AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 2 of the Rules read with Section 245 of the A.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 (the Act
  • Constitution of India, the Constituent Assembly (Legislative) Rules of Procedure
  • Article 118(2) of the Constitution. These Rules of Procedure
  • ARTICLE 118 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 245 read with Rules 2, 3, 6 and 7 of the Rules.
  • 1989. Rule 198 of the Rules of Procedure
  • Rules 3, 6 and 7 read with Section 245(1)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 245,
  • provisions of Section 245(1)
  • Rules. Rule 3
  • sub-rule (2),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 2 of the Rules read with Section 245 of the A.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 (the Act
  • Constitution of India, the Constituent Assembly (Legislative) Rules of Procedure
  • Article 118(2) of the Constitution. These Rules of Procedure
  • ARTICLE 118 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 245 read with Rules 2, 3, 6 and 7 of the Rules.
  • 1989. Rule 198 of the Rules of Procedure
  • Rules 3, 6 and 7 read with Section 245(1)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 245,
  • provisions of Section 245(1)
  • Rules. Rule 3
  • sub-rule (2),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the elected President of Mandal Parishad, Kulcharam. Respondents 3 to 7 served a notice under Rule 2 read with Section 245 of the A.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, in Form No. II together with a copy of a resolution expressing want of confidence; that notice was served on the second respondent on 22-10-1999. Pursuant to Rule 3, the second respondent (the Revenue Divisional Officer) issued notices in Form No. V giving members notice of a meeting to consider the no-confidence motion, scheduling it for 17-11-1999 and providing the prescribed notice period. On 27-10-1999 respondents 3 to 7 sent a joint letter to the second respondent stating they had changed their mind and desired that the petitioner should continue as President. The petitioner approached this Court just two days before the scheduled meeting (i.e., shortly before 17-11-1999), seeking relief on the ground that the second respondent was convening the meeting without making any enquiry into the alleged change of intention and that doing so was illegal and arbitrary. The matter concerns the interpretation and application of Section 245 of the Act and the Rules (in particular Rules 2, 3, 6 and 7) governing no-confidence motions and their lapse or withdrawal. The writ petition was ultimately dismissed by the Court; the Court also ordered no costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a notice of intention to move a motion expressing want of confidence (served under Section 245 and Rule 2) can be withdrawn other than by lapse under the conditions specified in the Rules (specifically Rule 7).
  2. Whether the Court should issue a writ of mandamus directing the Revenue Divisional Officer not to convene or proceed with the meeting scheduled to consider the no-confidence motion, in light of a subsequent non-statutory representation by the signatories withdrawing their intention.
  3. How the statutory scheme in Section 245 read with the Rules (Rules 2, 3, 6 and 7) governs the procedure for convening meetings, quorum requirements and the circumstances in which a notice of no confidence will lapse.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (through Sri V. Ravi Kiran Rao, learned counsel) argued that the respondents who had given the notice of no-confidence had subsequently changed their mind and sent a joint letter withdrawing that intention, and therefore the meeting should not proceed.
  • The petitioner relied on an excerpt from "Practice and Procedure of Parliament" by M.N. Kaul and S.L. Shakdher (III Edition 1986) suggesting that a no-confidence notice can be withdrawn by the members concerned by sending letters of withdrawal prior to the item being taken up.
  • Implicit in the petitioner's approach was a request for the Court to accept that the non-statutory joint representation withdrawing the motion should prevent the Revenue Divisional Officer from convening or proceeding with the meeting, and to grant relief by way of a writ (including a mandamus) restraining the meeting or declaring the notice lapsed.

Respondents' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the statutory scheme and the Rules governing no-confidence motions under the A.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1994. The key elements of the Court's reasoning are summarized below:

  1. Statutory and regulatory framework: Section 245 of the Act requires that a motion expressing want of confidence in the President of the Mandal Parishad be by written notice in the prescribed form, and that the competent authority (the Government and its officers) act on such notice in accordance with Rules made under the Act (Rules made under Section 268 read with Section 245(1) and (2)).
  2. Mandatory procedural requirements: The Court identified Rules 3, 6 and 7 (read with Section 245(1) and (2)) as containing mandatory requirements:
    • Rule 3 requires the Revenue Divisional Officer, after receiving notice in Form No. II, to give every member notice in Form No. V of not less than 15 clear days and to convene a meeting within 30 days after receipt of the Form No. II notice.
    • Rule 6 (as referenced) provides the quorum requirement (two-thirds of total members) which the Revenue Divisional Officer must consider on the day of the meeting.
    • Rule 7 provides that if within one hour after the appointed time there is no quorum, the meeting shall stand dissolved and the notice given under Rule 2 shall lapse.
    The Court treated these provisions as mandatory; the notice of intention to move no confidence can lapse only in the specific circumstance described in Rule 7 (i.e., dissolution for want of quorum within one hour).
  3. Effect of a subsequent non-statutory withdrawal: The Court considered the petitioner's reliance on parliamentary practice authorities (M.N. Kaul & S.L. Shakdher and Erskine May) which discuss withdrawal of motions in parliamentary contexts. The Court observed:
    • The parliamentary excerpt from Kaul & Shakdher indicates that notice of a no-confidence motion can be withdrawn by the signatories by sending letters of withdrawal before the item is taken up, and in such a case the item is not brought before the House. However, the Court read the same passage as actually indicating that the meeting may still be convened but the item will not be mentioned.
    • Rule 198 of the Lok Sabha Rules (cited in the opinion) and Erskine May show that in parliamentary practice a motion cannot be withdrawn except by leave of the House (and subject to other procedural constraints). The Court emphasized that such practice does not establish a rule that permits unilateral withdrawal of a statutory notice in the present context.
    Based on this, the Court concluded that parliamentary practice (even if taken as a convention) does not support the petitioner's position that a non-statutory representation or letter withdrawing the motion can override the statutory regime under the Act and Rules.
  4. Democratic and legal considerations: The Court highlighted that the power to remove an elected person by a no-confidence motion is an "extraordinary power" and that the law requires strict application of mandatory procedural requirements to protect the rights of elected persons. Hence, neither expressing no confidence nor expressing confidence in an elected person can be done outside the prescribed statutory and rule-bound process.
  5. Conclusion of analysis: The Court held that once notice of intention is served under Section 245(1), the process prescribed by the Rules must be followed and the notice can only lapse in accordance with Rule 7. There is no other method of withdrawing the notice under the statutory scheme; accordingly, the petitioner's request for relief (including a writ of mandamus preventing the meeting) would be contrary to the Act and the Rules and could not be granted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The Court also directed that there be no costs.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The notice of intention to move a no-confidence motion served under Section 245 and Rule 2 remains subject to the mandatory procedural requirements of the Act and Rules (in particular Rules 3, 6 and 7), and cannot be treated as withdrawn by a separate, non-statutory joint representation by the signatories.
  • The only circumstance in which the notice will lapse under the Rules is if, on the appointed date, the meeting is convened and within one hour there is no quorum, in which event the meeting stands dissolved and the notice lapses (Rule 7).
  • The Court declined to issue a writ of mandamus to restrain the convening or proceeding of the meeting on the basis of the respondents' non-statutory representation; the statutory process must be followed.
  • No broader precedent was announced beyond the Court's interpretation and application of the statute and rules in this case; the Court did not purport to create or modify law beyond the matter before it and specifically ordered no costs.

    P. Ramachandraiah v. Government Of A.P, Panchayat Raj, Secretariat, Hyderabad And Others

    1. The petitioner is the elected President of Mandal Parishad, Kulcharam, approached this Court in a very peculiar circumstance. The respondents 3 to 7 served notice under Rule 2 of the Rules read with Section 245 of the A.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 (‘the Act’ for brevity). These Rules, which govern the passing of No Confidence Motions, are made by the Government under Section 268 read with sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 245 of the Act. Be that as it may, the notice in Form No. II, along with a copy of the resolution, expressing want of confidence was served on the second respondent on 22-10-1999. After receiving the same, as required under Rule 3, the second respondent sent notices in Form No. V, enclosing a copy of the proposed resolution, informing the respondents 3 to 7 and other members of the Mandal Parishad that a meeting shall be held on 17-11-1999 for considering the Motion of No Confidence given by the respondents 3 to 7. It is now alleged that on 27-10-1999 itself the respondents 3 to 7 sent a letter/joint representation to the second respondent informing that they have changed their mind and it is their desire that the petitioner should alone continue as President of Mandal Parishad.

    2. After the respondents 3 to 7 sent joint/common representation to the second respondent the petitioner has approached this Court just two days before the scheduled meeting on 17-11-1999, complaining that the second respondent without causing any enquiry and without satisfying with regard to the intention of the members, is proceeding to convene the meeting on 17-11-1999. This is complained as illegal and arbitrary. Section 245 of the Act says that a motion expressing want of confidence in the President of the Mandal Parishad shall be by giving written notice of intention to move the motion in the form as prescribed, and the competent authority is required to act on such notice in accordance with the Rules prescribed under the Act. If the motion is carried with the support of not less than ⅔rd of the total members, the Government shall, thereupon, by notification, remove the President from the Office. The method and manner of conducting a meeting by the Officer concerned, in this case Revenue Divisional Officer, is prescribed by the Rules. Rule 3 is relevant and it states that after receiving notice of intention in Form No. II, the Revenue Divisional Officer shall give the every member the notice in Form No. V, of not less than 15 clear days within a period of 30 days after receipt of the notice in Form No. II and convene a meeting for considering the motion of No Confidence. Rule 7 is all the more important. It reads as follows:

    “If within one hour after the time appointed for the meeting, there is no quorum, the meeting shall stand dissolved and the notice given under Rule 2 shall lapse.”

    3. Therefore, the only event when a notice issued under Rule 2 shall lapse is, when within one hour after convening the meeting on the specified date there is no quorum, the meeting gets dissolved and notice of No Confidence shall lapse. These rules require the Revenue Divisional Officer to convene a meeting within 30 days after receiving the notice of intention under Rule 2 and giving a notice of clear 15 days before the meeting is convened. The other mandatory requirement is that the Revenue Divisional Officer is under obligation to wait at least for one hour on the specified date to come to the conclusion that there is no quorum namely ⅔rd of total number of members as per Rule 6. In such event alone the notice of intention to move no confidence will lapse. To this extent, Rules 3, 6 and 7 read with Section 245(1) and (2) are mandatory requirements. Therefore, the prayer, as asked for, would be contrary to the provisions of the Act as well as the Rules. Indeed, such a Writ of Mandamus shall not issue from this Court.

    4. If the respondents 3 to 7 have changed their mind, nothing prevents them or nobody comes in their way to maintain ‘their change of mind’ even on the date of meeting on 17-11-1999. However, Sri. V. Ravi Kiran Rao, learned Counsel for the Petitioner has brought to my notice the following excerpt from “Practice and Procedure of Parliament” by M.N Kaul and S.L Shakdher (III Edition 1986):

    “Notice of no-confidence motion can also be withdrawn by the members concerned by sending letters of withdrawal signed by all the signatories to the notice before the item is taken up in the House. In that case the item is not mentioned in or brought before, the House.”

    5. On the basis of this, the learned Counsel would desire this Court to come to the same conclusion that the process of expressing no confidence in the elected President can always be withdrawn.

    6. The learned Authors M.N Kaul and S.L Shakdher relying on the Lok Sabha Debates of 1963, commented on a situation when notice of no confidence can be withdrawn by the members concerned by sending letters of withdrawal. Even this statement of Parliamentary Practice is also against the petitioner because, according to the learned authors, the Meeting will nevertheless be convened, but the agenda item concerning expressing No Confidence is not mentioned or called for consideration of the House. Therefore, this Parliamentary Practice, which is neither supported by a ruling of a Speaker nor any decided case, even if it is taken as a convention, does not support the petitioner.

    7. Article 118 of the Constitution of India empowers the Parliament to make rules for regulating its procedure and regulating the conduct of the business. After inauguration of the Constitution of India, the Constituent Assembly (Legislative) Rules of Procedure and conduct of business were modified and adopted by the Speaker of Lok Sabha in exercise of powers under Article 118(2) of the Constitution. These Rules of Procedure were amended from time to time. In 1989 the VIII Lok Sabha considered all the amendments and new Rules of Procedure were brought out in December, 1989. Rule 198 of the Rules of Procedure which deals with Motion of No Confidence of Council of Ministers does not provide that when once leave is granted by the House to a member to make the Motion of No Confidence, the same motion can be withdrawn without putting it to the house either to amend the motion or to pass the motion as moved. Rule 198 is as follows:

    “Motion of No Confidence in Council of Ministers and Statement by Minister who has Resigned.

    198(1) A motion expressing want of confidence in the Council of Ministers may be made subject to the following restrictions, namely—

    (a) Leave to make the motion shall be asked for by the member when called by the Speaker;

    (b) The member asking for leave shall be 10.00 hours on that day give to the Secretary-General a written notice of the motion which he proposes to move:

    Provided that notices, received after 10.00 hours shall be deemed to have been received at 10.00 hours on the next day on which the House sits.

    (2) If the Speaker of the opinion that the motion is in order, he shall read the motion to the House and shall request those members who are in favour of leave being granted to rise in their places, and if not less than fifty members rise accordingly, the Speaker shall declare that leave is granted and that the motion will be taken up on such day, not being more than ten days from the date on which the leave is asked or as he may appoint. If less than fifty members rise, the Speaker shall inform the member that he has not the leave the House.

    (3) If leave is granted under sub-rule (2), the Speaker may after considering the state of business in the House, allot a day or days or part of a day for the discussion of the motion.

    (4) The Speaker shall, at the appointed hour on the allotted day or the last of the allotted days, as the case may be forthwith put every question necessary to determine the decision of the House on the motion.

    (5) The Speaker may, if he thinks fit, prescribe a time limit for speeches.”

    8. Therefore, the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha do not permit a Motion of No Confidence to be withdrawn even before the same is put to vote in the House. In view of this, I am not able to accept the contention of the learned Counsel based on the passage from ‘Practice and Procedure of Parliament’ by M.N Kaul and S.L Shakdher (III Edition 1986).

    9. It is also useful to refer to ‘Treatise on Parliamentary Practice’ by Erskine May, Twenty-second edition, 1997 (p. 339)—

    Withdrawal of Motions

    “A member who has made a motion can withdraw it only by leave of the House, granted without any negative voice. This leave is signified, not upon question but by the Speaker taking the pleasure of the House. He asks, ‘Is it your pleasure that the motion be withdrawn?’ If no one desists, the Speaker says ‘Motion by leave withdrawn’. However, if there is any objection or if a Member rises to continue the debate, the Speaker must put the question at the end of the debate as, even if a dissentient Member no longer objects, the motion can no longer be withdrawn. An amendment can be withdrawn in the same way, but neither a motion nor an amendment can be withdrawn except by the Member who moved it. It is, however, the practice for a member of the Government to withdraw a motion in the absence of the Member (also a member of the Government), who moved it. Occasionally a motion or amendment is, by leave, withdrawn, and another motion or amendment substituted, in order to meet the views of the House, as expressed in debate. This course can be taken only with the general assent of the House. Where an amendment has been proposed to a question, the original motion cannot be withdrawn until the amendment has been first disposed of by being agreed to, withdrawn or negatived, since the question on the amendment stands before the main question.”

    (emphasis supplied)

    10. In view of the authority on Parliament Practice as well as the binding statutory Rules, it has to be concluded that when once notice of intention of no confidence is served under sub-section (1) of Section 245, the same has to undergo the process as per the provisions of the Rules and the same can only be deemed to have lapsed when the conditions as mentioned in Rule 7 are satisfied. There is no other method of withdrawing the notice of no confidence. In this case, as already noticed, the provisions of Section 245(1) and (2) clearly state that No Confidence in the President can be expressed only in accordance with the provisions under Section 245 read with Rules 2, 3, 6 and 7 of the Rules. There cannot be any other method or manner of either expressing No Confidence or withdrawing intention of Motion of No Confidence. In a democratic polity, the power of the people to recall the elected representatives again through elected representatives by expressing Motion or No Confidence is an extraordinary power coupled with a duty. Therefore, the Law requires that an elected person can not be removed from the office unless the mandatory requirements of Law are strictly applied. The same principle equally applies to a case where the same members, who gave intention of Motion of No Confidence, again changed their mind and sent a common non-statutory representation to the concerned Officer expressing their confidence in the elected President. Either expressing No Confidence or expressing confidence in the elected person should be strictly in accordance with the Act and Rules. Therefore, the submission made by the learned Counsel for the petitioner is liable to be rejected.

    11. In the result, for the above reasons, the writ petition is dismissed.

    12. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Ramachandraiah v. Government Of A.P, Panchayat Raj, Secretariat, Hyderabad And Others
    (Nov 16, 1999)