Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner in the writ petitions is the management of Pithavadian and Partners, Architects and Planners. Two claims for gratuity were made against the firm under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972: (i) the wife and legal heir of C. Ramamurthi claimed gratuity for his service from 13 August 1959 to 8 October 1974 and the Controlling Authority awarded Rs. 3,750; (ii) G.M. Joseph claimed Rs. 4,675 for about seventeen years and three months of service and the Controlling Authority allowed that claim. The management appealed to the Appellate Authority, which upheld the Controlling Authority's awards. The management filed the present writ petitions seeking quashing of those orders. A single Judge of this Court referred the matter to a Bench because of a doubt whether an earlier Madras High Court decision (L.M. Chitale & Sons v. Commissioner of Labour) — which held that a firm of architects did not fall within the Shops and Establishments Act — remained good law in view of later rulings of the Supreme Court (including Bangalore Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. Rajappa) and a decision of the Delhi High Court. The matter was then heard by a Division Bench, which delivered the judgment summarized below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a firm of architects is covered by the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 — specifically, whether such a firm is an "establishment" within the meaning of Section 1(3)(b) of the Act.
  2. Whether the decision in L.M. Chitale & Sons v. Commissioner of Labour (holding that a firm of architects did not fall within the Shops and Establishments Act) remains good law in view of later Supreme Court authority (including Bangalore Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. Rajappa) and other later rulings.
  3. Whether authorities constituted under the Payment of Gratuity Act are sufficiently empowered/qualified to determine disputes under Section 7 of the Act that may involve intricate questions (for example, title to gratuity or the identity of a legal heir).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Management) Arguments

  • The firm of architects is not an "establishment" within S.1(3)(b) of the Payment of Gratuity Act because the Madras Shops and Establishments Act's definition of "shop" (S.2(16)) contemplates trade or commercial activity and does not extend to a learned profession such as architecture; L.M. Chitale & Sons supports this position.
  • The authorities appointed under the Payment of Gratuity Act are not professionally qualified to decide certain intricate questions (e.g., determination of legal heirship) that may arise under Section 7 of the Act.

Respondents' (Claimants / Authorities) Arguments

  • The decision in L.M. Chitale & Sons is no longer good law in view of subsequent Supreme Court rulings (notably Bangalore Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. Rajappa and the State of Punjab v. Labour Court decision referred to in the opinion), which interpret S.1(3)(b) broadly to include establishments defined by any law in force relating to shops and establishments.
  • The Payment of Gratuity Act constitutes a complete, self-contained code and the authorities under it are competent to decide disputes arising under the Act, including contested questions such as legal heirship.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
L.M. Chitale & Sons v. Commissioner of Labour (Madras High Court) Held that the Madras Shops and Establishments Act's definition of "shop" did not apply to a firm of chartered architects; on that footing a firm of architects was not covered as an "establishment" under S.1(3)(b) of the Payment of Gratuity Act. The Division Bench reviewed this earlier ruling and concluded, in light of later Supreme Court authority, that L.M. Chitale had been wrongly decided and must be regarded as overruled by the Supreme Court's later interpretation.
Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. Rajappa (Supreme Court, AIR 1978 S.C. 548) Interpreted S.1(3)(b) of the Payment of Gratuity Act broadly; treated the Payment of Gratuity Act as applying to establishments as defined by any law in force relating to shops and establishments; recognised that enactments such as the Payment of Wages Act (and its definition of industrial or other establishment) fall within the ambit of S.1(3)(b). The Court relied on this Supreme Court precedent to hold that the Payment of Gratuity Act applies to establishments of the kind in question and that the narrower view taken in L.M. Chitale is inconsistent with the Supreme Court's interpretation.
State of Punjab v. Labour Court, Jullender (Supreme Court) The Supreme Court held that S.1(3)(b) contemplates any law in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State and that statutes such as the Payment of Wages Act, which define industrial or other establishments, fall within the expression used in S.1(3)(b). The Division Bench reproduced and relied on these observations to support the conclusion that S.1(3)(b) has a wide scope and that the Payment of Gratuity Act applies to establishments included under other statutes; this reasoning contributed to the view that L.M. Chitale was wrong.
Messrs. C.C. Sharma & Sons v. R.K. Bawaja (Delhi High Court) Referenced by earlier court(s) as one of the later authorities that raise doubt about the continuing validity of L.M. Chitale. The opinion notes the Delhi High Court decision as part of the later rulings relied on by respondents and by the single Judge in ordering the reference to a Bench; the Division Bench's ultimate reliance was on Supreme Court authority rather than on this decision alone.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, based solely on what appears in the opinion:

  1. Admitted facts: The petitioner is a firm of architects which employed more than ten persons; the employer-employee relationship between the firm and the claimants was not disputed. Those facts are relevant because S.1(3)(b) applies where ten or more persons are or were employed on any day of the preceding twelve months.
  2. Characterisation of L.M. Chitale: The Division Bench reviewed the reasoning of L.M. Chitale & Sons, which relied on the Madras Shops and Establishments Act's definition of "shop" (S.2(16)) to exclude a firm of chartered architects from the scope of "shop" and, by extension, from the Payment of Gratuity Act.
  3. Assessment of statutory breadth: The court examined S.1(3)(b) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, which applies the Act to "every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State." The court considered whether that language should be read narrowly (as in L.M. Chitale) or broadly.
  4. Reliance on Supreme Court authority: The court relied upon the Supreme Court's analysis (in the State of Punjab v. Labour Court decision and in Bangalore Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. Rajappa) which interprets S.1(3)(b) broadly. The Supreme Court explained that the expression "any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State" is comprehensive and can include laws that define industrial or other establishments (for example, as in the Payment of Wages Act S.2(ii)(g)).
  5. Consequence for L.M. Chitale: Given the Supreme Court's wider construction, the Division Bench concluded that the reasoning and conclusion in L.M. Chitale (that architects' firms are excluded) were inconsistent with the later Supreme Court interpretation and therefore could not be regarded as good law.
  6. Competence of statutory authorities: The court addressed the petitioner's contention that authorities under the Payment of Gratuity Act lack professional qualifications to decide intricate disputes (e.g., legal heirship). The court rejected this contention, relying on the Supreme Court's statement that the Payment of Gratuity Act constitutes a complete, self-contained code and that proceedings under it must be taken under that Act; hence the authorities created by the Act are competent to decide disputes arising under it.
  7. Outcome application: Applying these legal conclusions to the facts (petitioner employs more than ten persons; employer-employee relationship admitted; awards made by Controlling Authority and upheld on appeal), the court found no merit in the writ petitions and dismissed them.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Division Bench dismissed the writ petitions and held that the earlier Madras High Court decision in L.M. Chitale & Sons v. Commissioner of Labour was wrongly rendered and must be regarded as overruled by later Supreme Court authority. The court also upheld the competence of the authorities constituted under the Payment of Gratuity Act to adjudicate disputes under the Act. The court made no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Controlling Authority's awards of gratuity (and the Appellate Authority's confirmation of those awards) stand — the petitions to quash those orders were dismissed.
  • On coverage under the Payment of Gratuity Act: The opinion adopts the Supreme Court's broad interpretation of S.1(3)(b); a firm of architects employing ten or more persons was treated as falling within the statutory scheme for payment of gratuity. The decision makes clear that the Payment of Gratuity Act applies to establishments that fall within the scope of "any law... in relation to shops and establishments" and that earlier narrower readings (as in L.M. Chitale) cannot be maintained in the face of Supreme Court authority.
  • On adjudicatory competence: The court's reliance on the Supreme Court's description of the Payment of Gratuity Act as a complete, self-contained code indicates that disputes arising under the Act (including those involving questions such as legal heirship) are to be resolved by the authorities and appellate mechanism provided by the Act.
  • Precedential note: The Division Bench did not purport to create a novel principle but applied and followed the Supreme Court's existing interpretation; it expressly treated the earlier Madras decision as having been overtaken by higher authority.

No information beyond what appears in the provided opinion has been added. Sections and conclusions are drawn only from the text of the opinion supplied.

    The Management Of Pithavadian Patrners, Rep. By Its Managing Partner v. Controlling Authority Under The Payment Of Gratuity Act 1972, Madras 6 And Others

    1. The short question that arises for consideration in this case is, whether a firm of Architects would be governed by the provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. Under S. 1(3)(b) of the said Act, it is stated as follows—

    “It shall apply to—(b) every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State, in which ten or more persons are employed, or were employed, on any day of the proceeding twelve months.”

    2. In this State it is the Tamil Nadu Shops and Establishments Act that is in force in relation to the shops and establishments. There is a direct ruling of Srinivasan, J., in L.M Chitale and Son by sole surviving partner S.L Chitale v. The Commissioner of Labour, Chepauk, Madras and others,1 holding that the Shops and Establishments Act will not apply to the firm of Architects. That decision has been relied on by the learned counsel for the petitioner in these writ petitions for certiorari, while the learned counsel for the respondents would say that it cannot be contended that the ruling can any longer be held to be good law in view of the later rulings of the Supreme Court in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. Rajappa and others . A.I.R 1978 S.C 548=91 L.W S.C 149 S.N and the ruling of the Delhi High Court in Messrs. C.C Sharma and sons. v. Sri R.K Bawaja Presiding officer, Labour Court, and others . 1972-2-L.L.J 475.. This is an important point which requires to be decided by a Bench because I have my own doubt whether the ruling of Srinivasan, J., cited above could still be held to be good law in view of the later rulings of the Supreme Court. In this view, I direct that the papers may be placed before my Lord, the Chief Justice, for suitable orders as to the posting before a Bench.

    (Pursuant to the above order of reference these cases coming on for hearing before the Division Bench, the Court delivered the following judgment:

    The Chief Justice,

    3. The petitioner in both the writ petitions is the Management of Pithavadian and Partners, Architects and Planners, and has prayed for quashing the order of the authorities under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, directing the petitioner to pay gratuity to its erstwhile employees, under the said Act.

    4. The facts leading to the filing of these writ petitions lie in a narrow compass. One C. Ramamurthi was employed in the petitioner firm as a draughtsman and served under the petitioner from 13th August, 1959 to 8th October, 1974. His wife and legal heir filed a claim application before the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) for payment of gratuity, and the Controlling Authority after notice to the petitioner, awarded a sum of Rs. 3,750. Another worker, G.M Joseph claimed a sum of Rs. 4,675 as gratuity, for having served the petitioner firm as a draughtsman for seventeen years and three months and the Controlling Authority after notice to the parties and after hearing them, allowed the said claim.

    5. The Management filed an appeal against both the orders before the Appellate Authority under the Act and the Appellate Authority by a common order, upheld the order of the original authority, allowing the claim for gratuity. It is against both these orders that the management has filed the present writ petitions. Pending disposal of the writ petitions, G.M Joseph died and his legal representatives have been brought on record by an order dated 4th March, 1982 in W.M.P No. 469 of 1982.

    6. The main contention raised in these writ petitions is that the petitioner firm, which is a firm of architects, will not come under the purview of the Payment of Gratuity Act, as it is not an establishment within the meaning of S. 1(3)(b) of the Act, as held by this Court in L. M. Chitale and Son v. Commissioner of Labour. The claimants-respondents contested this position before the learned single Judge and contended that the said decision is no longer good law, in view of the later ruling of the Supreme Court in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. Rajappa and others. The learned Judge has therefore, referred the case for decision by a Division Bench and that is how the matter is before us.

    7. The Act provides for a scheme for the payment of gratuity to employees engaged in factories, mines, oil fields, plantations, ports, railway companies, shops or other Establishments and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. S. 1 (3) of the Act lays down that it shall apply to—

    (a) every factory, mine, oil field, plantation, port and railway company;

    (b) every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State, in which ten or more persons are employed, or were employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months;

    (c) such other establishments or class of in which ten or more employees are employed, or were employed on any day of the preceding twelve months, as the Central Government, may by notification, specify in this behalf.

    8. It is an admitted position before us that the petitioner is a firm of architects. The firm also engages clerks and other workers, and their work is supervised by the firm and the firm employees more than ten persons as provided in S. 1(3)(b) of the Act. It is also admitted before us that the relationship of employer and employee existed between the petitioner and its employees.

    8. Messrs. L.M Chitale & Sons v. Commissioner of Labour, was a case of a registered firm of Chartered Architects. The firm terminated the services of an employee. Thereafter the employee applied for payment of gratuity. On a dispute being raised, the matter was referred to the Commissioner of Labour to decide whether the Madras Shops and Establishments Act would apply or not. The Commissioner held that the firm would come within the purview of the definition in S. 2(16) of the Act. Thereafter the application of the workman for payment of gratuity was allowed by the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation. Both these orders were challenged in the writ proceedings.

    9. S. 2(16) of the Shops and Establishments Act 1947 reads as follows—

    “shop’ means any premises where any trade or business is carried on or where services are rendered to customers and includes offices, storerooms godowns, and warehouses, whether in the same premises or otherwise, used in comnection with such business but does not include a restaurant, eating house or commercial establishment.”

    The learned Judge who heard the case came to the conclusion that S. 2(16) defining a shop is restricted in its scope and envisages an activity which as commonly understood is associated with the carrying on of trade or commerce, and cannot take in establishments where professional services are rendered and finally held as follows—

    “The other part of the definition of ‘shop’ that is, ‘shop’ means any premise where services are rendered to customers’ is to my mind equally inapplicable to the case of a chartered architect, It is not denied by the other side that a Chartered Architect does carry on a learned profession and that it is his special qualifications that are placed at the disposal of his clients,”

    It was on the above finding and the concession made in that case that the order of the Commissioner of Labour holding that the firm would come within the definition of ‘shop’ under the said Act and the order of the Additional Commissioner of Workmen's Compensation directing payment of gratuity, were set aside.

    10. The above decision proceeds on the footing that the amplitude of the definition in S. 1(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act is confined in its application to the definition of shop’ in S. 2(16) of the Madras Shops and Establishments Act.

    11. The question of interpretation of the provisions of S. 2(3)(b) of the Payment of Gratuity Act came up for consideration before the Supreme Court in State of Punjab v. Labour Court, Jullender, and the Supreme Court came to the conclusion that the provisions of S. 1(3)(b) of the Payment of Oratuity Act were wide enough to include any law—Central or State—applicable to every shop or establishment and that a firm or architect such as the petitioner in this case, would come within the purview of ‘establishment’ as defined in the Payment of Wages Act. S. 2(ii)(g) of the said Act fades as follows:—

    “2(ii) ‘Industrial or other establishment’ means (g) establishment in which any work relating to the construction, development or maintenance of buildings, roads, bridges or canals or relating to operations connected with navigations, irrigation of the supply of water, or relating to the generation, transmission and distribution of electricity or any other form of power is being carried on”.

    The following observations of the Supreme Court from the above judgment may usefully be reproduced:—

    “It is urged for the appellant that the Payment of Wages Act is not an enactment contemplated by S. 1(3)(b) of the Payment of Gratuity Act. The Payment of Gratuity Act it is pointed out is a Central enactment and S. 1(3)(b), it is said, refers to a law enacted by the State legislature. We are unable to accept the contention. S. 1(3)(b) speaks of ‘any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishments in a State’. There can be no dispute that the Payment of Wages Act is in force in the State of Punjab. Then it is submitted that Payment of Wages Act is not a law in relation to ‘shops and establishments’. As to that the Payment of Wages Act is a statute which, while it may not refer to shops, relates to a class of establishments that is to say industrial establishments. But, it is contended, the law referred to under S. 1(3)(b) cannot be a law which relates to both shops and establishments, such as, the Punjab Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1958. It is difficult to accept that contention, because there is no warrant for so limiting the meaning of the expression ‘law’ in S. 1(3)(b). The expression is comprehensive in its scope, and can mean a law in relation to shops as well as separately, a law in relation to establishments, or a law in relation to shops and commercial establishments and a law in relation to non-commercial establishments. Had S. 1(3)(b) intended to refer to a single enactment, surely the appellant would have been able to point to such a statute, that is to say, a statute relating to shops and establishments, both commercial and non-commercial. The Punjab Shops and Commercial Establishments Act does not relate to all kinds of establishments. Besides shops, it relate to commercial establishments alone “Had the intention of Parliament been, when enacting S. 1(3)(b) to refer to a law relating to commercial establishments, it would not have left the expression ‘establishments’ unqualified. We have carefully examined the various provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, and we are unable to discern any reason for giving the limited meaning of S. 1(3)(b) urged before us on behalf of the appellant. S. 1(3)(b) applies to every establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to establishments in a State. Such an establishment would include an industrial establishment within the meaning of S. 2(ii)(g) of Payment of Wages Act. Accordingly, we are of the opinion that the Payment of Gratuity Act applies to an establishment in which any work relating to the construction, development or maintenance of buildings, roads, bridges or canals, or relating to operations connected with navigation, irrigation or the supply of water, or relating to generation, transmission and distribution of electricity or any other form of power is being carried on. The Hydel Upper Beri Doab Construction Project is such an establishment and the Payment of Gratuity Act applies to it.”

    12. Learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner has next contended that the authorities under the Payment of Gratuity Act are not qualified as professional persons to determine a dispute under S. 7 of the Act, which in its purview may require a decision as to intricate question of title as to who is the legal heir of the employee, so as to claim payment of gratuity. There is no substance in this contention of the learned counsel far the petitioner. The Supreme Court in the case referred to above, has held that the Payment of Gratuity Act is a complete and self contained Code and has made provision for the decision of all disputed questions that may arise for consideration under the Act. Reference in this connection may be made to the following observations of the Supreme Court (at page 1983—1984)—

    “It is apparent that the Payment of Gratuity Act enacts a complete Code containing detailed provisions covering all the essential features of a scheme for payment of gratuity….Upon all these considerations, the conclusion is inescapable that Parliament intended that proceedings for payment of gratuity due under the Payment of Gratuity Act must be taken under that Act and not under any other.”

    We are therefore, of the opinion that, in view of the decision of the Supreme Court referred to above, the decision in L.M Chitale and Son v. Commissioner of Labour, must be held to have been wrongly rendered, and must be taken to have been overruled by the above decision of the Supreme Court.

    13. In the result we do not find any merit in the writ petitions and they are accordingly dismissed. But in the circumstances we make no order as to costs.

    VCS.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Management Of Pi... v. Controlling Authorit...
    (Sep 5, 1983)