AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision petition was filed by the decree-holder and petitioner in IA No. 42/1999 in O.S. No. 48/1992. The petitioner had earlier instituted a suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale in respect of Ac.0.32 cents in Survey No. 155/1 against defendant Nos. 1 to 5. One defendant who had a share in the property did not sign the agreement of sale; the lower Court therefore granted a decree only to the extent of shares of those who had signed the agreement (decree dated 17.4.1986).

At the instance of the revision petitioner a Commissioner was appointed to localise and divide the property so as to exclude the third defendant's share. The Commissioner, assisted by a surveyor, verified the boundaries and extent described in the agreement and the plaint, but reported that the scheduled land actually lay partly in Survey No. 155/1 and partly in Survey No. 154/2. The revision petitioner then filed IA No. 42/1999 under Sections 151 to 153 and Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, seeking correction of the plaint schedule and of the schedule attached to the decree dated 17.4.1986. The lower Court dismissed that petition by order dated 8.11.2002. The present revision challenges the legality and validity of that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to the relief of correction of the plaint schedule and the schedule attached to the decree so as to include the additional survey number (Survey No. 154/2) discovered by the Commissioner.
  2. Whether the application for correction was barred by limitation or otherwise impermissible at the stage of final decree or execution proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner’s Arguments

  • There is no dispute as to the boundaries and extent of the land; therefore the survey number may be corrected in the plaint schedule and in the decree schedule without objection.
  • If correction is not allowed, the petitioner faces real hardship at the stage of delivery of possession (denial of delivery or delay of sale).
  • Even though the agreement mentioned only one survey number, there is no bar to amending the plaint schedule to add another survey number so long as identity of the land is clear from extent and boundaries.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • While conceding that boundaries and extent tallied, respondents argued that a correction cannot be ordered in the plaint schedule or the decree unless a corresponding correction is first made in the agreement of sale.
  • Relied on authority (Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Radhakrishna Chettiar, Madras High Court) that Section 152 CPC cannot be used to correct errors anterior to the proceedings (i.e., in documents on which suits are brought) and that the remedy in such cases lies by a suit under Section 31 of the Specific Relief Act; further that Section 151 CPC cannot be used to effect such rectification.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahendra C. Mehta and Ors. v. Kousalya Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Hyderabad (Single Judge) When boundaries of land covered by a deed are specific and clear, a wrong mention of survey number is of no consequence because boundaries prevail over extent and survey number. The Court relied on this principle to support the proposition that a mis-description of survey number does not affect identity where boundaries and extent are clear and undisputed.
P. Udayani Devi v. V.V. Rajeswara Prasad, 1995 (2) ALT 2 (DN) Authority relied upon for the principle that mis-description of survey/plot number does not affect identity when the property is otherwise clearly identified. Followed as supporting authority for treating a survey-number mistake as not affecting identity where boundaries and extent are established.
Sheodhyan Singh v. Mussamma Sanicharakver (Supreme Court) The mistake in the plot number should be treated as a mis-description which does not affect the identity of the property sold when identity is well established through plot/boundary particulars. Relied upon to reinforce the view that mistakes in plot/survey numbers do not defeat identity if the true property is otherwise identified by extent and boundaries.
Narkulla Venkayya and Anr. v. Noona Satyavarayana and another (Division Bench) A mistake in entering a survey number (or acreage) due to inadvertence, when the executant was not in possession of the other survey number, can be treated as a mistake and rectified. Used to demonstrate that clerical/inadvertent mistakes in survey numbers in pleadings/judgment/decree can be corrected under Section 152 CPC.
Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Radhakrishna Chettiar, AIR 1948 Mad. 13 (Division Bench) Section 152 CPC is for correcting errors in the proceedings themselves, not for correcting errors anterior to proceedings (e.g., errors in deeds); where a wrong survey number is inserted in the deed (and repeated in plaint/decree) the remedy is a suit under Section 31 Specific Relief Act; Section 151 CPC cannot supply the jurisdiction to rectify such a document. The Court considered and distinguished this authority: it applied the principle that the remedy for some deed-errors is under the Specific Relief Act, but found this case distinguishable because the present matter involved an inadvertent omission and undisputed identity/boundaries rather than a situation lacking sufficient material to show correct boundaries/extent.
Appat Krishna Poduval v. Lakshmi Nathiar and Ors. (Madras High Court) Where there is no dispute as to the identity or boundaries of the property, an application for correction of survey numbers in plaint and decree schedules may be allowed under Section 152 CPC; errors in underlying deeds do not automatically disentitle applicants. The Court followed this decision to permit correction under Section 152 CPC where identity/boundaries are undisputed and the error is corrigible despite similar errors in the assignment deed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from the undisputed factual premise that the agreement of sale had been executed for Ac.0.32 cents within fixed boundaries and that the boundaries and extent in the agreement and plaint matched the physical verification carried out by the Commissioner and the surveyor. The Commissioner, however, observed that the scheduled land lay partly in Survey No. 155/1 and partly in Survey No. 154/2 — an observation not reflected in the written agreement or the plaint schedule.

The Court applied established legal principles that where the identity of land is clear from boundaries and extent, a mis-description or omission of a survey/plot number does not defeat identity; boundaries prevail over a mere wrong or omitted survey number. The Court referred to and relied upon earlier decisions (including the Supreme Court and this High Court) which treat mistakes in plot numbers as mis-descriptions not affecting identity when boundaries are specific and undisputed.

The Court addressed the respondents' reliance on the Madras High Court decision (Ramakrishna Chettiar) which limits Section 152 CPC to correcting errors in proceedings and cautions that where a wrong survey number is inserted in a deed the remedy may be by suit under Section 31 of the Specific Relief Act. The Court distinguished that authority on the ground that in the present case there was not a contested or unsupported claim about boundaries/extent; instead there was an inadvertent omission (not a disputed assertion of a different survey number) and the identity of the land was otherwise established by boundaries and extent.

The Court also relied on authorities (including Narkulla Venkayya and Appat Krishna Poduval) holding that Section 152 CPC empowers the Court to correct inadvertent clerical mistakes in pleadings and decrees where identity or boundaries are not in dispute. On that footing the Court concluded that the parties had omitted to include Survey No. 154/2 through inadvertence, that there was no ambiguity as to the land's identity, and that the lower Court erred in dismissing the correction application — including by wrongly holding it barred by limitation at the stage of final decree proceedings.

The Court further rejected the lower Court's suggestion that the plaintiff needed to file a separate suit merely because the property was in the possession of a third party who purchased the scheduled land during pendency; that conclusion did not stand given the undisputed identity and the nature of the correction sought.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is allowed. The order of the lower Court dismissing IA No. 42/1999 is set aside, and the lower Court is directed to permit the revision petitioner to amend the plaint and to amend the schedule of the decree accordingly. Each party shall bear their own costs.

Implications:

  • The direct and practical effect is that the petitioner is entitled to have the plaint schedule amended to include Survey No. 154/2 (which the Commissioner identified as part of the scheduled land) and the decree schedule to be correspondingly corrected.
  • The Court distinguished authorities that limit the power of Section 152 CPC where identity is not established; here, because boundaries and extent were undisputed and the omission was inadvertent, correction under Section 152 CPC is appropriate.
  • This decision resolves the dispute between the parties as to the propriety of correcting a plaint/decree schedule where identity is clear and the omission was inadvertent; the opinion does not purport to create a new broad precedent beyond applying and distinguishing existing authorities.

Costs: Each party to bear their own costs (as ordered in the decision).

    Cherukuwada Vijaya Laxmi v. Veluri Sitapathi (Died) & Ors.

    1. This revision petition is filed by the decree holder and petitioner in IA No. 42/1999 in O.S. No. 48/1992. She filed the suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale in respect of an extent of Ac.0.32 cents situated in Survey No. 155/1 against defendant Nos.1 to 5.

    2. One of the defendants, who has a share in the property, did not sign the agreement of sale though it was executed on behalf of all the persons. The lower Court, therefore, granted the decree to the extent of the shares of the persons, who signed on the agreement of sale on 17.4.1986.

    3. Subsequently, at the instance of the revision petitioner, a Commissioner was appointed to localise and divide the property by way of excluding the share of the third defendant. The Commissioner during the localisation, identified the property with the help of the surveyor, satisfied with the boundaries, the extent mentioned in the agreement of sale and the plaint. But, the Commissioner in his report mentioned that the schedule land is situated partly in Survey No. 155/1 and partly in Survey No. 154/2. In view of the observation made by the Commissioner, the revision petitioner filed IA No. 42/1999 under Sections 151 to 153 and Order 6, Rule 17 of Code of Civil Procedure praying to pass suitable orders for correcting the plaint schedule and schedule attached to the decree dated 17.4.1986. The lower Court passed the impugned order on 8.11.2002 dismissing the petition. The revision petitioner being aggrieved by the order of the lower Court, preferred this revision petition questioning its validity and legality.

    4. The learned Counsel for the revision petitioner submitted that since there is no dispute regarding the extent and boundaries, there cannot be any objection for ordering correction of the survey number in the plaint schedule and schedule attached to the decree and requested to pass appropriate orders setting aside the order of the lower Court.

    5. The learned Counsel for the respondents while conceding that the boundaries and extent of the land tallied with the boundaries, raised an objection that unless and until a correction is made in the agreement of sale, the corrections cannot be ordered in the plaint schedule and consequentially in the schedule of the decree.

    6. The point for consideration is whether the petitioner is entitled for the relief of correction of the plaint schedule and the schedule attached to the decree as prayed for.

    7. It is an undisputed fact that the agreement of sale was executed for an extent of Ac.0.32 cents situated within fixed boundaries. The boundaries and the extent mentioned in the agreement of sale and in the plaint tallied with the boundaries and the extent on physical verification. In the agreement of sale, the survey number of the land was mentioned as 155/1 but the Commissioner noticed that the land situated within the boundaries, is partly in Survey No. 155/1 and partly in Survey No. 154/2.

    8. The learned Counsel for the revision petitioner submitted that unless and until the correction is ordered in the plaint and schedule of the decree, there is likelihood of the revision petitioner facing a problem at the time of delivery of the property and it is likely to cause hardship to him either due to denial of delivery or delay of sale. He further submitted that though only one survey number was mentioned in the agreement of sale, there is no bar for correction of the schedule of the plaint by adding another survey number so long as there is no dispute regarding identity of the land by its extent and boundaries.

    9. The teamed Counsel for the revision petitioner relied on a judgment of a learned Single Judge of this High Court in Mahendra C. Mehta and Ors. v. Kousalya Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., Hyderabad and Ors. , , wherein, the learned Single Judge observed that, "it is well known that when boundaries of a land covered by a deed are specific and clear wrong mention of the survey number or door number etc., of the property covered by the deed is of no consequence, because boundaries prevail over the extent and survey number mentioned therein." The learned Judge relied on a judgment of this Court in P. Udayani Devi v. V.V.Rajeswara Prasad, 1995 (2) ALT 2 (DN) and rendered a judgment by following a judgment of the Supreme Court in Sheodhyan Singh v. Mussamma Sanicharakver, . The Supreme Court in the above decision held that, "the mistake in the plot number must be treated as a mis-description and which did not effect the identity of the property sold when the identity of the property sold was well established through plot number."

    10. From the above legal position, it is made clear that when the identity of the property is not in dispute and when the boundaries and the extent are tallying with the mis-description of a particular survey number or plot number or non-mentioning of a survey number will not have any effect.

    11. The learned Counsel for the revision petitioner also relied on a judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in Narkulla Venkayya and Anr. v. Noona Satyavarayana and another, , it is observed that

    "a mistake committed by the plaintiffs in entering the correct acreage in relation to a particular survey number, which was incorrectly entered as different survey number due to sheer inadvertence of giving description of the survey number in the gift deed. When admittedly the executant was not in possession of other survey number, it can be treated only as a mistake,"

    12. In the case covered by the above decision, the suit property was once in possession of a woman by name Nagamma and Survey Number 529 was in her possession. As a mistake in this behalf was crept into the plaint schedule, the same was mentioned in the judgment and decree. The Court observed that it was an accidental slip and a clerical mistake and this can be rectified under Section 152 of Code of Civil Procedure. There is nothing which limits the power of the Court under Section 152 of Code of Civil Procedure to correct such errors and mistakes, that arise in the suit. It was further observed by the Bench that in appropriate cases like this, where mistakes have arisen by reason of inadvertence in entering the number in the plaint, the Court has ample power under Section 152 of Code of Civil Procedure to correct such mistakes.

    13. Though the mistake is due to inadvertence of both parties in noticing that the schedule land is situated in two survey numbers and as they were under a bona fide impression that the entire land is situated in Survey No. 155/1, they mentioned the same to that effect. Therefore, there is no scope to draw any other interpretation regarding the intention of the parties in relation to the land involved in the transaction. The survey number, which was noticed by the Commissioner, could not be mentioned in the plaint schedule since it was not mentioned in the agreement of sale. Since it is an undisputed fact that the Survey No. 154/2 is also part of the schedule land, it can be safely concluded that the parties failed to mention the said number due to inadvertence. Therefore, the request of the revision petitioner can be considered favourably.

    14. The learned Counsel for the respondents drew the attention of this Court to a judgment of Madras High Court in Ramakrishna Chettiar v. Radhakrishna Chettiar, AIR (35) 1948 Mad. 13, wherein, the Division Bench of the Madras High Court while considering the scope of Section 152 of Code of Civil Procedure observed as follows:

    " Section 152 of Code of Civil Procedure is for the purpose of correcting errors and directly involved in the proceedings themselves and not for correcting errors which are anterior to the proceedings particularly in documents upon which suits are brought. Hence, where there is a mutual mistake in the insertion of a wrong survey number in the mortgage deed and the error is repeated in the plaint and the decree, the Court cannot rectify the error under Section 152 as it is not a clerical or of arithmetical error or an accidental slip or omission. The remedy lies by way of suit under Section 31 of Specific Relief Act. It was also observed by the Madras High Court that Section 151 also cannot be invoked for correcting the mistake in the mortgage deed because Section 151 does not confer any jurisdiction upon the Court to merely declare that nothing shall limit or otherwise affect the Court's inherent power and the Court cannot be set to possess inherent power to make an order for rectification of a document when a remedy by way of suit under Section 31 of Specific Relief Act, is provided."

    15. In the case covered by the above decision, the survey number of the and was wrongly mentioned, whereas in the case on hand, there was an inadvertent omission of including another survey number in respect of the same extent of land covered by the schedule of agreement of sale. Though, there is no dispute regarding the number laid down by the Madras High Court, a wrong survey number cannot be corrected when there is no sufficient material to show that the boundaries and the extents are correct. But, since there is no dispute regarding the boundaries and the extent of the land and as there was only an inadvertent omission of adding another survey number in schedule, this Court can permit the plaintiff to correct the schedule of the plaint by adding Survey No. 154/2. Consequentially to correct the schedule of the decree, the decision of the Madras High Court was distinguished through a judgment of the same High Court in Appat Krishna Poduval v. Lakshmi Nathiar and Ors., , wherein the Madras High Court while distinguishing the number laid down by the same Court in the earlier decision held as follows:

    "Where an application is filed for correction of an error as regards the survey numbers of an item of property in the plaint schedule and decree schedule and there is no dispute as regards the identity of the property or boundaries to it, the amendment may be allowed under Section 152 of Code of Civil Procedure. The fact that the assignment deed of the property also has the same errors cannot disentitle the applicants to have the errors set right if they are entitled to it under the Code. So also, the amendment cannot be refused on the ground that the decree sought to be amended is barred by limitation."

    16. In the light of the above legal position, it is noticed that the lower Court went wrong in holding that the application is barred by limitation, when it was at the stage of final decree proceedings and when the E.P. was not filed for delivery of the property. The other observation of the lower Court was that the property was in possession of a third party, who purchased the schedule land, during the pendency of the proceedings. Therefore, the plaintiff has to file a separate suit to work out his rights, does not hold good.

    17. In the light of the above discussion, I hold that the order of the lower Court cannot sustain and I find sufficient force in the grounds of revision. The revision petition is accordingly allowed. The lower Court is directed to permit the revision petitioner to amend the plaint and consequently the Court shall direct that the schedule of the decree be suitably amended. Each party do bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Cherukuwada Vijaya Laxmi v. Veluri Sitapathi (Died) & Ors.
    (Dec 11, 2003)