AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8-A (1) of the C.S.T Act (identical to Rule 6(1)(i)
  • Rule 6(1)(1) of the A.P General Sales Tax Rules
  • Section 8-A(1) of the Central Sales Tax Act.6.
  • Section 8(2-A) of the Central Sales Tax Act.
  • SECTION 8 CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT
  • SECTION 14 CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT
  • Section 8-A(1)(a) of the Central Act
  • Section 8-A(1) of the Central Act,
  • Section 5(c) of the CST Act, 1956.
  • Rule 6(1)(i) of the APGST Rules.
  • Section 15(c) of the C.S.T Act.
  • Section 8-A(1)(a) of CST Act
  • Rule 6(1)(i) of APGST Rules.
  • Sec. 15(c) of the C.S.T Act
  • clause (1) of Rule 6(1).
  • Central Sales Act
  • Section 15(c)
  • Rule 6(1)(i)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 8-A (1) of the C.S.T Act (identical to Rule 6(1)(i)
  • Rule 6(1)(1) of the A.P General Sales Tax Rules
  • Section 8-A(1) of the Central Sales Tax Act.6.
  • Section 8(2-A) of the Central Sales Tax Act.
  • SECTION 8 CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT
  • SECTION 14 CENTRAL SALES TAX ACT
  • Section 8-A(1)(a) of the Central Act
  • Section 8-A(1) of the Central Act,
  • Section 5(c) of the CST Act, 1956.
  • Rule 6(1)(i) of the APGST Rules.
  • Section 15(c) of the C.S.T Act.
  • Section 8-A(1)(a) of CST Act
  • Rule 6(1)(i) of APGST Rules.
  • Sec. 15(c) of the C.S.T Act
  • clause (1) of Rule 6(1).
  • Central Sales Act
  • Section 15(c)
  • Rule 6(1)(i)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment delivered by P. Venkatarama Reddi, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitions were filed by rice millers challenging assessment orders passed by the first respondent (assessing authority) for the year 1997–98. The petitioners contended that the deduction for the tax element permissible under Rule 6(1)(i) of the A.P. General Sales Tax Rules was not correctly given because the assessing authority computed deductions in accordance with a Circular issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (the second respondent) (Roc. No. ATT (1)/1950/98 dated 24‑2‑1998). The assessing authority applied the Commissioner's Circular in computing the tax deduction on the sale turnover of rice, reducing the tax attributable to rice by the tax on corresponding paddy (in light of Explanation III to the Third Schedule). The petitioners challenged this methodology.

The Court noted that ordinarily it would not examine the correctness of assessment orders in writ jurisdiction and would dismiss the petitions as premature, but it proceeded to consider the matter because the Commissioner's Circular was binding on assessing officers and likely to affect future assessments widely. The Court ultimately set aside the impugned assessment orders to the extent they relied on the Circular and directed fresh assessments without reference to the Circular. The writ petitions were allowed and no costs were awarded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the formula laid down in Rule 6(1)(i) of the A.P. General Sales Tax Rules has been correctly applied by the assessing authority in the assessment orders under challenge.
  2. Whether the Commissioner's Circular dated 24‑2‑1998 (Roc. No. ATT (1)/1950/98), which directs that the tax payable on sales of rice should be the net tax after providing rebate for tax on paddy (in light of Explanation III to the Third Schedule), is consistent with and permissible under Rule 6(1)(i) (i.e., whether the Circular is contrary to the formula in the Rule).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The formula in Rule 6(1)(i) must be worked out without importing Explanation III to the Third Schedule into the deduction computation.
  • The reduction or rebate attributable to the tax on paddy should not enter into the computation of the deductible amount under Rule 6(1)(i); the petitioners suggested an alternative method of computation (the opinion states the petitioners advanced a suggested method, but does not set out that method in detail).

Respondents' Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The Commissioner issued a Circular directing assessing officers to calculate the tax on rice as the net tax after giving rebate for tax levied on paddy (i.e., to work out deduction on the basis of net tax payable on rice after rebate for corresponding paddy tax).
  • Assessing officers applied the Circular in the assessments under challenge; in at least one assessment, the assessing officer treated the sale price as exclusive of tax and applied the formula after deducting the purchase value of corresponding paddy, thereby reducing the tax element attributable to rice before applying Rule 6(1)(i).
  • The respondents did not contend that the expression "rate of tax" for rice meant anything other than the standard 4% rate specified in the Third Schedule (the Court records that it is not the respondents' stand that the rate is other than 4%).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sri Ganesh Trading Company v. The State of A.P. (1988 6 APSTJ 258) Interpreting the expression "rate of tax" (in context of Sec. 8(2)(a)): the statutory rate applicable to rice inside the State is 4% and Explanation III does not alter the rate; it only provides a concession/rebate. The Court relied on this decision to support the view that "rate of tax" must be read as the statutory rate (4%) and that Explanation III does not change the rate for purposes of the formula; the Commissioner's Circular could not be reconciled with this interpretation.
Tribunal decision in T.A. No. 838/96 (referenced as applying the view in Sri Ganesh Trading Company) Applied the principle that rebate under Section 15(c) (Explanation III analog) should not be excluded when giving deduction for tax element under Section 8-A(1) / Rule 6(1)(i); affirmed the interpretation in Ganesh Trading. The Court noted that the Tribunal followed Ganesh Trading and rejected contentions that the rebate should be excluded in computing the deduction, indicating a consistent line of tribunal authority contrary to the Commissioner's Circular.
State of A.P. v. Lakshminarayana Gupta (1995 21 APSTJ 21) Construction of the proviso to Section 8-A(1)(a) of the Central Sales Tax Act (identical to proviso to Rule 6(1)(i)): the formula's object is to avoid tax on tax; deduction under the formula is available only if the tax forms part of the sale price, and the burden to show that the turnover includes the tax is on the dealer. The Court relied on this reasoning to hold that the deduction under Rule 6(1)(i) is available only if the dealer shows the tax formed part of the sale price; this supported the conclusion that the Commissioner's Circular (which effectively changed how the formula was applied) was inconsistent with the statutory rule and established precedents.
Rallie's India Ltd. v. State of A.P. (53 STC 267) Principle: The formula in Section 8-A(1) applies only where the Central Sales Tax is shown to have been collected by the dealer and forms part of the aggregate sale price; tax should not be deducted where it was not collected, and the dealer is best placed to show whether tax was collected. The Court cited this authority to emphasise that the burden lies on the dealer to prove that the sale price included the tax component and to support the proposition that Rule 6(1)(i) requires an evidential foundation before the formula-based deduction can be allowed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court set out the statutory and regulatory framework before analysing the dispute. It observed:

  • Paddy and rice are declared goods and, under the A.P. GST and the Third Schedule, are taxable at a single point at rates not exceeding 4%, with paddy taxable at the first purchase point and rice at the first sale point. To avoid double taxation, Explanation III to the Third Schedule provides that where tax has been levied on paddy, the tax leviable on rice procured out of that paddy shall be reduced by the tax levied on such paddy.
  • Rule 6(1)(i) of the A.P. GST Rules contains a formula to determine the deductible tax element from the aggregate sale prices (including Sales Tax) so as to avoid tax on tax. The formula produces the amount of tax to be excluded from turnover for taxation purposes; the proviso states that no deduction shall be made under the formula if the tax collected by the registered dealer has been otherwise deducted from aggregate sale prices.
  • The Commissioner's Circular directed that the deduction be calculated on the basis of the net tax payable on rice after giving rebate for tax paid on the corresponding paddy (i.e., effectively reducing the "rate of tax" in computation by the amount of paddy tax before applying the formula).
  • Although the Commissioner is empowered under Section 42‑A to issue directions to subordinate officers, such directions must be consistent with the Act and the Rules. The Court analysed whether the Circular was consistent with Rule 6(1)(i).
  • The assessing authority, following the Circular, deducted the purchase value of corresponding paddy from the sale value of rice and then applied the Rule 6(1)(i) formula; in at least one assessment the assessing officer treated the sale price as exclusive of tax.
  • The Court held that the Commissioner's Circular "flies in the face" of the plain language and formula of Rule 6(1)(i). The formula contemplates the statutory "rate of tax" (4% for rice) being applied in the computation; it does not contemplate first reducing the tax attributable to rice by the tax levied on paddy before applying the formula. To reconcile the Circular with the Rule would require an artificial or strained construction of the phrase "rate of tax" to mean the net tax after rebate — an interpretation the Court rejected, noting that respondents did not assert that the "rate of tax" was anything other than 4%.
  • The Court relied on existing authorities (Sri Ganesh Trading Company, the Tribunal decision, Lakshminarayana Gupta and Rallie's India Ltd.) which establish that (a) the statutory rate remains unaffected by Explanation III, which only grants a concession; (b) the formula for avoiding tax on tax applies only where the tax element forms part of the sale price; and (c) the burden is on the dealer to show that the tax was collected and included in turnover.
  • Accordingly, the Court concluded that the Commissioner's Circular was inconsistent with Rule 6(1)(i) and could not control or override the plain language of the Rule. The Court observed that while the Circular may rest on a rational policy basis (i.e., it arguably gives a better practical effect to the Rule's object of avoiding tax on tax by measuring the actual net tax payable on rice), the Circular was legally untenable in light of the Rule's specific language and existing judicial authorities. The Court stated that any change to give effect to the Circular's approach should be made by the Legislature or the rule‑making authority through amendment.
  • Because the impugned assessments were made in reliance on the Commissioner's Circular and the method of computing the deduction under Rule 6(1)(i) was based on an incorrect understanding, the Court set aside those assessments and directed the assessing authorities to make fresh assessments without reference to the Circular and in light of the Court's observations. The Court declined to adjudicate a separate point about deduction for rural development cess, noting an effective alternative remedy for that issue.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court held that the Commissioner's Circular dated 24‑2‑1998 is contrary to Rule 6(1)(i) of the A.P. General Sales Tax Rules and therefore cannot be applied in the manner done by the assessing authorities. Consequently, the impugned assessment orders are set aside insofar as they arrived at the deductible amount under Rule 6(1)(i) by reference to the Commissioner's Circular, and the assessing authorities are directed to make fresh assessments without reference to that Circular and in accordance with the observations of the Court. The writ petitions were allowed and no costs were awarded.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the specific assessment orders for 1997–98 that applied the Commissioner's Circular for computing deduction under Rule 6(1)(i) are set aside and remitted for fresh assessment consistent with the Rule and judicial precedents; petitioners obtain relief on that ground.
  • Administrative consequence: assessing authorities must not apply the Commissioner's Circular insofar as it departs from the formula in Rule 6(1)(i); instead, they must apply the Rule's formula (using the statutory "rate of tax" as contemplated) and may, where appropriate, hold enquiries to determine whether the tax element was included in sale prices (the burden to show inclusion rests on the dealer).
  • Wider legal consequence: the Court affirmed existing interpretations that the statutory rate remains the rate for purposes of the formula and that Explanation III grants a concession but does not alter the statutory "rate of tax." The Court observed that if a different approach is desired (to compute deductions on the basis of net tax after rebate), it is for the Legislature or the rule‑making authority to amend the Rule; the Court itself declined to adopt the Circular's construction as a matter of law.
  • Other issues: the Court declined to decide the petitioners' contention about rural development cess, noting the availability of alternative remedies for that question.

No additional factual or legal information has been added beyond what appears in the opinion summarized above.

    Sri Laxmiganapathi Enterprises, Huzurnagar And Others v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kodad And Others

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    P. Venkatarama Reddi, J.:— In these writ petitions, the petitioners who are rice millers question the legality of the assessment orders passed by the first respondent for the year 1997-98 on the ground that the deduction of tax to the extent permissible under Rule 6(1)(1) of the A.P General Sales Tax Rules has not been given based on the Circular issued by the Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, the 2nd respondent herein in Roc. No. ATT (1)/1950/98, dated 24-2-1998.

    2. Paddy and rice are declared goods. Declared goods are specified in Section 14 of Central Sales Tax Act to be goods of special importance in inter-State Trade and Commerce. The declared goods are chargeable to tax under Section 6 of APGST Act read with III Schedule at single point and at a rate not exceeding 4%. Paddy is taxable at 4% at the first purchase 11 point whereas rice is taxable at the point of first sale at 4%. In order to avoid the contingency of both paddy and corresponding rice being subjected to tax, the Legislature introduced Explanation (III) to III Schedule in tune with Section 15(c) of the C.S.T Act. The said Explanation reads as follows:

    “Explanation III:— For the purpose of items 21 and 22, where a tax has been levied under this Act in respect of the sale or purchase inside the State of any paddy, the tax leviable on rice procured out of such paddy shall be reduced by the amount of tax levied on such paddy.”

    3. To illustrate the application of the Explanation if the sale value of rice is Rs. 5,000/- and the purchase value of paddy from which rice is derived is Rs. 4,000/-, the actual rate of tax payable would be Rs. 40/- i.e, 0.8%. This is the net amount of tax payable, though if the general rate of 4% is applied, the tax would have been Rs. 200/-. Sales-tax is leviable on the net turnover of the dealer which, broadly speaking, is nothing but an aggregate of sale prices of taxable goods. Normally and in the absence of the stipulations to the contrary, the sale price is made up of tax element also. Whatever is charged by the seller from the buyer in the form of tax or other pre-sale expenses would be in the nature of consideration for the sale of goods and accordingly enters into the sale price and it constitutes the turnover of a dealer. However, the Act and the Rules provide for certain deductions and exemptions in arriving at the net turnover of a dealer which is ultimately subjected to tax at the prescribed rate. Rule 6(1)(i) of the APGST Rules is one such Rule which provides for certain deductions “in determining the net turnover” of a dealer.

    4. The Rule was introduced in 1995 after the definition of ‘turnover’ was changed by APGST (Amendment) Act No. 22 of 1995 with the object of excluding the tax on tax. The amount collected towards tax is excludable from ‘turnover’. In other words, if the sale price is inclusive of tax, the amount representing the tax shall be deducted from the sale price and the tax should be levied on the balance. If the tax passed on to the buyer is separately shown or otherwise deducted, no tax should be leviable thereon. In order to give effect to the principle that there should be no tax on tax, a formula has been set out in clause (1) of Rule 6(1). The relevant portion of the rule reads as under:

    “(1) In determining the net turnover of a dealer the following deduction shall be made from the aggregate of the sale prices, including Sales Tax, namely:—

    The amount arrived at by applying the following formula:—

    Rate of tax X aggregate of sale prices

    100 + rate of tax.

    “Provided that no deduction on the basis of the above formula shall be made if the amount by way of tax collected by a registered dealer, in accordance with the provisions of this Act, has been otherwise deducted from the aggregate of sale prices.”

    5. It may be noted that the said rule is exactly similar to Section 8-A(1) of the Central Sales Tax Act.

    6. Whether the formula laid down in the Rule has been correctly applied by the assessing authority and whether the Commissioner's Circular goes contrary to the said rule is the question that falls for consideration. The material portion of the Commissioner's Circular dated 24-2-1998 is extracted below:

    “It is decided that the tax payable on sales of rice is the net tax payable after providing rebate towards the tax on paddy as provided in the Explanation-Ill to the Third Schedule of APGST Act and also as provided under Section 5(c) of the CST Act, 1956. In all paddy and rice cases, the deduction towards tax component on rice will be worked out on the basis of the net tax payable on sales of rice after the rebate is given on the basis of tax paid on corresponding purchase of paddy consumed.”

    7. Under Section 42-A of the APGST Act, the Commissioner is empowered to issue orders, instructions and directions not inconsistent with the provisions of the Act or the Rules made thereunder to his Subordinate Officers for the proper administration of the Act and such Officers are bound to comply with them.

    8. It is not in dispute that the tax deduction vis-a-vis the turnover of rice was worked out in the light of the Circular. Taking the figures in Writ Petition No. 7690 of 1999, let us explain how the Assessing Officer arrived at the figure qualifying for deduction towards the tax component. The sale value of rice is mentioned at Rs. 3,19,71,580/-. From this purchase value of corresponding paddy to the extent of Rs. 2,63,08,760/- has been deducted. After such deduction an amount of Rs. 56,62,820/- has been arrived at. It is with reference to this, the said formula has been applied. The element of tax has thus been worked out at Rs. 2,17,800/-. It may be noted that the formula was applied on the basis that the sale price was exclusive of tax, as observed by the Assessing Officer himself. The above method of quantifying the deduction under Rule 6(1)(i) is on the basis that the assessing authority imported Explanation III to Third Schedule into the process of computation. In accordance with the Circular issued by the Commissioner, the assessing authority did not apply the standard rate of 4% on the sale value of rice, but he proceeded to arrive at the figure by reducing the tax attributable to paddy.

    9. According to the learned Counsel for the petitioners, the formula under Rule 6(1)(i) has to be worked out without projecting the Explanation III to Third Schedule. The reduction or rebate towards paddy tax shall not enter into the computation of deductible amount towards tax element according to the petitioners. The petitioners therefore suggest the following method of computation.

    10. Before proceeding to consider the crucial issue, let us make it clear that in the normal course, we would not have gone into the question of correctness of the assessment orders and we would have rejected the writ petitions in limini relegating the petitioners to alternative remedies provided under the Act. But, this is a case where the assessing authority has relied on the Commissioner's Circular which was binding on him. So long as the Commissioner's Circular remains in force, quite probably, the future assessments will also be made in accordance with the said Circular. The resultant position would be that uncertainty will loom large and illegality will be perpetuated. We have therefore thought it expedient to consider the question of legality of the Commissioner's Circular and direct review of assessments in the light of the view expressed by us.

    11. Taking up then the issue of legality of the Commissioner's Circular, we are of the considered view that the Circular flies in the face of Rule 6(1)(i) of the APGST Rules. We are of the view that within the framework of the Rule, it is not possible to give effect to the Circular. What is clarified by the Commissioner goes contrary to what is laid down in the formula enunciated in Rule 6(1)(i). The formula does not contemplate that the tax attributable to corresponding turnover of paddy shall be excluded before arriving at the deduction of the amount relatable to tax on rice as per Rule 6(1)(i). The only possible way of reconciling the Circular with the Rule is to construe the expression ‘rate of tax’ as the net amount of tax payable on rice after allowing the rebate on paddy tax in accordance with the Explanation III to Schedule III. Such an interpretation would amount to giving strained interpretation to the expression ‘rate of tax’. In fact, it is not the stand of the respondents that ‘rate of tax’ on rice is anything other than the standard rate of 4 per cent.

    12. The rebate or reduction provided for by Explanation III to Schedule III does not determine the ‘rate of tax’ contemplated by the formula. Even the assessment order shows that the ‘rate of tax’ was taken as 4%. Apart from the direct decisions of this Court which interpreted the expression ‘rate of tax’, we are informed that if expression ‘rate of tax’ vis-a-vis. rice is taken as the net amount of tax after giving rebate to tax on paddy, the loss of revenue to the State would be more inasmuch as the same meaning may have to be given to the expression ‘rate of tax’ occurring in Section 8(2-A) of the Central Sales Tax Act. We are also informed that under Section 8(2-A), the rate of 4% is applied to the inter-State sales of rice, though the corresponding paddy had suffered local tax.

    13. The Commissioner's Circular fails to take into account the decisions of this Court which have been holding the field for long. In Sri Ganesh Trading Company v. The State Of A.P . 1988 6 APSTJ 258., a Division Bench interpreted ‘twice the rate of tax’ occurring in Sec. 8(2)(a) as follows:

    “The rate of tax applicable to the sale of rice inside the State of Andhra Pradesh is 4 per cent as specified against item 22 of the Third Schedule to the Act. Liability to tax under Sec. 8(2)(a) has to be quantified with reference to that rate and at double that rate. Emphasis is on the expression ‘calculated at twice the rate’. Sri Dasaratharama Reddy, learned Counsel appearing for the assessee, would like us to interpret the expression ‘rate’ as meaning the amount of tax ultimately levied. There is no warrant for such an interpretation. It is well settled that the words of a statute must be given their ordinary meaning. Given the said meaning, the expression ‘calculated at twice the rate’ applicable to the sale of goods inside the appropriate State only mean that the goods viz., the rice sold by the petitioner outside the State of Andhra Pradesh and not supported by declarations in form ‘C’ is liable to tax at the rate of 8 per cent i.e, double the rate of 4 per cent applicable to sale of rice inside the State of Andhra Pradesh. Explanation III to entries 21 and 22 of the Third Schedule to the Act does not alter or revise the rate; it only provides for a concessions to the extent indicated therein.”

    14. We are told that the decision in Ganesh Trading company is being consistently followed by the Tribunal and the view taken therein has not been questioned before us for obvious reasons. The view taken by the Tribunal in that appeal T.A No. 838/96 was affirmed by this Court, the TRC having been rejected in limine. It is brought to our notice that the view taken in Ganesh Trading Company was followed and applied by the Tribunal to a case in which Section 8-A (1) of the C.S.T Act (identical to Rule 6(1)(i) came up for consideration. The Tribunal rejected the contention that the rebate under Section 15(c) has to be excluded while giving deduction for the tax element in respect of inter-State sales. Thus, the Commissioner's Circular runs counter to the catena of decisions both of the High Court and of the Tribunal. The effect and impact of these decisions were obviously not considered by the Commissioner.

    15. It is relevant to refer to one more decision of the Division Bench in State of A.P v. Lakshminarayana Gupta . 1995 21 APSTJ 21.. Their Lordships were construing the proviso to Section 8-A(1)(a) of CST Act which is identical to the proviso to Rule 6(1)(i) of APGST Rules. While observing that the basic principle embodied in Section 8-A of the Central Sales Tax Act is that there should be no tax on tax, the legal position as regards the true scope of the proviso to Section 8-A(1)(a) has been stated as follows:

    “The proviso to Section 8-A(1)(a) of the Central Act enjoins that on the basis of the formula contained in Section 8-A(1) of the Central Act, no deduction shall be made if the amount of tax collected by the registered dealer in accordance with the provisions of the Central Act, has already been deducted from the aggregate of the sale price or otherwise. This also supports that the intention of the Parliament in prescribing the formula is that the relief should be confined to avoid tax on the tax component. But it is equally clear that the deduction allowed under Section 8-A(1) of the Central Act would be available to the dealer only if the tax forms a part of the sale price. The burden of showing that the turnover includes the Central Sales Tax for purpose of application of the formula under Section 8-A(1) of the Central Act, is on the dealer.”

    16. In this context; the learned Judges relied on the dicta laid down in Rallie's India Ltd. v. State of A.P . 53 STC 267., wherein it was observed as follows:

    “While it is true that Central Sales Tax is payable irrespective of the fact whether the dealer collects the same or not from his purchaser it does not follow therefrom that Central Sales tax should be deducted even where it is not collected, for such a course would result in, as rightly pointed out by the Tribunal, reducting the sale price, a result not contemplated or permissible by the Act. And nobody is in a better position than the dealer to show whether he has collected the Central Sales Tax or not.

    For the above reasons, we are of the opinion that the formula in Sec. 8-A(1) applies only in cases where Central Sales Tax is shown to have been collected by the dealer and forms part of the aggregate of sale price. Where, of course, Central Sales Act has been otherwise shown to have been deducted from the aggregate of the sale price, there is no occasion for applying the formula.”

    17. Thus, the burden is on the dealer to show whether and to what extent the tax component entered into all inclusive price charge while claiming the deduction under Rule 6(1)(i). As far as the present cases are concerned, there is a finding of the assessing authority that the sale price is inclusive of tax. Of course, it is not specified whether it is 4 per cent or less as no enquiry at all was made on those lines.

    18. Our conclusion is that the Circular of the Commissioner is contrary to law and cannot control the plain effect of formula laid down in Rule 6(1)(i). However, it is open to the assessing authority to hold an enquiry whether and to what extent the tax element has been included in the sale price. In view of the fact that the assessment orders are based on the Commissioner's circular (in fact, in some of the assessments a specific reference has been made to the Commissioner's Circular) and the mode of arriving at the deduction under Rule 6(1)(i) is based on incorrect understanding of the Rule, we set aside the assessments and direct fresh assessments to be made without reference to the Commissioner's Circular.

    19. Before parting with the case, we must record that we have found fault with the Commissioner's Circular because it goes contrary to the plain language of the formula and for the reason that the expression ‘rate of tax’ does not take any rebate under Explanation III to Schedule III. But, it seems to us that the circular rests on a rational basis and perhaps gives better effect to the intention of the Rule-making authority in avoiding levy of tax on the tax component. In arriving at the tax component forming part of ‘all inclusive price’, there is nothing irrational or improper in restricting the relief to the actual or net amount of tax payable on rice (arrived at after reducing the tax paid on paddy). Whereas the actual tax liability of the assessee is much less than 4 per cent on account of Explanation III to Schedule III, when it comes to the question of deduction under Rule 6(1)(i), the rate of tax to be taken into account is 4 per cent having regard to the specific language of the Rule. As the Rule now stands, the Commissioner's view cannot stand the scrutiny of law, though as we observed earlier, it is perhaps a more rational view to take. It is for the Legislature or the Rule making authority to take into account this factor and bring in suitable amendment in so far as the tax deduction on the sale turnover of rice is concerned, in the context of the peculiar situation that has arisen on account of the operation of Sec. 15(c) of the C.S.T Act read with Explanation III to Schedule III to A.P.G.S.T Act.

    20. One more point has been urged in the writ petition i.e, with regard to the quantum of deduction towards rural development cess. We are not inclined to go into this question as the petitioner has an effective alternative remedy. We repeat that in so far as deduction under Rule 6(1)(i) is concerned, we have gone into that question for the reason that the Commissioner's Circular which is contrary to law stands in the way of the assessing authority.

    21. For the reasons aforesaid, the impugned assessment orders in so far as the amount arrived at by the assessing authority for the purpose of deduction under Rule 6(1)(i) are set aside and the assessing authorities are directed to make fresh assessments without reference to the Circular of the Commissioner and in the light of the observations made by us. Accordingly, the writ petitions are allowed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sri Laxmiganapathi Enterprises, Huzurnagar And Others v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kodad And Others
    (Sep 10, 1999)