AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed as a receiver to carry on quarrying operations on a hillock that was the subject matter of litigation between the parties. The appointment was made by an order in C.M.P No. 2689 of 1947, following an earlier consent-based order by Rajamannar J. in C.M.P No. 2424 of 1947 allowing quarrying on a “seignorage” basis and permitting employment of two watchers. The petitioner has been functioning as receiver, conducting ejectment suits and possession proceedings related to encroachments on the hillock. The present application seeks remuneration for the petitioner’s labour in supervising the quarrying operations.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the receiver is entitled to any special remuneration for supervising quarrying operations on the subject hillock.
  2. Whether any exceptions to the general rule against receivers receiving salaries apply in this case.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Re Bignell Bignell v. Chapman Where a trustee functioning as a receiver had remuneration before appointment, he may continue to receive it; remuneration is subject to trial judge's discretion. The court found no justification to apply this exception since the petitioner was appointed after opposition and no prior remuneration was indicated.
Budhulal Jagannath Firm v. Hirdagarh Collieries, Ltd. and Mohamed Kamil v. Hedayitulla General principle that receivers are not entitled to salaries unless by consent; exceptions are rare and fact-specific. The court held that the petitioner’s circumstances did not present any special exception warranting remuneration.
Halsbury's Laws of England, Hailsham Edition, Volume 28, p. 81 General rule that receivers do not receive salaries unless parties consent; exceptions exist but are limited. The court relied on this principle to deny special remuneration to the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged that the petitioner, as receiver, was entitled to reimburse costs related to conducting ejectment suits and possession cases from the estate’s funds. However, it found that no special scientific skill or technical knowledge was required for supervising the quarrying operations, and the petitioner’s affidavit did not indicate any loss of other employment or occupation. The court applied the well-established legal principle that receivers generally do not receive salaries unless agreed upon by parties, citing English and Indian authorities. The exception recognized in Re Bignell Bignell v. Chapman was inapplicable as the petitioner was appointed after opposition and had no prior remuneration arrangement. The court concluded that the petitioner’s situation did not justify deviation from the general rule and thus denied the request for special remuneration.

Holding and Implications

The petition for special remuneration to the receiver is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner will not receive any special pay beyond reimbursement for expenses related to legal proceedings. The court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed the established principle that receivers are not entitled to salaries unless parties consent or exceptional circumstances exist, which were absent here.

    Muhammad Abdul Halim Baig v. Muhammad Ali Hussain And Others.

    By the order made in C.M.P No. 2689 of 1947 my learned brother Shahabuddin, J., appointed the petitioner herein as receiver for the purpose of carrying on quarrying operations in a hillock which formed the subject matter of the litigation between the parties on a “seignorage” basis. Various directions were given to the receiver and he was ordered to work under the general supervision of the lower Court. Previously, by the order in C.M.P No. 2424 of 1947, Rajamannar J., as he then was, had directed, by consent of parties, that the applicant, the present petitioner, may be permitted to carry on quarrying on the suit hillock on a “seignorage” basis; and he was also permitted to employ two watchers at a salary not exceeding Rs. 25 each per month. It is admitted that the petitioner has been carrying on the functions of a receiver. The present application by Mr. B. Lakshminarayana is, that the receiver may be allowed some remuneration for his labour in connection with this quarrying. What exactly the receiver is doing is contained in paragraph 7 of the affidavit of the petitioner, which is in the following terms:

    “As receiver I have been conducting two ejectment suits, O.S Nos. 132 and 133 of 1946, at Bezwada as third parties have encroached upon the foot of the hillock which is the subject of this appeal; and also one possession case No. 22 of 1947 relating to the same subject on the file of the First Class Magistrate, Bezwada. These matters have already been placed before this Honourable Court in the affidavits filed by the receiver in C.M.P No. 2424 of 1947 and C.M.P No. 2689 of 1947. I have been discharging all these duties to the best of my abilities.”

    So far as the conduct of suits and other proceedings are concerned, he is entitled to reimburse himself out of the moneys belonging to the estate. I am, however, of opinion that no special scientific skill or any technical knowledge is necessary, for the purpose of acting as receiver. Nothing to this effect has been mentioned in paragraph 7.

    In these circumstances, what I have to decide is whether the receiver is entitled to any kind of special pay for utilising a portion of his daily time in supervising the quarrying. The law is well settled both in England and in this country that generally where a party is appointed receiver, he is not allowed a salary unless by consent of parties (vide Halsbury's Laws of England, Hailsham Edition, Volume 28, page 81). No doubt, in England there are exceptions to the general rule, and one of such exceptions is contained in a judgment of the Court of Appeal in Re Bignell Bignell v. Chapman (1), where Lindley L.J discusses the question and lays down that where a trustee has been functioning as a receiver and where that trustee, had been before becoming a receiver obtaining some remuneration, he is entitled to get the same even after he was appointed receiver. Moreover, Lindley L.J says that it was a discretion of the trial Judge, North, J. who thought that certain remuneration was reasonable and allowed it. I do not find any justifying reason why the present petitioner who was appointed as receiver on his own application and after opposition from the other parties, is entitled to any kind of special consideration. The Indian decisions, to which my attention has been drawn are those contained in Budhulal Jagannath Firm v. Hirdagarh Collieries, Ltd. and Mohamed Kamil v. Hedayitulla, (2). Both these decisions lay down the general principle as enunciated in Halsbury's Laws of England and it is also stated that there may be few exceptions to this general rule. The facts set forth in the affidavit of the petitioner cannot be said to constitute any special circumstances which would justify him in asking for a remuneration, for it is conceded that no special, technical or scientific knowledge is necessary for carrying on this quarrying operations; and it is nowhere stated that the petitioner, by utilising his time for supervising this quarrying operations, has in any way, suffered by the loss of his employment or other occupation during this period. In these circumstances, I do not feel justified in departing from the usual rule by ordering that this party receiver should be given a special remuneration.

    The petition is therefore dismissed.

    N.R.R

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Muhammad Abdul Halim Baig v. Muhammad Ali Hussain And Others.
    (Jan 22, 1948)