AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 29 and 31 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (hereinafter referred
  • provisions of section 31(3) and section 32(F) as well as section 32(F)(1)
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • provisions of sections 31, 32(F)(a), 32(G)
  • section 32-F
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 29 and 31 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (hereinafter referred
  • provisions of section 31(3) and section 32(F) as well as section 32(F)(1)
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • provisions of sections 31, 32(F)(a), 32(G)
  • section 32-F
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by D.K. Trivedi, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are heirs of a tenant who challenged the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal, Pune judgment and order dated 29 October 1985. The Tribunal had rejected the petitioners' Revision Application and confirmed the Assistant Collector, Haveli Sub-Division, Pune order dated 7 February 1985 which had dismissed the tenant's appeal (TNC Appeal No. 140 of 1981). That appellate order in turn had confirmed the A.L.T. & Additional Tahsildar, Haveli order dated 18 October 1975 in Tenancy Case No. 173. The proceedings below arose from an application filed by the respondent (referred to as respondent No. 1 / landlord) under sections 29 and 31 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (the "said Act"), seeking possession of lands (variously described by survey numbers in village Gorhe Khurd / Gurhe Khurd, Tal. Haveli, Dist. Pune) which were in the possession of the tenant.

The tenant (petitioner) has occupied agricultural lands described by several survey numbers for many years (including Survey Nos. 41/12, 62/7, 67/11 and 14/1). The respondent relied on a registered partition deed dated 28 March 1958 (referred to variously as 18th/20th/28th March in different parts of the record) by which certain survey numbers were said to have been allotted to respondent No. 1, who was a minor at the time. The tenant challenged the validity and effect of that partition in light of statutory protections for tenants and the proviso to section 32-F of the Act. The authorities below accepted the respondent's claim and ordered possession in favour of the landlord; the Revenue Tribunal affirmed that result. The present writ petition under Article 227 challenged those confirmations.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the revenue authorities complied with the proviso to section 32-F of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 — specifically the duty of the Mamlatdar to inquire and be satisfied that the share of a minor (or other protected person) in joint family land was separated by metes and bounds and was proportionate with respect to area, assessment, classification and value of the land.
  2. Whether the authorities correctly applied sections 29 and 31 (and section 31-A conditions) regarding a landlord's right to terminate tenancy for personal cultivation, including adequate consideration of the landlord's other lands, income and whether the claimed land was the landlord's principal source of income.
  3. Whether the Assistant Collector and the Revenue Tribunal erred by mechanically confirming the lower authority's decision without giving due inquiry into the partition, the landlord's overall share in the joint family property and the statutory enquiries mandated by the proviso to section 32-F.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioners') Arguments

  • The revenue authorities did not follow mandatory statutory requirements (in particular the proviso to section 32-F) when entertaining the landlord's application to take possession under sections 29 and 31 of the Act.
  • The registered partition deed (dated March 1958) purporting to allot the disputed survey numbers to respondent No. 1 (who was a minor then) is invalid or was effected to defeat the statutory protections of tenants, because a partition in favour of a minor during the lifetime of the father (with grandfather also joined) cannot operate to defeat tenant rights.
  • The partition did not show separation of the minor's share by metes and bounds across the entire joint family property; accordingly the proviso's protections (and the Mamlatdar's statutory inquiry) were not satisfied.
  • The authorities below failed to consider that respondent No. 1 had other lands (where he held a one-third share) that were not taken into account when determining whether the landlord legitimately required possession for bona fide personal cultivation or whether his primary source of maintenance would be cultivation of the claimed land.

Respondent No. 1 (Landlord)'s Arguments

  • The registered partition deed and revenue entries show that respondent No. 1 became the owner of the land in question by virtue of the partition deed dated March 1958.
  • The tenant accepted respondent No. 1 as landlord and did not object; the landlord served notice after attaining majority and initiated proceedings under sections 29 and 31; the authorities were therefore justified in entertaining and granting the application.
  • Given the findings of the lower authorities up to the Revenue Tribunal, the High Court should not interfere in a writ petition under Article 227 and the writ petition ought to be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vedu Sampat Patil v. Mansukhlal Ratanlal (High Court, unreported judgment dated 30 July 1969) Interpreted provisions including sections 31, 32-F(a) and 32(G); recognised that an equitable or actual division may be valid under the proviso provided other conditions (including separation by metes and bounds and Mamlatdar satisfaction about proportion) are complied with. The court relied on the observations in this judgment to emphasise that the proviso's conditions (separation by metes and bounds and Mamlatdar satisfaction regarding proportion and value) are substantive and must be complied with before a disabled/minor person's share is treated as separated for the purposes of the Act.
Balkrishna Somnath v. Sada Devram Koli v. Chintamini Govind Patil, (1977) 2 SCC 15 : A.I.R. 1977 S.C. 894 Held that the proviso requires separation by metes and bounds and that the share of the disabled/minor is to be assessed with reference to the entire joint family property (not only land); the Mamlatdar's statutory inquiry must ensure that there is no unfair manoeuvre to defeat the Act by allocating a larger proportion of land to the disabled person. The court applied this ratio to find that the authorities below had failed to inquire into and consider the respondent's share in other joint family lands and therefore ignored the statutory enquiry required by section 32-F proviso, which was fatal to their conclusions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court structured its analysis around the statutory framework and the factual record produced in the revenue proceedings:

  1. The court reproduced and relied on section 32-F(1)(a) of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 and its proviso. It emphasised that the proviso imposes a statutory duty on the Mamlatdar to inquire and be satisfied that where a person (such as a minor) is a member of a joint family, the person's share must have been separated by metes and bounds and that the Mamlatdar must be satisfied that the separation, considering area, assessment, classification and value, corresponds to that person's share in the entire joint family property.
  2. The court also referred to the conditions in Chapter 3 of the Act (including section 31 and section 31-A) that constrain a landlord's right to terminate a tenancy for purposes of personal cultivation — one condition being that the land to be cultivated should be the principal source of maintenance where applicable.
  3. On the facts, the court noted that the partition deed dated March 1958 purported to allot to respondent No. 1 only four survey numbers (amounting to a small area, described as "hardly about 3.2-1/4 gunthas") which were the subject of the tenant's possession. However, the registered partition deed also showed that respondent No. 1 had a one-third share in other survey numbers (Survey Nos. 184, 185, 188 and 22) which, taken together, amounted to substantially more land (the court references an aggregate extent "to the extent of 15 acres") and additionally a jointly held house property.
  4. The court found that the revenue authority (A.L.T. & Additional Tahsildar) raised and answered multiple issues (11 issues), but did not make the necessary inquiry under the proviso to section 32-F to satisfy itself about the separation and proportion of the minor's share in the joint family property. The Assistant Collector later “mechanically dismissed” the tenant's appeal and confirmed the Tahsildar's order; the Revenue Tribunal likewise affirmed the result without adequately probing the statutory requirements.
  5. The court relied on the cited precedents (including Vedu Sampat Patil and Balkrishna Somnath) to underline that the proviso's requirement of separation by metes and bounds and the Mamlatdar's enquiry into the proportion of the share in the entire joint family property are substantive safeguards intended to prevent unfair maneuvers to defeat tenants' rights. Given the presence of additional lands and joint assets (not considered by the authorities) and the absence of a proper statutory inquiry, the court held that the authorities below failed to apply the law correctly.
  6. On that basis, the court concluded that the basic statutory requirement (the Mamlatdar's inquiry and satisfaction under the proviso to section 32-F) was not complied with; therefore the orders granting possession could not stand without a proper fresh inquiry.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court set aside the order of the Revenue Tribunal (Revision Application No. MRT-P-III-14/83 (TEN-B-76/83) Pune dated 29 October 1985) and likewise set aside the orders passed by the Assistant Collector, Haveli and the A.L.T. & Additional Tahsildar, Haveli. The matter was remanded to the A.L.T. & Additional Tahsildar, Haveli with a direction to decide the respondent's application in accordance with law after giving opportunity to the parties and having regard to the statutory requirements (including the proviso to section 32-F). The writ petition was allowed; the court directed that the tenancy case (year 1975) be decided expeditiously. By virtue of interim relief earlier granted in favour of the petitioner, the land remained with the petitioner and the court confirmed that interim relief; there was no order as to costs.

Core Ruling: The orders of the Revenue Tribunal and the lower revenue authorities are set aside and the matter is remanded for fresh consideration in accordance with the statutory requirements (including the Mamlatdar's inquiry under the proviso to section 32-F).

Implications: The direct consequence is that the possession determination made by the revenue authorities cannot be sustained without the mandatory inquiry under the proviso to section 32-F; the authorities must re-examine the partition, consider the landlord's share in all joint family assets (land and otherwise), and determine whether separation by metes and bounds and proportionate allocation existed before granting possession. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying existing statutory requirements and established precedent; it remands for compliance with those existing rules rather than setting a new precedent.

Outcome: Petition allowed; orders below set aside; remand to A.L.T. & Additional Tahsildar for fresh decision in accordance with law; interim relief confirmed; no order as to costs.

    Shri Maruti Krishna Matale & Another v. Shri Mohan Keshav Deshpande & Others

    D.K Trivedi, J.:— In this petition, the heirs of tenant have challenged the judgment and order passed by the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal, Pune dated 29th October 1985 wherein the tribunal has rejected the Revision Application of the petitioners and confirmed the order passed by the learned Assistant Collector, Haveli Sub-Division, Pune, dated 7th February 1985 in an appeal filed by the tenant being TNC Appeal No. 140 of 1981 and inturn, even the learned Assistant Collector has also while dealing with the appeal of the tenant, while dismissing the appeal, confirmed the order of A.L.T and Additional Tahsildar Haveli dated 18th October 1975 passed in Tenancy Case No. 173 filed by the respondent-tenant while deciding the application made by the respondent-Landlord under sections 29 and 31 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (hereinafter referred to as the “said Act”), wherein the Revenue Authority has granted possession of the land in favour of landlord out of Survey No. 141/1 of village Gorhe Khurd.

    2. During the hearing, the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioners Mr. Sali, took me through the order passed by the authorities in a proceedings initiated by the landlord initially and order passed in the Appeal and the Revision Application moved at the instance of the tenant in respect of the granting possession of the land in favour of respondent-landlord while granting the application of the landlord under the Act. He also while arguing the matter, has taken me through the registered Partition Deed dated 28th March, 1958 in respect of allotment of the land in favour of respondent No. 1 landlord who was at the relevant time minor. He has also raised legal contention that on examining the order passed by the Revenue Authority, the Revenue Authority has not followed requirement of law which is must while considering the request for taking possession of the land from the tenant. It is not in dispute that the original opponent is a tenant over the suit land as described from the order passed by the Revenue Authority and that the agricultural lands in dispute situated at village Gurhe Khurd, Tal. Haveli, Dist. Pune is occupied by the petitioner (tenant) since many years. These agricultural lands being Survey Nos. 41/12 admeasuring 0 acres 13 gunthas, Survey No. 62/7 0 acres 8 gunthas, Survey No. 67/11 ¼th gunthas (10 areas) and Survey No. 14/1 1 acre 34 gunthas. The learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants has vehemently urged and raised a question of law that while deciding the proceedings initiated at the instance of the respondent landlord when the landlord had approached the Revenue Authority after giving notice to the tenant terminating his tenancy after he became major, he has sought for possession of the land for his bona fide and personal cultivation. According to the learned Counsel Mr. Sali, if we examine the record it will be clear that there cannot be any partition in favour of minor son viz. the respondent No. 1 during the lifetime of the father where his father was joined with his grand-father and the suit lands were standing at the relevant time, in the name of grandfather of the respondent No. 1. As per the case made out by the respondent-landlord that there was a registered partition deed in respect of the property dated 18th March 1958 and as per the said partition deed, the suit lands which are tenanted land, came to be allotted to the share of respondent No. 1 who was at the relevant time, minor aged about 4 years who was unable to cultivate the said land and accordingly, the said partition was effected to defeat the provisions of law and adversely affect the petitioner who was cultivating the said land as a tenant. On the tillers day, all the tenants were entitled to become owners of the suit land. It is only because of the partition deed, the said date was extended as the lands in question were allotted in the share of respondent No. 1 who was minor at the relevant time and that as affected adversely to the interest of the petitioner. According to Mr. Sali, even such partition is invalid and contrary to the provisions of section 31(3) and section 32(F) as well as section 32(F)(1) of the proviso of the said Act and the share of such person namely as per the partition Deed, said, survey numbers were allotted to respondent No. 1 in joint family and has not been separated by metes and bounds and it is the duty of Taksildar to make proper inquiry and to reach his satisfaction that share of such minor in the land is separated having regard to the area, assessment, classification and value of the land in proportion as the share of that person in the entire joint family property and not in a larger proportion.

    3. On the other hand, Mrs. Agarwal the learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent No. 1- landlord, has supported the judgment of all the authorities and she submitted that once the tenant has accepted the respondent No. 1 has a landlord and further all the revenue entries in respect of suit lands, clearly show that by virtue of the registered partition-deed in respect of property dated 28th March 1958, the land in question occupied by the petitioner-tenant wherein the respondent has become the owner and if the tenant has not objected and accepted him as a landlord, all the authorities were justified in entertaining the application when the application under sections 29 and 31 was moved when the landlord has become major and admittedly the said proceedings were initiated after serving the notice to the tenant and accordingly, the Revenue Authority below on examining the application and evidence and more particularly the registered partition deed dated 20th March 1958, has rightly granted the said application by granting possession of the land Survey No. 14/1 as per the law and accordingly, she submitted that when all the authorities upto the Revenue Tribunal has not accepted the case of the petitioners-tenant and confirmed the order of granting the land this Court is not required to interfere in writ petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India and accordingly, she submitted that the writ petition deserves to be dismissed.

    4. On considering the submission made before me and on examining the provisions, it is necessary for me to refer to the relevant provisions viz. section 32-F(1)(a) of the Act which reads as under:

    “32-F. (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the preceding sections,—

    (a) where the landlord is a minor, or a widow, or a person subject to any mental or physical disability, the tenant shall have the right to purchase such land under section 32 within one year from the expiry of the period during which such landlord is entitled to terminate the tenancy under section 31 (and for enabling the tenant to exercise the right of purchase, the landlord shall send an intimation to the tenant of the fact that he has attained majority, before the expiry of the period during which such landlord is entitled to terminate the tenancy under section 31):

    (Provided that where a person of such category is a member of joint family, the provisions of this sub-section shall not apply if at least one member of the joint family is outside the categories mentioned in this sub-section unless before the 31st day of March 1958 the share of such person in the joint family has been separated by metes and bounds and the Mamlatdar on inquiry is satisfied that the share of such person in the land is separated, having regard to the area, assessment, classification and value of the land, in the same proportion as the share of that person the entire joint family property and not in a large proportion.)”

    5. As per the proviso, it is statutory duty of the Mamlatdar to inquire and to satisfy himself that the share of such person in the land is separate in respect of the area, assessment, classification and value of the land in the same proportion as the share of that person in the entire joint family property and not in larger proportion. It is also equally necessary for me to examine the provisions made for termination of tenancy and the right of landlord to terminate the tenancy for the personal cultivation and non-agricultural purpose as found in Chapter 3 of the Act. Section 31 deals with regarding the landlords right of terminating the tenancy for personal cultivation and for non-agricultural purpose and section 31-A(a) deals with conditions of termination of tenancy, which reads as under:

    “31-A. The right of a landlord to terminate a tenancy for cultivating the land personally under section 31 shall be subject to the following conditions:—

    (a) If the landlord at the date on which the notice is given and on the date on which it expires has no other land of his own or has not been cultivating personally any other land, he shall be entitled to take possession of the land lease to the extent of ceiling area.”

    6. One of the conditions as per Clause (1) is income by cultivation of the land of which he is entitled to take possession is the principle source of income for his maintenance.

    7. In the present case, as per the partition deed dated 28th March 1958 only four survey numbers which are in possession of the tenant are allotted in the share of respondent No. 1 who was minor at that time viz. 4 years and the total area in all the four survey numbers is hardly about 3.2-1/4 gunthas which is in possession of the petitioner-tenant. It is an admitted fact that while deciding the application made by the landlord relying upon the registered partition deed dated 20th March 1958, all the authorities below have not actually considered the other land wherein the respondent has also his share. As demonstrated by Mr. Sali, over and above four survey numbers which are subject matter of this petition, admittedly there are other four survey numbers where the respondent-landlord has ⅓rd share. On going through the partition deed, these survey numbers are Survey Nos. 184 admeasuring 11 acres 18 gunthas, Survey No. 185, 17 acres and 34 gunthas, Survey No. 188 area 11 acres of 2-1/2 gunthas and Survey No. 22, area 11 acres. Over and above, these agricultural land, there is a house property which is kept jointly. In these survey numbers, the respondent-landlord has ⅓rd share and if we calculate the total area covered in these four survey numbers, admittedly, the respondent-landlord has even further more land to the extent of 15 acres. I am referring this because it is found from the registered partition deed which is on the record. Admittedly, it has not been considered by the authorities even when the revision application is filed by the petitioner-tenant before the Revenue Tribunal.

    8. Mr. Sali, the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner has also heavily placed reliance upon certain decisions of this Court as well as of the Apex Court. I was also taken through these decision and as found in unreported judgment of this Court dated 30th July 1969 in the matter of (Vedu Sampat Patil v. Mansukhlal Ratanlal)1, in Special Civil Application No. 699 of 1969, the High Court has considered the provisions of sections 31, 32(F)(a), 32(G) and others and observations made by Justice Deshpande as he then was, on page 7 are reproduced below:

    “I find considerable substance in the second and the third contentions raised before me by the learned Advocate. Such equitable division and partition thereof cannot be said to have been ruled out by this proviso, provided of course, it complies with other conditions laid down in the said proviso. One such other condition is that such share in the landed property as also other properties of the joint family should be separated by metes and bounds. The second condition laid down in the proviso is that Mamlatdar on inquiry should be satisfied, that the extent of land allotted to the share of such disabled person is in proportion to his share in the joint family property, particularly, the land of the joint family “having regard to the area, assessment, classification and value of the land. The third condition which is a corollary to the second condition, is that the land in larger proportion should not be allotted to the share of such disabled landlord.”

    9. Mr. Sali has also next relied upon the decision in the matter of (Balkrishna Somnath v. Sada Devram Koli v. Chintamini Govind Patil)2, reported in (1977) 2 SCC 15 : A.I.R 1977 Supreme Court page 894. Head Note (1) of the said ruling reflects that:

    “Tenant's right to purchase land kept in abeyance in case of disabled landlords-Protection under the proviso is not available when the separation of widow or minor is restricted to agricultural lands.

    The proviso clearly states that the disabled person's share in the joint family must have been separated by metes and bounds. Separation from the joint family means separation from all the joint family assets. Notional division or division in status may not be enough because the act insists on separation by metes and bounds are appropriate to real property, meaning as the phrase does, the boundary lines of land, with their terminal points and angles. In the context, the thrust of the expression is that the division must be more than notional but actual, concrete, clearly demarcated. The ineptness and involved structure and some ambiguity notwithstanding the sense of the sentence is clear.

    …It really means his share in the entire joint family property. Moreover, the statutory exercise expected of the Mamlatdar by the proviso involves an enquiry into the share of the disabled person in the land, and its value, the share of the person in the entire joint family property, the proportion that the allotment of the land bears to his share in the entire joint family property with a view to see that there is no unfair manoeuvre to defeat the scheme of the Act.”

    10. It is further found from the observations made in paragraph No. 13 of the said judgment, which is reproduced below:

    “Thus it is reasonable to hold that when the expression used is the share of such person in the joint family, it is not confined to the share in the land only. It really means his share in the entire joint family property. Moreover, the statutory exercise expected of the Mamlatdar by the proviso involves an enquiry into the share of the disabled person in the land, and its value the share of that person in the entire family property, the proportion that the allotment of the land bears to his share in the entire joint family property with a view to see that there is no unfair manoeuvre to defeat the scheme of the Act”.

    11. He has also cited several judgments even of this Court, however, for the purposes of considering the contentions raised before me and applying the ratio of these judgments, as found in the present case, the respondent-landlord was minor at the relevant time when the lands in question were given to his shares and after terminating the tenancy of the respondent by giving notice, he has moved A.L.T and Additional Tahsildar by filing application under sections 29 and 31 of the Act for getting possession of the land. On going through the order, though the revenue authority has raised 11 issues and one of the issues viz. issue No. 8 reads thus: whether the share of the landlord was considered before 31st March 1958 and whether he got an equal share in the partition?. As found from the answer given on issues and more particularly on issue No. 8, the Revenue Authority has held it in the affirmative and held that the landlord was separated and got his share in the partition. It is further found from the reasonings of the Additional Talshildar that he considered the registered document of partition deed dated 20th March 1958 and further the record of rights in respect of suit lands which show that the lands were standing in the name of predecessors in title of the applicant-landlord in January 1952 and thereafter these lands came to his share. The learned authority has also while considering the case put forward by the landlord for seeking possession on the ground of bona fide personal cultivation, has also while referring in brief, has observed that tenant has not been able to prove that the applicant's father is getting an income of Rs. 1000/- to Rs. 1200/- per month. It is further found that the applicant-landlord could not prosecute his study due to mental deficiencies and Revenue Authority has held that there is no reason to suspect that the applicant will not cultivate the land personally. In my view, the Revenue Authority has ignored the requirement of law as contemplated under section 32-F proviso. No inquiry is made for his satisfaction regarding the share of a person in the land which has to be determined as per the proviso to section 32-F of the said Act, which I have already reproduced hereinabove. In my view, the A.L.T and Additional Tahsildar has not looked into this aspect while deciding the application of the landlord and admittedly even the partition deed which the landlord has relied upon clearly indicates that there are other lands where the landlords has ⅓rd share. Even there is nothing to indicate that what is the income available from these remaining lands. In my view, even no proper inquiry is made as contemplated under the Act which is must and even thereafter when the said order of the Tahsildar is challenged at the instance of the petitioner-tenant by taking the matter before the Appellate Court, it is found that the Assistant Collector has mechanically dismissed the appeal and confirmed the order of the lower authority. It is also very surprising that when the matter has been reached and taken by the tenant before the Revenue Tribunal, even, in my view, the Revenue Tribunal has also not gone into deep into the matter for which, the authority is supposed to examine closely on the point of application made by the landlord from seeking possession of the land from tenant and I have to observe that even revisional authority has also mechanically examined the matter and mechanically disposed of the revision of the tenant by confirming the order of the appellate authority.

    12. In my view, basic requirement as per the Statute has not gone into and even if the authority on perusing the registered partition deed, and even though the tenant has accepted the respondent as a landlord, but the revenue authority cannot ignore the provisions of law and even by reading this deed, it is amply clear that there are other lands wherein the others have interest considering ⅓rd share of the landlord in these lands. Accordingly, in the fitness of things and in the interest of justice, matter requires consideration at the hands of lower authority for which the lower authority has to examine and give exact findings on the points raised.

    13. Accordingly, the order of the Revenue Tribunal in revision application by the tenant being Revision Application No. MRT-P-III-14/83 (TEN-B-76/83) Pune dated 29th October 1985 is set aside and inturn all the orders passed by the Assistant Collector, Haveli and the order passed by the A.L.T and Additional Tahsildar, Haveli, are set aside and matter is remanded back to the A.L.T and Additional Tahsildar, Haveli with direction to decide the application of the respondent in accordance with law after giving an opportunity to the parties in the light of the above judgment. Accordingly, this writ petition is allowed. As the Tenancy Case is of the year 1975, A.L.T and Additional Tahsildar is directed to decide the same as expeditiously as possible, in accordance with law.

    14. By virtue of the interim relief granted in favour of petitioner, the land is with the petitioner. Accordingly, rule is made absolute by confirming the interim relief. However, there will be no order as to costs.

    15. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Maruti Krishna Matale & Another v. Shri Mohan Keshav Deshpande & Others
    (Jan 14, 2000)