Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-Sec. (4) attracts Ss. 5 and 12 of the Indian limitation Act
  • Employees Insurance Court. Sub-Sec. (2) of that section
  • S. 73-A of the Employees State Insurance Act.
  • S. 78 of the Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-Sec. (4) attracts Ss. 5 and 12 of the Indian limitation Act
  • Employees Insurance Court. Sub-Sec. (2) of that section
  • S. 73-A of the Employees State Insurance Act.
  • S. 78 of the Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges an order of the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Madras, which held the appellant liable to pay the employer's special contribution to the Employees' State Insurance Corporation under S. 73-A of the Employees' State Insurance Act. Before the Commissioner the appellant denied liability on two grounds: (1) that the persons employed in his establishment were not "workmen" as defined by S. 2(9) of the Act, and (2) that the establishment was not a "factory" as defined in the Factories Act. Before the present court the appellant additionally contested that the indicia of master-and-servant were absent and thus the appellant did not fall within the Act's purview.

The petition before the Commissioner was brought under S. 78 of the Employees' State Insurance Act, but was decided by the Additional Commissioner rather than by an Employees Insurance Court. The appeal to the High Court is claimed under S. 82 of the Act. The respondent contended that S. 82 applies only to orders of the Employees Insurance Court, not to orders made by an authority appointed under S. 73-B(1) (in this case the Additional Commissioner). Because the Court found it unnecessary to reach the merits in view of the jurisdictional issue, the substantive questions about the employment relationship and factory status were not decided on the merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal under S. 82 of the Employees' State Insurance Act lies from an order made by an authority (here, the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation) constituted under S. 73-B(1) when an Employees Insurance Court has not been constituted.
  2. Whether the authority appointed under S. 73-B(1) should be treated as equivalent to an Employees Insurance Court for the purpose of appeal under S. 82.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The persons employed in the appellant's establishment were not "workmen" as defined by S. 2(9) of the Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • The appellant's establishment was not a "factory" as defined in the Factories Act.
  • On appeal, the appellant argued that the indicia of master-and-servant were absent, so the appellant would not fall within the purview of the Employees' State Insurance Act.

Respondent's Arguments

  • S. 82 of the Employees' State Insurance Act does not apply to an order made by the Additional Commissioner (an authority constituted under S. 73-B(1)) and is confined to orders made by an Employees Insurance Court.
  • Implicitly, it was argued (and considered) that where an authority under S. 73-B(1) exercises the same powers as an Employees Insurance Court in relation to certain disputes, it should be regarded as virtually an Insurance Court for the purpose of appeal under S. 82.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
East Asiatic Co. v. Regional Director, E.S.I Corporation(1) Authority cited as having held that an appeal lay (as apparently expressed by Venkatadri, J.). The court stated that Venkatadri, J. was apparently of the view that an appeal lay, but the present court could not share that view. The court noted that the learned Judge's attention did not appear to have been drawn to differences in constitution, powers and procedures (including S. 73-B(2)), and therefore did not follow that approach.
P.P Works and Co. v. Union of India(2) Used as authority supporting the view that no appeal lies from orders of an authority constituted under S. 73-B(1). The court observed that Shah, C.J. and Baxi, J. in that case took the same view as the present court, and thus relied on it as supportive precedent for the conclusion that no appeal under S. 82 lies from an authority under S. 73-B(1).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the statutory scheme in Chapter VI of the Employees' State Insurance Act. It noted:

  • S. 74 empowers the State Government to constitute an Employees Insurance Court by notification; S. 75 lists matters to be decided by such a Court.
  • Ss. 76 to 81 prescribe procedural rules to be followed by the Employees Insurance Court (institution, commencement, powers, appearance by counsel, limitation for claims, referral of questions of law to the High Court).
  • S. 82(1) states that, except as expressly provided, no appeal lies against an order of an Employees Insurance Court; S. 82(2) permits an appeal to the High Court from an Employees Insurance Court order if it involves a substantial question of law; S. 82(4) applies Ss. 5 and 12 of the Indian Limitation Act to appeals under the section.

On this statutory reading the court concluded that an appeal under S. 82 is available only from an order of an Employees Insurance Court as constituted under S. 74. Where no Employees Insurance Court exists, S. 73-B(1) directs that the Central Government may specify another authority to decide disputes concerning an employer's special contribution under Chapter V-A; by notification the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation had been specified for the present case.

Sub-section (2) of S. 73-B makes certain procedural provisions (sub-section (1) of S. 76 and Ss. 77 to 79 and 81) apply "so far as may be" to proceedings before an authority specified under S. 73-B(1). Crucially, S. 73-B(2) makes no reference to S. 82 and thus does not make S. 82 applicable to proceedings under S. 73-B(1). The court observed that, as the section currently stands, there is therefore no provision for an appeal from an order made by an authority constituted under S. 73-B(1).

The court rejected the argument that an authority under S. 73-B(1) should, for the purpose of appeals, be regarded as virtually an Employees Insurance Court. The rejection was based on the statutory distinction: an Employees Insurance Court is constituted specifically under S. 74, by a different process and authority, and the bodies are distinct in constitution, set up, powers and procedures. The mere fact that, where an Employees Insurance Court does not exist, an authority under S. 73-B(1) is expected to decide certain disputes does not clothe it with the character of an Employees Insurance Court for appeal purposes.

The court noted that Venkatadri, J., in East Asiatic Co. v. Regional Director had apparently taken the view that an appeal lay, but the present court disagreed and indicated that the earlier judgment did not appear to consider S. 73-B(2). The court also referred to P.P Works and Co. v. Union of India where judges reached the same view as the present court. Although the judge would have preferred to refer the question to a Division Bench, he felt bound by the clear statutory provision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: APPEAL NOT MAINTAINABLE AND DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The appeal was dismissed on the jurisdictional ground that S. 82 does not provide for an appeal from an authority constituted under S. 73-B(1) (here, the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation).
  • The Court did not decide the merits of the appellant's contentions regarding the employment relationship or factory status; those substantive questions remain undetermined by this judgment.
  • No costs were awarded.

Judge's initials as in the opinion: V.C.S

    Kandaswami Weaving Factory I Co., Represented Partnership Firm By Mg. Partner J. K.K Natarajan v. Regional Director, Employees State Insurance Corporation, Madras.

    This appeal is directed against an order of the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, Madras, holding that the appellant is liable to pay the employer's special contribution to the Employees' State Insurance Corporation, Madras, under S. 73-A of the Employees State Insurance Act. The appellant contended that before the Commissioner that the persons employed in his establishment were not workmen as defined by S. 2 (9) of the Act and that the establishment itself was not a factory as defined in the Factories. Act. On those grounds, he denied his liability to make the employer's special contribution. Before me the order of the Commissioner sioner has been canvassed on the ground that the indicia required to constitute the relationship of master and servant are wholly absent, so that the appellant would not come within the purview of the Employees' State Insurance Act. But in view of the question raised for the respondent and the view I take on that question, it has become unnecessary to deal with the validity of the order on its merits.

    The petition before the Commissioner was no doubt under S. 78 of the Employees' State Insurance Act. But the petition was actually dealt with not by the Employees Insurance Court but by the Commissioner. The appeal before me is under S. 82 of the Act. What is argued by the respondent is that S. 82 does not apply to an order made by the Commissioner and it is confined only to orders made by the Employees Insurance Court. It seems to me that the objection has force. Chapter VI of the Act relates to adjudication of disputes and claims. S. 74 provides for the constitution of the Employees Insurance Court by the State Government by notification in the Official Gazette. The matters to be decided by such a Court are enumerated in S. 75. Ss. 76 to 81 contain rules of procedure to be followed by the Employees Insurance Court relating to institution, commencement of proceedings, the Court's powers, appearance by Counsel, time limit for making claims and reference by the Employees Insurance Court of a question of law for the decision of the High Court. S. 82 (1) says that save as expressly provided in the Section, no appeal shall lie against an order of an Employees Insurance Court. Sub-Sec. (2) of that section provides for an appeal to the High Court from an order of an Employees Insurance Court if it involves a substantial question of law. The next sub-section provides for a period of limitation for an appeal and Sub-Sec. (4) attracts Ss. 5 and 12 of the Indian limitation Act to appeals under the section. It is obvious, therefore, that an appeal under S. 82 will only lie on a point of law from an order of an Employees Insurance Court as constituted under S. 74. The claim here in question related, as already mentioned, to the appellant's liability to make employee's special contribution to the Corporation. Sec. 73-A enjoins that every principal employer shall pay to the Corporation a special contribution at the rates specified under the section. Disputes or questions relating to such contribution under the contemplation of the Act are generally to be decided by the Employees' Insurance Court where one exists. In fact, S. 75 specifically says that the Employees' Insurance Court will, among other things, have jurisdiction to decide whether any person is an employee within the meaning of the Act or whether he is liable to pay the employee's contribution. Where no such Insurance Court has been constituted for a particular jurisdiction, S. 73-B (1) directs that if any question or dispute arises in respect of an employer's special contribution payable or recoverable under Chapter V-A, such question or dispute shall be decided by such authority as the Central Government may specify in that behalf. It is not in dispute that by notification the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation has been spedcified as the authority to decide such a question or dispute. It is in exercise of this authority, the order under appeal was made by the Additional Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation. Sub-S. (2) of S. 73-B reads :

    “The provisions of Sub-S. (1) of Ss. 76 and 77 to 79 and 81 shall, so far as may be, apply in relation to a proceeding before an authority specified under Sub-S. (1) as they apply in relation to a proceeding before an Employees Insurance Court.”

    It is significant that the sub-section makes no reference to S. 82 and does not make that section applicable in respect of proceedings under S. 73-B (1). While therefore, the statutory provisions in Ch. VI, relating to the procedure to be followed by the Employees Insurance Court, where one exists, apply to the proceedings before an authority constituted under S. 73-B (1), the terms of Sub-S. (2) of that section do not make any provision for an appeal against an order made by such authority. There appears to be a lacuna. Logically there could be no reason why when an appeal is provided against an order by the Employees Insurance Court, no such appeal is provided against an order made under S. 73-B (1). But the fact is that as S. 73-B stands at the moment, there is no appeal from an order made by an authority constituted under S. 73-B (1).

    It is argued that because an authority under S. 73-B (1) is empowered to decide a dispute relating to an employer's liability to pay special contribution which an Employees Insurance Court, where one is constituted, can decide, for that purpose and for the purpose of appeal under S. 82, the authority under S. 73-B(1) should be regarded as virtually an Insurance Court, In other words, the argument is that if the same powers, as the Employees Insurance Court may exercise, are exercisable by the authority under S. 73-B (1), by a process of equation the authority must be regarded as an Insurance Court. The fallacy underlying the argument is obvious because the constitution of the Employees Insurance Court is under the specific provision, namely, under S. 74 and by an authority different from the case of the authority under S. 73-B (1). It may not also be correct to say that the authority under S. 73-B (1) and the Employees Insurance Court exercise parallel powers in all respects. The authority and the Emloyees Insurance Court are entirely two different bodies and the fact that where an Employees Insurance Court does not exist, the authority is expected to decide certain disputes, will not clothe it with the character of an Emyloyees Insurance Court. In my view, therefore, no appeal lies under S. 82 from the order of an authority constituted under S. 73-B (1). Venkatadri, J., in East Asiatic Co. v. Regional Director, E.S.I Corporation(1), was apparently of the view that an appeal lay with due respect, I am unable to share this view. Normally, I would hare referred the question to a Division Bench. As far as I can see from the reported judgment of the learned Judge; it does not appear that his pointed attention was drawn to the difference in the constitution, set up, powers and procedures in relation to the authority referred to under S. 73-B(1) and an Employees Insurance Court under S. 74. Especially Sub-S. (2) of S. 73-B does not appear to have been considered there because the learned Judge's attention was not invited to it. I feel that I am bound by the statutory provision which is expressly clear. Reference may also be made to P.P Works and Co. v. Union of India(2), where Shah, C.J and Baxi, J., took the same view as I have taken.

    The appeal is not maintainable and is dismissed on that ground. No costs.

    V.C.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kandaswami Weaving F... v. Regional Director, E...
    (Feb 5, 1965)