1. A short question arises for consideration in
the above Petition, namely, whether the commodity,
which is given free or extra along with the commodity
packed in the standard package, infringes Rule-5 and,
Schedule-III of the Standards of Weights & Measures
(Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977.
2. The Petitioner is a company registered under
the provisions of the Indian Companies Act, 1913, as
then applicable. The Petitioner carries on business
inter alia of the manufacture, production,
distribution and sale of biscuits and daily products.
The Petitioner manufactures biscuits which are
popularly known as 50-50 Biscuits . The said
biscuits, at the relevant time, were sold in the
standard pack size of 75 grams for a Maximum Retail
Price of Rs.6.50 in addition to the said standard
pack size of 75 grams, the Petitioner was giving free
cost to the buyers 20% extra of the said 50-50
biscuits i.e. 15 grams The total weight of the
biscuits packed therefore was 90 grams.
3.
On or about 21st July 2000, the Inspector of
Legal Metrology, Chembur Division, inspected the
premises of one M/s.Rajgor Brothers, a dealter of the
Petitioner located at 15, Poornima Building, M G
Road, Ghatkopar (East), Mumbai-400 077. During the
inspection 605 packages of 50-50 Britannia Biscuits
were seized as according to the said Inspector, the
packages were not packed as per Schedule III of the
Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976 read with
Rule 23(1), 4 and 5 of Standards of Weights and
Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rule 1977
[hereinafter referred to as the said Act and the
said Rule ].
4. Similarly on 11th July 2000, the Inspector of
Legal Metrology, Chembur Division, inspected the
premises of one M/s.Parvati General Stores, a dealer
located at Shop No.1, Kamraj Marg, Chembur, Bombay
400 071. During the inspection 4 packages of 50-50
Britannia biscuits were seized as according to the
said Inspector, the packages were not packed as per
the Third Schedule of the said Rule.
5. Similarly in the case of M/s.Milan Stores, a
dealer, located at Khalrew Road, Sakinaka, Bombay 400
072 during the inspection on 10th July 2000 by the
Inspector of Legal Metrology `A Division, two
packages of 50-50 Britannia biscuits were seized on
the same ground of violation of Rule 5 read with
IIIrd Schedule.
6. A show cause notice was, therefore, issued
to the Petitioner by the respective Inspectors in
respect of the alleged violation of the said Act and
the said Rule. The Petitioner by separate letters
dated 20th August 2000, 10th August 2000 and 21st
August 2000 replied to the said show cause notices
inter alia pointing out that the Petitioner has not
contravened any of the provisions as pointed out in
the said show cause notice issued by the department.
The letters addressed to the 2nd Respondent in respect
of all the three show cause notices were in identical
terms. It appears that in response to the
Petitioner s reply, the Inspector by his letter dated
4th September 2000, reiterated the stand of the
department that the said packages of the Petitioner s
50-50 biscuits which had been seized, had been packed
in contravention of Rule 5 r/w IIIrd Schedule. It was
stated on behalf of the department in the said letter
that if any additional quantity was to be given free
or extra to the consumer, the Petitioner was at
liberty to pack the same separately and even free or
extra quantities would have to conform to the
quantities prescribed under the said Rules and the
Schedule. It was contended that by adding the
commodity, which was to be given free or extra, the
total weight of the package becomes 90 grams which
was in clear violation of Rule 5 and the IIIrd
Schedule.
7. On receipt of the said letter, the
Petitioner s representative had a meeting with the
Deputy Controller, Legal Metrology, Mumbai on 16th
September 2000 wherein the Petitioner s
representative reiterated the stand of the
Petitioner. The General Manager of the Petitioner,
by his letter dated 27th September 2000 addressed to
the office of
ig the Asst. Controller of Legal
Metrology, recorded as to what had transpired in the
meeting of 16th September 2000 and reiterated that
merely adding 20% of the commodity which was given
free and declaring the same clearly on the pack did
not in any way violate the Rules.
8. Similar letter, which was dated 11th October
2000, was forwarded to the Government of India,
Ministry of Consumer Affairs and Public Distribution,
Department of Consumer Affairs. In response to the
said letter the Deputy Director, Legal Metrology,
Government of India, contended that it was the
considered view of the department that the
commodities listed under the Third Schedule of the
said Rules should only be packed in accordance with
the specified quantity prescribed under the Rules.
The said letter further went on to state that The
practice of packing additional quantity, over and
above the specified quantity in respect of
commodities listed under the Third Schedule violates
the provisions of the Rules. It was therefore
advised that the specified quantities prescribed
under Third
Schedule may be scrupulously complied
with.
9. It is the case of the Petitioner that
despite the several representation made by the
Petitioner to the State Authorities as well as the
Central Government, the Inspector of Legal Metrology,
Chembur, invoked the provisions of Section 39 of the
said Act r/w Rule 5 and IIIrd Schedule and filed a
complaint under the said provisions in the Court of
the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 31st Court,
Vikhroli, Mumbai. It is the case of the Petitioner
that though the said complaint was filed of which
intimation was given to the Petitioner by the
Inspector of Legal Metrology by his letter dated 18th
November 2000, till the date of filing of the above
Petition, no process was issued by the learned
Magistrate and neither the Petitioner nor its
directors, officers and servants was summoned to
attend the Court.
10. It appears that pursuant to the
correspondence which ensued between the Petitioner
and Deputy Director, Letal Metrology, Krishi Bhavan,
New Delhi, by letter dated 30th January 2001 the
Deputy Director, Legal Metrology, New Delhi, which
was in reply to the Petitioner s letter dated 15th
January 2001 inter alia recorded that in consonance
with the said Rules the net quantity contained in the
package in question may be declared as 100 grams. It
is the case of the Petitioner that to avoid further
action being taken against the Petitioner, the
Petitioner discontinued the practice of giving 20%
free but started marketing their 50-50 biscuits in
the packet consisting of 75 grams with additional 25
grams free so as to make total weight of the package
to 100 grams which is one of the standard weights
mentioned in the III Schedule. However, apprehending
further action being taken in respect of the packages
wherein 20% has been given free along with 75 grams,
the Petitioner has filed the instant Petition
challenging the constitutional validity of the Rule 5
r/w 3rd Schedule and also challenging the impugned
notices dated 10th August 2000, 20th August 2000 and
the letter dated 28th November 2000 as the same being
illegal, altra-vires, unconstitutional and void.
11. We have heard the learned counsel for the
Petitioner Shri Pooniwalla, the learned counsel Shri
Nair for the Respondent Nos.2 3 and 4; and the
learned counsel for the Respondent No.1 Union of
India Shri Y S Bhate.
12. Shri Pooniwalla the learned counsel
appearing for the Petitioner principally contended
that looking to the objects of the said Standards of
Weights and Measures Act, 1976, the provisions of the
said Act could not be applicable to a commodity which
is given free of cost. He relied upon the provisions
of the said Act and especially Sections 2(b), 2(c)
and 2(v), Section 39, as also Rule 5 and contended
that the said provisions make it explicitly clear
that the said Act and the Rule are applicable to pre-
packed commodities which are sold for a price. Shri
Pooniwalla further submitted that looking to the
objects of the said Act, the Petitioner, in packing
the commodity which is given free of cost along with
the quantity which is given for a price, has not
committed any
violation of the said Act and the
Rules. He further submitted that in fact the
quantity given free of cost enures to the benefit of
the consumer and thereby the safe-guards provided in
the said Act are not violated in any manner. The
learned counsel for the Petitioner also submitted
that if the said Rules are sought to be interpreted
in the manner as is sought to be done by the
authorities by applying them to the commodity which
is given free of cost, the said Rules would be
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
The learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that
the decision of the Petitioner to give certain
amount free of cost along with the standard quantity
is a marketing strategy adopted by the Petitioner so
as to increase its sales and market coverage in
respect of the biscuits and, therefore, if the Rules
are to be applied as is sought to be done by the
authorities to the quantity which is given free of
cost, the said Rules would also be in violative of
Article 19 of the Constitution of India as the right
of the Petitioner to do business in the manner it
deems fit would be affected. The learned counsel for
the Petitioner further submitted that in terms of
Rule 5 specific commodities have to be packed only in
the standard package mentioned in the Third Schedule.
In so far as biscuits are concerned, the standard
packages are mentioned in the Third Schedule. The
learned counsel for the Petitioner further submitted
that if the Rule is sought to be interpreted in the
manner as is sought to be done by the authorities
whereby something which is given free is held to be
in violation of the said Rule, it would result in
absurd consequences and would also not act in the
interest of the consumers. He further submitted that
though reasonable restriction can be placed on the
right to carry on business, in the instant case, if
the Rule is sought to be interpreted in the manner as
is sought to be done by the authorities, it cannot be
said that the same is a reasonable restriction as the
same amounts to interfering with the freedom to do
business as envisaged under Article 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution of India.
13. The learned counsel for the Petitioner
further submitted that if by the Rules mentioned, the
provisions of the said Act are sought to be applied
to a commodity which is given free of cost, then the
said rules can be said to be in violation of the said
Act. The Rules being in the nature of subordinate
legislation, they cannot transgress the provisions of
the said Act. The learned counsel for the Petitioner
in support of his said submission relied upon the
judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Indian
Express Newspapers v/s. Union of India reported in
(1985) 1 SCC 641. In his submission the learned
counsel for the Petitioner laid much emphasis on
Paragraphs 75 and 79 and, therefore, they are
reproduced herein under :-
degree of immunity which is enjoyed by
a statute passed by a competent
Legislature. Subordinate legislation
may be questioned on any of the
grounds on which plenary legislation
is questioned. In addition it may also
be questioned on the ground that it
does not conform to the statute under
which it is made. It may further be
questioned on the ground that it is
contrary to some other statute.
must yield to plenary legislation. It
may also be questioned on the ground
that it is unreasonable, unreasonable
not in the sense of not being
reasonable, but in the sense that it
is manifestly arbitrary. In England,
the Judges would say Parliament never
intended authority to make such rules.
bearing on the above point is stated
by Diplock, L.J. In Mixnam s
Properties Ltd. v. Chertsey Urban
District Council thus :
The various special grounds on
which subordinate legislation has
sometimes been said to be void... can,
I think, today be properly regarded as
being particular applications of the
general rule that subordinate
legislation, to be valid, must be
shown to be within the powers
conferred by the statute. Thus, the
kind of unreasonableness which
invalidates a bye-law is not the
antonym of reasonableness in the
sense in which that expression is used
in the common law, but such manifest
arbitrariness, injustice or partiality
that a court would say : Parliament
never intended to give authority to
make such rules; they are unreasonable
and ultra vires ... if the courts can
declare subordinate legislation to be
invalid for uncertainty as distinct
from unenforceable... this must be
because Parliament is to be presumed
not to have intended to authorise the
subordinate legislative authority to
make changes in the existing law which
are uncertain .
Para 79 :- We do not, therefore,
find much substance in the contention
that the courts cannot at all exercise
judicial control over the impugned
notifications. In cases where the
power vested in the Government is a
power which has got to be exercised in
the public interest, as it happens to
be here, the Court may require the
Government to exercise that power in a
reasonable way in accordance with the
spirit of the Constitution. The fact
that a notification issued under
Section 25(1) of the Customs Act, 1962
is required to be laid before
Parliament under Section 159 thereof
does not make any substantial
difference as regards the jurisdiction
of the Court to pronounce on its
validity.
14. The learned counsel for the Petitioner also
relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in the
case of Bannari Amman Sugars Ltd v/s Commercial Tax
Officer and others reported in (2005) 1 SCC 625 in
support of his submission that the action of the
Respondents in applying the said rules to the
commodity which is given free of cost does not
satisfy the test of reasonable restriction. The
learned counsel for the Petitioner has relied upon
para 17 of the said Judgment in support of his said
submission. The said para 17 is reproduced herein
under:-
Para 17 :- Reasonableness of
restriction is to be determined in an
objective manner and from the
standpoint of interests of the
general public and not from the
standpoint of the interests of
persons upon whom the restrictions
have been
ig imposed or upon abstract
consideration. A restriction cannot
be said to be unreasonable merely
because in a given case, it operates
harshly. In determining whether there
is any unfairness involved, the
nature of the right alleged to have
been infringed, the underlying
purpose of the restriction imposed,
the extent and urgency of the evil
sought to be remedied thereby, the
disproportion of the imposition, the
prevailing condition at the relevant
t6ime enter into the judicial
verdict, the reasonableness of the
legitimate expectation has to be
determined with respect to the
circumstances relating to the trade
or business in question. Canalisation
of a particular business in favour of
even a specified individual is
reasonable where the interests of the
country are concerned or where the
business affects the economy of the
country.
15. The learned counsel for the Petitioner
submitted that the Petitioner s challenge to the said
Rule 5 and Schedule is an alternative challenge in
the event the Petitioner s contention that the action
of the Petitioner in packing the quantity which is
given free of cost with the quantity which is sold
for a price does not amount to violation of the said
Act and the Rule, is not accepted by this Court.
Shri Pooniwalla, the learned counsel for the
Petitioner, lastly submitted that the action of the
Respondents therefore requires to be quashed and set
aside and the Petition is required to be allowed.
16. On behalf of the Respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4,
the learned counsel appearing for the said
Respondents Shri Nair submitted that the said Act has
been enacted towards the object of the consumers
protection. In support of the said submission, he
relied upon the Judgment of the Apex Court in the
case of India Photographic Co. Ltd. v. H.D Shourie
reported in AIR 1999 SC 2453. The relevant paras of
the said Judgment would be adverted to in the latter
part of this judgment.
17. Relying upon the said Judgment, Shri Nair,
the learned counsel appearing for the Respondent Nos.
2, 3 and 4 submitted that the said Act having been
enacted for the consumers protection there would have
to be a strict compliance with the provisions of the
said Act and especially Rule 5 and the IIIrd Schedule
to the said Act. He further submitted that the
object in enacting the said Schedule under the said
Rule 5 and specifying the commodities therein to be
packed and sold in standard packages was with a view
to protect the consumers interest as the consumer
would know the quantity which he is buying and at
what price. The learned counsel for the said
Respondents submitted that if the practice followed
by the Petitioner is allowed to continue and if the
Petitioner is allowed to pack the commodity which is
allegedly given free along with the quantity which is
mentioned in the said Schedule in a given case it may
amount to the consumer being taken for a ride. He
further submitted that in the instant case the
Petitioner has not clarified as to whether for the
same price of 75 grams of biscuits, whether it is
giving 15 grams extra. The learned counsel for the
said Respondents submitted that there is no material
placed by the Petitioner on record to show that the
price for 75 grams earlier was Rs.6.50 and for the
same price they are giving 15 grams free of charge.
He also submitted that if there is no strict
compliance of the Rule it may be possible that a
manufacturer with ingenious methods would breach the
Rule and would take the consumer for a ride. He
relied upon the provisions of the said Act viz
Section 2(f), Sections 21, 29, 39, Rule 5 and Rule
29. The learned counsel for the Respondent Nos.2, 3
and 4 submitted that if the Petitioner is desirous of
giving something free to the consumer, the Petitioner
need not pack it along with the standard quantity
mentioned in the Schedule but can pack it separately
so that there is no violation of the said Rule and
the consumer is aware of the quantity for which he is
paying and the quantity which he is getting free of
cost. He submitted that there is nothing arbitrary
in the said Act and Rule for the same to be violative
of Article 14 of the Constitution of India, as the
object of the said Rule is consumer protection. The
learned counsel for the said Respondents further
submitted that right to carry on trade and business
is also not affected in any manner inasmuch as the
Petitioner would be entitled to pack the quantity
which is given
free in a separate package and,
therefore, the said Rule cannot be said to be in
violation of Article 19 of the Constitution of India.
The learned counsel appearing for the
Respondent No.1 adopted the submissions of the
learned counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to 4 and
thereby supported the case of the said Respondents.
18. We have heard the submissions of the learned
counsel for the Petitioner and the Respondents. It
would be relevant, at this stage, to quote Para-4 of
the Judgment of the Apex Court in the case of
M/s.India Photographic Co. Ltd. v/s. H D Shourie
reported in AIR 1999 SC 2453. The Apex Court in the
said Judgment, whilst considering the declaration to
be made in terms of Rule-6 of the Act on pre-packed
commodity has observed in Para-4 as under :-
The Consumer Protection Act, 1986 has
been enacted to provides for better
protection of the interests of the
consumers by making provisions for the
establishment of consumer councils,
other authorities for the settlement
of consumer disputes and for matter
connected therewith. The Act was
enacted as a result of wide spread
consumer protection movement. On the
basis of the report of the Secretary
General on Consumer Protect6ion dated
27th May 1983, the United Nations
Economic and Social Council
recommended that the World Governments
should develop, strengthen and
implement a coherent consumer
protection policy taking into
consideration the guidelines set out
therein. Each Government was obliged
to set its own priorities for the
protection of consumers in accordance
with the economic and social
conditions of the country keeping in
view the needs of its people and
bearing in mind the costs and beneft6
of the proposed legislation Government
were to further provide adequate
infrastructure including the bodies as
well as financial facilities to
develop, implement and monitor
consumer protection policies. The
introduction of new products in the
developing countries was to be
assessed in relation to the local
conditions ig having regard to the
existing production, distribution and
consumption patterns of the country or
region concerned. The various
enactments such as the Contract Act,
the Standards of Weights and Measures
Act, the Motor Vehicles Act, the
Monopolies and Restrictive Trade
Practices Act, Food Adulteration Act
etc were found to be inadequate inn
providing the relief to the consumers.
country, the Consumer Protection Act,
1986 was enacted (hereinafter called
`the 1986 Act ). The reference to the
consumer movement and the
international obligations for
protection of the rights of the
consumer, provision has been made
therein with the object of
interpreting the relevant law in a
rational manner and for achieving the
objective set forth in the Act.
Rational approach and not a technical
approach is the mandate of law.
The Apex Court has laid down, whilst interpreting
the provisions of the said Act, that the same would
have to be done
ig in a rational manner and for
achieving object set-forth in the said Act.
19. In the context of the issue raised in the
above Petition, it would also be relevant to refer to
certain provisions of the said Act. Section 2(b)
defines `Commodity as follows :-
bottle, tin, wrapper or otherwise, in units
suitable for sale, whether wholesale or
retail ;
transfer of property in any weight, measure
or other goods by one person to another for
cash or for deferred payment or for any other
valuable consideration, and includes a
transfer
ig of any weight, measure or other
goods on the hire-purchase system or any
other system of payment by instalments, but
does not include a mortgage or hypothecation
of, or a charge or pledge on, such weight,
measure or other goods.
Section 6 sets out what is Base unit of mass which is
as under :-
Section 6 :- Base unit of mass--(1)
The base unit of mass shall be the kilogram.
(2) The `kilogram is the unit of mass,
it is equal to the mass of the international
prototype of the kilogram.
Section 21 prohibits the use of non-standard weight
or measure and is as under :-
measure or numeral, other than the standard
weight, measure or numeral shall be used as
a standard weight, measure or numeral.
Section 39 mandates declaration of the quantities and
origin of commodities in packed form and Section
39(1)(ii) reads thus :-
39(1)(ii) the net quantity, in terms
of the standard unit of weight or measure,
of the commodity in the package.
Rule-5 :- Specific commodities to be
packed and sole only in standard packages---
On and from the commencement of these rules,
no person shall pre-pack or cause or permit
to be pre-packed, any commodity for sale,
distribution or delivery except in such
standard quantities as are specified in
relation to that commodity in the Third
Schedule.
THE THIRD SCHEDULE
[See rule 5]
Commodities to be packed in specified quantities
The following commodities shall be packed in such
quantities by
weight, measure or number as are
specified in the corresponding entries against them.
20. Reading of the aforesaid provisions no doubt
make it clear that the said provisions are applicable
only to a commodity which is sold for a price.
However, Rule 5 mandates that specified commodities
are to be packed and sold only in the standard
package and the said standard quantities are
specified in relation to a particular commodity in
the IIIrd Schedule to the said Act. In so far as
biscuits are concerned, Schedule inter-alia sets out
the standard quantity in which the said biscuits can
be packed. Considering the object of the said Act
viz. Consumers protection, it is obligatory on the
part of the manufacturer/distributor to sell the
commodity in the standard package mentioned in the
Third Schedule, merely because the
manufacturer/distributor wants to give 15% or 20% of
the commodity free of cost it would not be open for
him to pack it with the standard quantity commodity
which is being sold for a price. Since the object of
the Act is the consumers protection, the said Rules
and the Third Schedule would have to be strictly
adhered to. If the said Rules and the Third Schedule
are not strictly adhered to, it is possible that in a
given case, the consumers may be taken for a ride in
terms of the quantity or price at which the commodity
is being sold. The contention of the learned counsel
for the Petitioner that the provisions of the Act and
Rule cannot be invoked in respect of the commodity
which is given free of cost, therefore, cannot be
accepted. If the manufacturer or distributor is
interested in giving something free of cost, it would
be open for such manufacturer or distributor to pack
the said quantity in a separate package along with
standard package or pack it in a standard quantity
package. We therefore find merit in the submission of
the learned counsel for the Respondents that the
Rules would have to be strictly adhered to. We do
not find anything arbitrary in the said Rule-5. The
said Rule in fact ensures that the consumer stands to
get for whatever he has paid for. Rule-5 mandating
that the commodities are to be pre-packed in
standard packages, in our view, has nexus with the
object sought to be achieved by the said Act, namely
the protection of the interest of the consumer.
21. In so far as challenge of the Petitioner to
the said Rule-5 and the Third Schedule on the ground
of being arbitrary and hence violative of Article 14
is concerned, we do not find any merit in the said
submission. The Rule postulates that the commodity in
question has to be pre-packed in a standard package
mentioned in the Third Schedule. It does not prohibit
the manufacturer or distributor to pack the commodity
which is given free of cost in a separate package or
the commodity which is given free of cost along with
the commodity of standard quantity results in a
package of standard quantity mentioned in the
Schedule, and therefore, in our view, it cannot be
said that the said rule is arbitrary and violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
22.
In so far as challenge of the Petitioner on
the ground of violation of Article 19(1)(g) is
concerned, it is well settled that reasonable
restrictions can be placed by the Government on the
right to do business. Considering the object of the
said Act the legislature in its wisdom has mandated
certain commodities to be pre-packed in a standard
package. However, as stated herein-above there is no
impediment on a manufacturer or distributor to pre-
pack the commodity which he intends to give free of
cost in a separate package or pack it in a package of
a standard quantity, mentioned in the Schedule The
requirement to pack particular commodity in a
standard package, in our view, does not, in any
manner, violate Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution
of India. We therefore do not find any merit in the
said submission of the learned counsel for the
Petitioner.
23. In so far as the submission of the
learned counsel for the Petitioner that only certain
commodities have been covered by the said Schedule
which have to be packed in a standard package whereas
certain commodities have been left out. It is not
for this Court to determine as to who should be
brought in the legislative sweep. The legislature in
its wisdom has sought to regulate the sale of certain
commodities by including them in the Schedule to the
said Act. We therefore do not find any merit in the
said submission of the learned counsel for the
Petitioner.
24. From the averments made in the above
Petition it is clear that after the complaints were
filed against the Petitioner in the Court of the
Metropolitan Magistrate, Mumbai invoking the
provisions of the said Act, the Petitioner has
started the practice of pre-packing the commodity
given free of cost along with the standard quantity
commodity so as to make the package of one of the
standard quantities mentioned in the Third Schedule.
Judicial notice can also be taken of the fact that
various other companies or manufacturers, who are
coming out with such scheme of giving certain
quantity of commodity free of cost are either packing
the said commodity separately or packing it in a
standard quantity package. Though we have come to a
conclusion that the challenges raised by the
Petitioner have no merits, however, in so far as the
prosecution launched against the Petitioner is
concerned, in view of the fact that sufficient time
has now elapsed and since no process has been issued
and also in view of the fact that the Petitioner has
discontinued the said practice, We are of the view
that the authorities should take into consideration
whether the prosecution launched against the
Petitioner should be proceeded with in the light of
the aforesaid facts. In our view, Rule-5 does not
transgress the provisions of the said Act and in fact
the said rule only aids the implementation of the
said Act and regulation of the sale of the commodity
in question. In so far as issue of reasonable
restriction is concerned, as held herein above the
need to pre-pack the commodity in a specified
standard quantity can at the highest be held to be a
reasonable restriction imposed, considering the
object sought to be achieved by the said Act.
discharged but with no order as to costs.
[R.M.SAVANT, J] [P.B.MAJMUDAR,J]
At this stage, the learned counsel for
the Petitioner applies for continuation of the
Interim order which is operating in this Petition
since 10th April 2001. Considering the facts and
circumstances of the case, though the Petition is
dismissed and the rule is discharged, the interim
relief granted earlier is continued for a further
period of four weeks from date.
[R.M.SAVANT, J] [P.B.MAJMUDAR,J]