AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent appeal arises from a dispute over subrogation rights connected with several mortgages and a later sale of mortgaged property. Between 1924 and 1934 multiple mortgage deeds were executed by Jagandhara (husband of defendant 7) in respect of items listed in Schedule B of the plaint:

  • 6 Aug 1924: Ex. D-1 — mortgage in favour of defendants 2 and 3 over item 4 for Rs. 1,000;
  • 6 Sept 1924: Ex. P-1 — mortgage in favour of defendants 4 and 5 over items 1–3 for Rs. 750;
  • 29 June 1930: Ex. D-2 — mortgage by Jagandhara to defendants 2 and 3 over items 1, 3 and 4 for Rs. 500;
  • 11 July 1930: Ex. P-2 — mortgage for Rs. 1,670 over items 1–5.

On 7 Oct 1933 (Ex. D-11) Mahalakshmi (the vendor's minor daughter, represented by her father) executed a sale-deed conveying item 4 to defendants 2 and 3 for Rs. 2,500, the consideration being composed of (1) Rs. 1,710 due under Ex. D-1 (assigned to defendant 6), (2) the principal and interest due under Ex. D-2, and (3) cash of Rs. 126-14-0. Defendants 2 and 3 later admitted in a 31 Mar 1934 statement (E. P. No. 788 of 1933) that Ex. D-2 was discharged and that the property was not subject to that mortgage. On 29 Aug 1938 defendants 2 and 3 paid defendant 6 the sum due under Ex. D-1 (Ex. D-1(a) records the endorsement acknowledging payment).

Following a money decree against the mortgagors, items 1, 2 and 5 were sold in court on 2 Nov 1934 and purchased by defendant 3, who later sold them (Ex. D-7 dated 10 Sept 1938) to defendant 1. The plaintiff is the assignee of mortgage rights under Ex. P-1 and Ex. P-2 and instituted O.S. No. 27 of 1942 to enforce those mortgages.

In the trial court the Subordinate Judge rejected priority/subrogation claims by defendants 1, 2 and 3. The District Judge allowed those claims on appeal. On further appeal (S. A. No. 759 of 1945) Patanjali Sastri J. agreed with the Subordinate Judge and set aside the District Judge's decree. With leave of that Judge the defendants whose priority claims were rejected brought the present Letters Patent appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether defendants 2 and 3, who were puisne mortgagees under Ex. D-2 and later purchasers of item 4 under Ex. D-11, were entitled to subrogation to the rights of the prior mortgagee under paragraph 1 (legal subrogation) of Section 92, Transfer of Property Act, in respect of Ex. D-1.
  2. How Sections 91 and 92 of the Transfer of Property Act should be construed in the factual matrix: specifically, whether the existence of a pre-existing interest on the date of the sale-deed (Ex. D-11) suffices for subrogation, or whether the manner and purpose of payment/discharge of the prior mortgage determine which paragraph of Section 92 applies.
  3. Whether paragraph 3 of Section 92 (conventional subrogation) applies, and if so whether its conditions (including the requirement of a registered agreement) were satisfied to permit subrogation for the persons who advanced or paid sums to discharge Ex. D-1.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as represented by Mr. Narasaraju)

  • Accepting the learned judge's conclusion as to item 1, counsel confined his argument to item 4.
  • He contended that defendants 2 and 3 were puisne mortgagees of item 4 prior to their purchase under Ex. D-11 and therefore had a pre-existing interest in the mortgaged property.
  • On that basis, they claimed entitlement to subrogation under paragraph 1 of Section 92 (legal subrogation), arguing that existence of an interest on the date of the sale-deed was sufficient for subrogation irrespective of whether the prior mortgage was discharged to protect that interest or pursuant to an agreement with the vendor.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' separate legal arguments in the same particularized form.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lakshmiammal v. Sankara Narayana Menon, 59 Mad. 359; A.I.R. 1936 Mad. 171 (Full Bench) Distinction between paragraph 1 (legal subrogation) and paragraph 3 (conventional subrogation) of Section 92: paragraph 1 relates to those with pre-existing interest who discharge a prior encumbrance to protect that interest; paragraph 3 relates to persons who acquire interest only by reason of advancing money. The court extracted this distinction and relied on it as central to determining whether defendants 2 and 3 had legal subrogation: the case supports restricting paragraph 1 to those who discharge a prior charge to protect a pre-existing interest.
Subbarayudu v. Lakshminarasamma, 1939-2 M.L.J. 533; A.I.R. 1939 Mad. 949 (Division Bench) Affirmed and elaborated the principles of Lakshmiammal; provided an exhaustive exposition of Section 92 and confirmed the distinction between paras. 1 and 3. The court relied on this decision (including a summary of the law at p. 544 of that report) to support the view that paragraph 1 is confined to legal subrogation and paragraph 3 to conventional subrogation and to guide application to the facts.
Srinivasulu v. Damodaraswami Naidu, A.I.R. 1938 Mad. 779 Referred to in the opinion as having raised doubt on some observations in the Madras Pull Bench decision; part of the case-law considered when analysing the scope of Section 92. The court noted that Srinivasulu had cast doubt on some earlier observations, but that subsequent treatment (notably Subbarayudu) led to adherence to the earlier Full Bench approach; Srinivasulu was part of the wider judicial discourse considered.
Hira Singh v. Jai Singh, I.L.R. 1937 All. 880; A.I.R. 1937 All. 588 Accepted the Madras decisions' distinction: paragraph 1 = subrogation by operation of law (person himself redeems by paying out of his own pocket); paragraph 3 = subrogation by agreement (requires writing and registration). The court cited this judgment as supporting the mutual exclusivity of paragraphs 1 and 3 and the requirement of a registered instrument for conventional subrogation under paragraph 3.
Bansidhar Dhandania v. Kaloo Mandar, 17 Pat. 666; A.I.R. 1938 Pat. 532 Illustrated that when a purchaser pays prior mortgagees with money left with him by the vendors (i.e., pursuant to an agreement), paragraph 3 applies and paragraph 1 does not; payment made under a covenant from the vendor does not give legal subrogation under paragraph 1. The court relied on this example to demonstrate that payment pursuant to an agreement or from vendor-supplied funds does not create legal subrogation, supporting rejection of the appellants' broader construction.
Mukaram Marwari v. Muhammad Hossain, (reported reference in the opinion) Principle that if the debt is the debt of the person who paid it, or a debt which he has covenanted to pay, his payment raises no right of subrogation — it is performance of his own obligation. The court cited the case to reinforce that a payment of an obligation that is the payer's own does not found a right of subrogation; used to counter the appellants' claim that mere pre-existing interest on an earlier date is sufficient.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis focused on the statutory structure of Sections 91 and 92 of the Transfer of Property Act and on the equitable principle underlying subrogation. The essential analytical steps were:

  1. Statutory framing: The court emphasised that Section 91 lists persons (other than the mortgagor) who may redeem or institute a suit for redemption, and Section 92 grants subrogation rights to those persons who redeem (paragraph 1 — legal subrogation) and provides for conventional subrogation where there is an agreed (and registered) arrangement (paragraph 3).
  2. Distinction between legal and conventional subrogation: The court relied on authoritative exposition in Lakshmiammal and Subbarayudu (and supportive decisions) explaining that paragraph 1 applies where a person with a pre-existing interest pays off a prior encumbrance to protect his interest (i.e., pays out of his own pocket in excess of his legal liability), whereas paragraph 3 applies where a person acquires an interest by virtue of advancing money and there is an agreement (requiring registration) for subrogation.
  3. Application to the facts — purpose of payment: The court examined why defendants 2 and 3 discharged Ex. D-1. It concluded that they did not discharge that prior mortgage to protect a pre-existing interest; rather, they discharged it because of an obligation undertaken under the sale-deed Ex. D-11. The court emphasised the difference between paying to protect one's equity of redemption and paying pursuant to an agreement (i.e., performing an obligation).
  4. Timing and admission of discharged status: The court noted that defendants 2 and 3 had admitted (in Ex. P.9 / statement dated 31 Mar 1934) that Ex. D-2 was discharged prior to 31 Mar 1934, and Ex. D-1 was shown to be discharged on 29 Aug 1938 (Ex. D-1(a)). The court found that on the date the prior mortgage (Ex. D-1) was discharged, defendants 2 and 3 no longer had an interest in the mortgaged properties — undermining reliance on a pre-existing interest at the time of discharge.
  5. Rejection of the "crucial date" argument: The appellants argued the crucial date was the date of the sale-deed (Ex. D-11), when defendants 2 and 3 allegedly had a pre-existing puisne mortgage. The court rejected this, reasoning that the right to subrogation (and the equitable right of reimbursement) arises only upon discharge of the prior mortgage and depends on the circumstance and motive of payment at that time.
  6. Conclusion on applicable paragraph: Given that defendants 2 and 3 discharged the prior mortgage by virtue of an obligation under the sale-deed and not to protect a then-existing interest, and given that the conditions of paragraph 3 (conventional subrogation) — notably a registered agreement conferring subrogation — were not satisfied, the court concluded paragraph 3 governed the situation and its conditions had not been complied with. Hence, defendants 2 and 3 were not entitled to subrogation under paragraph 1 or paragraph 3.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Appeal dismissed. The court dismissed the Letters Patent appeal and ordered costs in favour of the first respondent.

Implications:

  • The direct effect of the decision is that defendants 2 and 3 are not subrogated to the rights of the prior mortgagee under Ex. D-1; their claim to priority in respect of item 4 fails.
  • The court applied and reaffirmed the established distinction between legal subrogation (paragraph 1 of Section 92) and conventional subrogation (paragraph 3 of Section 92), holding that a payment made pursuant to an obligation under a sale-deed does not amount to legal subrogation unless the payer discharged the prior encumbrance to protect a pre-existing interest or the statutory conditions for conventional subrogation are met.
  • No broader legal innovation or new precedent was announced; the decision applied the existing authorities and statutory provisions to the facts and refused to extend paragraph 1 beyond its established scope.

    Dadi Appala Naidu And Others v. Kolluri Bhimalingam And Others.

    1. This is a Letters Patent appeal against the judgment of Patanjali Sastri J. and it raises a question of subrogation.

    2. On 6th August 1924, one Jagandhara, the husband of defendant 7, executed a mortgage deed Ex. D-1 in favour of defendants 2 and 3 in respect of item 4 of Sch. B annexed to the plaint for a sum of Rs. 1000. On 6th September 1924 he executed another mortgage deed, Ex. P 1, in favour of defendants 4 and 5 in regard to items 1 to 3 for a sum of Rs. 750. He again mortgaged items 1, 3 and 4 to defendants 2 and 3 under Ex. D-2 dated 29th June 1930 for a sum of Rs. 500. On 11th July 1930 he borrowed another sum of Rs. 1670 and executed a mortgage deed, Ex. P-2, mortgaging items 1 to 5, On 9th September 1933 by Ex. D-10, defendants 2 and 3 transferred their interest under Ex. D-l to defendant 6. Under Ex. D-11, dated 7th October 1933, Jagandhara's wife Mahalakshmi, being minor represented by her father, executed a sale-deed in favour of defendants 2 and 3 for a sum of Rs. 2500 conveying to them item 4 of the plaint B schedule. The consideration for that sale-deed was made up of three items : (1) Rs. 1710 due under the mortgage deed, Ex. D-1, which was assigned in favour of defendant 6. The vendees undertook to pay this amount. (2) The amount of principal and interest due under Ex. D-2 executed by the vendor's husband Jagandhara in favour of the vendees, i. e., defendants 2 and 3. (3) Rupees 126-14.0, the amount received in cash.

    3. On 31st March 1934, defendants 2 and 3 filed a statement in E. P. No. 788 of 1933 wherein they admitted that EX. D-2 was discharged and the property was not subject to the mortgage. On 29th August 1938, defendants 2 and 3 paid to defendant 6 the sum due under Ex. D-l and Ex. D-l (a) is the endorsement acknowledging the said payment. In execution of a simple money decree against the mortgagors, items 1, 2 and 5 were brought to sale and were purchased by defendant 3 on 2nd November 1934, who, in his turn, sold those properties under Ex. D-7 dated 10th September 1938 to defendant 1. The plaintiff is the assignee of the mortgage rights under Ex P-l and Ex. P-2. He instituted O. S. No. 27 of 1942 on the file of the Subordinate Judge of Vizagapatam to enforce the two mortgages assigned in his favour. Defendants 2 and 3 who became the owners of item 4 claimed to be subrogated to the rights under the prior mortgage Ex. D 1 which they discharged. Defendant 1 claimed in respect of item 1 the right to fall back upon the prior mortgage Ex. D-2 as against Ex. P-2 as his vendor, defendant 3, who was the mortgagee of items l, 3 and 4 under Ex. D-2 purchased that item along with items 2 and 5 in the court sale of November 1934. The learned Subordinate Judge rejected the claims of priority set up by defendants 1, 2 and 3; but the learned District Judge in appeal allowed the two claims. The plaintiff preferred S. A. No. 759 of 1945 against the decree and judgment of the learned District Judge. Patanjali Sastri J. agreed with the learned Subordinate Judge and set aside the decree of the District Judge. With the leave of the learned Judge the defendants whose claims to priority were rejected prefer this Letters Patent appeal.

    4. Mr. Narasaraju, learned counsel for the appellants accepted the conclusion of the learned Judge in regard to item 1 of the B schedule and confined his arguments only to item 4 of the plaint B schedule. He contended that defendants 2 and 3 being the puisne mortgagees of item 4 before they purchased the said item under Ex. D-11, had a pre-existing interest in the mortgaged property, and therefore were entitled to be subrogated under para. 1 of Section 92, T. P. Act. The question raised in this appeal depends upon the construction to be put on Sections 91 and 92, T. P. Act. The material provisions of the said sections read :

    "91. Besides the mortgagor, any of the following persons may redeem, or institute a suit for redemption of the mortgaged property, namely:

    (a) any person (other than the mortgagee of the interest sought to be redeemed) who has any interest in, or charge upon, the property mortgaged or in or upon the right to redeem the same;

    (b) any surety for the payment of the mortgage-debt or any part thereof; or

    (c) any creditor of the mortgagor who has in a suit for the administration of his estate obtained a decree for sale of the mortgaged property.

    92. Any of the persons referred to in Section 91 (other than the mortgagor) and any co mortgagor shall, on redeeming property subject to the mortgage, have, so far as regards redemption, foreclosure or sale of such property, the same rights as the mortgagee whose mortgage he redeems may have against the mortgagor or any other mortgagee.

    The right conferred by this section is called the right of subrogation, and a person acquiring the same is said to be subrogated to the rights of the mortgagee whose mortgage he redeems.

    A person who has advanced to a mortgagor money with which the mortgage has been redeemed shall be subrogated to the rights of the mortgagee whose mortgage has been redeemed, if the mortgagor has by a registered instrument agreed that such person shall be so subrogated. . . . ."

    Text book writers treated the law conveniently under two categories (1) Legal subrogation or subrogation by operation of law; and (2) Conventional subrogation. Sir D. F. Mulla in his commentary on the Transfer of Property Act broadly states the two principles in the following manner:

    "(1) Legal subrogation or subrogation by operation of law arises where a person who has in the property an interest of his own to protect, discharges a prior encumbrance.

    (2) Subrogation is conventional when there is an agreement express or implied that the person making the payment shall exercise the rights and powers of the original creditor."

    There was no comprehensive statement of law of subrogation in the Transfer of Property Act till Section 92 was inserted by the amending Act, XX of 1929. The first paragraph of Section 92, deals with legal subrogation and the third paragraph pro-vides for the conventional subrogation. There was a lucid and an exhaustive exposition on the interpretation of the provisions of this section by two judgments of this Court: one that of the Pull Bench reported in Lakshmiammal v. Sankara Narayana Menon, 59 Mad. 359: (A. I. R. (23) 1936 Mad. 171 FB) and the other by a Division Bench reported in Subbarayudu v. Lakshminarasamma, 1939-2 M. L. J. 533: (A. I. R. (26) 1939 Mad. 949). It would be redundant if we attempted to re-state the law at any length. It would be enough if we extract the principles embodied in those judgments and the judgments of other Courts following these judgments. The distinction between paras. 1 and 3 of Section 92, Transfer of Property Act, has been succinctly brought out by Varadachariar J, in Lakshmiammal v. Sankaranarayana Menon, 59 Mad. 359: (A. I. R. (23) 1936 Mad. 171 F. B.) in the following passage:

    "There is a well established distinction between cases in which a person who has a pre-existing interest in property pays off a prior charge on that property for the protection of his own interest and cases in which a person acquires an interest in property only by reason of his advancing money to pay off an existing mortgage debt. It seems to me that clause 1, Section 92 must be held to relate to the first type of cases above referred to and clause 3 to the second type."

    Venkataramana Rao states the law to the same effect but in different terms. He says:

    "The first clause enunciates no new principle (Vide Section 74. Transfer of Property Act, since repealed). It applies to all persons who have an interest in the equity of redemption and are under no personal obligation to discharge prior incumbrances. Clause 3 has been enacted to confer a benefit on persons who advance money to discharge an incumbrance only 'if the mortgagee has by a registered instrument agreed that such persons shall be subrogated'. The clause is intended to apply to all persons who acquire an interest in the mortgaged property by advancing moneys to discharge prior incumbrances and there is no warrant for restricting the scope of that clause to persons other than purchasers or mortgagees."

    In view of the observations of Venkatasubba Rao and Abdur Rahman JJ. in Srinivasulu v. Damodaraswami Naidu, A. I. R. (26) 1938 Mad. 779: (1938 M. W. N. 708) throwing considerable doubt on the correctness of the aforesaid observations; Venkataramana Rao J., had to consider the position in greater detail in his judgment reported in Subbarayudu v. Lakshminarasamma, 1939-2. M. L. J. 533: (A. I. R. (26) 1989 Mad. 949). After exhaustively considering the case-law on the subject, he adhered to the view expressed by him in the Pull Bench judgment Lakshmiammal v. Sankara Narayana, 59 Mad. 359: (A. I. R. (23) 1936 Mad. 171 F. B.). At p. 544 the learned Judge summarises the law under various aspects which may usefully be referred to.

    5. In Hira Singh v. Jai Singh, I. L. R. 1937 ALL. 880: (A. I. R. (24) 1937 ALL. 588 F. B.) Sulaiman C. J. accepts the law as enunciated in the Madras decisions and states it in his own words at page 893 as follows:

    Now it is well known that subrogation can arise in two ways, (1) by agreement and (2) by operation of law. Paragraph 1 deals with subrogation arising by operation of law and paragraph 3 deals with subrogation by agreement. It is necessary that there should be an agreement for subrogation, that the agreement should be in writing and that it should be a. registered instrument. It would be impossible to hold that these two paragraphs overlap each other, for, paragraph 3 requires certain stringent conditions which are not found in paragraph 1. They must therefore be mutually exclusive. The basic difference underlying these two paragraphs consists in this that paragraph 1 refers to a person redeeming property and the paragraph 3 to a person who advances money with which a mortgage is redeemed."

    Later on he states :

    "Where a person himself redeems a mortgage, that is to say, pays the mortgage money out of his own pocket and not merely discharges a contractual liability to make the payment, he is entitled to the rights of subrogation under paragraph 1 if he is one of the persons enumerated in Section 91. But where the person does not himself redeem the mortgage, that is to say, does not himself pay the money out of his own pocket in excess of his contractual liability but advances money to a mortgagor and the money is utilised for payment of a prior mortgage, whether the money is actually paid through the hands of the mortgagor or is paid through the hands of the mortgagee, the latter acquires the right of subrogation only if the mortgagor has by a registered instrument agreed that he shall be so subrogated . . . . He is really not himself redeeming the mortgage but redeeming it as the agent of the mortgagor.'' The same view was also expressed by the Patna High Court in Bansidhar Dhandania v. Kaloo Mandar, 17 Pat. 666: (A. I. R. (25) 1938 Pat. 532). At page 667, the learned Judges observed :

    "The first paragraph of Section 92 would undoubtedly have entitled the appellant as purchaser of the equity of redemption to subrogation if he had redeemed the prior mortgages on his own account and independently of any agreement with the mortgagor who is specifically excluded in this paragraph; but, the appellant paid off the prior mortgagees with moneys that were left with him for the purpose by the vendors mortgagors. The third paragraph of the section, which it is claimed by the respondent would apply to the appellant, provides that a person who had advanced to a mortgagor money with which a mortgage has been redeemed shall be subrogated to the rights of the mortgagee whose mortgage has been redeemed, if the mortgagor has by a registered instrument agreed that such persons shall be so subrogated ..... That they were not paid into the hands of the mortgagors is immaterial, for, it wag by agreement with them (if not at their instance) and in pursuance of what the learned Judge of this Court has called an express covenant that the appellant actually paid them to the old mortgagees... "

    The same view was expressed by the Calcutta High Court in Mukaram Marwari v. Muhammad Hossain, 62 Clause 677: (A. I. R. (23) 1936 Clause. 42). Nasim Ali J. observes :

    "It is equally well established on authorities that if, the debt is the debt of the person who paid it, or is a debt which he has covenanted to pay, his payment of it raises no right of subrogation, but is simply a performance of his own obligation or covenant."

    Indeed Mr. Narasaraju for the appellant not only did not question the aforesaid principles but relied upon them in support of his argument. He contended that when defendants 2 and 3 purchased the property under Ex. D- 11 on 7th October 1933, they had a pre-existing interest in the property being the puisne mortgagees under Ex. D-2 dated 29th June 1930, and therefore they would be entitled to the right of subrogation under the first paragraph of Section 92 Learned counsel said that the existence of an interest in the property on the date of the sale-deed was sufficient and it did not matter whether a prior mortgage was discharged not to protect his interest but only pursuant to an agreement entered into with the vendor. If this argument was accepted it would be destructive of the principles on which he purported to rely upon. The distinction between legal subrogation and conventional subrogation is that in the case of the former the person having the pre-existing interest discharges the prior mortgage to protect his interest and by meeting an obligation in excess of his liability; whereas in the latter case he would be discharging only an obligation he had undertaken under a specific agreement. Defendants 2 and 3 did cot discharge, Ex.-D-l, to protect their interest but because of their obligation under the sale-deed Ex. D-11. The argument of Mr. Narasaraju ignores this distinction and therefore we cannot accept it.

    6. Further the facts of this case disclose that on the date when defendants 2 and 3 discharged Ex. d-1 they had no longer any interest in the mortgaged properties. In Ex. P. 9, as we have already stated, defendants 2 and 3 admitted that the mortgage in their favour was discharged even prior to 31st March 1934. Exhibit D-1 (a) shows that Ex. D- 1 was discharged on 29th August 1938. It, therefore, follows that on the date when the prior mortgage was discharged, they ceased to be puisne mortgagees in view of their unambiguous admission. In this view also the contention of Mr. Narasaraju has no merits.

    7. Learned counsel for the appellants further pressed on us that the crucial date for the application of the doctrine of subrogation is the date of the sale-deed whereunder defendants 2 and 3 took upon themselves the obligation to discharge Ex. D-1 and on that date as the puisne mortgage in their favour was-subsisting they must be deemed to be persons having a pre-existing interest within the meaning of the Full Bench decision reported in Lakshmiammal v. Sankaranarayana Menon, 59 Mad. 359: (A. I. R. (23) 1936 Mad. 171 F. B.) This argument again is based upon a misapprehension of the principles of legal subrogation. The foundation of the right is the equitable principle of reimbursement. If a person is interested in the payment of money which another is bound by law to pay, and therefore pays it he is entitled to be reimbursed by the other. The personal obligation arising under the circumstances is embodied in Section 69, Contract Act and the equitable right of subrogation under Section 92, Transfer of Property Act. Sir D. F. Mulla puts the same principle in the following manner:

    "Subrogation by operation of law rests therefore on the same equity of reimbursement as is enacted in Section 69, Contract Act."

    In either case, the right to subrogation or reimbursement will arise only on the discharge of the prior mortgage and not earlier. We therefore agree with the learned Judge that on the facts of this case, paragraph 3 of section 92, applies and the condition laid down therein not having be en complied with, the defendants 2 and 3 would not be entitled to be subrogated to the rights of the mortgagee under Ex. D- 1.

    8. In the result the appeal is dismissed with costs of the first respondent.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dadi Appala Naidu And Others v. Kolluri Bhimalingam And Others.
    (Jul 26, 1949)