Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Indian Contract Act. Sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Contract Act
  • section 74-A of the Railways Act. Section 74-C
  • sections 74-A and 74-C of the Railways Act
  • provisions of S. 74-A of the Railways Act
  • SECTION 72 RAILWAYS ACT
  • S. 106 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • SECTION 74 RAILWAYS ACT
  • section 72 oft the Railways Act
  • S. 74-C of the Railways Act
  • S. 106 of the Evidence Act,
  • Section 74-C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Indian Contract Act. Sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Contract Act
  • section 74-A of the Railways Act. Section 74-C
  • sections 74-A and 74-C of the Railways Act
  • provisions of S. 74-A of the Railways Act
  • SECTION 72 RAILWAYS ACT
  • S. 106 of the Indian Evidence Act
  • SECTION 74 RAILWAYS ACT
  • section 72 oft the Railways Act
  • S. 74-C of the Railways Act
  • S. 106 of the Evidence Act,
  • Section 74-C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a First Appeal by the original plaintiff Ramkrishna Ramnath shop. The plaintiff's suit against the Union of India (represented by the Eastern Railway, Central Railway and the Southern Railway) sought damages of Rs. 15,047 for alleged damage to 54 bags of tobacco out of a consignment delivered by the plaintiff to the Southern Railway at Nipani for carriage to Tumsar Road.

At trial, the Additional District Judge, Bhandara, accepted that 54 bags had been damaged but assessed the value of the damage at Rs. 13,808-6-6 and dismissed the suit on the ground that the plaintiff had failed to prove either misconduct or negligence on the part of the railways. The plaintiff appealed, challenging the finding that misconduct or negligence had not been proved. The appellant accepts the trial court's valuation of damages at Rs. 13,808-6-6.

Admitted factual background: 340 bags of tobacco were handed over at Nipani to the Southern Railway for carriage to Tumsar Road; 54 bags arrived in a very wet condition; the consignee protested and a Railway Inspector inspected and assessed 70% damage; goods were despatched from Kolhapur on metre-gauge and transhipped at Ghorpadi to broad-gauge wagons; the forwarding note by the plaintiff recorded acceptance of "owner's risk" and noted packing in single bags.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the railways are responsible for the damage to the 54 bags of tobacco (i.e., whether the plaintiff has proved negligence or misconduct on the part of the Railway Administration or its servants).
  2. Whether Section 74-A of the Railways Act applies (i.e., whether the damage resulted from defective condition or defective/improper packing such that the Administration is excused except upon proof of negligence or misconduct).
  3. Whether Section 74-C of the Railways Act applies (i.e., whether the goods were carried at an owner's risk rate because two alternative rates existed and the sender elected not to pay the railway risk rate), and if so, whether that shifts the burden to the plaintiff to prove negligence or misconduct.

Arguments of the Parties

Railways' Contentions

  • Sections 74-A and 74-C of the Railways Act are applicable: S.74-A because the packing was defective; S.74-C because the consignor had accepted "owner's risk".
  • Because of the applicability of those provisions, the burden is on the plaintiff to prove either misconduct or negligence on the part of the railways.

Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • Section 74-A does not apply because the damage was not caused by defective packing (if any) of the goods.
  • Section 74-C does not apply because there is no evidence that the railway provided two different rates for the class of goods in question and that the goods were carried at a specially reduced (owner's risk) rate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Roshan Umar Karim and Co. v. Madras and Southern Maharatta Railway Co. Ltd., ILR 59 Mad 789 (AIR 1936 Mad 508) Recognition that the word "misconduct" is capable of different interpretations. Used to introduce the different possible meanings of "misconduct" and to frame discussion on how "misconduct" should be understood in railway cases.
B.B. and C.I. Railway v. Rajnagar Spinning etc. Co. Ltd., AIR 1930 Bom 129 View that "misconduct" suggests a railway servant had acted inconsistently with company rules; distinguishes "misconduct" from "negligence" and rejects inferring misconduct from mere damage. Adopted the Bombay High Court's view that misconduct requires proof of rule-violation and cannot be inferred merely from deterioration; applied to assess whether railway servants violated monsoon rules.
Dwarkanath v. Rivers Steam Navigation Co., 20 Bom LR 735 (AIR 1917 PC 173) Under S.106 Evidence Act, the bailee (carrier) should call material witnesses to prove facts uniquely within its knowledge. Relied upon to hold that the railway (as bailee) ought to have produced material witnesses (e.g., wagon clerks, wagon inspector) to show wagons were watertight; failure to do so was material against the railway.
Governor-General in Council v. Motilal Kajriwall, AIR 1945 Pat 159 Observation that if wagons were watertight and flap-doors securely fastened, rain-water would not have forced its way in and damaged goods. Applied to support the inference that damage by rain-water indicated a failure to provide watertight wagons; used to link admission of rain-water entry to prima facie negligence.
Union of India v. Parikh Shankarlal Jethalal, AIR 1956 Nag 255 Carrier is not required to prove positively how loss occurred but must place material concerning the occurrence before the court; consignees still must satisfy court on carrier's lack of due care. Used to explain the evidentiary duties of the railway: obligation to lay material before the court and the consequence of failing to do so.
Asaram Gangaram v. Union of India, New Delhi, AIR 1957 Nag 59 When goods deteriorated in custody of railway, a prima facie case of negligence arises and under S.106 the railway must place material about how the consignment was handled. Applied to hold that the admitted deterioration while in railway custody created a prima facie case of negligence which the railway failed to rebut by adducing material to show requisite care.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by setting out the statutory framework:

  • Section 72 of the Railways Act makes the railway administration's responsibility for loss/deterioration that of a bailee governed by sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Indian Contract Act (bailee's duty to take as much care as a person of ordinary prudence would take of his own goods).
  • Sections 74-A and 74-C are special provisions that modify this general bailee responsibility in two distinct situations:
    • S.74-A applies where goods are in defective condition or defectively packed or packed contrary to railway orders and are thereby liable to damage; in such cases the railway is not responsible except upon proof of negligence or misconduct.
    • S.74-C applies when the railway offers two rates (a railway risk rate and a special reduced owner's risk rate) and the consignor elects not to pay the railway risk rate; goods carried at owner's risk are not the railway's responsibility except upon proof of negligence or misconduct.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court made the following key analytical moves:

  1. S.74-A was considered and rejected as inapplicable because the damage was not shown to have been caused by defective packing. Although the tariff required Jarda tobacco to be packed in baskets or mats, securely packed in gunny (classification P/10), there was no evidence that damage was due to defective packing; the actual admitted cause was rain-water entering through wagon door crevices.
  2. S.74-C was found applicable on its facts: the tariff provided two alternative rates for Jarda tobacco (classification P/10 at railway risk and P/9 at the reduced owner's risk) and the plaintiff's forwarding note expressly accepted "owner's risk." Thus S.74-C operates to place on the plaintiff the burden to prove negligence or misconduct to recover.
  3. Even where S.74-C applies and the plaintiff bears the burden, the court reviewed the evidentiary position. The railways admitted that rain-water entered through crevices of the wagon door and that the damage resulted from rain-water. The railways attempted to show that some wagons (e.g., No. 3498) were water-tight, but crucially the damaged bags were found mainly in wagon No. 30525 (and one in No. 15809), and the railway had not produced evidence to show those particular wagons were water-tight.
  4. The court examined the railway's non-production of witnesses (clerks and the wagon inspector). The defendant had applied for adjournment to produce certain witnesses but the court had refused further adjournment. The opinion records that the failure to examine the witness who loaded wagon No. 30525 was due to the defendant's default. The court further observed that other material witnesses (e.g., wagon inspector at Ghorpadi) were available and could have been produced.
  5. Relying on authority (Dwarkanath) and S.106 Evidence Act principles, the court held that the bailee (railway) should call material witnesses and place before the court the special facts within its knowledge. The railway's failure to adduce such material, combined with its admission that rain-water entered through wagon door crevices, gave rise to a prima facie case of negligence.
  6. The court concluded that the failure to provide watertight wagons (a duty under monsoon rules) constituted negligence. Because the monsoon rules required provision of watertight wagons and the railway did not demonstrate compliance for the relevant wagons, the court also treated this failure as amounting to misconduct (i.e., conduct inconsistent with railway rules) for the purposes of S.74-C.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The court held that the plaintiff proved negligence (and, given the breach of monsoon rules, misconduct) on the part of the Railway Administration and is entitled to recover damages.

Decree: A decree is to be passed in favour of the plaintiff for Rs. 13,808/6/6 (the quantum of damages as found by the trial court and accepted by the appellant). The appeal is allowed with costs and the suit is decreed with proportionate costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the Railway Administration is ordered to pay Rs. 13,808/6/6 to the plaintiff with costs; the trial court's dismissal on the ground of absence of proved negligence/misconduct is overturned.
  • On evidentiary practice: the decision underscores the obligation of a carrier/bailee to produce material witnesses and evidence under S.106 of the Evidence Act when special facts are within its knowledge; failure to do so can lead to an adverse inference and a finding of negligence.
  • The opinion does not state that it creates any new legal precedent beyond its application of existing statutory provisions and authorities; the court applied established principles (S.72, S.74-A, S.74-C and S.106) and cited prior decisions in support of its conclusions.

    Ramkrishna Ramnath Shop, Through Proprietor Radhakisan Ramnath, Kamptee v. Union Of India And Others,

    Raju, J.:— This is a First Appeal by the original plaintiff Ramkrishna Ramnath shop, whose suit against the Union of India, represented by the Eastern Railway, Central Railway and the Southern Railway, for damages amounting to Rs. 15,047 in respect of damage said to have been caused to 54 bags out of the bags of tobacco delivered by the plaintiff to the Southern Railway at Nipani for carriage to Tumsar Road, was dismissed by the Additional District Judge, Bhandara. The learned Additional District Judge accepted the plaintiff's case that 54 bags of tobacco had been damaged, and according to him the value of damage was Rs. 13,808-6-6 only and not Rs. 15,047 as claimed in the plaint. But holding that the plaintiff has failed to prove either misconduct or negligence on the part of the railways, the learned Additional District Judge dismissed the suit. The plaintiff has now come up in appeal and challenges the finding of the Additional District Judge that the plaintiff has failed to prove either misconduct or negligence on the part of the railway. The learned counsel for the appellant accepts the finding of the trial Court that the damage was to the extent of Rs. 13,808-6-6 only.

    2. The admitted facts are that the plaintiff handed over 340 bags of tobacco at Nipani to the Southern Railway for being carried to Tumsar Road. It is also admitted that 54 bags out of these bags came in a very wet condition to Tumsar Road, and on a protest lodged by the consignee, the Railway Inspector inspected the goods and assessed the damage at 70 per cent and gave delivery without prejudice to the rights of the Railway Administration. The goods were despatched from Kolhapur railway station on the metre guage railway and transhipped at Ghorpadi railway station to broad guage wagons. When the plaintiff delivered the bags of tobacco he gave a forwarding note in which he accepted the risk as “owner's risk”, and on the forwarding note it is also noted that the tobacco was packed in single bags.

    3. The only point argued in appeal is whether the railways are responsible for the damage admittedly caused to 54 bags of tobacco. On behalf of the railway it is contended that both sections 74-A and 74-C of the Railways Act are applicable, the former section because the packing was defective, and the latter section because the consignor had accepted “owner's risk”. It is therefore contended that the burden is on the plaintiff to prove either misconduct or negligence on the part of the railways. The learned counsel for the appellant however contends that section 74-A of the Railways Act does not apply because the damage in this case had not been caused by the defective packing (if any) of the goods, and that Section 74-C of the Act does not apply because there is no evidence to show that for the class of goods in question the railways provided two different rates and that the goods were carried at a specially reduced rate.

    4. Section 72 of the Railways Act provides that the responsibility of a railway administration for the loss, destruction or deterioration of animals or goods delivered to the administration to be carried by railway shall, subject to the other provisions of the Act, be that of a bailee under sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Indian Contract Act. Sections 151, 152 and 161 of the Contract Act provide that a bailee is bound to take as much care of the goods bailed to him as a man of ordinary prudence would, under similar circumstances, take of his own goods of the same bulk, quality and value as the goods bailed, and that in the absence of any special contract, the bailee is not responsible for the loss, destruction or deterioration of the thing bailed, if he has taken the amount of care of it described in section 151. Ordinarily therefore, when section 72 oft the Railways Act applies, the responsibility of the railway is that of a bailee to show that it has taken as much care of the goods as a man of ordinary-prudence would under similar circumstances take of his own goods of the same bulk, quality and value as the goods bailed. This general provision relating to the responsibility of the railway is however altered in two special cases, to which sections 74-A and 74-C of the Railways Act are applicable. When goods tendered to the railway for carriage are in defective condition or when they are either defectively packed or packed in a manner not in accordance with the general or special orders of the railway, as a consequence of which the goods are liable to deterioration, leakage, wastage or damage in transit, section 74-A of the Railways Act applies and the Railway Administration is not responsible for any deterioration, leakage, wastage or damage, except upon proof of negligence or misconduct on the part of the railway administration or any of its servants. This is provided in section 74-A of the Railways Act. Section 74-C provides as follows:

    “74-C. Liability of a railway administration for animals or goods carried at owner's risk rate.—(1) When any animals or goods are tendered to a railway administration for carriage by railway and the railway administration provides for the carriage of such animals or goods either at the ordinary tariff rate (in this Act referred to as the railway risk rate) or in the alternative at a special reduced rate (in this Act referred to as the owner's risk rate), the animals or goods shall be deemed to have been tendered to be carried at owner's risk rate, unless, the sender or his agent elects in writing to pay the railway risk rate.

    (2) Where the sender or his agent elects in writing to pay the railway risk rate under sub-section (1), the railway administration shall issue a certificate to the consignor to that effect.

    (3) When any animals or goods are carried or are deemed to be carried at owner's risk rate, a railway administration shall not be responsible for any loss, destruction or deterioration of or damage to such goods from any cause whatsoever except upon proof that such loss, destruction, deterioration or damage was due to negligence or misconduct on the part of the railway administration or of any of its servants.”

    5. This section applies when the railway provides two alternative rates for the carriage of goods and when the sender does not pay the railway risk-rate. In such a case the Railway Administration is not responsible for any loss, destruction or any deterioration of or damage to such goods from any cause whatsoever, except upon proof that such loss, destruction, or damage was due to negligence or misconduct on the part of the Railway Administration or of any of its servants.

    6. In the instant case, in the written statement of the railways it is admitted that the damage was due to rain water having entered through the crevices of the door of the wagon. The goods are described as “Jarda tobacco” and for “Jarda tobacco” the railway rules provide that the packing condition shall be according to the classification P/10 in Chapter IX of the Goods Tariff. The packing classification P/10 is described as follows: “Must be in baskets or mats, securely packed in gunny.” It is not necessary that there should be double gunny bags, but there is no evidence to show that tobacco was in baskets or mats. In any case it is clear that the damage actually caused was not due to the defective packing and therefore the provisions of S. 74-A of the Railways Act are not attracted. Section 74-A applies only when goods are liable to damage, leakage, wastage or deterioration as a consequence of their defective condition or as a consequence of defective or improper packing. But the railways are entitled to rely on S. 74-C of the Act because for “Jarda” or country-manufactured tobacco two rates are provided, namely, under the general classification P/10 at railway risk and under the general classification P-9 at the reduced rate i.e at the owner's risk. Two rates are provided for this type of goods, and the owner did not pay the special rate for railway risk but elected to send the goods at his own risk as stated in his forwarding note. Section 74-C therefore applies to the facts of this case and unless the plaintiff proves either misconduct or negligence on the part of the Railway Administration, or of any of its servants, he would not be entitled to recover any damages.

    7. The word “misconduct” is capable of three different interpretations, as observed in Roshan Umar Karim and Co. v. Madras and Southern Maharatta Railway Co., Ltd., ILR 59 Mad 789 at p. 795 : (AIR 1936 Mad 508 at pp. 510-511). But the view taken by the Bombay High Court in B.B and C.I Railway v. Rajnagar Spinning etc. Co. Ltd., AIR 1930 Bom 129, is that the word “misconduct” suggests that a railway servant had been guilty of doing something which was inconsistent with the conduct expected of him by the rules of the company. “Misconduct” and “negligence” are different notions. Some kinds of negligence may amount to “misconduct”, while some kinds of negligence may not amount to “misconduct”. According to the view taken by the Bombay High Court there can be misconduct only if some rules of the company are violated. The principle of res ipsa loquitur may be applied to infer negligence but it cannot be applied to infer misconduct. Misconduct, that is conduct inconsistent with the rules of the railway, has to be proved and cannot be inferred from the mere fact of deterioration or damage. In the instant case, there are rules for taking precautions during the monsoon, and it is admitted by both sides that Railway Rules provide that for the carriage of goods during the monsoon it is the duty of the railway servants to provide water-tight wagons for goods which are liable to damage by water. In the Instant case the railways have examined the railway clerk Hanmant (D.W 4) who was a clerk at Ghorpadi transhipment Shed. He has deposed that he examined wagon No. 3498 and assured himself that it was water-tight before the tobacco bags were loaded. But in the instant case the goods of the plaintiff were sent in three different wagons bearing Nos. 19412, 30525 and 3498 at Ghorpadi. At Ajni railway station near Nagpur, the bags were sent in three wagons bearing Nos. 19412, 30525 and 15809, 147 bags were sent in wagon No. 30525 which was a through wagon from Ghorpadi to Tumsar Road, and it is this wagon that was found to contain 53 damaged bags. One damaged bag of tobacco was in wagon No. 15809. It is therefore necessary to know whether wagons Nos. 30525 and 15809 were water-tight or not.

    8. On this point the railways have not examined any witness to show that these wagons were water-tight as required by the Rules. It appears that one Raikar was the clerk who loaded the bags in wagon No. 30525, but it is contended that this clerk is not examined because the Court did not grant adjournment to the defendant to enable it to examine the witness. The order sheet of the Court dated 29-7-1954 shows that the defendant had made an application for adjournment of the case on the ground that the three witnesses Sheikh, Raikar and Mahapatra were absent and that Raikar and Sheikh were ill. The application for adjournment was rejected by the Court which stated as Follows:

    “I consider that no valid ground exists for granting further adjournment. The defendant had agreed and had undertaken to produce the evidence for to-day. Already two adjournments had been granted. It will be seen that this case was fixed for the defendant's evidence on 22-3-1954 on which date the defendant was not ready with the evidence. The defendant was specially told on that date that no further adjournment will be allowed. The application for adjournment is rejected.”

    9. The failure to examine the witness in question was therefore due to the default of the defendant railways. Moreover, it is in evidence that there was a Wagon Inspector at Ghorpadi. The railway could have examined the Inspector of Wagons at Ghorpadi even if one of the clerks who was in charge of the wagon was ill. In any case, the defendant had taken two previous adjournments and had undertaken to produce the witness on the day. The blame for not examining witnesses to prove that the wagons in question were water-tight wagons is therefore clearly on the defendant railways. It is also admitted in the written statement that the goods were damaged on account of the rain water having entered through the crevices of the door of the wagon. As observed in Governor-General in Council v. Motilal Kajriwall, AIR 1945 Pat 159, if the wagons were water-tight and the flap-doors had been securely fastened, goods would not have been damaged by the rain-water forcing its way into the wagon.

    10. In cases to which S. 74-C of the Railways Act is applicable the burden of proving misconduct or negligence is of course on the plaintiff, but as observed by the Privy Council in Dwarkanath v. Rivers Steam Navigation Co., 20 Bom LR 735 : (AIR 1917 PC 173), under S. 106 of the Indian Evidence Act the bailee should call all the material witnesses to prove the facts which were within the special knowledge of the bailee. As observed in Union of India v. Parikh Shankarlal Jethalal, AIR 1956 Nag 255, the law does not cast any burden upon the Administration to establish positively how the loss or damage occurred, and to prove an absence of negligence on their part, but a duty is cast on the Administration to lay all the materials concerning the occurrence before the Court; but even so it remains for the consignees to satisfy the Court that the true inference from the materials is that the carrier's servants have not shown due care, skill and nerve. As observed in Asaram Gangaram v. Union of India, New Delhi, AIR 1957 Nag 59:

    “It is no doubt true that it is always for the plaintiff to prove that the loss was caused by the neglect or negligence of the Railway Administration. But when the Court has the evidence that the goods had deteriorated while in the custody of the Railway Administration, there is a prima facie case of negligence for the Railway Administration to answer. Under S. 106 of the Evidence Act, the special facts and circumstances under which the consignment was handled are only known to the Railway Administration, and therefore, it is for them to place that material before the Court for forming its opinion on the question whether it had taken as much care of the goods as is required of them. The Railway Administration should place material before the Court from which it could be inferred how the consignment was dealt with, in order to ascertain whether the Railway Administration took as much care as is required of them, being bailees of the goods under Ss. 151, 152 and 1161 of the Contract Act.”

    11. In the instant case, admittedly 54 bags were damaged by rain water. As already observed, the Railway Administration has failed to adduce evidence to show that it had provided rain-proof wagons at Ghorpadi railway station. It has also admitted that rain-water had entered the crevices of the door of the wagon. As observed in AIR 1945 Pat 159, rain water would not have damaged the tobacco bags if rain-proof wagons had been used. This is therefore a prima facie case of negligence. In these circumstances, we hold that the plaintiff has succeeded in proving negligence on the part of the Railway Administration. The failure to provide water-tight wagons would also amount to misconduct because admittedly under the rules relating to conveyance of goods in monsoon it was the duty of the railway servants to provide water-tight wagons.

    12. For these reasons, we are satisfied that the plaintiff has succeeded in proving that he is entitled to damage. As regards quantum of damages, the learned counsel for the appellant accepts the finding of the trial Court that he has suffered damages to the extent of Rs. 13,808/6/6. This finding is not challenged by the railways. We therefore allow the appeal and order that a decree shall be passed in favour of the plaintiff for Rs. 13,808/6/6. The appeal is allowed with costs and the suit will be decreed with proportionate costs.

    DD/H.G.P
    Appeal allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramkrishna Ramnath S... v. Union Of India And O...
    (Jan 11, 1960)