AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was filed by Thanthai Periyar Transport Corporation challenging the award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Second Judge, Court of Small Causes), Madras, in M.C.O.P. No. 128 of 1988. The appeal raises two questions: (1) whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that rash and negligent driving by the bus driver caused the accident on 7.1.1988 in which the respondent was injured, and (2) whether the Tribunal was justified in awarding compensation of Rs. 35,750 with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the claim petition until payment.

The accident occurred on 7.1.1988 involving a corporation bus (the judgment text refers to the bus as TML 8630 in one place and TML 8650 in another). The respondent was a passenger in that bus and sustained injuries when, according to his case, the bus stopped near the entrance to the Broadway bus stand and while he was attempting to alight the driver suddenly started the bus causing his right foot to be run over. The respondent originally claimed Rs. 75,000 as compensation.

The appellant denied liability, asserting that the passenger alighted from a moving bus despite warnings and that parked vehicles and traffic obstructions meant the bus was being driven slowly and cautiously. The Tribunal found for the respondent and awarded Rs. 35,750 plus interest. The appellant appealed, and the respondent filed a memorandum of cross-objections seeking the disallowed portion (Rs. 39,250).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in concluding that the rash and negligent driving of the appellant's bus caused the accident on 7.1.1988 in which the respondent sustained injuries.
  2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in awarding compensation of Rs. 35,750 together with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the claim petition until payment.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that the respondent alighted from a moving bus and therefore the injuries resulted from the respondent's own negligence; consequently, the respondent could not claim compensation.
  • It was further contended that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal was excessive and should be reduced.

Respondent / Cross-Objector's Position

  • The respondent maintained that the bus was stopped at the entrance to the Broadway bus stand due to traffic obstruction and that while he was alighting the driver started the bus rashly and negligently, causing the bus's front wheel to run over his right leg.
  • He claimed total compensation of Rs. 75,000 and, on cross-objection, sought the disallowed portion of Rs. 39,250 in addition to the amount awarded by the Tribunal.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the oral and documentary evidence placed before the Tribunal. It focused on the testimony of the respondent (examined as P.W.3) and the driver and conductor of the bus (examined as R.Ws.1 and 2).

On the question of causation, the court analyzed conflicting versions:

  • P.W.3 stated that the bus had reached the entrance to the Broadway bus stand but could not enter because of traffic obstruction, it had stopped outside, and while he was in the process of alighting (one foot in the bus and one on the road) the driver suddenly started the bus; the front wheel ran over his right foot.
  • The driver (R.W.1) and conductor (R.W.2) admitted there was traffic obstruction and that the bus could not enter the bus stand, but described the bus as proceeding slowly and said passengers were warned not to alight; they said an elderly person nonetheless alighted from the front exit, brakes were applied and he fell.

The court observed that once R.Ws.1 and 2 accepted there was traffic obstruction preventing entry into the bus stand, it was difficult to reconcile that fact with the assertion that the bus was moving slowly (as distinct from being stopped). The court noted common practice that buses stop outside the Broadway terminus to allow passengers to alight and concluded that P.W.3's account — that the bus had stopped and then started suddenly while he was alighting — was probable and acceptable.

The court also considered the potential bias of R.Ws.1 and 2, as they were employees of the appellant and their evidence tended to support the appellant's case of non-liability. On the basis of credibility and probability of the versions, the court agreed with the Tribunal that rash and negligent driving by the bus driver caused the accident.

On the quantum of compensation, the court reviewed the medical and hospital evidence and the Tribunal's apportionment:

  • Medical records (Exs. A3 and A7) showed a de-gloving injury to the right foot, subsequent ulceration with pus formation, and periods of hospitalization — initially 12 days and later almost one month at a hospital in Kancheepuram.
  • The doctor (P.W.1) issued a disability certificate (Ex. P1) recording a 20% permanent disability.
  • P.W.3 testified that he earned his livelihood as a lorry driver and, due to his injuries and disability, he could no longer drive a lorry as before and had difficulty squatting, climbing stairs, walking and standing.
  • The Tribunal's awards — Rs. 500 for transport, Rs. 250 for extra nourishment, Rs. 5,000 for pain and suffering, Rs. 20,000 for permanent disability, and Rs. 10,000 for loss of earning capacity — were considered in light of the medical evidence, P.W.3's age (55 at the time of the accident), his licence (Ex. P6) and his stated income (Rs. 40–50 per day).

The court found each head of compensation to be reasonable on the evidence. Counsel for neither party produced material to justify reducing or enhancing the amounts. Accordingly, the court found no grounds to interfere with the Tribunal's award.

Procedurally, the court concluded by dismissing both the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal (C.M.A.) and the memorandum of cross-objections; it ordered no costs for either side.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court affirmed the Tribunal's decision and ordered that the appeals be dismissed. The precise formulation in the judgment is that "The C.M.A and the Memorandum of Cross Objections will stand dismissed."

DISPOSITIVE RESULT: The Tribunal's award of Rs. 35,750 together with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the claim petition until payment stands confirmed; there will be no order as to costs.

Implications: The decision leaves intact the Tribunal's factual findings on causation and the quantum awarded. The opinion contains no discussion of broader legal principles intended to create or alter precedent; its effect is limited to the resolution between the parties and affirmation of the compensation awarded by the Tribunal.

RR/VCS.

    The Managing Director, Thanthai Periyar Transport Corpn., Ltd., Villupuram. v. N. Hussain Mohideen.

    JUDGMENT

    In this appeal, at the instance of Thanthai Periyar Transport corporation, against the award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Second Judge, Court of Small Causes), Madras, in M.C.O.P No. 128 of 1988, the two questions, which arise for consideration, are (1) whether the Tribunal was right in its conclusion that the rash and negligent driving of the bus TML 8630 belonging to the appellant, by its driver, caused the accident on 7.1.1988, in which the respondent sustained injuries, and (2) whether, in respect of the injuries so sustained by the respondent, the Tribunal was justified in awarding to him compensation in a sum of Rs. 35,750/- together with interest at 12% pa from the date of claim petition till the date of payment

    2. There is no dispute now that in an accident that took place on 7.1.1988, involving the bus TML 8650, near the entrance to the Broadway Bus stand, the respondent, who was a passenger in that bus, sustained certain injuries. According to the case of the respondent, the bus was stopped at the entrance to the Broadway bus stand and while the respondent was attempting to get down from the bus, the driver started the bus rashly and negligendy, as a result of which, he fell down and sustained injuries, in that, the front wheel of the bus ran over his right leg. In respect of that, he prayed that compensation in a sum of Rs. 75,000/- should be awarded to him.

    3. This claim was resisted by the appellant on the ground that the bus was about to enter the bus stand at Broadway and despite warning, a passenger got down from the moving bus and sustained injuries and as there were parked vehicles on the road, passengers were warned that they should not get down and the bus was being driven slowly and cautiously. The appellant thus attributed the negligence to the respondent. The compensation claimed was also characterised to be excessive.

    4. On a consideration of the evidence, oral as well as the documentary, the Tribunal found that the rash and negligent driving of the bus by its driver caused the accident, in which the respondent sustained injuries and in respect of those injuries, the respondent deserved to be awarded compensation in a sum of Rs. 35,750/- together with interest, as stated earlier. It is the correctness of the award so passed that is questioned in this appeal, while, the respondent, in the Memorandum of Cross objections, has prayed that the disallowed portion of compensation in a sum of Rs. 39,250/- should also be awarded to him.

    5. Learned counsel for the appellant first contended that the conclusion of the Tribunal on the question of rashness and negligence, is erroneous. According to learned counsel, the respondent got out of the running bus and sustained injuries and therefore, he cannot claim compensation in respect of the accident brought about on account of his own negligence. However, it is not possible to accept this contention. Regarding the manner, in which the accident, took place, there is the evidence of the respondent, examined as P.W 3 and that of the Driver and Conductor of the bus, examined as R.Ws 1 and 2. P.W 3, in his evidence, stated that the bus reached the entrance to the Broadway bus stand and at that time, the bus was unable to enter the bus stand on account of traffic obstructions, and stopped outside and passengers got down and while he was also getting down with one foot in the bus and another on the floor, the driver suddenly started the bus and his right foot was run over by the bus by its driver, R.W 1. The driver, R.W 1, in his evidence, accepted that there was traffic obstruction, when the bus was about to enter the bus stand, but stated that the bus was proceeding only slowly and when the passengers attempted to get down they were warned not to do so, but in spite of it, one elderly gentleman got down from the front exit and the brakes were applied and in spite of that, he fell down and sustained injuries. The Conductor of the bus, examined as R.W 2, has also given evidence to similar effect. From the evidence of P.W 3 and R.Ws 1 and 2, it is clear that the respondent had travelled as a passenger in the bus in question on the date of accident and that the bus had reached the destination and it was not in a position to get into the bus stand owing to the traffic obstruction. While the respondent claimed that he was, like other passengers, attempting to get down from the bus, the bus started rashly and negligently and that had caused the accident, R.Ws 1 and 2 would say that the bus was in motion and the respondent, in the process of alighting from the moving bus, got injured. When once it is accepted by R.Ws 1 and 2 that there was a traffic obstruction and the bus could not enter the bus stand, it is difficult to accept that the bus was moving slowly, as claimed by R.Ws 1 and 2. It is common knowledge that even before the bus could enter the Broadway bus stand, it is stopped outside to enable passengers to get down from the bus and in this case, from the evidence, it is clear that, the bus had to stop outside the bus terminus, owing to traffic obstruction in the access-road. Under those circumstances, there is nothing, improbable in the evidence of P.W 3 when he stated that he attempted to get down from the bus, while the other passengers did that and before he could alight from the bus completely, the bus had started. The evidence of R.Ws 1 and 2, being employees of the appellant-Corporation, would only be to support the case of the appellant so as to see that no liability is fastened on the appellant. Thus, on a due consideration of the manner in which the accident took place, the version given by P.W 3 is more probable and acceptable and the Tribunal cannot, therefore, be stated to have committed any error in holding that the rash and negligent driving of the bus belonging to the appellant, by its driver by had caused the accident, in which the respondent sustained injuries.

    6. Learned counsel for the appellant next contended that the amount of compensation awarded is on the high side and deserved to be reduced, while the counsel for the respondent-Cross Objector submitted that the disallowed portion of compensation should also be awarded to him. It is seen from the hospital records Exs. A3 and A7, that the respondent had sustained a de-glowing injury in his right foot which had also subsequently developed into ulcer with pus formation. The respondent had been hospitaised for a period of 12 days initially and later for almost one month in the hospital at Kancheepuram. P.W 3, in his evidence, had stated that he was eking out his livelihood as a lorry driver and that, as a result of the injuries sustained by him in the accident, he had also been subjected to a disability, in that, he is not in a position to drive the lorry, as before, and he was also unable to sit cross legged and was finding it difficult to climb up stairs and to walk or even to stand for some time. The Doctor, examined as P.W 1, under Ex. P1 had granted a disability certificate to the effect that the respondent had sustained permanent disability of 20%. It is in the background of the aforesaid injuries that the amount of compensation awardable to the respondent has to be determined. The Tribunal had awarded to the respondent a sum of Rs. 500/- in respect of transport charges, which, on the evidence available, appears to me to be fair and just, in as much as the respondent had to be hospitalised at Madras initially and later at Kancheepuram and necessarily, amounts must have been spent towards his transport to the hospitals. In regard to extra nourishment, the Tribunal had awarded a sum of Rs. 250/-, which is also very fair and reasonable. Considering the nature of the injuries sustained by the respondent in his right foot, he must have taken extra nourishment for purposes of facilitating healing of the injuries and also to recoup his health and a sum of Rs. 250/- under this head cannot, by any means be stated to be very high or inadequate. Towards pain and suffering, the Tribunal had awarded a sum of Rs. 5,000/-. The details of the injuries sustained by the respondent are found in the case sheet, Ex. A.3 and therefrom, it is seen that the de-glowing injury had affected the right foot of the respondent. The nature of the injury is such that the respondent undoubtedly ought to have been in a state of pain at least immediately after the accident and also during the period of his treatment at Madras as well as in Kancheepuram. The award of Rs. 5000/- under this head by the Tribunal, cannot be stated to be exorbitant or very low. The respondent had been eking out his livelihood as a lorry driver, as stated earlier and as P.W 3, he had stated that as a result of the injuries sustained by him in the accident, in his right foot he has not been able to drive lorry at all and he had also sustained 20% disability. In regard to this the Tribunal had awarded compensation in a sum of Rs. 20,000/- which also appears to be very reasonable. A proper and functional right foot is very essential for driving and controlling a lorry and with the loss of the use of the right foot, the respondent cannot attempt to drive lorry as before. The percentage of disability no doubt has been stated to be 20. But it cannot be gainsaid that the disability is such that the respondent cannot any longer drive a lorry as spoken to by him. Further, P.W 3 had also stated that he finds it difficult to fold his legs and he is not able to squat, besides he is not able to climb up stairs or even to walk or stand and this would certainly affect the respondent in his daily life. Taking these aspects into account, the award of Rs. 20,000/- by way of compensation for permanent disability cannot be stated to be either excessive or even low. In respect of loss of earning capacity, the Tribunal had awarded Rs. 10,000. The respondent was aged 55 years at the time of the accident, in which he sustained injuries. The driving licence of the respondent has been produced and marked as Ex. P6. The injuries sustained by him in the accident had left him in such a condition that he is not able to drive the vehicle and that would necessarily have an effect upon his earning capacity. The evidence of P.W 3 discloses that he was earning Rs. 40/-, to Rs. 50/- a day. Even on a low income, the loss of earning capacity for the next 5 to 10 years during which the respondent could have driven the lorry, was rightly computed at Rs. 10,000/-. Counsel on both sides, were not in a position to bring to the notice of Court any evidence which would justify either a reduction or even a further enhancement of the amount awardable to the respondent under any of the aforesaid heads. No case is therefore, made out to interfere with the award of the Tribunal. The C.M.A and the Memorandum of Cross Objections will stand dismissed. There will be however, no order as to costs either in the appeal or in the memorandum of cross objections.

    RR/VCS.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Managing Director, Thanthai Periyar Transport Corpn., Ltd., Villupuram. v. N. Hussain Mohideen.
    (Jun 29, 1992)