AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Sethuraman, J.) — T.C. Nos. 432 & 433 of 1975

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns two references under s. 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961: (i) T.C. No. 433 of 1975 — whether Rs. 76,429 of managing agency remuneration accrued to the assessee before 31 March 1970 and was therefore assessable in assessment year 1970-71; and (ii) T.C. No. 432 of 1975 — whether the Tribunal was right in law in reducing the quantum of penalty levied (initial reference to s. 273(c) appears at the start of the opinion, while the text later refers to applicability of s. 273(e)).

Key factual matrix (as stated in the opinion):

  • The assessee is a private limited company and was appointed managing agent of M/s. Simco Meters Ltd. under an agreement dated 12 April 1962, covering a ten-year period from 27 September 1961.
  • Clause 3 of the managing agency agreement provided remuneration calculated on net profits (10% on the first Rs.10 lakhs, with progressively reduced percentages thereafter). In cases of absence/inadequacy of profits a minimum remuneration fixed by the Government could be paid; the managing agent could draw this minimum in twelve equal monthly instalments on the last working day of each month for which it was due. Any excess over minimum was to be drawn only after audited accounts and P&L had been laid before the company in general meeting.
  • The minimum remuneration was fixed at Rs. 24,000 per annum and the assessee received Rs. 24,000 during the previous year ending 31 March 1970.
  • Computed remuneration at 10% of net profits amounted to Rs. 100,429; after crediting the Rs. 24,000, a balance of Rs. 76,429 was paid to the assessee by M/s. Simco Meters Ltd. subsequent to 7 September 1970 (the date on which the managed company's general meeting approved the accounts).
  • The assessee returned income on the basis of assessable managing agency remuneration being only Rs. 24,000 and disclosed income resulting in tax liability lower than subsequently assessed by the ITO.
  • The ITO added Rs. 76,429 to the assessee's income for assessment year 1970-71 on the ground that it was due for the period ending 31 March 1970. The AAC confirmed the ITO. The Appellate Tribunal reversed on the accrual point, holding the Rs. 76,429 accrued only after 31 March 1970 and was therefore not taxable for the assessment year in question. This gave rise to the reference in T.C. No. 433/1975.
  • Separately, the ITO initiated penalty proceedings under provisions relating to failure to file a revised estimate and pay advance tax (notice under s. 210, and reference to s. 212(3A)); the ITO initially levied a penalty of Rs. 4,031, which was confirmed by the AAC. The Tribunal, having excluded the Rs. 76,429 from assessment, computed and confirmed a minimum penalty of Rs. 305. The correctness of the Tribunal's reduction of penalty was referred in T.C. No. 432/1975.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was right in law in reducing the quantum of penalty levied under the relevant penalty provisions referred to in the opinion (initially referenced as s. 273(c), later discussion refers to s. 273(e)).
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was right in holding that to the extent of Rs. 76,429 the managing agency commission accrued to the assessee only after 31 March 1970 and hence was not assessable in the assessment year 1970-71.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The Rs. 76,429 became due to the assessee only after the managed company approved the audited statement of accounts in its general meeting on 7 September 1970; therefore that sum did not accrue on or before 31 March 1970 and was not assessable for assessment year 1970-71.
  • Insofar as the managing agency agreement expressly provided for payment of the minimum remuneration on a monthly basis, the balance (excess over minimum) lacked a contractual accrual date prior to approval of accounts, and therefore could not be treated as income accruing in that previous year.

Revenue's (ITO/AAC) Position

  • The ITO treated the Rs. 76,429 as due for the period ending 31 March 1970 and added it to the assessee's income for assessment year 1970-71.
  • For penalty purposes, the ITO and AAC held that even excluding the Rs. 76,429 the assessee's tax payable on its returned income exceeded the advance tax demanded and paid by more than 33-1/3 per cent, and therefore a revised estimate ought to have been filed under s. 212(3A), justifying a penalty (initially quantified as Rs. 4,031).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
E.D. Sassoon & Co. Ltd. v. CIT, [1954] 26 ITR 27 (SC) Managing agency remuneration arises on completion of the definite period of service (end of the year) and does not accrue de die in diem; remuneration was not held apportionable between outgoing and incoming agents where accounts were made up at year end. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that managing agency remuneration may accrue only at a terminus ad quern (end of year) rather than daily; used as an authority that remuneration did not necessarily accrue before the year end in cases where agreement fixes accrual by reference to the year-end.
Morvi Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) Calcutta, [1971] 82 ITR 835 (SC) Where the managing agency agreement specifically fixed a date (e.g., 31 December) for accrual, the commission accrues on that date even if payment is deferred until after accounts are passed; distinction between accrual and right to receive. The Court cited Morvi to explain that when an agreement specifies a due date for accrual, the income accrues on that date; used to contrast cases where an accrual date is specified with cases (like the present) where no specific accrual date for the excess commission is fixed.
CIT v. Birla Gwalior (P.) Ltd., [1973] 89 ITR 266 (SC) Where no due date is fixed in the managing agency agreement, the commission can be ascertained only after the managed company makes up its accounts; the real question is whether income has in fact accrued. The Court relied on Birla Gwalior to emphasize that absent a contractual due date, accrual depends on whether the income has in fact accrued; this decision informed the Court's conclusion about accrual timing where the contract is silent.
CIT v. Shoorji Vallabhdas & Co., [1962] 46 ITR 144 If an income did not in fact result, there is no tax liability even though bookkeeping may show a hypothetical income; in cash system receipt equates to accrual, while in mercantile system accrual may precede receipt. The opinion invoked Shoorji Vallabhdas to support the proposition that where income did not accrue on or before the accounting year-end, tax could not be imposed; the Court used the distinction between cash and mercantile systems to explain accrual principles.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two linked strands: (A) the accrual question as to the Rs. 76,429 managing agency commission, and (B) the consequence for penalty liability.

A. Accrual Analysis

  1. The Court examined the terms of the managing agency agreement. It found a specific contractual provision for the minimum remuneration to be payable monthly (and the assessee had in fact received Rs. 24,000 for the year ending 31 March 1970), but there was no specific contractual provision fixing the date on which the excess commission (the balance over the minimum) would accrue.
  2. Because the agreement did not fix a date of accrual for the excess commission, the Court held that the date of accrual must be taken to be the date when the amount became payable to the assessee (i.e., when the assessee had a right to receive it), rather than automatically treating it as due on the last date of the accounting year.
  3. The Court relied on established Supreme Court decisions to delineate the principles: (i) where an agreement fixes a due date (Morvi), accrual occurs on that date even if payment is postponed; (ii) where the agreement is silent, the key question is whether the income has in fact accrued (Birla Gwalior and Shoorji Vallabhdas); and (iii) remuneration which is by its terms ascertainable only after the making up of accounts cannot be treated as having accrued earlier merely because the accounting year ended.
  4. Applying these principles to the facts, the Court concluded that the excess commission of Rs. 76,429 did not accrue to the assessee on or before 31 March 1970 because the managing company only approved the accounts on 7 September 1970 and the agreement contained no provision fixing an earlier accrual date for that excess. Consequently, the amount was not assessable in assessment year 1970-71.

B. Penalty Analysis

  1. The penalty reference arose from proceedings under the advance tax/estimate regime: a notice under s. 210 required payment of advance tax, the assessee paid instalments, and later returned a higher income. The ITO considered that tax payable even on the returned income exceeded the advance tax paid by more than 33-1/3 percent and levied a penalty under the relevant penalty provisions (the opinion references s. 273(c) initially and later refers to applicability of s. 273(e)).
  2. The Tribunal reduced the penalty after excluding the Rs. 76,429 from the assessment and computed the minimum penalty as Rs. 305; the ITO/AAC had levied a larger penalty (Rs. 4,031).
  3. The Court observed that the applicability of the stated penalty provision was not in dispute; the only contested point was whether, having regard to the correct assessment (i.e., exclusion of Rs. 76,429), the Tribunal was right to compute the minimum penalty of Rs. 305.
  4. Because the Court had concluded that the Rs. 76,429 was not assessable in the year under consideration, it followed that the Tribunal correctly computed the minimum penalty at Rs. 305. The Court noted that the position would have been different had the revenue's contention been accepted that Rs. 76,429 was assessable for that year.

Holding and Implications

Core Holdings

  • On accrual and assessment (T.C. No. 433 of 1975): The question whether Rs. 76,429 had accrued by 31 March 1970 is answered in the affirmative in favour of the assessee — i.e., the Court held that Rs. 76,429 did not accrue on or before 31 March 1970 and therefore was not assessable in assessment year 1970-71.
  • On penalty (T.C. No. 432 of 1975): The question regarding the levy of penalty is answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee — the Tribunal was justified in computing the minimum penalty at Rs. 305 given that Rs. 76,429 was not assessable in that year. The assessee is also awarded its costs and counsel's fee of Rs. 500.

Direct Consequences and Implications on the Parties

  • The Rs. 76,429 excess managing agency remuneration is not charged to tax for assessment year 1970-71 (it accrued only after 31 March 1970).
  • The penalty originally levied by the ITO (quantified higher by the ITO/AAC) was reduced by the Tribunal to a minimum of Rs. 305, and the Court upheld that computation; the assessee is entitled to costs and counsel's fee of Rs. 500.

Broader precedent impact: The opinion applies and distinguishes existing Supreme Court authorities on accrual of managing agency remuneration (E.D. Sassoon; Morvi Industries; Birla Gwalior; Shoorji Vallabhdas) but the Court's conclusion is contextual to the contractual terms at issue. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel principle beyond the application and reconciliation of those authorities to the facts before it.

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Tamil Nadu-Ii v. South Madras Industrial Development Co. (P.) Ltd.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Sethuraman, J.:— In T.C No. 432 of 1975, the following is the question that has been referred to this court under s. 256(1) of the I.T Act, 1961

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was right in law in reducing the quantum of penalty levied under section 273(c) of the Income-tax Act of 1961?”

    2. In T.C No. 433 of 1975, the following question has been referred

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was right in holding that to the extent of Rs. 76,429 the managing agency commission accrued to the assessee only after March 31, 1970, and hence was not assessable in the assessment year 1970-71?”

    3. The assessee is a private limited company. Whether the amount of Rs. 76,429 is assessable in 1970-71 or 1971-72, is not likely to be of any consequence, because ordinarily the tax rates leviable on companies are more or less uniform, whatever be the total income of the company. However, in the present case, the question assumes some significance because of the penalty proceedings. We shall first set out the facts relating to the assessment proceedings before going into the penalty proceedings. The assessee entered into an agreement with M/s. Simco Meters Ltd. on 12th April, 1962, under which it was appointed as the managing agent for a period of 10 years from 27th September, 1961, that being the date of the incorporation of the’ managed company. Clause 3 of the agreement provided that the assessee should be paid for its work as managing agent remuneration as detailed therein. It was to be at the rate of 10 per cent, on the first Rs. 10 lakhs of net profit or fraction thereof of the managed company, and thereafter, the percentage of net profit payable as remuneration went on going down on a progressively reduced scale. In the absence of or inadequacy of profits, the agent was to be paid such minium remuneration per year as may be fixed by the Government, and the managing agent could draw the same in twelve equal instalments on the last working day of the month for which the remuneration was due. Any amount due over and above the minimum remuneration was to be drawn by the managing agent after the audited balance-sheet and profit and loss account of the company for the relative year had been laid before the company in general meeting.

    4. The minimum remuneration was fixed at Rs. 24,000 per year with the approval of the Government of India. The assessee received this sum of Rs. 24,000 from M/s. Simco Meters Ltd. during the relevant previous year ending March 31, 1970. The total remuneration calculated at 10 per cent, of the net profits, under the terms of the agreement, came to Rs. 1,00,429. The balance of Rs. 76,429, after giving credit to the sum of Rs. 24,000, was paid to the assessee-company by M/s. Simco Meters Ltd., subsequent to September 7, 1970, on which date the general body meeting of the managed company approved the statement of accounts and affairs.

    5. The assessee filed a return disclosing its income on the basis that the managing agency remuneration assessable on it, was only Rs. 24,000 and after claiming the deduction due with respect to the income, the balance of the income disclosed in the return was Rs. 22,279. The ITO determined the total income as Rs. 98,726. In doing so, he made an addition of Rs. 76,429 on the ground that the remuneration to that extent was due to the assessee for the period ending on 31st March, 1970, and was, therefore, assessable for the assessment year 1970-71.

    6. The assessee appealed to the AAC and contended before him that this sum of Rs. 76,429 became due only after the managed company had approved the audited statement of accounts in the meeting held on September 7, 1970, and, therefore, was not assessable as its income for the assessment year under consideration. The AAC rejected this contention and confirmed the order of assessment.

    7. The assessee appealed to the Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal after referring to certain decisions cited before it and having regard to the fact that the managing agency agreement entered into between the assessee and the managed company had not fixed the date of accrual, held that the remuneration of Rs. 76,429 accrued only after 31st March, 1970, and hence was not liable to be taxed in its hands for the assessment year under consideration. It is this order of the Tribunal that has given rise to the question whether the sum of Rs. 76,429 accrued to the assessee as managing agency remuneration only after 31st March, 1970, so as not to be assessed in the assessment year 1970-71.

    8. The question as to when the managing agency remuneration is liable to be assessed, has been considered by the Supreme Court in some cases. Before referring to the decisions, it may be useful to refer to the relevant provisions of the Companies Act. Prior to the Companies Act of 1956, the managing agency remuneration fell under two parts; one was the monthly remuneration called office allowance, and the other was based on net profits and sometimes on the turnover either by way of sale or by way of purchase or both. Section 354 of the Companies Act, 1956, provided that the managing agent shall not be paid any office allowance and, therefore what was previously paid as monthly remuneration was no longer available. The remuneration calculated on the net profits of the company could alone be contracted for. It was provided in s. 348 of the Companies Act, that a company shall not pay to its managing agent in respect of any financial year beginning at or after the commencement of the Act, by way of remuneration, any sum in excess of ten per cent, of the net profits of the company for that financial year. It is this maximum of 10 per cent, which was reduced when the profits went up. The procedure for determining the net profit is to be found in s. 349. Section 353 provides that the remuneration payable to the managing agent for any financial year or part thereof shall not be paid to him until the accounts of the company for such financial year have been audited and laid before the company in general meeting. Under the proviso to that section, the minimum remuneration, if any, payable in pursuance of s. 198 may be paid to the managing agent in such suitable instalments as may be specified either in the articles of the company or in a resolution passed by the company at the annual general meeting, or in the managing agency agreement executed by the company. Section 198 provided that the total managerial remuneration payable by a public company or a private company which is a subsidiary of a public company shall not exceed the eleven per cent, of the net profits of that company. Thus there is a ceiling on the managing agency remuneration fixed under s. 348 read with s. 198 of the Companies Act. Section 353 regulated the time when the remuneration was to be paid. However, these provisions do not deal with the time of accrual of remuneration which is relevant for the purpose of income-tax. It is on this aspect of accrual that the decisions of the Supreme Court throw light.

    9. In E.D Sassoon & Co. Ltd. v. CIT, [1954] 26 ITR 27 (SC), the question of assessability of the managing agency remuneration when there was an assignment of the managing agency agreement in the course of a year arose for consideration. Sassoon & Co. were the managing agents of certain textile mills. Under the managing agency agreement, the managing agents were entitled to receive a commission on the annual net profits which was due on the 31st of March every year. The managing agent assigned the office to another company by name Agarwal & Co. and the accounts of the managing agency commission payable to the managing agent for the calendar year were made up in 1944. Sassoon & Co. were the managing agents up to 1st December, 1943, and, thereafter, Agarwal & Co. The question was whether in the assessment year 1944-45 Agarwal & Co. was liable to pay tax on accrual basis on the whole of the commission, or whether the tax was payable by Agarwal & Co. and Sassoon & Co. on proper apportionment being made between them having regard to the period during which they rendered service. The Supreme Court held that the managing agency remuneration was not liable to apportionment in proportion to the services rendered by each one of them, but that Agarwal & Co. was liable to pay tax on the whole commission. The majority of their Lordships considered that the remuneration payable by the managed company to the managing agents arose only on the completion of the definite period of service, and that it was a condition precedent for the recovery of any wages or salary that the services or duties should be completely performed. The right to receive the remuneration or commission would, according to their Lordships, arise only at the end of the year which was the terminus ad quern for the making up of the accounts and ascertaining the net profits earned by the managed company. This decision established the proposition that the managing agency remuneration did not accrue de die in diem or daily, but only at the end of the year.

    10. In Morvi Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Central) Calcutta, [1971] 82 ITR 835 (SC), the assessee was the managing agent of its own subsidiary company. The managing agent was entitled to receive an office allowance of Rs. 1,000 per month and a commission on net profits and an additional commission on purchases and sales.’During the calendar years 1954 & 55, the managed company suffered loss and the assessse earned commission only on the sale of cloth and yarn for those two years. Under cl. 2(e) of the managing agency agreement, commission was due to the assessee on 31st December, 1954, 31st December, 1955, respectively, and it was payable after the annual accounts of the managed company were passed in the general meetings held in November, ‘55, and July, ‘56, respectively. Prior to the annual general meetings in November, ‘55, and July, ‘56, the board of directors resolved to relinquish the managing agency commission on sales and office allowance because the managed company was suffering losses in the past years. The question was whether the managing agent was still liable to be assessed on the remuneration due to it, but forgone by it. The Tribunal held that the relinquishment was after it had become due and was of no effect. The further finding of the Tribunal was that the amount forgone by the assessee could not be said to be expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the managing agent's business. The High Court agreed with these findings. The Supreme Court held that the commission had under the agreement accrued to the assessee on December 31, 1954, and December 31, 1955, and the fact that the payment was deferred till after the accounts were passed by the managed company in its annual general meetings did not affect the accrual of the income. As the income was given up unilaterally by the assessee after accrual, it was held that it could not escape liability to tax. At page 838, it is stated that cl. 2(e) of the managing agency agreement in that case provided that the commission due to the agent yearly on the 31st day of December or any other date on which the company's yearly accounts were closed in each and every year. Having regard to this specific provision in the managing agency agreement, the Supreme Court pointed out that the commission was due on 31st December of every year, though it was payable only after the annual general meeting of the company. The distinction between the amount accruing to an assessee and the assessee's right to receive it, was pointed out.

    11. This problem came to be considered, again in CIT v. Birla Gwalior (P.) Ltd., [1973] 89 ITR 266 (SC). The assessee in that case was also a managing agent of two companies. The managing agent was entitled to an office allowance and also commission. No date was fixed for the payment of commission in the managing agency agreement. The assessee gave up the managing agency commission due for the previous years relevant for the assessment years 1954-55, to 1956-57 after the end of the previous years but before the accounts were made up by the managed companies. The Appellate Tribunal held that the commission given up was not the managing agent's real income and that in any event it had been given up on grounds of commercial expediency and was, therefore, an allowable deduction under s. 10(2)(xv) of the Indian I.T Act, 1922. The High Court on a reference came to the conclusion that the commission forgone was not the real income. When the matter came to be considered by the Supreme Court, there were two, questions which were considered by the Supreme Court. One was whether the commission forgone by the assessee was allowable as a revenue expenditure and the other was whether the office allowance forgone was allowable as a revenue expenditure under s. 10(2)(xv). The Supreme Court pointed out at page 270:

    “As mentioned earlier, no due date was fixed for the payment of the commission under the managing agency agreements, The commission receivable could have been ascertained only after the managed company made up its account.”

    12. Reference was made to the decision in Morvi Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Central) Calcutta, [1971] 82 ITR 835 (SC), and it was pointed out at page 273 in relation to that decision:

    “In arriving at the conclusion that the income in question accrued on the 31st December, 1955, and 31st December, 1956, this court primarily took into consideration the terms of the agreement.”

    13. It was also pointed out that the decision in Morvi Industries’ case emphasised the fact that the real question for decision was whether the income had really accrued or not.

    14. The question for consideration is whether the present case falls within the scope of the principle in Morvi Industries' case or CIT v. Birla Gwalior (P.) Ltd., [1973] 89 ITR 266 (SC). In the present case we have already referred to the terms of the managing agency agreement under which there is a specific provision relating to the minimum remuneration being payable to the managing agent at the end of every month. As regards the rest of the commission, there is no specific provision as to when it accrues. In the absence of such a provision, we have to take it that it accrues at a time when it became payable to the assessee. As pointed out by the Supreme Court in CIT v. Shoorji Vallabhdas and Co., [1962] 46 ITR 144 at 148, if an income did not result at all, there could not be a tax even though in bookkeeping an entry is made about a hypothetical income which did not materialise. In the case of cash system of accounting the problem which is now before us was not likely to arise as the receipt is synonymous with accrual in such cases. However, in the case of mercantile system of accounting where the amount under the contract is due to an assessee even though its payment is postponed, the liability to tax arises at the time when the amount is due, though the amount is actually paid subsequently. Where the contract is silent as to when the amount becomes due then it is not possible to treat the amount as being due on the last date of the accounting year. In such a case, the date of accrual will be the same as the date of the right to receive it. In the present case, the income did not accrue at all to the assessee on or before March 31, 1970, so that there is no question of it being assessed in the assessment year 1970-71. The result is that the question in T.C No. 433 of 1975 has to be and is answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee. Now turning to the reference in T.C No. 432 of 1975, relating to the levy of penalty, the question arose on account of the deficiency in the payment of the advance tax. A notice u/s. 210 of the I.T Act was issued to the assessee calling upon it to pay the advance tax of Rs. 6,806 on the estimated income of Rs. 10,470. The assessee paid the instalments in response to the said notice. However, it filed a return on September 24, 1970, disclosing an income of Rs. 22,297 and the tax payable thereon amounted to Rs. 13,145. The assessment was completed on a total income of Rs. 98,730 and the tax payable was Rs. 56,019. In the assessment so made, the sum of Rs. 76,429 was added as the managing agency remuneration. The ITO noting that the tax payable even on the income as returned exceeded the advance tax demanded from and paid by the assessee by more than 33-⅓ per cent, initiated action for levy of penalty for the assessee's failure to send a revised estimate of income and payment of advance tax on the basis of such revised estimate as required by s. 212(3A). The assessee submitted his objections to the proposal to levy penalty and the ITO held that even on the basis that a sum of Rs. 76,429 was not included, the assessee should have filed a revised estimate under s. 212(3A) and, therefore, levied a penalty of Rs. 4,031. The AAC confirmed the order of the ITO. On further appeal, the Tribunal held that the sum of Rs. 76,429 which was included in the assessment was not liable to be included. With reference to the balance of the income, the Tribunal considered that the minimum penalty leviable was only Rs. 305 and, therefore, confirmed the levy of a penalty of Rs. 305. It is to this part of the order of the Tribunal relating to the penalty, that the question reproduced above was raised and referred to this court.

    15. The applicability of the provisions of s. 273(e) is not in dispute, and the only point to be considered is whether the Tribunal was justified in computing Rs. 305 as the minimum penalty leviable. If the sum of Rs. 76,429 was not taken as assessable in the year of assessment under consideration, then it is not in dispute that the sum of Rs. 305 would be the minimum penalty leviable. As we have held Rs. 76,429 was not assessable in this year, we are satisfied that the Tribunal did not commit any error of law in computing the minimum penalty of Rs. 305. The position would have been different if we had accepted the contention of the revenue that the sum of Rs. 76,429 was also assessable in the year of assessment under consideration. Consequently, the question as regards the penalty is answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee. The assessee is entitled to its costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 500 (one set).

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Tamil Nadu-Ii v. South Madras Industrial Development Co. (P.) Ltd.
    (Jul 9, 1979)