Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • BANKING PUBLIC FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS AND NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS LAWS AMENDMENT ACT 1988
  • Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act read with Section 179 Cr.P.C
  • provisions of Negotiable Instruments Act and Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • SECTION 138 NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
  • Sections 178 (b) and 178 (d) Cr.P.C Both Sections 178 (b) and 178 (d) Cr.P.C,
  • SECTION 142 NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
  • Sections 178 and 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act,
  • Section of law (138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act),
  • Section 138 (b) of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • Section 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • provision of Sections 178 (b) and 179 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 138 (c) Negotiable Instruments Act,
  • clause (c) of the provision to Section 138,
  • Section 178 (d) Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Sections 178 and 179 of the Code
  • Sections 177 to 179 Cr.P.C
  • Section 178 (b) Cr.P.C
  • Section 179 Cr.P.C
  • Section 482 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 177 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 178 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 138 (b),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • BANKING PUBLIC FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS AND NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS LAWS AMENDMENT ACT 1988
  • Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act read with Section 179 Cr.P.C
  • provisions of Negotiable Instruments Act and Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • SECTION 138 NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
  • Sections 178 (b) and 178 (d) Cr.P.C Both Sections 178 (b) and 178 (d) Cr.P.C,
  • SECTION 142 NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT
  • Sections 178 and 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act,
  • Section of law (138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act),
  • Section 138 (b) of the Negotiable Instruments Act
  • Section 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • provision of Sections 178 (b) and 179 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 138 (c) Negotiable Instruments Act,
  • clause (c) of the provision to Section 138,
  • Section 178 (d) Criminal Procedure Code,
  • Sections 178 and 179 of the Code
  • Sections 177 to 179 Cr.P.C
  • Section 178 (b) Cr.P.C
  • Section 179 Cr.P.C
  • Section 482 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 177 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 178 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 138 (b),
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Two criminal original petitions (Crl.O.P. Nos. 5067 and 5068 of 1996) were filed to quash complaints registered as C.C. Nos. 2685 and 3661 of 1994 before the XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Madras. The petitioners (a company and its Managing Director located in New Delhi) entered a hire-purchase agreement with the complainant company whose registered office was at Chamiers Road, Madras. The petitioners issued two cheques (dated 12-11-1993 for Rs. 50,000 and 17-3-1994 for Rs. 2,10,000), drawn on New Delhi banks, which on presentation were returned unpaid with the endorsement "funds insufficient."

The complainant served statutory notices, from its Madras office, demanding payment within fifteen days. The petitioners did not reply or pay, and complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act were filed in Madras. The learned Magistrate recorded the complainant's sworn statement, issued summons which the petitioners did not answer, and subsequently issued non-bailable warrants. The petitioners then moved the High Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeking quashing of the proceedings primarily on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction of the Madras courts.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is maintainable to quash criminal proceedings where the trial Court allegedly lacks territorial jurisdiction.
  2. Whether the Madras courts had territorial jurisdiction to take cognizance and try offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act in the present facts (cheques issued/presented/dishonoured in New Delhi but statutory notices issued from the complainant's Madras registered office).
  3. How Sections 177–179 Cr.P.C., and Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, interact to determine territorial jurisdiction in cheque dishonour cases where acts and consequences occur in different localities.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Ranka)

  • The agreement was entered into in New Delhi; the cheques were issued, presented and dishonoured in New Delhi. Therefore, only courts in New Delhi have territorial jurisdiction to take the complaints on file.
  • Taking cognizance by the Madras Court is without jurisdiction; accordingly the proceedings are liable to be quashed under the High Court's inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
  • Several authorities were cited to support the contention that jurisdiction lies where the acts constituting the offence occurred and therefore the Madras process is illegal and without jurisdiction.

Respondent's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. V. Padmanabhan)

  • Proceedings under Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act, for which cognizance has been taken by the Court below, cannot be quashed at this stage under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
  • Citing Sections 178 and 179 Cr.P.C., the respondent submitted that an offence consisting of several acts done in different local areas may be tried by a Court having jurisdiction over any such area; the offence under Section 138 involves various acts and the cause of action arises only after expiry of 15 days from service of notice.
  • Since the statutory notice was issued from the Madras office, the cause of action (and hence jurisdiction) arose at Madras as well; therefore Madras courts also have jurisdiction to try the case.
  • The respondent relied upon multiple authorities to support these submissions regarding the scope of jurisdiction and maintainability of the proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jai Parkash v. Dinesh Dayal and Another (1991 Crl.L.J 418) Cited on territorial jurisdiction: where agreement and dealings occur determines appropriate forum. Referenced as authority supporting petitioners' contention that venue must reflect where dealings occurred; considered among other cases but not determinative here.
Ravindra Sonusing Patil & Another v. Rajendera Pandit Patil & Others (1991 Crl.L.J 963) Territorial jurisdiction where documents were executed/acts occurred. Cited by petitioners to support jurisdiction at place where acts (e.g., execution) occurred; court summarized the decision and considered it in analysis.
Madavrao Jiwaji Rao Scindia (AIR 1988 SC 709) One of two Apex Court decisions cited by petitioners' authorities (context: limitations on resort to inherent powers). Listed among higher court authorities cited; the opinion did not elaborate the specific principle from this decision beyond its citation.
State of Bihar v. Murad Ali Khan (AIR 1989 SC 1) Cited as Apex Court precedent in support of counsel's submissions. Referenced among authorities; text does not detail the specific rule applied from this decision in the opinion's reasoning.
M/s Ess Bee Food Specialities & Others v. M/s Kapoor Brothers (1992 Crl.L.J 739) Held that issuance/dishonour of cheques are part of cause of action but offence completes when debtor fails to discharge liability; venue can be where creditor's office is located. Used by court to support proposition that the place where the creditor demands payment (here Madras office) may give jurisdiction; court relied on this reasoning in concluding Madras had jurisdiction.
Dynamatic Forgings India Ltd. & Another v. Nagarjuna Investment Trusts Ltd. & Another (1993 Crl.L.J 1206) Application of Sections 178 and 179 Cr.P.C.: part of cause of action arising at place where cheque was presented/ dishonoured gives that place jurisdiction. Cited by petitioners; court examined this and similar decisions in assessing whether jurisdiction lay in New Delhi or Madras.
J. Veeraraghavan v. Lalith Kumar (1994 (2) L.W (Crl.) 663) Authority cited by respondent concerning non-quashability and procedure under NI Act. Referenced by respondent; court considered it among authorities supporting that proceedings under Section 138 ordinarily should not be quashed at interlocutory stage.
State of Maharashtra v. Ishwar Piraji Kalpatri & Others (1996 SCC (Crl.) 150) Cited regarding criminal procedure and maintainability of proceedings. Referenced by respondent; the opinion lists it among cases bearing on maintainability and jurisdiction but does not extract a unique rule beyond that context.
State of Orissa v. Bansidhar Singh (1996 SCC (Crl.) 259) Authority cited by respondent on procedural/ jurisdictional points. Listed among authorities relied upon by respondent; court considered overall jurisprudence including this case in its reasoning.
Musthaq Ahmad v. Mohd. Habibur Rehman Faizi & Others (1996 SCC (Crl.) 443) Authority on criminal procedural matters cited by respondent. Referenced in respondent's list; treated as part of corpus of decisions the court weighed in framing principles on jurisdiction and quashing.
State Of U.P v. O.P Sharma (1996 SCC (Crl.) 497) Authority cited by respondent on procedural/ jurisdictional principles. Included among respondent's citations; court included it in the broader review of authority without extracting a bespoke holding for the facts.
State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal (A.I.R 1992 S.C 604) Principle: Section 482 Cr.P.C. may be exercised where there is an express legal bar to institution or continuance of proceedings or to prevent abuse of process. Cited as articulating the "crux" used to consider when quashing is appropriate; court relied on the Bhajan Lal principle to accept that S.482 can be invoked where jurisdiction is lacking.
P.K. Murakedharan v. C.K. Pareed (1993 (1) Crimes 46) — "Muraleedharan's case" Held that cause of action under Section 142 arises where the drawer fails to make payment; venue can include place where cheque was issued/delivered or where money is payable; averments in complaint matter. Quoted and relied upon by the court for the proposition that averments in complaint as to where the offence took place are significant and that cause of action may be where money is payable; supported Madras jurisdiction conclusion.
Om Prakash Ummat, Proprietor, M/s Techni Science Industries v. VII Metropolitan Magistrate George Town, Madras-I (1990 M.L.J (Crl.) 76) Applied Sections 178 and 179 Cr.P.C. to hold that courts in place where consequence occurs (e.g., bank where cheque presented) have jurisdiction. Used by petitioners; court reviewed that decision among others concerning venue where consequences ensued.
Hamosons Apparels Pvt. Ltd. v. Sivan Textiles (1994 (1) Crimes 427) Section 138(b): notice issuance location can confer jurisdiction; where notice issued and payment would be made, that place has jurisdiction under Section 178 Cr.P.C. Cited by respondent and relied upon by the court as precedent supporting jurisdiction where notice giving and demand occurred (here Madras).
Tarsem Lal v. Prem Nath Palta (1995 Crl.L.J 2408) Illustrated that place where cheques were presented, dishonour intimated and notices sent could determine jurisdiction (Moga court had jurisdiction in that case). Referenced by respondent to show that multiple locales connected to the transaction can support jurisdiction where notice/ consequences were experienced; considered in the court's evaluation.
M.M. Malik v. Prem Kumar Goyal (1992 (Supple.) M.W.N (Cr.) 4) Observed that Section 138 offence is complete when drawer fails to make payment within 15 days of notice; cause of action completed on expiry of notice period. Quoted by the court to support the proposition that dishonour is part of the cause of action and the offence completes only after expiry of the notice period.
State of M.P v. K.P Ghaira (AIR 1957 SC 196) Authority on determining venue of enquiry by reference to averments in the complaint. Referred to by the court (via Muraleedharan case) as precedent for the proposition that the complaint's averments are primary in determining venue.
M/s Deepee Shoe Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s Pallava Leathers & Products (1997-1-L.W (Crl.) 205) Held that place where notice was issued gives rise to jurisdiction; Section 178 Cr.P.C. applies where offence is committed partly in multiple local areas. Cited by respondent and considered by the court as supporting the proposition that notice-issuing place (Madras) could confer jurisdiction to try the complaint.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two broad steps: first to consider whether the High Court's inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. could be invoked to quash proceedings for lack of jurisdiction; second to resolve whether the Madras Court in fact lacked territorial jurisdiction.

1. Maintainability of petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C.: The court accepted the petitioners' submission that Section 482 may be validly invoked where a court has no jurisdiction to take a case on file or proceed with trial. The court relied on settled principle (as reiterated in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal) that Section 482 can be exercised where an express legal bar exists or to prevent abuse of process; therefore the petition was maintainable on jurisdictional grounds.

2. Legal framework examined: The court examined relevant statutory provisions—Sections 177–179 Cr.P.C., and Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act—to determine where an offence under Section 138 is to be tried when different parts of the transaction occurred in different localities.

3. Nature of cause of action under Section 138: The court emphasized that the cause of action for an offence under Section 138 crystallizes only after the drawer fails to make payment within fifteen days of receipt of the statutory notice (per proviso to Section 138 and Section 142). The dishonour of the cheque and the earlier acts (issuance, presentation, return) are parts of the cause of action but the offence becomes complete upon failure to pay after notice.

4. Application of Section 179 Cr.P.C.: The court found Section 179 Cr.P.C. particularly apt: where an offence arises by reason of something done and a consequence which ensued, the offence may be tried where the act was done or where the consequence ensued. The court explained that Section 179 applies where the act and its consequence together constitute the offence; if consequence is a necessary part of the offence, jurisdiction may lie where that consequence ensued.

5. Factual application: Applying these principles to the facts, the court observed the following (as supported by the record and the complaints):

  • The hire-purchase agreement bore connections to both Delhi and Madras (complainant's registered office at Madras and petitioners in Delhi).
  • Issuance/presentation/dishonour of cheques occurred in New Delhi, but the statutory notices demanding payment were issued from the complainant's Registered Office at Madras, demanding payment to Madras.
  • The complaint averred that "The offence has taken place within the jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court" (Madras).

6. Synthesis and conclusion: Taken together, the court concluded that the consequence (demand from Madras and failure to make payment at Madras) was a necessary part of the offence under Section 138. Precedents (including Ess Bee, Hamosons Apparels, Deepee Shoe Fabrics, and Muraleedharan) supported the proposition that where notice is issued from a place and payment is demanded there, that place may have jurisdiction. Accordingly, the Madras Court also had jurisdiction to try the offences; there was no jurisdictional bar warranting quashing of proceedings.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petitions under Section 482 Cr.P.C. are DISMISSED.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The criminal complaints filed in C.C. Nos. 2685 and 3661 of 1994 before the XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Madras, shall continue; there is no basis to quash them on territorial jurisdiction grounds in the circumstances of this case.
  • The petitioners, who had non-bailable warrants issued against them by the trial Court, were directed to surrender before the trial Court and to file applications to recall the warrants; such recall applications are to be considered by the trial Court according to law.
  • The trial Court was directed to dispose of the cases as expeditiously as possible (these matters had been pending since 1994).

The opinion confines its discussion to the application of extant statutory provisions and existing authorities to the facts; it does not purport to lay down any broader novel precedent beyond applying established principles on jurisdiction, Section 179 Cr.P.C., and the completion of offence under Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act.

    Narang Industries Ltd. Rep. By Its Managing Director And Another v. Ashok Leyland Finance Ltd., Rep. By Its Executive (Legal)

    Both these Crl.O.P Nos. 5067 and 5068 of 1996, filed against C.C Nos. 2685 and 3661 of 1994, on the file of the XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Madras, respectively, could be disposed of by a common order, as the parties as well as the issue involved are one and the same in both these proceedings.

    2. The petitioners 1 and 2, the company, as well as its Managing Director, having office at Vasant Vihar, New Delhi, approached the respondent, the complainant company, having its main office at Chamiers Road, Madras-18, and entered into an agreement on a hire purchase scheme, agreeing to pay the hire dues regularly as per the schedule for the purchase of redistillation plants.

    3. Towards the part settlement of hire dues, the petitioners issued two cheques on two different dated, one cheque dated 12-11-1993 for Rs. 50,000/- drawn on Canara Bank, Diplomatic Enclave, New Delhi, and another dated 17-3-1994 for Rs. 2,1,000/- drawn on State Bank of Hyderabad, Pragati Vihar, New Delhi. On due dates, the complainant, presented the above cheques for encashment through their bankers, viz. State Bank of India, New Delhi, but the same were returned unpaid with the endorsement “funds insufficient”. Therefore, in respect of these two cheques, separate statutory notices were sent on different dates, from the office at Madras, demanding for repayment of the cheques amount, within fifteen days from the date of the said notices. Though notices were received by the petitioners they did not choose to reply, nor make any payment. Therefore, within the stipulated time, the complainant, the respondent herein, filed the above complaints before the learned Magistrate, which were taken on file in C.C No. 2685 and 3661 of 1994, by the learned XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Madras-15.

    4. The learned Magistrate, after having taken on file, on recording the sworn statement of the complainant, issued summons to the petitioners. Since they did not appear, learned Metropolitan Magistrate issued non-bailable warrant against the petitioners. On receipt of information about the issuance of non-bailable warrant, the petitioners have, now directly moved this Court by filing these above applications, requesting this Court to invoke the inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C, and quash the above proceedings.

    5. Mr. Ranka, learned counsel for the petitioners, elaborately argued, mainly on the point of jurisdiction. According to the learned counsel, the agreement was entered into between the parties at New Delhi, the cheques were issued at New Delhi, and the same were presented and dishonoured at New Delhi, and that therefore, the Court at New Delhi alone will have the jurisdiction to take the complaint on file, and as such, taking congnizance for these offences by the Court at Madras, is without jurisdiction, and so, the proceedings are liable to be quashed. Learned counsel also cited several authorities to support his submission with reference to the power under Section 482 Cr.P.C, to quash the proceedings, which is illegal and without jurisdiction.

    The authorities are :—

    Jai Parkash v. Dinesh Dayal and Another, 1991 Crl.L.J 418

    Ravindra Sonusing Patil and Another v. Rajendera Pandit Patil and Others, 1991 Crl.L.J 963

    Wherein the following two decisions of the Apex Court had been cited:

    Madavrao Jiwaji Rao Scindia's case, AIR 1988 SC 709: 1988 Crl.L.J 853

    State of Bihar v. Murad Ali Khan, AIR 1989 SC 1: 1989 Crl.L.J 1005

    M/s Ess Bee Food Specialities and Others v. M/s Kapoor Brothers, 1992 Crl.L.J 739

    Dynamatic Forgings India Ltd. and Another v. Nagarjuna Investment Trusts Ltd. and Another, 1993 Crl.L.J 1206

    6. Per contra, Mr. V. Padmanabhan, learned counsel for the respondent, by citing several authorities, strenuously submitted that the proceedings initiated by the complainant under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, on which cognizance has been validly taken by the Court below, cannot be quashed at this stage, under Section 482 Cr.P.C

    The authorities are :—

    (1) J. Veeraraghavan v. Lalith Kumar, 1994 (2) L.W (Crl.) 663

    (2) State of Maharashtra v. Ishwar Piraji Kalpatri and Others, 1996 SCC (Crl.) 150

    (3) State Of Orissa v. Bansidhar Singh, 1996 SCC (Crl.) 259

    (4) Musthaq Ahmad v. Mohd. Habibur Rehman Faizi and Others, 1996 SCC (Crl.) 443

    (5) State Of U.P v. O.P Sharma., 1996 SCC (Crl.) 497

    7. The Crux of the authorities cited by both, as reiterated in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, (A.I.R 1992 S.C 604), is that “Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and continuance of the proceedings, exercised in order to prevent the abuse of process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice.”

    8. On applying the above analogy, it is quite evident that when the Court has no jurisdiction to take the case on file and to proceed with the trial, the inherent power of this Court can be validly exercised to prevent the continuance of the proceedings, which was, without jurisdiction, as it amounts to bar of jurisdiction. Therefore, I am not able to persuade myself to accept the objection raised by Mr. V. Padmanabhan, learned counsel for the respondent, with regard to the maintainability of this petition filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C As far as this point is concerned, I hold in favour of the submission made by Mr. Ranka, as in my view, the position is maintainable.

    8 (a). Let me now endeavour in the process of appreciating the next question posed in this case, with reference to the jurisdiction :—

    (i) A perusal of the records filed before this Court would reveal that the agreement entered into between the parties was at New Delhi. The issuance of cheques, the presentation and the dishonour of the same were also at New Delhi.

    (ii) Under Section 177 Cr.P.C, “every offence shall ordinarily be inquired into and tried by Court within whose local jurisdiction it was committed.

    (iii) Under these circumstances, learned counsel for the petitioners would with vehemence submit that each and every transaction culminated into an offence had taken place only in New Delhi, and as such, the proceedings initiated before the Court at Madras, is without jurisdiction and the same is liable to be quashed.

    (iv) On the contra, Mr. V. Padmanabhan, learned counsel for the respondent would submit that under Section 178 Cr.P.C, if an offence consists of several acts done in different local areas, it may be enquired into or tried by a Court having jurisdiction over any of such local areas, and an offence under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, consists of various acts and mere dishonour itself is not an offence, and the cause of action arises only after the expiry of 15 days, after service of notice on the accused, calling upon him to pay the amount due under the dishonoured cheque, and as such, every transaction prior to the cause of action arises put together constitutes an offence, and as such, since the issue of statutory notice was admittedly done from Madras office, the Court at Madras also has got jurisdiction to try the case. Both the Counsel cited authorities in support of their respective submissions.

    9. Let me now consider the decisions cited by learned counsel for the petitioner, with reference to the question of jurisdiction :—

    (a) In P.K Murakedharan v. C.K Pareed and Another, (1993 (1) Crimes 46), the High Court of Kerala, has held as follows: —

    “The place where the creditor resides or the place where the debtor resides cannot be said to be the place of payment unless there is any indication to that effect either expressly or impliedly. The cause of action as contemplated in Section 142 of the Act arises at the place where the drawer of the cheque fails to make payment of the money. That can be the place where the bank to which the cheque was issued is located. It can also be the place where the cheque was issued or delivered. The Court within whose jurisdiction any of the above mentioned places falls has, therefore, got jurisdiction to try the offence under Section 138 of the Act.”

    (b) The next decision, which the learned counsel for petitioner referred is reported in 1991 Crl.L.J 418 (Jai Parkash v. Kinesh Dayal and Another), wherein the Delhi High Court has held as follows :—

    “In the present case also, it will be seen that the agreement between the parties i.e the Company of the petitioner and the branch office of respondent No. 2 at Bhadohi was entered into at Bhadohi. Simply because the head office of respondent No. 2 closeted at New Delhi, it will not furnish any cause for filing any criminal complaint against the petitioner to respondent No. 2 at New Delhi because there were actually no dealings between the company of the petitioner at Bhadohi and the head office of respondent No. 2 at New Delhi”.

    (c) The next decision relied on by learned counsel is reported in 1993 Crl.L.J 1206 (Dynamatic Forgings India Ltd. and Another v. Nagarjuna Investment Trusts Ltd. and Another), in which the High Court of Andhra Pradesh, has held as follows :—

    “It is to be seen that the office of the first respondent is located at Nagarjuna Hills, Hyderabad over which the 5th Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad has jurisdiction. The cheque was issue in favour of the first respondent company with head office at Nagarjuna Hills, Hyderabad, the said cheque was presented at Hyderabad for collection and consequently part of the cause of action arose at Hyderabad by virtue of Sections 178 and 179 of the Code and consequently the Court at Hyderabad have got jurisdiction to try the offence.”

    (d) In Ravindra Sonusing Patil and Another v. Smt. Rajendra Pandit Patil and Others, (1991 Crl.L.J 963), the Bombay High Court, observed thus :—

    “In the present petition filed by the accused there is no dispute raised with regard to the execution of the two documents in question at Bombay, and therefore, it will have to be held that since the documents were executed at the residence of the complainant, that regardless of the fact of the partnership property and business being located at Jalgaon that as far as the present complaint is concerned that the Bombay Court before which it has been filed did have jurisdiction to entertain the complaint. Section 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure very clearly specifies that an offence is triable at the place where the act is done or the consequence ensures. In the present case, the allegation is to the effect that the complainant was induced to sign the consent letter at her residence at Bombay and consequently, since the act of signing has taken place at Bombay, the local Court at Bombay would have jurisdiction to entertain and try this complaint.”

    (e) Learned counsel also cited a decision in the case of M/s Ess Bee Food Specialities and Others v. M/s Kapoor Brothers, (1992 Crl.L.J 739), where in the Punjab & Haryana High Court, held as hereunder :—

    “Coming to the question of jurisdiction, it is to be considered that the issuance of the cheques and their dishonouring are only a part of cause of action, the offence was complete only when the petitioners failed to discharge their liability to the respondent/firm. For discharging a debt, it is the debtor who has to find out his creditor and since in the present case, the respondent, who is the creditor, has its office at Panchkula, the Court at Ambala had the territorial jurisdiction to try the offence complained of.”

    (f) The next decision cited by learned counsel is reported in 1990 M.L.J (Crl.) 76 (Om Prakash Ummat, Proprietor, M/s Techni Science Industries v. The Honourable VII Metropolitan Magistrate George Town, Madras-I), in which this Court has held as follows :—

    “In so far as the jurisdiction of the criminal court in inquiry and trials, Sections 178 and 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, without any doubt, indicate that in a contingency of this type, the Court situate in a place where the consequence had occurred, has jurisdiction to try and dispose of the case. If that be so, the complaint filed by the petitioner will have to be entertained by the VII Metropolitan Magistrate within whose jurisdiction, Karur Vysya Bank is situate and which bank is the banker of the petitioner.”

    10. On the strength of these decision, it is pointed out by learned counsel for the petitioners that the transactions, such as issuance of cheques, presentation, dishonour, and the agreement entered into, were taken place only at New Delhi and as such, the Court at Madras has no jurisdiction to entertain the complaint and issue process against the petitioners.

    11. Mr. V. Padmanabhan, learned counsel for the respondent, in support of his plea, referred earlier, cited very many authorities, to point out the scope and object of the Act, the procedure to be adopted, the manner of conducting the trial relating to the offences under this Act, and with reference to the jurisdiction. Since the question of jurisdiction is mainly argued in this petition by learned counsel for the petitioner, it would suffice to refer about the Judgments relating to the jurisdiction point alone.

    (a) Learned counsel for the respondent cited a decision in Hamosons Apparels Pvt. Ltd. v. Sivan Textiles (M/S), (1994 (1) Crimes 427), wherein this Court, observed as follows :—

    “As per Section 138 (b), the payee making a demand for the payment of the said amount of money by giving a notice in writing to the drawer of the cheque is one requisite. In Page 3 of the typed set, filed by the petitioner, copy of notice sent by the respondent herein is filed. From it, I find that it was issued at Erode on 13-4-1991. As such the notice contemplated under Section 138 (b) of the Negotiable Instruments Act and which is a requisite for making out the offence was issued at Erode. Under Section 178 (d) Criminal Procedure Code, the Court at Erode also has got jurisdiction to try the case. Furthermore, as per Section 138 (c) Negotiable Instruments Act, if there is failure to make the payment of the said amount within 15 days of the receipt of notice, the complaint is to be filed. The respondent is at Erode. The payment which is to be made within 15 days of receipt of notice can be made only at Erode. In this view of the matter also a part which constitute offence would be only at Erode.”

    (b) The Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of Tarsem Lal… v. Prem Nath Palta…. (1995 Crl.L.J 2408), has held that “in the present case the cheques were issued at Mega and these were presented by the respondent for collection of payment to State Bank of Patiala at Moga. The cheques were dishonoured by the State Bank of India, Jalandhar, but intimation of dishonour was received at Moga. Notices were sent by the respondent to make payment at Moga. Moga court had therefore, jurisdiction to try the case.”

    (c) The next decision referred by learned counsel for the respondent is reported in 1992 (Supple.) M.W.N (Cr.) 53, wherein the High Court of Karnataka, has held as follows :—

    “The offence falling under Section 138 of the Act will not be the only solitary act of dishonour by the Bank on which the cheque is drawn. Even giving of the cheque by the accused when he has not made arrangements for honouring of the cheque itself will be a part of the facts constituting the offence. Section 178 (b) Cr.P.C lays down that when an offence is committed partly in one local area and partly in another area, it may be enquired into and tried by a Court having jurisdiction over any of such local areas. Under Section 179 Cr.P.C when an act is an offence by reason of anything which has been done and of a consequence which has ensued, the offence may be inquired into or tired by a Court within whose local jurisdiction such thing has been done or such consequences has ensued. Giving the cheque by the accused to the complainant and giving the cheque for collection by the complainant to its Banker at Bangalore will also be the facts constituting the offence. Therefore, in view of the provision of Sections 178 (b) and 179 Cr.P.C, the complaint can be filed in a Court within the jurisdiction of which the cheque has been issued or the place where the cheque is presented for collection or the place where the cheque is not honoured.”

    (d) In a recent decision reported in 1997-1-L.W. (Crl.) 205 (M/s Deepee Shoe Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. rep. by their Director, Meenakshi Natarajan v. M/s Pallava Leathers & Products, rep by their Partner, P. Srinivasan) while considering this point on similar situation, by quoting Section 178 Cr.P.C, and Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, held that the place at which notice was issued also would have jurisdiction to try the complaint. The relevant observations are as follows :—

    “It therefore follows that the above provision of law (Sec. 178 Cr.P.C) provides the jurisdiction for inquiry or trial to be conducted by the courts when it is uncertain in which or several local areas an offence was committed and the offence was committed partly in one area and partly in another and when such offence is a continuing one in more local areas than one or otherwise by the Court having jurisdiction over any of such local areas.

    It would clearly mean from the wordings of the above Section of law (138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act), that in the place where the legal notice is given to the drawer of the negotiable instrument making the demand to pay and in the event of which has not been complied with, would also give rise to a cause of action for the purpose of the existence of the debt or other liability as provided in the explanation added to the above Section.

    12. From a careful reading of the citations referred above it could be seen that only two authorities would refer about the situation, in which the similar question has been raised. They are: (1) 1994 (1) Crimes 427-the decision rendered by Justice Pratap Singh; and (2) 1997 (1) L.W (Crl.) 205-the decision rendered by Justice N. Arumugham, by referring Sections 178 (b) and 178 (d) Cr.P.C Both Sections 178 (b) and 178 (d) Cr.P.C, would relate to the several acts constituting offences, partly in one local area and partly in another area.

    13. It is quite relevant at this stage, to refer about Section 179 Cr.P.C, which has not been considered in the above decisions. In my view, Section 179 Cr.P.C, is more relevant to solve the situation arose with reference to the facts of this case. Section 179 Cr.P.C, runs as follows :—

    “179. Offence triable where act is done or consequence ensues :— When an act is an offence by reason of anything which has been done and of a consequence which has ensued, the offence maybe inquired into or tried by a Court within whose local jurisdiction such thing has been done or such consequence has ensued.”

    14. In order to understand the applicability of the concept enshrined in Section 179 Cr.P.C, let me first endeavour to collect the relevant provisions of Negotiable Instruments Act and Code of Criminal Procedure, in the process of determining the issue of jurisdiction.

    (a) Section 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, provides that “no Court shall take cognizance of any offence punishable under Section 138 except upon a complaint in writing, made by the payee or, as the case may be, the holder in due course of the cheque, made within one month of the date on which the cause of action arises under clause (c) of the provision to Section 138, before the Metropolitan Magistrate or Judicial Magistrate of the First class.

    (b) A reading of Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, would make it crystal clear that the cause of action arises only when the drawer of the cheque fails to pay the amount to the payee or holder in due course of the cheque, as the case may be within fifteen days of the receipt of notice of demand, provided in clause (b) of the proviso to Section 138 of the said Act.

    (c) As envisaged under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the omission to pay the amount on demand by issue of a notice, after return of a cheque, is an offence. An ‘offence’ as defined in S. 2 (n) of the Code includes not only the doing of a positive act but by omitting to do something as well. In the instant case, it is an omission to pay the amount on demand by issue of notice, after cheque was returned, mat is made an offence.

    (d) Drawing the cheque is not the act by which the offence is deemed to have been committed. When the drawer fails to make the payment within the period specified in Clause (c) of the proviso, the offence is complete. This aspect is made further clear in S. 142 (b) of the Act. Under the said clause, no Court shall take cognizance of any offence punishable under Section 138 of the Act, unless “such complaint is made within one month of the date on which the cause of action arises under Clause (c) of the proviso to S. 138”. Normally cause of action does not arise until the commission of the offence. When S. 142 (C) says that the cause of action is the one which arises under clause (c) of the proviso, such cause of action is the omission to make payment within fifteen days of the receipt of the notice.

    (e) However, this cause of action is a product of several parts of an offence, such as dishonour of a cheque, notice for payment of cheque issued, in conformity with the clause (b) of the proviso to Section 138 of the Act, and expiry of the period for payment as envisaged in clause (1) of the proviso to Section 138 of the Act. Again the basic cause, viz. the dishonour of a cheque also includes several stages, such as (i) issuance of a cheque by the drawer; (ii) presentation of that cheque by the payee to his banker for collection; and (iii) intimation to the payee from his banker, that the cheque has been dishonoured by the banker of the drawer.

    (f) While dealing with this, the Punjab & Haryana High Court, in the case of M/s Ess Bee Food Specialities and others (supra) (1992 Crl.L.J 739), observed thus :—

    “The Legislature has by means of the Banking Public Financial Institutions and Negotiable Instruments Laws (Amendment) Act, 1988 inserted Ss. 138 and 142 to make out the dishonouring of a cheque to be an offence if the same is dishonoured for want of funds and after service of a notice, the amount is not paid within the period prescribed. The offence that is deemed to have been committed under the provisions of Section 138, shall be a complete offence only if the three conditions, specified in the provisos to the Section also exist.”

    (g) Therefore, where punitive action is sought against the drawer of a cheque, who has failed to honour the same on presentment, the following conditions should be satisfied :—

    (1) There should be some existing debt, or liability between the drawer and the payee;

    (2) The amount of money standing to the credit of the particular account in which the cheque is drawn is insufficient or it exceeds the arrangement;

    (3) The cheque must have been presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date of which it is drawn or within the period of its validity whichever is earlier.

    (4) The person who is entitled to get money under the cheque should have made a demand for payment of the amount covered by the cheque through a written notice addressed to the drawer within fifteen days from the date of receipt of intimation of the return of the cheque; and

    (5) The drawer of the cheque should have failed to make payment of the amount within fifteen days of receipt of the notice.

    Therefore, the service of notice of dishonour, and demand for payment is a condition precedent before the cause of action, since the cause of action does not arise until the drawer fails to make payment, after receipt of such notice within fifteen days.

    (h) The observations culled out from the decision reported in 1992 (Supple) M.W.N (Crl) 4, (M.M Malik v. Prem Kumar Goyal), would be quite relevant to be quoted here in this case :—

    “Section 138 come into play only when the three proviso to the Section are also complied with. . . . Section 142 (b) provides a clincher. The cause of action will be completed when the drawer of the cheque fails to make the payment within 15 days of the receipt of notice contemplated by proviso (b). The offence shall be deemed to have been committed only from the date when the notice period expired . . ..

    Dishonouring of the cheque was only a part of cause of action and the offence was completed only when the petitioner Company failed to discharge its liability to the creditors (the complainant herein). For discharging the debt, the petitioners had to find out their creditors and since the creditor has its office at Pehowa, the offence was completed at that place and in this situation, the Court at Kurukshetra had the territorial jurisdiction to try the matter.”

    (i) Under Section 179 Cr.P.C, when an act is an offence by reason of anything which has been done and of a consequence which has ensued, the offence may be enquired into or tried by a Court within whose local jurisdiction such thing has been done or such consequences has ensued. What Section 179 Cr.P.C, provides is that when a person is accused of the commission of any offence by reason of two things, by reason first, of anything which has been done, and secondly, of any consequence which has ensued, then the jurisdiction is conferred on the Court where the act has been done or the consequence has ensued. The offence, therefore, must be charged by reason of that two things, the act done and the consequence which ensued and the consequence, therefore, forms the necessary part of the offence.

    (j) Thus, a reading of Section 179 Cr.P.C, would make it clear, that Section confers jurisdiction on:

    (i) the Court within whose jurisdiction limits any consequence ensued by reason of which the person is accused of the commission of an offence.

    (ii) The expression “by reason of which” governs both the clauses, i.e, anything which has been done, and any consequence which has ensued.

    (k) It is settled law that Section 179 Cr.P.C, could apply, where the act and its consequence combined together constitute an offence, which is subject matter of the trial. In other words, Section 179 Cr.P.C, applies to those offences, which are not completed until a specified consequence constitute as an offence. This consequence must be a necessary part and ingredient of the offence.

    (1) Various rulings while interpreting Section 179 Cr.P.C, would hold that where the offence is complete irrespective of any consequence, this Section has no application and the place where the Act was done would determine the jurisdiction of the Courts. Section 179 Cr.P.C, applies to those offences, only when the act and its consequence taken together constitute the offence which is charged. If the accused is to be prosecuted for the act alone then the jurisdiction of the Court where the consequence occurred will not arise, but if the accused is prosecuted for that offence which was completed by the act followed by its consequence, then the Courts where the act was committed and where the consequence ensued will both have jurisdiction to try the offence.

    (m) In the light of the principles discussed above as laid down in the above decisions, the place from which the notice has been issued, intimating the dishonour of the cheque and demanding the cheque amount to be paid to the creditor and the failure to make payment would also have the jurisdiction, since the consequence as contemplated under Section 179 Cr.P.C for the act done by the accused, by issuing a cheque which was dishonoured due to which the demand of the amount and failure to make the payment had ensued.

    (n) It is also to be pointed out at this stage, that there is also an averment in the complaints filed in both the cases, in the following words :—

    “The offence has taken place within the jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court”.

    Even in the decision cited by learned counsel for the petitioners reported in 1993 (1) Crimes 46 (Muraleedharan's case), it has been clearly held that in order to ascertain the place where such failure to make payment has taken place, the averments in the complaint have to be looked into. In the said decision, the High Court of Kerala, following the Judgment of the Apex Court in State of M.P v. K.P Ghaira, (AIR 1957 SC 196), held that the venue of enquiry of trial of a case has primarily to be determined by the averments contained in the complaint, and that on the basis of such averments, if the Court finds the jurisdiction, it can proceed with the complaint.

    (o) Therefore, as pointed out earlier, there is also an averment, in the complaints stating that the Court at Madras would have got jurisdiction, since the offence had been completed at Madras. No doubt it is true that the hire purchase agreement entered into between the parties bears the seal of the office at Delhi. But a reading of the preamble of the hire purchase agreement would show that the agreement was entered into between M/s. Ashok Leyland Finance Ltd. (Complainant) carrying on business at its registered office, Chamiers Road at Madras and M/s Narang Industries Limited (the petitioners), New Delhi. Of course, mere mentioning of the office situate at Madras in the agreement will not be sufficient to decide about the jurisdiction, as contemplated under Sections 177 to 179 Cr.P.C But, a reading of the complaints in the light of Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act read with Section 179 Cr.P.C would make it clear that since the demand for cheque amounts was made by the complainant from the Registered Office at Madras, by issuing a written notice as per the second proviso to Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, with whom, the hire purchase agreement was entered into, cheque amount is payable at Madras.

    15. In view of the above circumstances, I am of the opinion that the non-payment of cheque amount at Madras, despite the written demand from the Registered office at Madras, would make the offence complete.

    This is made clear even from the observation made by the High Court of Kerala, in Muraleedharan's case, that the cause of action arises at the place, where the cheque was issued or delivered or the place where the money was expressly or impliedly payable. In the instant case, the complainant the Registered Office at Madras demands money from Madras, asking the drawer to pay the money to Madras Office. Therefore, the place where the money is payable also will have the jurisdiction.

    16. In the light of the above discussion, I am of the considered view that the Court at Chennai (Madras) would also have the jurisdiction to try the case. Therefore, I do not see any ground to quash the proceedings initiated against the petitioners, through the complaints filed by the respondent, and as such, these petitions have to be dismissed as devoid of merits.

    17. Accordingly, these two petitions are dismissed. As indicated earlier, the petitioners even without moving an application to recall the non-bailable warrant issued against them by the trial Court, have moved this Court by way of these quashing applications.

    18. Therefore, the petitioners are directed to surrender before the trial Court and file applications to recall the warrant, which will be considered by the trial Court, in accordance with law. The trial Court is also directed to dispose of the cases as expeditiously as possible, as they have been pending from the year 1994.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narang Industries Lt... v. Ashok Leyland Financ...
    (Jul 21, 1997)