AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963, in particular section 5A(1)(a) corresponding to section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.
  • cases.2. Section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, hereinafter referred to as the Act,
  • section 7-A(1)(b) or 7-A(1)(c) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959,
  • Court observed:Section 5A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. Because
  • section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.7.
  • Kerala General Sales Tax Act, namely, section 5A of that Act,
  • section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.
  • section 5A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act.
  • sub-section (1), the provisions of section 7
  • sub-section (1) of section 7.(3)
  • provisions of sub-section (1),
  • section 7-A(1)(a)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963, in particular section 5A(1)(a) corresponding to section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.
  • cases.2. Section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, hereinafter referred to as the Act,
  • section 7-A(1)(b) or 7-A(1)(c) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959,
  • Court observed:Section 5A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. Because
  • section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.7.
  • Kerala General Sales Tax Act, namely, section 5A of that Act,
  • section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959.
  • section 5A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act.
  • sub-section (1), the provisions of section 7
  • sub-section (1) of section 7.(3)
  • provisions of sub-section (1),
  • section 7-A(1)(a)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

These three tax revision cases concern the application of section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 to purchases of raw bones by dealers. The factual sequence (as stated in the opinion) is:

  • Dealers purchased raw bones and processed them in a disintegrator to break them into pieces (sizes cited as 3/8" and 5/8").
  • The processing produced several end-products and by-products in roughly the following proportions: about 50% crushed bone; about 15% bone grist; about 15% bone-meal; about 10% fluff; about 5% horn and hoof; the remainder becoming waste.
  • In T.C. No. 337 of 1979 the dealers exported crushed bone; the other three dealers sold bone-meal, bone grist, fluff and horn/hoof locally.
  • The Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal remitted the export question to the assessing officer to determine whether those sales fell within section 7-A(1)(b) or 7-A(1)(c) and whether purchase tax was payable in respect of the exports.
  • With respect to the locally sold products (bone-meal, bone grist, fluff, horn/hoof), the Tribunal held that section 7-A(1)(a) would not be attracted. That finding was challenged in these tax revision petitions.

Procedural outcome (as recorded in the opinion): the tax revision petitions were dismissed and there was no order as to costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether purchases of raw bones, which are processed into crushed bone, bone grist, bone-meal, fluff and horn/hoof, attract tax under section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 — i.e., whether the goods purchased are "consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise".
  2. In respect of exports of crushed bone (as in T.C. No. 337 of 1979), whether those sales fall within the scope of section 7-A(1)(b) or 7-A(1)(c) of the Act and whether purchase tax is payable (this aspect had been remitted by the Tribunal to the assessing officer).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Additional Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Madras Division, Madras v. Associated Sales of India, Madras-1 (T.C No. 1190 of 1979) [1980] 46 S.T.C 401. Distinguishes between "consumed" and "used" in section 7-A; holding that items merely "used" or "utilised" in manufacture (folded clips used in office files) are not "consumed" and therefore do not attract section 7-A. The court relied on this precedent to support the proposition that the word "consumes" requires exhaustion or loss of identity of the purchased goods; if goods are merely used, section 7-A(1)(a) is not attracted.
State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Salem v. K. Narayanaswamy Chetty and Sons (T.C No. 1183 of 1979). Held that conversion of turmeric into powder is not "consumption" for the purposes of section 7-A because the powder is a changed form but not a different commodity such that the original is consumed in the manufacture of other goods. Applied to demonstrate that mere processing or change of form (where identity substantially remains) does not amount to consumption under section 7-A(1)(a); relied on to conclude that section 7-A is not attracted where identity persists.
State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Coimbatore Division, Coimbatore-18 v. Vijayakumar Slate Works (T.C No. 300 of 1980). Held that wood made into frames for slates was not "consumed" in manufacture; the frames could not be said to be consumed in manufacturing other goods. Used to reinforce the textual emphasis on the word "consumed" in section 7-A(1)(a) and to support non-attraction of purchase tax where purchased goods retain identity as part of the end-product.
Deputy Commissioner Of Sales Tax v. Pio Food Packers — Kerala High Court decision and its affirmation by the Supreme Court [1980] 46 S.T.C 63 S.C. Explicated the tests for "consumption" and "manufacture": goods must be consumed in the manufacturing process; the resultant product must be commercially distinct and different from the original commodity for a "manufacture" to be said to have occurred; if identity remains, there is no consumption. The court relied on the Kerala High Court and Supreme Court reasoning (involving pineapple processed into slices and canned products) to adopt the test that commercial identity must be lost for "consumption" to be established; applied that test to the bone-processing facts and concluded section 7-A(1)(a) did not apply.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focuses on the proper construction of section 7-A(1)(a) and, in particular, on the meaning and consequences of the word "consumes" as used in that provision. The court proceeded as follows (based only on what is stated in the opinion):

  1. Statutory requirement: The court reiterated that for section 7-A(1)(a) to apply, the goods purchased must have been "consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise."
  2. Textual emphasis on "consumes": The court emphasized that the critical term is "consumes", which, in ordinary meaning and for the purposes of the section, contemplates that purchased goods are devoured or exhausted in the process of manufacture so that their identity is completely lost.
  3. Precedent analysis: The court reviewed several earlier decisions (including the Associated Sales, the Narayanaswamy Chetty matter, the Vijayakumar Slate Works decision, and the Kerala/Supreme Court decisions in Pio Food Packers) which consistently held that mere use, alteration or processing that leaves the commercial identity of the original commodity intact does not amount to "consumption" in the sense required by the statute.
  4. Application to facts: Having detailed the processing of raw bones into crushed bone, bone grist, bone-meal, fluff and horn/hoof (and the approximate proportions produced), the court held that the raw bones cannot be said to have been consumed in producing those end-products. The court explicitly states that the identity of the purchased goods remained and therefore the statutory condition of consumption was not satisfied.
  5. Conclusion from reasoning: On that basis the court concluded that section 7-A(1)(a) is not attracted in respect of the purchases and local sales of the processed bone products; the Tribunal's concurrent conclusion to that effect was correct.
  6. Export question: The opinion notes that the Tribunal had remitted the export-related question (whether exports fall under section 7-A(1)(b) or 7-A(1)(c) and whether purchase tax was payable) to the assessing officer. The court did not decide that remitted issue in this opinion; it confined its decision to the question under section 7-A(1)(a) concerning locally sold products.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court dismissed all three tax revision cases and upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959 is not attracted to the purchases and local sales of crushed bone, bone grist, bone-meal, fluff and horn/hoof because the purchased raw bones were not "consumed" in the manufacture of other goods.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The dealers are not liable to pay purchase tax under section 7-A(1)(a) in respect of the locally sold processed bone products, and the Tribunal's conclusion to that effect is affirmed by the court.
  • Export-related issue: The Tribunal's earlier remittance of the export question to the assessing officer (to determine applicability of section 7-A(1)(b) or 7-A(1)(c) and whether purchase tax is payable) remains in place; the court did not decide that remitted matter in this opinion.
  • No broader precedent set beyond application of existing principles: The opinion applies and follows prior decisions regarding the meaning of "consumes" and does not purport to lay down a novel rule beyond those established tests; in terms of the opinion's own language, it affirms the Tribunal's conclusion and dismisses the petitions (the opinion records that there will be no order as to costs).

Disposition recorded in the opinion: "Petitions dismissed." No order as to costs.

    The State Of Tamil Nadu v. Subbaraj And Co. (And Other Cases)

    M.M Ismail, C.J:— All these three cases raise the question relating to liability to tax tinder section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. In these cases, the dealer buys raw bones. The raw bones are converted into crushed bones. The process is done through breaking the bones in a disintegrator. In the process of breaking the bones into pieces of ⅜” and ⅝” bones, bone grist, bone-meal, fluff horns and hoof are obtained. Roughly 50 per cent of raw bone is obtained as crushed bone; 15 per cent of raw bone is obtained as bone grist; about 15 per cent is obtained as bone-meal; about 10 per cent is obtained as fluff; about 5 per cent is obtained as horn hoof. The rest becomes waste. The dealers in T.C No. 337 of 1979 exported crushed bone, but all the three dealers sold bone-meal, bone grist, fluff and horn hoof locally. As far as export is concerned, the Tribunal has remitted the matter back to the assessing officer in order to decide the question whether those sales fall within the scope of section 7-A(1)(b) or 7-A(1)(c) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, and whether the purchase tax is payable with reference thereto. With regard to the others, namely, bone-meal, bone grist, fluff and horn hoof, etc., the Tribunal has held that section 7-A(1)(a) will not be attracted. It is the correctness of this finding of the Tribunal with reference to section 7-A(1)(a) that is challenged in the present tax revision cases.

    2. Section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959, hereinafter referred to as the Act, reads as follows:

    “Levy of purchase tax.—(1) Every dealer who in the course of his business purchases from a registered dealer or from any other person, any goods (the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act) in circumstances in which no tax is payable under section 3, 4 or 5, as the case may be, and either,

    (a) consumes such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise; or

    (b) disposes of such goods in any manner other than by way of sale in the State; or

    (c) despatches them to a place outside the State except as a direct result of sale or purchase in the course of inter-State trade or commerce,

    shall pay tax on the turnover relating to the purchase aforesaid at the rate mentioned in section 3, 4 or 5, as the case may be, whatever be the quantum of such turnover in a year:

    Provided that a dealer (other than a casual trader or agent of a non-resident dealer) purchasing goods [the sale of which is liable to tax under sub-section (1) of section 3] shall not be liable to pay tax under this sub-section, if his total turnover for a year is less than fifty thousand rupees.

    (2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), the provisions of section 7 shall apply to a dealer referred to in sub-section (1) who purchases goods [the sale of which is liable to tax under sub-section (1) of section 3] and whose total turnover for a year is not less than fifty thousand rupees but not more than one lakh of rupees; and such a dealer may, at his option, instead of paying the tax in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (1), pay tax at the rates mentioned in sub-section (1) of section 7.

    (3) Every dealer liable to pay purchase tax under sub-section (1), shall, for i the purposes of this Act, be deemed to be a registered dealer.”

    3. Consequently, for the purpose of section 7-A(1)(a) to apply, the goods purchased should have been consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale of otherwise.

    4. In State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Additional Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Madras Division, Madras v. Associated Sales of India, Madras-1 [1980] 46 S.T.C 401. (T.C No. 1190 of 1979), the scope of this provision came to be considered by this Court. By the judgment dated 11th December, 1979, this Court held as follows:

    “The assessee in this case purchased folded clips from unregistered persons and those folded clips were used in the manufacture of office files. The question for consideration is whether the assessee was liable to pay tax on the purchase turnover under section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. Because the assessee purchased folded clips from unregistered persons, the purchase was not liable to tax. The only other point is whether the case can be brought under the scope of section 7-A of the Act. One of the requirements of section 7-A is that the goods so purchased should be consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise. No doubt in this case office files were manufactured by the dealer. But in that manufacture, the folded clips were not consumed, but were merely used or utilised. The language used in the section is ‘consumes such goods in the manufacture of other goods’ and not ‘uses such goods in the manufacture of other goods’. Consequently, we agree with the conclusion of the Tribunal and hold that since the folded clips were not consumed in the manufacture of office files, the purchase turnover does not attract tax under section 7-A of the Act.”

    5. The section came up for consideration again before this Court in T.C No. 1183 of 1979 (State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Salem v. K. Narayanaswamy Chetty and Sons). By judgment dated 11th December; 1979, this Court held as follows:

    “In this case, the assessees purchase turmeric from agriculturists, convert it into powder and sell the same, and the point that arises for consideration in this tax revision case is whether the purchase of turmeric from agriculturists will attract tax under section 7-A of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. One of the conditions that should be fulfilled for attracting section 7-A is that the goods purchased by the dealer should be consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise. When the turmeric purchased by the assessees in the present case is converted into powder, it cannot be said that the turmeric purchased by the assessees has been consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale. The powder is only a changed form of the turmeric purchased by the assessees. Consequently, section 7-A of the Act is not attracted and therefore the conclusion of the Tribunal does not call for interference.”

    6. The matter again came up for consideration by this Court in T.C No. 300 of 1980 (State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Deputy Commissioner (C.T), Coimbatore Division, Coimbatore-18 v. Vijayakumar Slate Works). By order dated 13th March, 1980, the court held as follows:

    “This is a petition to revise the order of the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, Additional Bench, Coimbatore, holding that the purchase turnover of the wood was not liable to purchase tax under section 7-A since the wood purchased was merely made into frames in which slates were inserted and the frames themselves therefore cannot be said to have been consumed in the manufacture of other: goods. We are of the opinion that this conclusion is correct having regard to the use of the word ‘consumed’ occurring in section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax’ Act, 1959.”

    7. The question came up for consideration with reference to the corresponding provision in the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, namely, section 5A of that Act, before the Kerala High Court in Deputy Commissioner Of Sales Tax v. Pio Food Packers. In that case, the assessee purchased pineapple and prepared pineapple slices by a process which included packing in tin containers for being made available in the market. The assessee purchased pineapple, washed it, removed the inedible portions, namely, the end, the crown, the skin and the core, sliced it, filled the slices in cans with some sugar added as preservative, sealed under temperature and put into boiling water for sterilisation and thus prepared pineapple slices. It prepared pineapple juice by crushing the pineapple and pressing it after removing the inedible portions. The juice thus obtained was sweetened, filled in cans, sealed under temperature and put in boiling water for sterilisation. It prepared jam and squash with pineapple by well-known processes. The question that arose for consideration was whether the pineapple slices fell within the ambit of section 5A of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963, in particular section 5A(1)(a) corresponding to section 7-A(1)(a) of the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, 1959. The learned Judges of the Kerala High Court, after referring to the provisions contained in section 5A(1)(a), said as follows:

    “The relevant clause in the section which has application is section 5A(1)(a) and the conditions to be established before liability can be attracted are: (1) that the goods purchased have been consumed; (2) that such consumption was in the process of manufacture; and (3) that the manufacture was of other goods for sale. It is necessary to concentrate on the expressions underlined*, namely, ‘consumption’, ‘manufacture’ and ‘other goods’. The last of these is to be noticed only to emphasise that the resultant product must be distinct and different from the goods consumed in the process of manufacture.”

    8. The learned Judges elaborately considered the scope of the expressions “consume” and “manufacture” with reference to the decided cases and ultimately took the view:

    “On the facts of this case, we are of the opinion that sliced pineapple, despite the rejection of the inedible portions, the core, the crown and the end of the fruit, and despite the processes involved in packing it in tin containers for being made available in the market, remains the same as pineapple, there is no ‘consumption’ of the commodity; nor any process of ‘manufacture’ of ‘other goods’.”

    9. This decision of the Kerala High Court was affirmed by the Supreme Court in Deputy Commissioner Of Sales Tax v. Pio Food Packers [1980] 46 S.T.C 63 S.C.. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court observed:

    “Section 5A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act envisages the consumption of a commodity in the manufacture of another commodity. The goods purchased should be consumed, the consumption should be in the process of manufacture, and the result must be the manufacture of other goods. There are several criteria for-determining whether a commodity is consumed in the manufacture of another. The generally prevalent test is whether the article produced is regarded in the trade, by those who deal in it, as distinct in identity from the commodity involved in its manufacture. Commonly, manufacture is the end result of one or more processes through which the original commodity is made to pass. The nature and extent of processing may vary from one case to another, and indeed there may be several stages of processing and perhaps a different kind of processing at each stage. With each process suffered, the original commodity experiences a change. But it is only when the change, or a series of changes, take the commodity to the point where commercially it can no longer be regarded as the original commodity but instead is recognised as a new and distinct article that a manufacture can be said to take place. Where there is no essential difference in identity between the original commodity and the processed article it is not possible to say that one commodity has been consumed in the manufacture of another. Although it has undergone a degree of processing, it must be regarded as still retaining its original identity.”

    10. After referring to the decisions relied on, the court stated as follows:

    “The comment applies fully in the case before us. Although a degree of processing is involved in preparing pineapple slices from the original fruit, the commodity continues to possess its original identity, notwithstanding the removal of inedible portions, the slicing and thereafter canning it on adding sugar to preserve it………

    In the result, we hold that when pineapple fruit is processed into pineapple slices for the purpose of being sold in sealed cans there is no consumption of the original pineapple fruit for the purpose of manufacture. The case does not fall within section 5A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act. The High Court is right in the view taken by it.”

    11. As pointed out by the Kerala High Court in its judgment, the most significant word occurring in section 7-A(1)(a) of the Act is the word “consumes”. Inasmuch as the goods purchased are not consumed in the process of manufacture of some other goods, section 7-A(1)(a) will not be attracted. The very use of the word “consume” contemplates that the goods purchased should have been devoured or exhausted in the process of manufacture with the result, its identity must have been completely lost. So long as its identity remained, the goods purchased and used in the manufacture of some other goods cannot be said to have been consumed in the process of manufacture of other goods. It is against this background, we have to consider the question raised in this case.

    12. We have already referred to what the dealers purchased in these cases and the processes they adopt for bringing into existence the end-product. From what we have stated it is clear that the raw bones purchased by the dealers in these cases cannot be said to have been consumed in the process of bringing into existence the crushed bone, bone grist, bone-meal, fluff or horn hoof, apart from the distinctive meaning that will have to be attributed to the word “manufacture”. Consequently, with regard to these purchases of the raw bones and the end-products which were sold locally, we are clearly of the opinion that the Tribunal was right in holding section 7-A(1)(a) is not attracted, as there has been no consumption of the goods purchased in the manufacture of other goods.

    13. The result is the Tribunal is right in its conclusion in this behalf and therefore all the three tax revision cases are dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.

    14. Petitions dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The State Of Tamil Nadu v. Subbaraj And Co. (And Other Cases)
    (Sep 23, 1980)