Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision arises from O.S.No.716 of 1995 on the file of the II Additional Subordinate Judge, Rangareddi District, Hyderabad. The plaintiffs (now revision petitioners) sued for declaration of title, recovery of possession and permanent injunction in respect of certain suit property. They allege that they and the defendants had jointly purchased properties under a registered sale deed dated 10-9-1979 and thereafter effected a partition on 17-2-1983. A document dated 17-2-1983 (described in the record as a memorandum or deed of partition) was produced while the plaintiff was being examined as PW1. The defendants objected to marking the disputed document as evidence on the ground that it is an unregistered partition deed and thus inadmissible. The trial Court (by orders dated 4-9-1997) upheld the objection and refused to admit the document for want of registration. The plaintiffs filed the present revision petition challenging those orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disputed document dated 17-2-1983 is a partition deed that is compulsorily registerable under Section 17 of the Registration Act and therefore inadmissible under Section 49 of the Registration Act to prove the terms or allotments contained in it.
  2. Whether, notwithstanding inadmissibility to prove the terms of the deed, the proviso to Section 49(c) (and related authorities) permits the admission of the unregistered partition document for collateral purposes — specifically, to prove the factum of partition and the nature of possession of the parties.
  3. Whether the nature of the partition alleged (i.e., partition between co‑sharers who jointly purchased property versus partition of joint family property or other categories) affects the scope of admissibility for collateral purposes.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioners (Plaintiffs) — Principal Contentions

  • They accept that the disputed document is a partition deed and that it was not registered.
  • They contend that under the Proviso to Section 49(c) of the Indian Registration Act the disputed document can be admitted for a collateral purpose — namely, to prove the factum of partition and the nature of possession of the parties.
  • They do not seek to use the document to prove the terms of the partition (i.e., they are not trying to use it to create, declare, assign or extinguish rights or to show precise allotments of specific properties to particular parties).

Respondents (Defendants) — Principal Contentions

  • The alleged partition does not concern partition of joint family properties; the properties were jointly purchased under a registered sale deed in 1979, and therefore there is no question of division or severance of status between joint family members.
  • The suit is founded on the disputed document and there is no collateral purpose to be established; consequently the unregistered document cannot be admitted even for collateral purposes.
  • Reliance was placed on the decision in Ratan Lal v. Hari Shanker to support the contention that the unregistered document cannot be used to show partition or specific allotments when registration is required.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ratan Lal v. Hari Shanker Even where a document is compulsorily registerable and unregistered, it may be admissible for collateral purposes; however such collateral use is limited and cannot be used to prove that the deed created, declared, assigned, limited or extinguished rights to immovable property. The Court distinguished this case on the ground that petitioners sought to admit the document only to prove the factum of partition and nature of possession (a collateral purpose), not to establish creation or allocation of rights; thus Ratan Lal did not preclude the limited admission sought here.
Kanamathareddi Kanna Reddy v. Kanamatha Reddy Venkata Reddy (Full Bench) Unregistered partition deed cannot be received as evidence of separate allotment or declaration of exclusive right to specific properties; clause (c) of Section 49 bars reception of such documents for proof of terms, but Section 91 of the Evidence Act limits exclusion to proof of the terms, leaving other areas (collateral matters) unaffected. The Court relied on this Full Bench decision to explain that if the unregistered document is not relied upon to prove the terms of disposition, neither Section 49(c) nor Section 91 will preclude its limited reception for collateral purposes such as establishing severance or nature of possession.
Ramayya v. Achamma (AIR 1944 Mad. 550) Earlier Full Bench authority on partition documents; cited for contrast and was distinguished on facts in the Court's discussion. The Court noted that the Kanamathareddi Full Bench distinguished Ramayya on the facts; the present case follows the approach in the later Full Bench which limits the bar to proof of terms and allows collateral use.
N. Seetharamaiah v. N. Ramakrisknaiah Unregistered documents requiring registration do not create/declare/assign rights; their inadmissibility does not prevent proving factum of partition by other evidence; such documents cannot be used to ascertain terms of partition or trace source of title. The Court quoted and relied on this authority to support the proposition that the partition deed, though unregistered and inadmissible to prove terms or title, does not prevent proving partition and possession by other means and may be used for limited collateral purposes.
Ruhnambai (Rukmambai) v. Lakshminarayana (Supreme Court) Authority supporting that unregistered documents can be looked into for limited collateral purposes (e.g., establishing severance in status) though not to prove terms creating rights. The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority (as cited in state decisions) to reinforce the limited collateral admissibility principle applied to unregistered partition deeds.
Muthyala Reddy v. Venkata Reddy (Full Bench) Unregistered partition documents are inadmissible to prove terms/allotments but can be looked into for establishing severance in status, which affects the nature of possession thereafter. The Court cited this five‑judge Full Bench decision to support permitting the unregistered partition deed to be used for establishing severance in status and thus the nature of possession (a collateral purpose) despite its inadmissibility to prove specific allotments.
Roshan Singh v. Zile Singh (AIR 1988 SC 881) Unregistered document may be examined for the limited purpose of establishing severance in status and to show that subsequent division followed an original intention to divide; limited/collateral reception is permissible. The Court quoted this Supreme Court decision to bolster the position that an unregistered partition document may be used for the limited collateral purpose of proving partition and resultant possession characteristics.
Rikki Ram v. Sada Ram (Punjab & Haryana High Court) Section 49 does not bar proving an unregistered instrument of partition for ascertaining the nature of possession; factum of partition and nature of possession can be proved by oral and other documentary evidence. Cited to support that the disputed unregistered partition deed may be admitted for limited purposes (factum of partition and nature of possession) while not being used to prove terms/allotments.
Nirmal Singh v. Gurbachan Singh (Punjab & Haryana High Court) An unregistered document of partition between co‑sharers is not admissible except to prove the factum of partition and the nature of possession; oral evidence is admissible to prove partition. Used to support the proposition that even between co‑sharers who jointly purchased property, an unregistered partition deed may be utilized only for the limited collateral purpose of showing partition and possession, not the detailed terms of allotment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner, strictly applying statutory provisions and precedent as follows:

  1. Characterisation of the document: On perusal the Court found the disputed document (dated 17-2-1983) was not a mere memorandum recording an earlier partition but was a partition deed under which the partition itself was effected and specific items were allotted to respective parties; it also recorded that parties became absolute owners of their allotted shares and took possession on the date of execution.
  2. Statutory consequence of that characterisation: Because the document created or declared rights in immovable property it is compulsorily registerable under Section 17 of the Registration Act; being unregistered, Section 49 (and in particular clause (c)) makes it inadmissible to prove the terms of the disposition or to show which properties fell to whose share.
  3. Consideration of the proviso to Section 49(c) and related evidence law: The petitioners relied upon the proviso to Section 49(c) to admit the document for collateral purposes (factum of partition and nature of possession). The Court analysed the scope of Sections 49 (Registration Act) and 91 (Evidence Act) and observed that Section 49 excludes the unregistered document from evidence as proof of the terms of disposition, while Section 91 forbids proving terms of a contract or disposition by evidence other than the document itself; but these prohibitions are limited in scope.
  4. Precedential synthesis: The Court surveyed a consistent line of authority — including Full Bench and Supreme Court decisions — holding that although unregistered partition deeds cannot be used to prove the terms of a partition or to establish title/allotments, such documents may be looked into or admitted for limited/ collateral purposes, notably to establish a severance in status and the consequent nature of possession, or to show factum of partition without proving the precise allotments.
  5. Application to the present case: The petitioners did not seek to prove by the disputed document the precise creation or allocation of rights; they sought to use it only to prove that a partition occurred and to show the nature of possession — collateral matters within the limited scope recognized by authorities. Additionally, the parties had instituted reciprocal suits (the defendants had filed a separate suit O.S.116 of 96) and the two matters were being tried together, which rendered the collateral proof of partition and possession materially relevant.
  6. Conclusion of analysis: On the authority cited and on the statutory reading, the Court concluded that while the document is inadmissible to prove the terms and specific allotments embodied in it (because it is unregistered and falls under Section 49), it is admissible for the limited collateral purpose of proving the factum of partition and the nature of possession of the parties. Accordingly, the trial Court's orders were to be modified to admit the document to that limited extent.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision is allowed to the limited extent that the disputed partition document dated 17-2-1983, though inadmissible to prove the terms and allotments contained in it (for want of registration), may be admitted in evidence for the collateral purpose of proving the factum of partition and the nature of possession of the parties.

Consequences and immediate effect:

  • The impugned orders of the lower Court (which refused to admit the document entirely) are modified to permit the document's reception in evidence only for collateral purposes (factum of partition and nature of possession) and not for proving the terms, allocations or creating/declaring rights to immovable property.
  • No order as to costs was made by the Court ("No costs").
  • The decision follows and applies established precedents; it does not purport to create any new or broader legal principle beyond the limited rule that unregistered partition deeds can be received for collateral purposes but not to prove terms/allotments. In other words, the ruling affects admissibility in this litigation context without purporting to expand the statutory bar in Section 49 to cover collateral matters.

    Smt. Kaheeda Moin & Ors. v. Md. Iqbal Ali & Ors.

    1. This revision is filed by the plaintiffs in O.S.No.716 of 1995 on the file of the II Additional Subordinate Judge, Rangareddi District, Hyderabad questioning the impugned orders dated 4-9-1997 by which the disputed document dated 17-2-1983 was not permitted to be marked as evidence as inadmissible on the ground of non-registration.

    2. The revision petitioners, who are the plaintiffs filed the said suit seeking the relief Of declaration of their title and for recovery of possession of the suit property and also for the relief of permanent injunction against the respondents herein contending that the suit property along with some other properties were jointly purchased by them under a registered sale deed dated 10-9-1979 and all of them continued to be in joint possession and enjoyment of the said properties that subsequently there was a partition of those properties effected on 17-2-1983 in the presence of elders and in that partition the present suit properties fell to the share of the plaintiffs and the other properties fell to the share of the defendants and ever since then the plaintiffs were in possession and enjoyment of the properties that fell to their share and that the suit is now filed as their title to the suit properties is being disputed by the defendants. They also contended that at the time of the abovesaid partition on 17-2-1983 the disputed document was executed mentioning the particulars of the abovesaid partition. When the plaintiff was being examined as PW1 and when the above said document, which isdescribed as memorandum of partition dated 17-2-1993 was sought to be marked as evidence, the defendants raised an objection on the ground that it is an unregistered partition , deed evidencing partition and as such it is inadmissible in evidence. The lower Court by the impugned orders dated 4-9-1997 upheld the said objection raised by the defendants and did not permit the said document to go into evidence on the ground that it is a partition deed which is compulsorily required to be registered and that inasmuch as it is not registered, it is inadmissible in evidence. Questioning such orders the present revision is filed by the plaintiffs.

    3. Both the Counsel are heard.

    4. It is now clear from a perusal of the disputed document, a copy of which is enclosed to the present revision petition that the plaintiffs and the respondents, who are alleged to have jointly purchased the present suit properties and some other properties under a registered sale deed dated 10-9-1979, had effected partition of those properties in the presence of elders on 17-2-1983 and that to evidence such partition of the properties and disputed document was executed between them. It is clear from the terms ofthe said document that the said document is not a mere memorandum of any partition which was already effected between the parties. On the other hand it is clearly mentioned that the partition of the properties between the parties was effected under that document itself and specific items of properties were allotted to the respective sharers. It is-also further mentioned in the said document that the parties to whom specific items of properties were allotted under the document, have become the absolute owners of the properties that were allotted to their respective shares in that partition and they have also taken possession of their respective shares in that partition on that day itself i.e., on 17-2-1983 which is the date of partition. It is clear from such terms and conditions ofthe disputed document that the said document of partition has created and declared the rights of the respective parties to the properties that were allotted to their respective shares under that document. Therefore, such a document is compulsorily registerable under Section 17 of the Registration Act and as it is not so registered, it cannot be admitted in evidence in view of the provisions of Section 49 of the Registration Act to prove the terms of the disposition of properties embodied in the document and to show as to which properties fell to whose share under that document.

    5. The learned Counsel for the revision petitioners does not dispute the abovesaid proposition, nor does he dispute the fact that the disputed document is a partition deed under which the actual partition of the properties took place between the parties. But he however tries to contend that in view of the Proviso to Section 49(c) of the Indian Registration Act the disputed document can be admitted in evidence for the collateral purpose of proving the factum of partition of the properties and the nature of possession of the parties and that the lower Court has however failed to consider this aspect and as such the impugned orders of the lower Court are to be modified accordingly. On the other hand the learned Counsel for the respondents, who are the defendants in the suit, tries to contend that in the present case the alleged partition of the properties does not relate to partition of joint family properties that the present suit properties and some other properties were jointly purchased by all the parties under a registered document in 1979 and as such there is no question of bringing any division or severence of status between the parties, that the suit itself is filed for declaration of title and for recovery of possession on the basis of the disputed document and as such there is no collateral purpose to be established in the present case and as such the document cannot be admitted in evidence for want of registration. He has also tried to rely upon the decision reported in Ratan Lal v. Hari Shanker, , in support of his contention in this regard. But such contention of the learned Counsel for the respondents cannot be accepted and the above cited decision is not of any assistance for such contention. It is observed in the said decision that even though a document is compulsorily registerable and has not been registered it will be admissible in evidence for collateral purpose, that such collateral purpose has however limited scope and meaning and that it cannot be used for the purpose of showing that the deed created or declared or assigned or limited or extinguished a right to immovable property, and that if such facts could not be established by the collateral purpose, then the document cannot be marked as evidence for showing that the property was partitioned or that particular properties were given to various parties in the partition. But, in the present case the learned Counsel for the petitioners does not propose to mark the document for the purpose of establishing any of the abovesaid acts namely creating, declaring or assigning of any right to any immovable property by marking the said document for collateral purpose and his contention however is that such document can be marked as evidence for the purpose of proving the factum of partition of the properties and the nature of possession of the properties which amount only to collateral purpose. It is now admitted by the parties that the defendants in this suit have chosen to file a separate suit in O.S.I 16 of 96 seeking the partition and separate possession of their share in the properties including the present suit properties and the said suit is being contested by the present plaintiffs who are the defendants in that suit on the ground that there was already a partition under the disputed document. It is also said that both these suits are being tried together. Under these circumstances, the disputed partition deed can be admitted for the limited purpose of proving the factum of partition and nature of possession which is collateral purpose even though it cannot be admitted in evidence for the purpose of proving any of the terms of the document or to show that particular properties fell to the share of any particular person. Such view is clearly held by various decisions of different Courts including the Full Bench decisions of this Court.

    6. In the Full Bench decision of our High Court presided by three Judges reported in Kanamathareddi Kanna Reddy v. Kanamatha Reddy Venkata Reddy, , it is held that unregistered partition deed cannot be received as evidence of separate allotment of and declaration of exclusive right and title to specific items of properties in favour of the parties, that the ban of clause (c) of Section 49 of the Registration Act is against the reception of the unregistered document as evidence that it does not however prohibit the reception of any other evidence of the transaction that Section 91 of the Evidence Act steps in here and imposes a prohibition by stating that when the terms of contract or of grant or any other disposition of property have been reduced to the form of a document, no evidence shall be given in proof of the terms of such contract, grant or other disposition of property, except the document itself, or secondary evidence of its contents in cases in which secondary evidence is admissible under the provisions of the Evidence Act, that such prohibition enacted by Section 91 of the Evidence Act is however limited in scope, that it relates only to the giving of other evidence "in proof of terms of such contract, grant or other disposition of properties" that there is an area which is not covered by Section 49(C) of die Registration Act and Section 91 of the Evidence Act, that Section 49(C) excludes from evidence the unregistered document and Section 91 precludes the proof of only the terms of the contract, grant or other disposition of property, and that if the unregistered document is not to be relied upon and if the terms of the disposition of the property embodied in that document are not sought to be proved by other evidence, the bar of neither of these sections will come into effect. Such observations were made by their Lordships in the said decision of our High Court by distinguishing the earlier Full Bench Decision of Madras High Court reported in Ramayya v. Achamma, AIR 1944 Mad. 550, on facts. In a subsequent decision of this Court reported in N. Seetharamaiah v. N. Ramakrisknaiah, , it is observed by relying upon the above said Full Bench decision of this Court in Gotla 's case (supra) and also die decision of Supreme Court reported in Ruhnambai v. Lakshminarayana, as follows:

    "Exs.B.l and B.5 are documents which require to be compulsorily registered under Section 17(1) (b) of the Registration Act. The effect of non-registration of these documents is that they will not create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish any right, title or interest in or to the immovable property comprised in the documents. In short these documents are ineffectual to achieve the object or purpose for which they were drawn up. But the fact that these documents are inadmissible in ' evidence will not affect the case of the defendants for the reason that they are not precluded from proving the factum of partition by other evidence. They cannot be looked into only for ascertaining the terms of the partition and tracing the source of tide in the property held by each of the sharers."

    7. In another Full Bench decision rendered by five Judges of this Court reported in Muthyala Reddy v. Venkata Reddy, in which the above cited decisions reported in Gotla's case and Ramayya's case (supra) and some other decisions including the decision of the Supreme Court in Rukmambai's case (supra) are referred, their Lordships have observed as follows:

    "In our view where a partition takes place the terms of which are incorporated in an unregistered document, that document is inadmissible in evidence and cannot be looked for terms of the partition. It is in fact the source of title to the property held by each of the erstwhile coparceners. That document, though unregistered, can however be looked into for the purpose of establishing a severence in status, though that severence would ultimately affect the nature of possession held by the members of the separated family who from thence onwards, hold it as co-tenants."

    After making such observation their Lordships have observed in para 36 that in view of such circumstances the unregistered partition deeds marked as Exs.B18 and Ex.B19 in that particular case, though inadmissible in evidence for want of registration, can however be looked into for establishing the severence in status.

    8. In the decision of the Supreme Court reported in Roshan Singh v. Zile Singh, AIR 1988 SC 881, it is observed in para 16 as follows:

    "It is well settled that the document though unregistered can however be looked into for the limited purpose of establishing a severence in status, though that severance would ultimately affect the nature of the possession held by the members of the separated family as co-tenants. The document Ex. P. 12 can be used for the limited and collateral purpose of showing that the subsequent division of the properties allotted was in pursuance of the original intention to divide."

    In the decision of Punjab and Haryana High Court reported in Rikki Ram v. Sada Ram, , also it is observed that the provisions of Section 49 of the Registration Act do not bar the proving of un-registered instrument of partition for the purposes of ascertaining the nature of possession of any party to such an instrument and that the factum of partition and the nature of possession of the parties regarding the properties in their possession could be proved by oral and other documentary evidence. In another decision of the same High Court reported in Nirmal Singh v. Gurbachan Singh, , also it is observed that an unregistered document of partition of land between co-sharers would not be admissible in evidence except to prove the factum of partition and nature of possession and that oral evidence is admissible to prove that there was partition of land between the co-sharers. In that case also partition of properties was between co-sharers as in our present case and not a partition of joint family properties between co-owners. In the said case also the parties had jointly purchased the properties previously and are alleged to have partitioned the properties under , the disputed document. Under these circumstances also it was held that an unregistered document can be utilised for the limited purpose of proving the factum of partition and nature of possession though it cannot be admitted in evidence for proving the terms of the document. Therefore, in view of all these circumstances, the disputed partition deed in the present case can be admitted in evidence for the limited purpose of proving the factum of partition and nature of possession of the parties even though it cannot be looked into for the purpose of proving the terms of partition and to show as to which properties fell to whose share in that partition. To this extent the orders of the lower Court are liable to be modified.

    9. In the result, the revision is allowed to the abovesaid extent holding that the disputed document, though inadmissible in evidence for the purpose of proving the terms and conditions of the document, can be admitted in evidence for collateral purpose of proving the factum of partition and the nature of possession of the parties and the impugned orders of the lower Court are modified to that extent. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Kaheeda Moin & Ors. v. Md. Iqbal Ali & Ors.
    (Sep 11, 1998)