AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 24 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, read with the provisions of sections 6 and 10
  • SECTION 24 INDIAN INCOME TAX ACT
  • section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922,
  • section 10, the provisions of section, 24(2)
  • section 24(2) of the Income-tax Act
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • sub-section (2) of section 24
  • section 10 and section 24(1)
  • section 24(2) the Income-tax
  • section 43(5)).6.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 24 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, read with the provisions of sections 6 and 10
  • SECTION 24 INDIAN INCOME TAX ACT
  • section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922,
  • section 10, the provisions of section, 24(2)
  • section 24(2) of the Income-tax Act
  • INCOME TAX ACT
  • sub-section (2) of section 24
  • section 10 and section 24(1)
  • section 24(2) the Income-tax
  • section 43(5)).6.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Tribunal referred to the court under section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922 the following question:

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, was the Tribunal justified in refusing to allow the set-off of carried forward losses of speculation business against the speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 of the assessment year 1958-59?”

The assessee, Ambalal Narsidas, an individual, had income from speculative transactions, business in ready shares and dividends. For assessment year 1958–59 the profit and loss account showed a loss of Rs. 6,866 after deducting dividend income of Rs. 51,274 and speculation profit of Rs. 11,369. The total loss before those deductions was Rs. 69,509. Unabsorbed carried forward speculation losses from earlier years amounted to Rs. 68,224 and had been allowed by the Income-tax Officer to be carried forward.

The Income-tax Officer refused the assessee’s claim to set off the current year's speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 against the carried forward speculation losses. This refusal was confirmed on appeal by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and subsequently by the Tribunal. The Tribunal construed the provisions of section 24 (and its interaction with section 10) to conclude that the normal computation under section 10 must be carried out first and that the restrictions in section 24(2) on set-off of carried forward speculation loss apply to the assessee’s right, so the tribunal refused relief. The assessee sought reference to this court for determination of the posed question.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in refusing to allow the set-off of carried forward losses of speculation business against the speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 for the assessment year 1958–59.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Assessee)

  • The net speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 for the year should be treated separately (i.e., not amalgamated with other business income), and the carried forward speculation losses from earlier years should be set off directly against that speculation profit.

Revenue's Arguments (as reflected in orders of taxing authorities)

  • The profit or loss for the assessment year must first be computed by amalgamating speculation profit with profit from ready transactions under section 10; only after arriving at the net result for the year would set-off of losses carried forward under section 24(2) arise.
  • The Tribunal further reasoned that section 24 generally provides for set-off of loss under one head against profits under another head after section 10 computation is complete, and that section 24(2) restricts an assessee’s right to carry forward and set off speculation loss only against profits of the speculation business in that year.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. N.C. Uftadhyaya [1974] 96 ITR 1, 17 Bom. That circulars issued by the Board (Central Board of Revenue) are binding on Income-tax Officers and should be given effect to by the courts, with the caveat that binding nature is confined to tax laws and for administrative relief to taxpayers rather than imposing burdens. The court relied on this authority to treat the Board's circular as binding guidance on the taxing authorities and the court itself when deciding the present question, while noting the limited scope described in the precedent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by first noting that counsel for both parties drew attention to a Central Board of Revenue circular (Circular No. 23 (XXXIX-4) D of 1960, F. No. 4(124)-60.TPL dated September 12, 1960) dealing with adjustment of speculation profits against carried forward speculation losses. The circular had not been cited before the Income-tax Officer, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner or the Tribunal.

The court observed the Division Bench decision in Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. N.C. Uftadhyaya holding that Board circulars are binding on Income-tax Officers and ought to be given effect to by the court, subject to the caveat in that case (bindingness confined to tax laws and to grant administrative relief, not to impose burdens). Having noted that, the court examined the relevant extract of the circular.

The circular's operative guidance (point (v) and the Board's decision) states that:

  • Speculation loss carried forward from earlier years or speculation loss in a year should first be adjusted against speculation profits of that particular year before allowing any other loss to be adjusted against those profits (for the purpose of set-off under section 10 and section 24(1)).
  • For purposes of section 24(2) the Income-tax Officer may allow the assessee either (i) to first set off carried forward speculation losses against current year's speculation profits and then set off current year's other losses against any remaining speculation profit, or (ii) to first set off current year's non-speculation losses against the current year's speculation profit and then set off carried forward speculation losses against any remaining speculation profit — whichever is advantageous to the assessee.

Applying that circular to the present facts, the court reasoned that where carried forward speculation losses exist (here, Rs. 68,224) and the assessee has a current-year speculation profit (here, Rs. 11,369), the circular requires that the current speculation profit be adjusted first against the carried forward speculation loss. The court concluded that this administrative instruction disposed of the substantive statutory construction dispute without further need to construe section 24 vis-à-vis sections 6 and 10 for the purpose of this reference.

On that basis the court held that the taxing authorities and the Tribunal were not justified in refusing the set-off and that the question must be answered against the revenue.

The court also explained that there would be no order as to costs because the circular was not brought to the notice of the taxing authorities or the Tribunal during the earlier proceedings.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The question referred is answered in the negative and against the revenue. The court applied the Central Board of Revenue circular and held that the current year's speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 must be set off first against the carried forward speculation losses from earlier years (aggregating Rs. 68,224) for assessment year 1958–59.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the taxing authorities (Income-tax Officer and appellate authorities) and the Tribunal were wrong to refuse the set-off, and the assessee is entitled to have the current-year speculation profit applied against the carried forward speculation losses in accordance with the Board's circular.
  • The court relied on an administrative circular (treating it as binding in the circumstances) rather than setting a new or broader precedent on the statutory construction of sections 10 and 24; no costs were awarded because the circular had not been produced earlier to the lower authorities.

    Navnitlal Ambalal And Others v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay City Ii.

    Kantawala, C.J:— At the instance of the assessee the Tribunal has referred to us under section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, the following question for our determination:

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, was the Tribunal justified in refusing to allow the set-off of carried forward losses of speculation business against the speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 of the assessment year 1958-59?”

    2. Ambalal Narsidas, the assessee, has income from speculative transactions, business in ready shares and dividends. He has been assessed in the status of an individual.

    3. For the assessment year 1958–59, according to the profit and loss account for the relevant year, the loss that the assessee had suffered was shown at Rs. 6,866. This amount of Rs. 6,866 was arrived at after deducting from the total loss the dividend income of Rs. 51,274 and speculation profit of Rs. 11,369. The total loss without deducting those two items of dividends and speculation profit was Rs. 69,509. Even in the earlier years the assessee was carrying on speculation business and had suffered heavy losses in speculation business. The unabsorbed speculation loss of Rs. 68,224 was allowed by the Income-tax Officer to be carried forward in earlier years and has been brought forward by the assessee to this year.

    4. While assessing the assessee for the assessment year 1958–59, a question arose whether the speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 should be first set off against the carried forward losses of the previous years or whether the speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 should be taken into account in determining the net result of the income or profit for the year in question and if there was income or loss appropriate adjustment should be made in accordance with the provisions of the Income-tax Act. The Income-tax Officer did not allow the claim for set-off in respect of the sum of Rs. 11,369 against the speculation losses brought forward from the previous years to the present year. The order of the Income-tax Officer was confirmed in appeal by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. The contention of the assessee before him was that the net speculation profit of 11,369 should have been treated separately by the Income-tax Officer and the speculation loss carried forward from the earlier years should have been set off against such profits. That contention was not accepted by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. He was of the opinion that the profit or loss for a given assessment year had to be first computed and then only set-off given for loss carried forward under section 24(2) of the Income-tax Act against such net result. In computing profit or loss of any given assessment year, according to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, the speculation profit had to be amalgamated with the profit in the ready transactions and only if there was resultant profit, the question of set-off of loss carried forward from earlier years would then arise. The order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner was confirmed in further appeal by the Tribunal. The Tribunal construed the provisions of section 24 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, and observed that the section provided for set off of loss under one head against profits or gains under any other head. The provisions of the said section, according to the Tribunal would come into operation only after the provisions of section 10 were exhausted for computation of the business income and that involved set off of loss of one business against the profits of any other business. There was only one exception to such a position. That exception is contained in Explanation 1 to section 24(1). Under that Explanation speculation loss cannot be set off against non-speculation income, but there was no objection under the Act, according to the Tribunal, to set off non-speculation business loss against speculation profits. The Tribunal held that non-speculation loss had to be adjusted against speculation profit and that the net result which was so arrived at under section 10 should be considered under section 24(1). After referring to the provisions of section 24(2) of the Act the Tribunal pointed out that it was laid down that speculation loss carried forward should only be set off against profits and gains, if any, of any business in speculation carried on by him in that year. This section did not lay down that before applying the normal method of computation of business income under section 10, the provisions of section, 24(2) should be applied., In the opinion of the Tribunal sub-section (2) of section 24 only restricted the assessee's right to carry forward and set off speculation loss but did not lay down any restriction on the department's, right to set off loss in one business against the profits of any other business under section 10. On this reasoning the contentions urged on behalf of the assessee did not find favour with the Tribunal. It is against this order of the Tribunal that the assessee has asked for reference to this court for determination of the question above referred to.

    5. At the outset it may be stated that Mr. Patil, counsel for the assessee and Mr. Joshi, counsel for the revenue, have drawn our attention to a circular of the Board of Revenue which gives guidelines for answering the question referred to. It may, however, be plainly stated that before none of the taxing authorities and the Tribunal, was this circular cited or brought to their notice. If the circular to which our attention has been drawn is sufficient to decide the question then it is unnecessary for us to consider and construe the provisions of section 24 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, read with the provisions of sections 6 and 10 thereof. On a plain reading of the circular, to which our attention is invited, the question referred to us can be answered without discussing the provisions of the statute. We may point out that a Division Bench of this court in the case of Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd. v. N.C Uftadhyaya [1974] 96 ITR 1, 17 Bom. has pointed out that the circulars issued by the Board would be binding on the Income-tax Officers and must be given effect to by this court. However, a note of caution was struck by the court by observing that the binding nature of circulars issued by the Central Board of Revenue must be confined to tax laws and that also for the purpose of giving administrative relief to the taxpayer and not for the purpose of imposing a burden on him. If such is the effect to be given to the circular then we have to consider whether, on the basis of the circular relied upon, it is possible for us to answer the question without going into the provisions of section 24 and the other relevant sections. On September 12, 1960 (Circular No. 23 (XXXIX-4) D of 1960) bearing No. F. No. 4 (124)-60.TPL, C.B.R was issued. This circular relates to adjustment of speculation profits in the current year against the carried forward speculation loss. The relevant part of the circular is as under:

    “Point (v): Speculation loss, if any, carried forward from the earlier years or the speculation loss, if any, in a year should first be adjusted against speculation profits of the particular year before allowing any other loss to be adjusted against those profits.

    Board's decision: The suggestion is acceptable. For the purpose of setoff under section 10 and section 24(1) the speculation loss of any year should first be set off against the speculation profits of that year and the remaining amount of speculation profits, if any, should then be utilised for setting off of any loss of that year from other sources. For the purposes of section 24(2) the Income-tax Officer may allow the assessee—

    (i) either to first set off the speculation losses carried forward from an earlier year against the speculation profits of the current year and then to set off the current year's losses from other sources against the remaining part, if any, of the current year's speculation profits,

    (ii) or to first set off the current year's losses from non-speculation business and other sources against the current year's speculation profits and then to set off the carried forward speculation losses of the earlier year against the remaining part, if any, of the current year's speculation profits, whichever is advantageous to the assessee. (For points (i) to (iv) considered by the C.B.R see section 43(5)).”

    6. It is thus clear from this circular that if speculation losses for the earlier years are carried forward and if in the year of account a speculation profit is earned by the assessee then the circular provides that such speculation profits for the accounting year should be adjusted against the carried forward speculation loss of the previous year before allowing any other loss to be adjusted against those profits. In view of this circular the position is beyond any doubt so far as the present question is concerned. In the accounting year relevant to the assessment year 1958–59, the assessee, inter alia, had a speculation profit of Rs. 11,369. It is equally clear that unabsorbed speculation losses for the previous years aggregating to Rs. 68,224 were carried forward by the Income-tax Officer from the earlier years. If that was so, then the sum of Rs. 11,369 which represented the speculation profit in the relevant year should first be set off in view of the provisions of this circular against the carried forward speculation losses of the earlier years and if that is done, then the question referred to us shall have to be answered against the revenue. Applying the provisions of the above circular of the Central Board of Revenue, we hold that the taxing authorities and the Tribunal were not justified in refusing to allow the setoff of carried forward losses of speculation business against the speculation profit of Rs. 11,369 of the assessment year 1958-59.

    7. Thus, the question referred to us is answered in the negative and against the revenue. There will be no order as to costs since the provisions of this circular were not brought to the notice of any of the taxing authorities or the Tribunal when the assessee's matter was heard by them.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Navnitlal Ambalal And Others v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay City Ii.
    (Jul 10, 1975)