of this Court have come to a conclusion that unless and until the alleged forgery is said to have been committed in respect of a document, which was in the custody of the Court, then the bar under Sec. 195 will not get attracted. This broad conclusion has not taken into consideration as to how the alternative in Sec. 195(1)(b)(ii) of the Code of Criminal Procedure was given evidence in a proceeding could be construed. In the aforesaid premises, we think it appropriate that the matter should be referred to a larger Bench and the records of the proceeding may be placed before Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India for constituting a larger Bench to consider this question. Pursuance to the summons issued in the complaint case, the accused must appear before the Magistrate and then apply for bail and on such an application for bail being filed, he may be released on bail. The further proceeding in the criminal case may thereafter be stayed. The probate proceeding may come to logical conclusion as expeditiously as possible.”

    5. From the above said decisions it is clear that under Sec. 195(1)(b) of Crl.P.C, no Court shall take cognizance of any offence punishable under Sees. 172 to 188 of the Indian Penal Code, except on the complaint in writing of the public servant concerned, or of some other public servant to whom he is subordinate. So far as the case on hand is concerned, even assuming that the petitioners committed offence under Secs.467,468 and 472, I.P.C before the Deputy Registrar of Chits in the Proceedings ARC.Nos 309-314 of 2001 which is still pending, only the concerned Deputy Registrar of Chits should have filed a complaint based on which charge should have been framed against the petitioners/accused. But, no such complaint has been forwarded by the said Deputy Registrar of Chits, Coimbatore. A case has been registered on the complaint of one K. Venkatachalam who is a party to the proceedings in ARC.Nos 309 to 314 of 2001 said to be pending. Therefore in such circumstances, the final report filed by the respondent police is not maintainable since the Court cannot take cognizance of the offences, unless the same is complained in writing by the public servant concerned, i.e, the Deputy Registrar of Chits, Coimbatore in this case. Therefore, the proceedings in C.C.No 18 of 2003 pending before the Judicial Magistrate No. 3, Coimbatore is liable to be quashed. Accordingly the same is quashed. The Crl.O.P is allowed. Consequently the concerned Crl.M.Ps are closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.C Palanisamy And O... v. State, Rep. By Inspe...
    (Mar 23, 2004)