AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

In 1951, the Appellants (original Defendants Nos. 1 and 2) purchased two acres of land from Survey No. 32/1 and a 2 annas and 8 pie share in a well situated at Survey No. 32/3 from the Respondents for Rs. 700/-. The sale deed was registered and undisputed as to the land, but a dispute arose regarding the 2 annas and 8 pie share in the well at Survey No. 32/2. The Respondents allegedly altered the mutation entry concerning the Appellants' share without notice, claiming adverse possession due to non-use of the well water by the Appellants. In 1984, the Respondents filed Civil Suit No. 244 of 1984 seeking cancellation of the mutation entry and injunction against the Appellants' use of the well water. The trial court dismissed the suit, holding that the Plaintiffs failed to prove adverse possession or title based on mutation entries. The Respondents appealed, and the appellate court reversed the trial court's decision, relying heavily on mutation entries and the Appellants' lack of objection until 1983. The Appellants then filed this second appeal challenging the appellate court's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a mutation entry by itself confers any title or legal status regarding immovable property.
  2. Whether a co-owner can claim an injunction against another co-owner in respect of jointly owned property.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • A mutation entry alone does not confer title or legal status to immovable property.
  • A co-owner cannot seek an injunction against another co-owner with respect to jointly owned property.
  • The Appellants are the rightful owners of the 2 annas and 8 pie share in the well as per the registered sale deed of 1951.
  • The mutation entries changed without notice to the Appellants and thus their failure to object earlier is not a valid ground against them.

Respondents' Arguments

  • By virtue of the mutation entry changes and the Appellants' non-use of the well water, the Respondents claim ownership of the 2 annas and 8 pie share through adverse possession.
  • The mutation entries substantiate their claim of ownership and possession.
  • The Appellants' delay in objecting to mutation changes weakens their claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Himachal Pradesh v. Keshav Ram, AIR 1997 SC 2181 Mutation entries or corrections in revenue records do not create or extinguish title to immovable property. The court held that mutation entries alone cannot form the basis for declaring title. The lower appellate court erred in relying on mutation entries to establish ownership.
Abasaheb Bali Gharge v. Balaji Ramhari Gharge, 1996 (I) Maharashtra Law Journal 209 Mutation entries serve fiscal purposes and do not transfer title of property. The court reiterated that mutation entries do not amount to transfer of title, supporting the Appellants' position against the Respondents' claim based on mutation changes.
Mohammad Baqar v. Naim-Un-Nisa Bibi, AIR 1956 SC 548 Possession by one co-sharer is possession of all co-sharers; adverse possession requires denial of right and ouster. The court applied this principle to hold that co-owners cannot claim adverse possession against each other without exclusion or ouster.
Patel Meghji Dayal v. Patel Jivraj Pragji, AIR 1984 Guj 32 Joint possession by coparceners negates adverse possession claims among them. Supported the principle that co-owners or coparceners cannot claim adverse possession against each other, reinforcing the Appellants' argument.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the legal effect of mutation entries and found them insufficient to confer title to immovable property. It noted that the mutation entries altered by the Respondents without notice to the Appellants could not override the registered sale deed establishing the Appellants' ownership share. The court emphasized settled legal principles that mutation entries serve only fiscal purposes and do not create ownership rights. Further, the court examined the law on co-ownership and adverse possession, concluding that a co-owner cannot acquire title by adverse possession against another co-owner without clear ouster or denial of rights. The Respondents’ claim based on adverse possession was rejected as the Appellants were not dispossessed nor excluded. The court found the lower appellate court’s reliance on mutation entries and the delay in objection by the Appellants legally unsustainable and set aside its order, restoring the trial court’s dismissal of the suit.

Holding and Implications

The second appeal is allowed.

The court set aside the lower appellate court's order and restored the trial court's dismissal of the suit, reaffirming that mutation entries alone do not confer title and that co-owners cannot claim ownership by adverse possession against each other. The decision directly affects the parties by confirming the Appellants' ownership share in the well and rejecting the Respondents' adverse possession claim. No new precedent beyond the application of established legal principles was created.

    Bhaguji Bayaji Pokale And Others v. Kantilal Baban Gunjawate And Others

    1. The brief facts leading to this second appeal are as under:

    In the year 1951, that is to say on 26th September, 1951, the Appellants herein who were the original Defendants Nos. 1 and 2, had purchased from the Respondents, two acres of land from Survey No. 32/1 and had also purchased a share of 2 annas and 8 pie in a Rupee with regard to a well situated at Survey No. 32/3 for a total sum of Rs. 700/-. This sale deed was duly registered. There is absolutely no dispute between the parties with regard to this sale deed. The Respondents herein also do not dispute the Appellants' title with regard to the two acres of land which is found in Survey No. 32/1. The only dispute is with regard to 2 annas and 8 pie share in the entire well which is situated at Survey No. 32/2. It appears that the Respondents, without any notice whatsoever to the Appellants, got the mutation entry changed with regard to the Appellants' right, title etc, regarding the aforesaid well. Only in the year 1983, the Appellants came to know of the aforesaid unauthorised change in mutation entry and took objection to the same. It is the contention of the Respondents that since the Appellants did not actually use the well water and by virtue of change in the mutation entry, the Respondents' claim that they have by adverse possession become sharer with regard to the 2 annas 8 pie share in the said well water. The Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 had filed a suit being Civil Suit No. 244 of 1984 before the Court of Civil Judge at Phaltan, District Satara, against the present Appellants as well as Respondents Nos. 3 and 4. Respondents Nos. 3 and 4 were the supporting Plaintiffs in that said suit. The Plaintiffs' suit was for cancellation of mutation entry with regard to the Appellants 2 annas and 8 pi e share in the suit well as well as for a permanent injunction restraining the present Appellants from user of the said well water with regard to the 2 annas and 8 pie share in the said well water. The main contention of the Plaintiffs in that suit was that, as the mutation entries were changed with regard to the names of the Appellants in that said Survey No. 32/3 with regard to the well and that as the Appellants had not used the said well water at all. By way of adverse possession, Plaintiffs had become the owners with regard to the 2 annas and 8 pie share in the said well. The trial Court, after considering all the issues, came to the conclusion that the Plaintiffs had failed to prove that they had become the owners with regard to the 2 annas and 8 pie share in the said well water by virtue of adverse possession. The trial Court also came to the findings that the plaintiffs had failed to prove their possession of the said suit property in preference to the persons having lawful title. The trial Court also came to the conclusion that mere change in mutation entry, does not confer any title upon the Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 herein.

    2. Against the said dismissal of the suit, the Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 filed a regular Civil Appeal No. 213 of 1987 before the 3rd Additional District Judge at Satara. The learned Appellate Court reversed the judgment of the trial Court, allowed the appeal and held that the mutation entry dated 26th September, 1983, was based on a sale-deed dated 26th September, 1951. The learned Appellate Court had also directed the present Appellants that they should not either personally or through their agents, servants, relatives raise any obstruction to the enjoyment of the suit well by Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 along with Respondents Nos. 3 and 4.

    3. The lower Appellate Court had very strongly relied upon various mutation entries and changes therein, which were caused by Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 herein, to substantiate the contention of Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 that as their names have been incorporated instead of the Appellants and that due to the fact that the Appellants had never used the well water, the Respondents had become the owners by virtue of adverse possession with regard to the aforesaid 2 annas and 8 pie share in the well water. The lower Appellate Court had also taken into account that the appellants had not objected to any of the change of the mutation entry from 1951 till 1983, and as such, the contention of Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 was accepted.

    4. It is an admitted position that when the changes in mutation entries were made from 1951 onwards, the present Appellants were not given any notice whatsoever in that behalf and only in the year 1983 when the appellants came to know of the said illegal change in the said mutation entry, they moved the Revenue Authority and by mutation entry No. 666 dated 26th September, 1983, the Appellants were able to incorporate their own names based on the aforesaid sale deed dated 26th September, 1951, with regard to the 2 annas and 8 pie share in the said well. Since the Appellants were not given ay notice whatsoever with regard to the mutation entries, the Respondents' contention that the Appellants ought to have objected, does not arise at all. Unless and until proper notice is given to the Appellants with regard to the proposed change in the mutation entry, there was no case for the Appellants to raise any, objection.

    5. Against this lower Appellate Court's order dated 16-11-1989, the present Second Appeal has been filed. The learned Counsel for the Appellants has raised two substantial questions of law, viz;

    (a) Mutation entry by itself, does not confer any title or legal status with regard to any immovable property,

    (b) The co-owner cannot claim an order of injunction against another co-owner with regard to the property owned jointly.

    6. It is an admitted position that as per sale-deed dated 26th September, 1951, the Appellants herein are the owners with regard to 2 annas and 8 pie share in the said well and the balance left out i.e 13 annas and 4 pie share is owned by all the Respondents. The learned Counsel for the Appellants had relied upon the following two authorities with regard to the first proposition that the mutation entry by itself does not establish any title to any immovable property. The first authority is reported in (1996) 11 SCC 257 : AIR 1997 SC 2181, State of Himachal Pradesh v. Keshav Ram. The Apex Court in para No. 4 has dealt with this issue in a very lucid and clear manner. The said Para No. 4 reads as under (at page 2182):

    “In view of the rival contentions, the question that arises for consideration is whether the Plaintiffs have been able to establish their title and the Courts below were justified in declaring Plaintiffs' title. As has been stated earlier the only piece of evidence on which the Court below relied upon to decree the plaintiffs' suit is the alleged order made by the Assistant Settlement Officer directing correction of the record of right. The order in question is not there on record but the plaintiffs relied upon the register where the correction appears to have been given effect to The question, therefore, arises as to whether the entry in the settlement papers recording somebody's name could create or extinguish title in favour of the person concerned? It is to be seen that the disputed land originally stood recorded in the name of Raja Sahib of Keonthal and thereafter the State was recorded to be the owner of the land in the record of rights prepared in the year 1949/50. In the absence of the very order of the Assistant Settlement Officer directing necessary correction to be made in favour of the plaintiffs, it is not possible to visualize on what basis the aforesaid direction had been made. But at any rate such an entry in the revenue papers by no stretch of imagination can form the basis for declaration of title in favour of the plaintiffs. To our query as to whether there is any other document on the basis of which the plaintiffs can claim title over the disputed land, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs-respondents could not point out any other document apart from the alleged correction made in the register pursuant to the order of the Assistant Settlement Officer. In our considered opinion, the Courts below committed serious error of law in declaring plaintiffs' title on the basis of the aforesaid order of correction and the consequential entry in the Revenue papers. In the circumstances, the appeal is allowed and the judgment and decree passed in all the three forums are set aside. The plaintiffs' suit stand dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.”

    7. From the above it is clear that the entries in revenue records can never form the basis of declaration of title with regard to immovable property. The learned counsel also referred to another judgment of our Court reported in 1996 (I) Maharashtra Law Journal 209, Abasaheb Bali Gharge v. Balaji Ramhari Gharge. In this case the same issue has been considered by our Court and has taken a similar view that the mutation entries or the entries in the record of rights are made only for the fiscal purpose of recovering revenues. The said entries cannot amount to transfer of the title of the holder of the property in favour of the person in whose name the entries are made. The Para No. 8 of the said authority reads as under:

    “But the real crux of this matter is as to what is the legal effect of the said Mutation Entry No. 2053 at Exhibit 45. The trial Court has come to the conclusion that because of the said mutation entry, Sonatai Joti Gharge got title to the property in question along with other properties. But that finding of the trial Court is not at all correct and proper. It is settled law that mutation entries or entries in the record of rights are made only for the fiscal purpose of recovering revenue. The said entries cannot amount to transfer of the title of the holder of the property in favour of the person in whose name, the entries are made. Therefore, merely because Bal Pandurang Gharge, father of the present Applicant No. 1, happened to make a Vardi application on 3rd of September, 1956 to delete his name and to enter the name of Sonatai Joti Gharge, that act on his part would not amount to transfer of the property in question and that giving of the Vardi application and certification of the said mutation entry would not create any title in favour of Sonatai Joti Gharge. Therefore, merely because the name of Sonatai Joti Gharge is entered in the Kabjedar column of the record of rights on account of the mutation entry at Exh. 45, it could not be said that in law Sonatai got title to the property in question.”

    8. With regard to second substantial question of law, i.e The co-owner cannot claim an order of injunction against another co-owner with regard to the property owned jointly, the learned Counsel for the Appellants has relied upon the Apex Court's Judgment reported in AIR 1956 SC 548, Mohammad Baqar v. Naim-Un-Nisa Bibi. The Apex Court has very categorically held in Para No. 7 as under (at page 550):

    “The parties to the action are co-sharers, and as under the law, possession of one co-sharer is possession of all co-sharers, it cannot be adverse to them, unless there is a denial of their right to their knowledge by the person in possession, and exclusion and ouster following thereon for the statutory period.”

    9. The learned Counsel for the Appellants also relied upon another judgment reported in AIR 1984 Guj 32, Patel Meghji Dayal v. Patel Jivraj Pragji, with regard to the second substantial question of law. In Para No. 2, this aspect has been considered as under (at page 33):

    “The possession of suit fields with defendant No. 1 was for and on behalf of coparceners and hence it was a joint possession. Therefore, there can be no question of adverse possession at all. A coparcener cannot hold adversely to other coparceners.”

    10. From the above, it is explicitly clear that mere mutation entry or change in any mutation entry does not confer any title to any immovable property This is a well settled law. Merely because the Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 were surreptitiously able to manage a change in mutation entry behind the back of the Appellants, the same does not confer any right whatsoever to them. It is very important to note here that it is an admitted position that the Appellants were given no notice whatsoever with regard to the aforesaid change in the mutation entry. Ultimately, in the year 1983 when the Appellants came to know of the same, they got mutation entry changed back again in their own names, with regard to their share of 2 annas and 8 pie in the said well water. Similarly, the legal position that the co-owner or co-sharer of the property can never claim ownership by adverse possession of the other share. This is also a well settled law.

    11. Under these circumstances, the lower Appellate Court's order D/- 16-11-1989, is totally unsustainable in law as well as on facts. Accordingly, the said order of lower Appellate Court dated 16-11-1989, is set aside and the trial Court's order dated 20th February, 1987 whereby the Civil Suit No. 244 of 1984 which was dismissed, is restored back.

    12. Second Appeal is accordingly allowed. However, with no order as to costs.

    Appeal allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhaguji Bayaji Pokale And Others v. Kantilal Baban Gunjawate And Others
    (Nov 6, 1997)