AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order XVI Rule 1 r/w. Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Order XVI Rule 1 of the Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order XVI Rule 1 r/w. Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • Order XVI Rule 1 of the Code
Smart Summary

Summary of Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a suit for permanent injunction restraining the respondents from interfering with his possession of the suit schedule property (O.S. No. 104/2008). Respondent No. 1 (defendant No. 3) denied the petitioner's claim of being granted a patta by the Tahsildar and pleaded that a patta was granted in her favour. Respondent No. 1 moved I.A. No. 284/2012 under Order XVI Rule 1 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking summons to the Tahsildar, Tadikonda village and Mandal, Guntur District, to give evidence about issuance of the patta and to prove a notice dated 13-5-2008. The petitioner filed a counter-affidavit opposing that application. The learned Principal Junior Civil Judge, Mangalagiri, allowed the I.A. by a non-speaking order dated 16-3-2012. The petitioner filed this Civil Revision Petition impugning that order. An interim order dated 10-4-2012 had been passed subsequently; the revision court ultimately vacated that interim order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the lower court erred in allowing the application under Order XVI Rule 1 r/w Section 151 CPC to summon the Tahsildar in a private dispute over immovable property.
  2. Whether respondent No. 1 had made out a sufficient case to summon the Tahsildar instead of producing the patta or other revenue records in evidence.
  3. Whether the lower court's order allowing the I.A. was legally acceptable given that it was a non-speaking order (i.e., without recorded reasons).

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent No. 1's Arguments

  • Respondent No. 1 asserted that the Tahsildar granted a patta in her favour and that the Tahsildar issued notice dated 13-5-2008 to both parties.
  • On that basis, she applied under Order XVI Rule 1 r/w Section 151 CPC to summon the Tahsildar to give evidence supporting her claim.

Petitioner's (Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The petitioner filed a counter-affidavit resisting respondent No. 1's application (details of the counter-affidavit are not elaborated in the opinion beyond its existence and resistance to the application).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first criticized the lower court for issuing a non-speaking order without referring to the pleadings or recording reasons for allowing the application, observing that such an approach by a judicial officer is unsatisfactory.

On the merits, the court analyzed the scope and proper use of Order XVI Rule 1 (as invoked) and Section 151 CPC in the context of a private suit over immovable property between two parties. The court noted:

  • The dispute is a private contest in which both parties claim title by reference to pattas allegedly issued by the Tahsildar.
  • Respondent No. 1 had not produced any patta certificate or other revenue records on file to substantiate her plea that a patta was granted in her favour.
  • If an official patta certificate exists, it is an official document admissible in evidence without the necessity of examining the Tahsildar who issued it; in contrast, respondent No. 1 relied instead on seeking the Tahsildar's oral testimony.
  • Order XVI Rule 1 is not intended to assist litigants who fail to adduce proper and relevant documentary evidence and instead seek to rely solely on the testimony of public servants. The principal object of the provision is to enable the court, when it itself thinks the evidence of a person is necessary for proper adjudication, to summon that witness.
  • The lower court did not, on the record, apply its mind to conclude that the Tahsildar's evidence was necessary to adjudicate any seriously disputed question; hence summoning a public servant to bolster one party's case was not warranted.
  • The court emphasized that private parties should not be allowed to burden public officials with attendance in court where the party could have produced the official record itself.

Based on these considerations, the court concluded that respondent No. 1 had not made out a case for summoning the Tahsildar and that the lower court's order allowing the I.A. could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

The Civil Revision Petition is allowed and the order under revision dated 16-3-2012 (allowing the I.A.) is set aside.

Direct consequences as stated in the opinion:

  • The order of the lower court allowing the application to summon the Tahsildar is set aside.
  • Respondent No. 1 is not precluded from obtaining and filing the patta certificate or other official revenue records from the authority concerned and placing them on record in the suit.
  • The interim order dated 10-4-2012 is vacated and CRPMP No. 2271 of 2012 is disposed of as infructuous.

The opinion does not discuss broader precedential implications beyond these direct effects; no new legal precedent or novel rule of law is announced in the text.

    Shaik Ujauddin v. Veerabhadra Uma Devi And Others

    ORDER:

    This Civil Revision Petition is filed against order dated 16-3-2012 in I.A No. 284/2012 in O.S No. 104/2008 on the file of the learned Principal Junior Civil Judge, Mangalagiri.

    The petitioner filed the above mentioned suit for permanent injunction restraining the respondents herein from interfering with his possession of the suit schedule property. Respondent No. 1 is defendant No. 3 in the suit. She has filed a written statement denying the petitioner's claim that he was granted patta by the Revenue officials, and has set up the plea that the Tahsildar, Tadikonda village and Mandal has granted patta in her favour. Respondent No. 1 has filed the above mentioned I.A under Order XVI Rule 1 r/w. Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “the CPC”) to issue summons to the Tahsildar, Tadikonda village and Mandal, Guntur District, for giving evidence on her behalf regarding issuance of patta in her favour and also to prove that the Tahsildar has issued notice dated 13-5-2008 to both the parties. The petitioner/plaintiff, as respondent No. 1, filed a counter-affidavit resisting the said application. The lower Court by a non-speaking order allowed the said I.A Feeling aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner/plaintiff filed this revision petition.

    In the first place, it needs to be mentioned that the manner in which the learned Principal Junior Civil Judge, Mangalagiri, has passed the order under the Revision is thoroughly unsatisfactory. When the petitioner/plaintiff filed a counter-affidavit and strongly resisted the application filed by respondent No. 1.defendant No. 3, it is the duty and obligation of the learned Junior Civil Judge to refer to the respective pleadings and record reasons for allowing the application. The order passed by the learned Junior Civil Judge is bereft of any reasons whatsoever. Such an approach on the part of a Judicial Officer cannot be appreciated.

    On the merits of the case, I am of the opinion that respondent No. 1 has not made out any case for summoning the Tahsildar, Tadikonda Mandal. The suit pertains to purely a dispute over immovable property between two private parties. Each of the parties is claiming right under purported pattas issued to them by the Tahsildar. As noted above, respondent No. 1, while denying the plea of the petitioner/plaintiff that the latter was granted patta by the Tahsildar, had set up the plea that the Tahsildar has granted patta in her favour. It does not appear from the available record that respondent No. 1 has filed any such patta certificate. If patta was granted in favour of respondent No. 1, being an official document, the same is admissible in evidence even without examining the Tahsildar who is stated to have issued such patta. It is not the pleaded case of respondent No. 1 that she has filed the patta certificate and that its genuineness is disputed by the petitioner/plaintiff. At least, in such a situation, perhaps, there may be some justification for respondent No. 1 to make an application for summoning the Tahsildar to speak about the genuineness of the patta certificate granted in her favour. On her part, respondent No. 1 has done precious little in substantiating her plea that the Tahsildar has indeed granted patta in her favour by filing the same and also any other revenue record in support of such plea.

    In my opinion, a private party, in order to substantiate his own plea, cannot seek to drag the Government officials to the Court as that would involve waste of precious time of the officials. Order XVI Rule 1 of the Code is not meant for helping litigants who fail to adduce proper and relevant evidence to prove their case and rely solely on the basis of the testimony of public servants. The predominant object of this provision is to enable the Court to summon any witness if it feels that the evidence of such person is necessary for proper and effectual adjudication of the dispute involved in the suit. It is not as if the lower Court, on application of its mind, has felt that the evidence of the Tahsildar is needed for adjudication of the dispute involved in the suit. In a suit involving disputes over immovable properties between two private parties, the Courts shall not ordinarily summon public servants to support the cause of one party unless the Court itself is of the opinion that the evidence of such public servant is required to adjudicate on the seriously disputed questions arising in the suit.

    For the above mentioned reasons, the order under the Revision cannot be sustained and the same is accordingly set-aside. The Civil Revision Petition is accordingly allowed. This order, however, would not preclude respondent No. 1 from filing the patta certificate stated to have been issued in her favour and any other official record after obtaining the same from the authority concerned.

    As a sequel, interim order dated 10-4-2012 is vacated and CRPMP No. 2271 of 2012 is disposed of as infructuous.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shaik Ujauddin v. Veerabhadra Uma Devi And Others
    (Sep 27, 2012)