Shri S.V. Kotwal with Adhik Shirodkar for Appellants
Shri P.A. Pol APP for State
----
CORAM: V.M. KANADE J.
:
1. Heard the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellants
and the Learned APP for the State.
2. The Appellants are original Accused Nos.1 to 2. Both these
appeals arise out of the judgment and order dated 7.2.2004 passed by the
Additional Sessions Judge, in Sessions Case No. 550 of 1995 along with
Sessions Case No.985 of 1996. In Criminal Appeal No.222 of 2004, the
Appellants are (1) Manmit Swarup Saggu @ Rocky and (2) Kulmit Swarup
Saggu @ Kaka, who were original Accused Nos.1 and 2. In Criminal Appeal
No. 258 of 2004, the Appellant Mahesh Taneja was the original
Accused No.4.
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/2/
Besides these Appellants, there were four other accused. Accused No.3
Ramsen Palawat was absconding and did not face the trial. Accused No.5
Babaji Bhogale and Accused No.6 Kanaram Choudhary had preferred
separate appeals before this Court. However, they have already served the
entire sentence and they withdrew their appeals. Accused No.7 was
acquitted.
2. The Appellants have been convicted under section 255 of the
Indian Penal Code and were directed to suffer R.I. for one year and to pay
fine of Rs.5,000/- and, in default to suffer R.I. for five months and, thereafter,
have been further convicted under section 256 and sentenced to suffer R.I. for
seven months and to pay fine of Rs.2,000/- and, in default, to suffer further
R.I. for two months. They have been also convicted under section 259 of the
Indian Penal Code and sentenced to suffer further R.I. for four years and, in
default, to pay fine of Rs.1,000/- and, in default, to suffer further R.I. for two
months. The accused were acquitted for the offences punishable under
section 257 of the Indian Penal Code.
3. The prosecution case in brief is that an information was received
by the D.C.B., C.I.D., Unit No.VI, Ghatkopar on 30.10.1994 that certain
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/3/
counterfeit stamps are being printed in the premises at Parel. In view of the
said information, raid was conducted at Mankul Industries at Parel and it is
the prosecution case that counterfeit stamps used for transfer of shares were
being printed in the premises and many sheets of such stamps were found in
the premises. It was also alleged that some printing material which was used
in the premises was also recovered during the raid.
4. In support of its case, the prosecution examined twelve witnesses
as follows:
i) P.W.1 Pandurang Patil was P.I. attached to D.C.B.,
C.I.D. who had received the information, had verified the same
and had given his F.I.R.
ii) P.W. 2 Rupesh Redkar was a pancha witness in whose
presence stamps were recovered at the instance of
accused No.6 Choudhary.
iii) P.W.3 Dharmendra Sone was a pancha witness in
whose presence, cash of Rs.65,000/- was recovered at the
instance of the Appellant- Accused No.2 Kulmit from his house.
iv) P.W. 4 Shrikrishna Ringe was an important witness
because he has acted as a pancha witness during the raid
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/4/
on 30.10.1994.
vi) P.W. 6 Satish Gamare was a photographer who had
taken photographs during the raid, however, the
photographs were not produced during trial.
vii) P.W. 7 Naresh Dudhani was a witness who has
introduced the accused No.3 Ramsing to the accused No.1
Manmit.
viii) P.W.8 Sohail Buddha was attached to D.C.B., C.I.D.
and who had recovered forged stamps from accused no.6
Choudhary.
ix) P.W.9 Jayram Kulkarni was an expert from the Indian
Security Press at Nashik, who had given his report in
respect of the samples sent to him.
x) P.W. 10 Pawde was attached to D.C.B., C.I.D. and he
had recovered the films from the possession of accused No.5
Babaji Bhogale at the instance of the accused No.1 Manmit.
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/5/
xi) P.W.11 P.I. Vast was the Investigating Officer who was
present during the raid.
xii) P.W. 12 Patange was examined as a Court
Commissioner who has submitted his report in respect of the
printing machine kept in the said premises.
5. In defence, the Accused examined four witnesses.
i) D.W.1 Kadam was the judicial clerk in the Court of
Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, 19th Court,
Esplanade, Mumbai.
ii) D.W. 2 Lamba was a technician who was examined to
show that minimum three workers are necessary to
operate the machines for printing purposes.
iii) D.W. 3 Salkar was examined to show the number of
skilled workers employed in Mankul Industries.
iv) D.W. 4 Varulkar was examined to show the condition of
the premises.
6. The learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellant submits
that the entire episode regarding the manner in which the raid was conducted
was unnatural. He submitted that after receiving information, P.I. Chavan, PSI
Vast when noticed that printing work was in progress, they immediately
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/6/
returned back to their office and lodged a complaint against four suspects.
Thereafter, PSI Vast again went back to the said premises and carried out
the actual raid. It was submitted by the learned Counsel for the Appellants
that the entire conduct of the officer was highly unnatural and it shows that the
evidence was created much later implicating the accused. He invited my
attention to the cross examination of these witnesses, wherein PSI Vasta
admitted that after watching their presence he returned back to the police
station and lodged his complaint. Secondly it was submitted that PW-1 had
recovered Rs.65,000/- at the instance of the Accused No.2 from his house.
However, panchanama was not shown to this witness, which was prepared by
him at the time of arrest. The panchnama, also did not state what actually
had transpired and what was actually seized during the raid. It was
submitted that the pancha witness P.W.4 Shrikrishna Ringe could not be
termed as an independent witness because he has admitted in the cross
examination that he was residing in B.D.D. Chawl and one of the constables
Mahadeo Jadhav was also residing in B.D.D. Chawl. It was further submitted
that there was discrepancy regarding actual seizure of the material from the
premises and P.W.4 has stated that 7 bundles were seized out of which 6
bundles were containing 1000 counterfeit sheets and he had further stated
that one of the sheets from these six bundles was separated as a sample,
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/7/
leaving behind 999 sheets in each of these 6 bundles. However, in his
deposition he has also stated that the bundles contained 1000, 936, 800,
999, 1094 and 985 sheets and a few blank sheets. It was submitted that the
numbers do not tally and no explanation has been given by the prosecution
regarding the discrepancy in the evidence of PW-4. Further, it was
submitted that this witness has also admitted that out of 7 bundles of stamp,
none of the bundles was found to be put on the machine. It is further
submitted that P.W.6 Satish Gamare was the photographer, who had taken
the photographs during the raid. However, neither the photographs nor the
negatives were produced during the trial. He,therefore submitted that an
adverse inference needs to be drawn against the prosecution. It was further
submitted that Jayram Kulkarni was examined by the expert, who had given
his opinion that the samples sent to him were forged. However, during the
trial, the photosensitive plates and negatives were not sent to him and the
opinion was not sought as to whether the seized forged stamps were actually
printed by making use of those sensitive plates and negatives.
7. It was further submitted that recovery at the instance of Accused
No.5 did not satisfy requirements of section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act.
Further, it was submitted that there was discrepancy in the evidence of PW-4
and PW-11 regarding the manner in which raiding party entered the place.
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/8/
Further, it was submitted that there was gross delay in sending the copy of the
FIR to the Magistrate. It was further submitted that there was a gap of 15
days in sending the FIR to the Magistrate. It was further submitted that
therefore, the prosecution had chance to manipulate the record in sending the
FIR to the Magistrate. Further, the carrier holder, who had taken the samples
had not been examined. It was further submitted that, therefore, there was
every possibility of the said samples having been tampered before they were
sent for examination.
8. The learned APP for the State, on the other hand, opposed the
submission made by the Appellant. He submitted that though there have
been some minor errors in prosecution investigation, all the witnesses have
deposed that the Accused were caught red handed when they were in
process of printing the counterfeit stamps. Entire machinery and the
counterfeits photosensitive plates and negatives were seized. He submitted
that merely there is a delay of fifteen days in sending the FIR that itself would
not vitiate the trial, particularly because the raid was conducted after the
information was received by the Investigating Officer. He submitted that
there was nothing unnatural on the part of the Investigating Officer. He first
verified whether the information was received by him was correct or not and,
thereafter recorded an FIR and raided the premises.
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/9/
9. In the present case, this Court by an order dated 15th September,
2008 had noticed that Article "H" which are two photosensitive plates seized
from the scene of the offence and certain photo negatives which are article
"O" seized at the instance of the Accused No.1 from the Accused No.5 were
not sent for comparative analysis with samples sheets of forged stamps. This
Court, therefore, by the said order had directed the Registrar General to
handover the aforesaid articles to the Investigating Officer for the purpose of
obtaining the report of an expert. Pursuant to the said order, a report was
sent in a sealed cover and it was opened in the Court by order dated 25th
September, 2008. However, the Counsel for the Appellant wanted to consider
whether the same can be admitted under section 292 of the Code of Cr. P.C.
or whether an application could be made for calling the expert for cross
examination.
10. The learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that he did not
wish to admit the said report. In my view, even if no reliance is placed on the
said report, the other evidence which is on record is sufficient for the purpose
of arriving at the conclusion that the prosecution has proved beyond the
reasonable doubt that there is a case against the present accused.
11. Though there are some discrepancies in the prosecution case, such
as not sending the FIR in time or discrepancy in the evidence of Investigating
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/ 10 /
officer and PW-4 regarding the manner in which the raid was conducted and
also further discrepancy in respect of bundles, which were seized or non-
examination of the carrier holder, who took the sample. These discrepancies
do not have the effect on verifying the case of the prosecution. It cannot be
said that the conduct of the Investigating Officer in verifying whether the
information received by him was correct or not, is unnatural. The
Investigating Officer, in fact, had taken an extreme care to ensure that he was
not conducting the raid on any incorrect information, which was given to him.
He, therefore, went to the police station, verified the printing of the counterfeit
stamps, came back, reported an FIR, mentioned the names of the four
accused and, thereafter, went there with raiding party, which included a
pancha and caught the Accused red-handed when the printing of the
counterfeit stamps was in progress. Merely because pancha was residing in
the building in which one of the constables was residing, it cannot be said that
the witness was not an independent witness. Taking into consideration the
seriousness of the complaint and need to urgently get a panch witness, he
may have called the person who was available at the spot. Further, though it
is true that the counterfeit stamps were not on the printing machine when the
raid took place, the witnesses have stated that they witnessed the accused
printing the counterfeit stamps and, thereafter, Accused No.1 stopped the
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/ 11 /
machine. This evidence, therefore, clearly shows that the Accused were
caught red-handed while they were processing the counterfeit stamps. This
evidence has been corroborated by all the persons, who were in the raiding
party. The submission made by the Counsel for the Appellant, therefore,
cannot be accepted.
12. For the purpose of proving the offence punishable under sections
255, 256 and 258 it has to be established that the accused was knowingly
performing any part of the process of counterfeiting any stamp issued by the
Government for the purpose of revenue and section 256 lays down that
whoever has in his possession any instrument or material for the purpose of
being used, or knowing or having reason to believe that it is intended to be used,
for the purpose of counterfeiting any stamp issued by Government for the
purpose of revenue, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for
a term which may extend to seven years, and shall be liable to fine
. In the
present case, the accused was caught red-handed. The printing machinery
was seized. Though there is some discrepancy in the opinion given by the
expert whether the negatives, which were found were actually used for the
purpose of printing the said counterfeit stamps, the fact that the said stamps
which were found in their possession were counterfeit stamps has been
established in his evidence. Therefore, in my view no case is made out to
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/ 12 /
interfere with the findings recorded by the Trial Court. The judgment and
order of the Sessions Court, is therefore confirmed.
13. So far as the question of reducing the sentence of the Accused is
concerned, the Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellants
submitted that the Appellants are the only earning members of the family and
that their parents are old and suffering from various ailments. He further
submitted that more than 14 years have been elapsed from the commission of
said offence and Appellants have already undergone more than 3 ½ and 4 ½
of sentence and other Appellant Taneja has undergone 5 years of sentence.
He submitted that therefore, the sentence may be reduced.
14. Taking an over all view of the matter and in view of the fact that
there is some discrepancy in the evidence given by the expert regarding the
actual use of the negatives for the purpose of printing the counterfeit stamps
and also taking into consideration that this is an old case of 1994, the
sentence of the accused is reduced from seven years to six years.
Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed. The conviction is confirmed. The
sentence, however, is reduced from seven years to six years. The Appellants
have already paid the fine which was imposed upon them. Both the appeals
are accordingly disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
This Order is modified/corrected by Speaking to Minutes Order
/ 13 /
V.M. KANADE J.