Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provisions in the Workmen's Compensation Act
  • provisions in Order 22, Rule 3, of the CPC
  • provisions in Order 22 of the CPC
  • 20 1968.7. Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provisions in the Workmen's Compensation Act
  • provisions in Order 22, Rule 3, of the CPC
  • provisions in Order 22 of the CPC
  • 20 1968.7. Rule
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion: Revisional Application Concerning Continuation of Workmen's Compensation Claim

Factual and Procedural Background

The revisional petition challenged an order of the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation who allowed the opponent (the widow of the deceased original applicant) to continue the original compensation application filed by her deceased husband. The petitioners contended that the application to bring the opponent on record was made after the original application had abated and was barred by limitation.

Counsel for the petitioners, Mr. Rele, submitted that the deceased original applicant died on September 25, 1967, and that the application for bringing the opponent (the widow) on record was made on February 21, 1968. He relied on Order 22, Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) to argue that the original application had abated and that the later application was out of time.

The Commissioner had allowed the opponent to be brought on record and ordered an amendment by an order dated December 20, 1968. The revisional application sought to challenge that action of the Commissioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application to bring the opponent on record was barred by limitation or whether the original application had abated.
  2. Whether the provisions of Order 22 (in particular Order 22, Rule 3) of the Code of Civil Procedure are applicable to applications for compensation made under the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  3. Whether provisions of the Limitation Act apply to applications for compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  4. Whether heirs of a deceased applicant are entitled to continue an application for compensation originally filed by the deceased.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented by Mr. Rele)

  • The petitioners argued that the original applicant's death (on September 25, 1967) caused the original application to abate and that any subsequent attempt to bring the widow on record (application made on February 21, 1968) was beyond the period of limitation and therefore barred.
  • They relied on Order 22, Rule 3 of the CPC as the legal basis for the contention that the application had abated and that the later application should be rejected.

The opinion does not set out any detailed argument advanced on behalf of the opponent (the widow); only the petitioners' submissions and certain admissions by their counsel are recorded.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the petitioners' reliance on Order 22 of the CPC and on the Limitation Act by asking counsel to identify any provision in the Workmen's Compensation Act that makes the provisions of Order 22 of the CPC applicable to applications for compensation under that Act. Counsel (Mr. Rele) candidly admitted that no such provision had been made applicable.

The court also requested counsel to point out any provision that makes the Limitation Act applicable to applications for compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act; counsel did not identify any such provision.

Based on these admissions and the statutory structure as presented in the record, the court reasoned as follows:

  1. There is nothing in law before the court to indicate that applications for compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act cannot be continued by the heirs of deceased applicants.
  2. No specific time is fixed by the applicable statute within which heirs must come on record to continue applications originally filed by deceased applicants.
  3. Applications filed under the Workmen's Compensation Act are for recovery of money and, on the facts as presented, are treated as rights to debts which survive to the heirs of a deceased applicant. Because the right asserted is not a purely personal right of the deceased applicant but a right to recover a debt, it survives to the opponent (the widow).
  4. Since the provisions of Order 22 of the CPC have not been made applicable to applications under the Workmen's Compensation Act, the mechanism or time-limits found in Order 22 cannot be used to declare the original compensation application abated.
  5. Consequently, the widow, as heir, was entitled to continue the original application in her own right, and the debt claimed survived to her; accordingly the Commissioner correctly granted the application to bring her on record and ordered the amendment (reflected in the order dated December 20, 1968).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court upheld the Commissioner's action. The revisional rule was discharged. The Commissioner was correct in granting the application to bring the opponent (the widow) on record and in ordering the amendment by the order dated December 20, 1968. The court recorded "No order as to costs."

Implications: As set out in the opinion:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The opponent (widow) is entitled to continue the original compensation application in her own right; the Commissioner's order allowing her to be brought on record stands.
  • Statutory construction effect: The court treated applications under the Workmen's Compensation Act as involving rights to debts that survive to heirs, and it concluded that Order 22 of the CPC and the Limitation Act were not shown to be made applicable to such applications in the circumstances of this opinion.
  • No broader precedent was expressly claimed to have been established in the opinion beyond the direct ruling on the present facts; the opinion rests on the absence of statutory provisions making Order 22 or the Limitation Act applicable to these applications and on the survival of the debt to heirs.

Core ruling (emphasized): Rule discharged.

    Manubhai Kikabhai And Co. v. Babajee Rajaram

    1. The grievance of the petitioners in this revisional application is that the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation wrongly held in favour of the opponent that she was entitled to continue the original application filed for compensation by her deceased husband, and in that connection the Commissioner wrongly rejected the contention made on behalf of the petitioners that the application for bringing the opponent on record was not made within the period of, limitation prescribed.

    2. In the submission of Mr. Rele for the petitioners, the application for bringing the opponent on record was much after the application had abated and was barred by limitation. The application should have been rejected.

    3. Mr. Rele's attempt was to rely upon the provisions in Order 22, Rule 3, of the CPC in support of his above submission. The contention was that the original applicant died on September 25, 1967, and the application for bringing the opponent, being the widow of the deceased applicant, on record was made on February 21, 1968. The original application must be held to have abated. The present application for bringing the opponent on record was made on February 21, 1968, and was beyond the time prescribed.

    4. In connection with these submissions, I repeatedly requested Mr. Rele to point out provisions in the Workmen's Compensation Act providing for application of the provisions of Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure to applications for compensation made under the Act.

    5. Mr. Rele candidly admitted that these provisions have not been made applicable to such applications, I also requested Mr. Rele to point out how provisions in the limitation act are made applicable to applications for compensation made under the above Act. He did not point out any such provision.

    6. It must under the above circumstances, be held that there is nothing in law to suggest that applications for compensation under the Act cannot be continued by heirs of deceased applicants. There is no time fixed within which heirs of deceased applicants must come on record to enable them to continue the applications originally filed by deceased applicants. Applications filed under the above Act being for recovery of money must be held to be in respect of rights to debts which survive to heirs of deceased applicants. As the right to the debt was not personal right of the deceased applicant, the opponent as his widow was entitled to continue the original application in her own right. The debt survived to the opponent and was claimable by her. As the debt survived, the application cannot be held to have abated at any date. This is so because the provisions in Order 22 of the CPC are not made applicable to applications made under the Act. The Commissioner was, therefore, right in granting the application and ordering the amendment, and in making the order dated December 20 1968.

    7. Rule discharged. No order as to costs.

    8. Rule discharged.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Manubhai Kikabhai And Co. v. Babajee Rajaram
    (Nov 14, 1969)