Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rules 1971." 15. Rule 2 (c)
  • 20. Rule 16
  • 26. Rule 23
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rules 1971." 15. Rule 2 (c)
  • 20. Rule 16
  • 26. Rule 23
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Twenty-seven licensees from three districts joined to file W.P. No. 4991 of 1972 (leading to W.A. No. 443 of 1973) seeking a writ of mandamus directing respondents to renew D.S. XI licences for the year beginning 1-10-1972 without imposing any cut in allotted quotas of denatured spirit. These petitioners manufacture French Polish from denatured spirit.

Separately, W.P. No. 4820 of 1972 (leading to W.A. No. 464 of 1973) was filed seeking renewal of a licence for the same year without any cut in the previously allotted quota for rectified spirit or, alternatively, denatured spirit.

The State Government opposed both writ petitions on the ground of a shortage of denatured spirit due to lower-than-expected production; overall equipment capacity was stated as 426 lakhs while expected production was 297 lakhs. The State had arranged quotas and imposed percentage cuts ranging from 30% to 75% according to priorities; manufacture of French Polish was assigned the lowest priority and had been cut by 75%.

The learned single Judge allowed the writ petitions and issued mandamus, holding that neither the Andhra Pradesh Excise Act nor its Rules empowered the Government to regulate supply and distribution of denatured spirit, and therefore the State could not refuse renewal of licences or transport permits by cutting down applied quantities.

The present appeals challenge that judgment. The principal question in the appeals is whether the State Government has the power to fix reduced quotas when renewing licences for denatured spirit and to issue transport permits accordingly.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government has power under the Act and Rules to fix reduced quotas for denatured spirit at the time of granting or renewing licences and to issue transport permits corresponding to those reduced quotas.
  2. Whether the statutory scheme (the Act and Rules) authorizes control and regulation of intoxicants (including denatured and rectified spirit) from production through possession, transport, purchase and sale, such that quotas and priority-based cuts are permissible.
  3. Whether the specific Rules and licence form (in particular, Form D. S. XI Condition No. 4 and Condition No. 5 under Rule 12) either expressly or by necessary implication authorize determination of yearly quantities and thereby support quota-fixing for denatured spirit.
  4. Whether the restrictions and quota-fixing mechanism violate Article 14 of the Constitution by allegedly lacking guidelines or acceptable principles for fixing quotas and priorities.
  5. Whether any specific authority must be named to determine quotas, or whether the licensing/permit-issuing authority inherently possesses that power.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners / Appellants

  • Sought writs of mandamus directing renewal of D.S. XI licences for the year from 1-10-1972 without any cut in allotted quotas of denatured spirit (W.P. No. 4991 of 1972 / W.A. No. 443 of 1973).
  • In the separate petition (W.P. No. 4820 of 1972 / W.A. No. 464 of 1973) similarly sought renewal without cuts in quota for rectified spirit or alternatively denatured spirit.

State Government / Respondents

  • Contended that overall capacity (426 lakhs) exceeded expected production (297 lakhs) and that shortages arising from molasses and alcohol constraints required the State to arrange quotas in order of priority.
  • Explained that denatured spirit is required for diverse purposes and, given scarcity, percentage cuts (30% to 75%) were necessary; manufacture of French Polish had lowest priority and was cut by 75%.
  • Maintained that such measures were required to equitably distribute scarce intoxicants according to requirements and priorities.

Lower Court's Finding (as described)

  • The learned Judge held there was no provision in the Andhra Pradesh Excise Act or rules empowering the Government to regulate supply and distribution of denatured spirit, and therefore the State could not refuse renewal of licences or transport permits by cutting down applied quantities.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Judgment of O. Chinappa Reddy, J. in W.P. No. 5931 of 1972 (Andh Pra) dated 14-3-1973 The learned Judge's view: the Excise Superintendent is not concerned with availability of denatured spirit stock or with fixing priorities; using transport permits to regulate distribution was improper and unjustified by the rules. The court reviewed and disagreed with this judgment. It held that the Act and Rules (including licence conditions and Rule 23 for rectified spirit) demonstrate an intention to control and regulate intoxicants throughout production-to-sale stages, permitting fixing of quotas and priorities and the imposition of cuts; accordingly the court rejected the view that transport permits could not be used as part of distribution control.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds in a structured sequence, closely following the provisions of the Act and the Rules and applying well-known rules of statutory construction:

  1. Statutory Definitions and Preamble: The court notes that Section 2(21) includes denatured and rectified spirit within "liquor" and Section 2(19) defines "intoxicant" to include such liquor. The preamble indicates the Act relates to production, manufacture, possession, transport, purchase and sale of intoxicating liquor and drugs and to excise duties. This demonstrates a legislative design to regulate intoxicants throughout their lifecycle, not merely to levy revenue.
  2. Relevant Provisions Empowering Regulation:
    • Section 11: empowers the Government to prohibit transport of an intoxicant between areas or beyond prescribed quantities.
    • Section 12: governs grant of permits for transport; permits may specify maximum quantities and must state the quantity, strength and description of intoxicants permitted.
    • Section 14: empowers the Government to prescribe by notification the maximum quantity a person may possess and makes possession above that quantity unlawful except under a licence or permit.
    • Section 15: prohibits sale or purchase except under a licence subject to its terms and conditions.
  3. Rules and Licence Conditions: Two rule sets were made under Section 72 — denatured Spirit Rules, 1971 and Rectified Spirit Rules, 1971. The court highlights:
    • Rule 5 and Rule 6: prohibit possession or transport in excess of prescribed quantities without licence/permit.
    • Rule 12 and Form D. S. XI: prescribe licences for possession and use of denatured spirit for manufacture (French Polish, varnish etc.). Condition No. 4 of Form D. S. XI caps quantity used and possessed "at any one time" to 25% of the quantity allowed for the year; Condition No. 5 allows the Commissioner to impose special terms and conditions regarding each sanction.
    • Rule 16 and Rule 17: prescribe procedure for obtaining and renewing licences (licences granted for a sugar year; verifying officers may conduct enquiries and grant licence if conditions are satisfied).
    • Rule 23 (Rectified Spirit Rules): expressly authorises the Commissioner to impose restrictions or fix quotas for rectified spirit depending on availability, demand, equitable distribution and intended use.
  4. Implication by Necessary Construction: Although there is no express clause in the Denatured Spirit Rules akin to Rule 23, the court reasons that Condition No. 4 of Form D. S. XI (and Condition No. 5) necessarily imply that a yearly quantity must be fixed and referred to in the licence; otherwise Condition No. 4 would be ineffective. Reading Sections 13–15 together with the relevant Rules, the court concludes quotas for both denatured and rectified spirit can and must be fixed in licences.
  5. Statutory Scheme and Principles of Construction: The court invokes the scheme of the Act, the purpose of controlling intoxicants (given their potential societal harm), and established rules of interpretation: look to the object/policy of legislation to resolve ambiguities; avoid constructions that subvert legislative purpose; construe provisions so as to suppress the mischief and advance the remedy. Applying these rules supports a construction that enables effective regulation through licences and permits.
  6. Rejection of Contrasting View (Chinappa Reddy, J. and the Learned Single Judge): The court disagrees with the view that licensing authorities are confined to issuing licences/permits without regard to stock or priorities or that transport permits cannot be used to regulate distribution. The court finds such a view would defeat the purpose of the Act and free commodities from control at many points, contrary to the express statutory scheme.
  7. Article 14 Objection: The court addresses the contention that quota restrictions violate Article 14 because guidelines are absent. It finds the scheme of the Act and the cited provisions provide adequate guidelines for fixing quotas and priorities (e.g., availability, demand, equitable distribution, and intended use). On the facts and data examined, the imposed cuts were not unreasonable and the priorities were not arbitrary or fanciful.
  8. Authority to Fix Quotas: The court holds that when the licence/permit must mention the quota, it follows that the authority which issues the licence/permit is empowered to fix the quota in the licence and the permit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeals are allowed. The judgments of the learned single Judge are set aside. The writ petitions are dismissed. The court awarded costs — advocate's fee Rs. 100 in each case and in each Court. The opinion concludes with the statement: "Appeals allowed."

Implications:

  • The court held that the Andhra Pradesh Excise Act and the Rules (read together and in light of the scheme and object of the legislation) empower the licensing/permit-issuing authorities to determine yearly quotas for denatured and rectified spirit and to impose cuts in supply as necessary to effectuate equitable distribution and meet social requirements.
  • Licences (including renewals) and transport permits may validly specify reduced quotas and quantities to be transported corresponding to those quotas, and such measures are consistent with the regulatory purpose of the Act.
  • The court rejected the argument that the regulatory scheme violated Article 14 on the ground of lack of guidelines, holding that the statutory scheme furnishes sufficient criteria (availability, demand, equitable distribution, intended uses and societal priorities) and that the specific cuts imposed in the facts before the court were not unreasonable.
  • Direct practical consequence on the parties: the petitions seeking renewal without cuts were dismissed; the State's quota-reduction scheme and related transport permit regime were upheld in substance in these appeals.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

    The Commissioner Of Excise, Board Of Revenue, A.P, Hyderabad And Others v. B. Bhogeswara Rao And Others

    1. 27 licensees belonging to three Districts having different quotas of denatured spirit allotted to them have joined in filing W.P. No. 4991 of 1972 out of which W.A. No. 443 of 1973 arises. They have sought the relief of issue of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to renew D.S. XI licences for the year beginning from 1-10-1972 for denatured spirit without imposing any cut as per the direction of the Board of Revenue. These petitioners manufacture French Polish from the denatured spirit.

    2. W.P. No. 4820 of 1972 has been filed by the petitioner to renew similarly its licence for the same year without any cut in its quota previously allotted for the same year for rectified spirit or in the alternative denatured spirit. W.A. No. 464 of 1973 arises out of that petition.

    3. Both these writ petitions were resisted by the State Government amongst others on the ground that the overall equipment of the State for the year is 426 lakhs of denatured spirit , whereas the expected production was only 297 lakhs. In view of the shortage owing to different reasons of molasses and alcohol the State Government had to arrange the quotas in order of priorities as the denatured spirit is required for various purposes. Keeping in view the realities of the situation regarding production and bearing in mind the priority so allotted cut in the allotment of quotas was directed to be made ranging from 30% to 75%. Since manufacture of French Polish is of the lowest priority, it was given a cut of 75% in the previous allotment.

    4. The learned Judge allowed the writ petitions and issued mandamus holding that there is no provision of law either in the a.p. excise act or the rules framed thereunder empowering the Government to regulate the supply and distribution of denatured spirit. The State Government therefore neither can refuse the renewal of licence nor refuse transport permits by cutting down the quantity of denatured spirit applied for by the petitioners.

    5. In these appeals , the principal question is whether the State Government has power to fix reduced quota while renewing the licences regarding denatured spirit and then issue transport permits accordingly.

    6. Now Section 2 (21) of the Act includes denatured spirit as well as rectified spirit within the definition of liquor. Any other intoxicating substance which the Government declares to be liquor is also included therein.

    7. Section 2 (19) also defines the term "intoxicant" to mean any liquor as defined in clause 21 or any intoxicating drug as defined in clause (20).

    8. Before we look to the other provisions of the Act, it is well to remember that the preamble of the Act indicates that this Act relates to the production, manufacture, possession, transport, purchase and sale of intoxicating liquor and drugs , the levy of duties of excise and countervailing duties on alcoholic liquors etc.

    9. Section 11 empowers the Government to prohibit the transport of an intoxicant from one area to any other area. It also prohibits the transport of intoxicant of any quantity exceeding the one prescribed either generally or for any particular area.

    10. We then come to the most relevant provision for our purposes i.e., Section 12. It relates to the grant of permits for transport of intoxicants. The section firstly says that a general permit shall be issued only to persons licensed under the Act. The permit may specify the maximum quantity of intoxicant that may be transported at any one time. Such a permit for the transport of intoxicant may be either general for definite periods and kinds of intoxicants or special for specified occasions and particular consignments only. Every permit shall specify the things enumerated in sub-section (3). One of the requirements is to mention the quantity , strength and description of intoxicants for which the permit is issued.

    11. We then proceed to Section 14. The Section empowers the Government to specify by notification the maximum quantity of any intoxicant which a person may have in his possession. Sub-section (2) enjoins that no person shall have in his possession any intoxicant in excess of the quantity so specified, except under the authority and in accordance with the terms and conditions of a licence or a permit granted by the authority.

    12. Section 15 then prohibits every person from selling or buying any intoxicant except under the authority and in accordance with the terms and conditions of a licence granted for that purpose.

    13. This short survey of the preamble and the said provisions of the Act would indicate that the intention of the Legislature manifestly is to control and regulate the intoxicants right from the stage of production down to the stage of purchase and sale as well as their possession. The scheme of the Act is not meant merely for the collection of the excise duties and countervailing duties although the Act provides for such levies. The intoxicants being a rare commodity and capable of having deleterious and disastrous effects on the morals and health of the members of the society is clearly intended to be controlled and regulated which power includes as is seen the power to prohibit their transport from one area to another. Thus the intoxicants can neither be transported without permits nor they can be manufactured , nor they can be possessed, purchased or sold without obtaining necessary licences and transport permits in that behalf. Once this basic principle underlying the Act is borne in mind , then it will not be difficult for the Court to answer the question posed in this enquiry.

    14. There are two sets of Rules made under Section 72 of the Act. One is 'the Andhra Pradesh denatured Spirit and denatured Spirituous Preparations Rules, 1971" and the other "The Andhra Pradesh Rectified Spirit Rules 1971."

    15. Rule 2 (c) of the denatured Spirit Rules defines the term 'denatured Spirit'.

    16. Rule 5 puts an embargo on the possession of denatured spirit etc. in excess of the quantities mentioned therein and without a licence or a permit.

    17. Similarly Rule 6 prohibits every person from transporting denatured spirit etc. in excess of quantities specified in Rule 5 except under a transport permit.

    18. Rule 9 then relates to sale of denatured spirit etc. and prohibits sale without a licence.

    19. We then come to Rule 12 which specifically relates to licence for possession and use of denatured spirit in manufacture of French Polish and Varnish etc. Such a licence is issued in Form D. S. XI. The licensee can get his supplies from the distillery which is manufacturing denatured spirit or a wholesale licensee in Form D. S. VII or from source outside the State under an import permit.

    20. Rule 16 prescribes the procedure for obtaining licence. It prescribes what is known as Sugar year and a licence is granted only for a year. It empowers the Excise Superintendent to make enquiries for verification of the details stated in the application and also such other enquiries as may be necessary. On being satisfied that conditions for the grant of the licence have been complied with the authority may grant the licence.

    21. Rule 17 relates to renewal of licence and Rule 18 pertains to amendment to licence and Rule 19 concerns itself with the cancellation and suspension of licence.

    22. Form D. S. XI of licence for possession and use of denatured spirit in manufacture of French Polish and Varnish etc. prescribed under Rule 12 specifically enjoins that the licence shall be subject to the conditions mentioned therein. Condition No. 4 which is every relevant reads :-

    "The quantity of denatured spirit , methylated spirit, methyl alcohol possessed at any one time and that used and consumed under the licence shall not exceed 25 percent of the quantity allowed for the year"
    (Emphasis is ours)

    23. Column No. 2 prescribed in condition No. 4 then mentions the quantity of the denatured spirit that may be used in a year or the period of currency of licence for manufacturing purposes.

    24. Finally condition No. 5 expressly states that the licensee shall abide by the special terms and conditions , if any , which the commissioner may impose with regard to each such sanction.

    25. The second set of rules relate to rectified spirit. It is pertinent to note that Rule 21 empowers the licensing authority to amend or alter the licence or may issue a new licence imposing further conditions.

    26. Rule 23 authorises the Commissioner to impose such restrictions or to fix such quotas as might be necessary on the quantity of rectified spirit to be allotted to the licensees depending on the availability, the demand for rectified spirit and the need for equitable distribution of rectified spirit in different local areas and also depending upon the use for which it is intended.

    27. What emerges from the provisions of the Act read along with the Rules is that the denatured spirit as well as the rectified spirit is a controlled and regulated commodity. The authority is empowered to fix quotas regarding rectified spirit in view of the considerations mentioned in Rule 23. Likewise quantity allowed for the year has to be determined in regard to denatured spirit . It may be that like Rule 23 of the Rectified Spirit Rules, there is no express rule in the Denatured Spirit Rules fixing the quotas in view of certain considerations. Nevertheless be necessary implication which arises from condition No. 4 incorporated in Form D. S. XI prescribed under Rule 12 of the Denatured Spirit Rules, the quantity allowed for the year must have to be determined and referred to in the licence: otherwise condition No. 4 would be ineffective. Thus Sections 13 to 15 both inclusive if read with the relevant Rules regarding both the said commodities , no one can be left in doubt that the quotas regarding both the commodities can be fixed in the licences.

    28. We have already referred to the scheme of the Act. The meaning of Sections or Rules can be determined , not so much be reference to other individual provisions of the statute, as by the scheme of the Act regarded in general. The object or policy of any legislation often affords the answer to problems arising from ambiguities , if any, it contains. The provisions and the Rules are to be construed in the light of the intention of the legislature.

    It is also a golden rule of construction, that there are certain objects which the legislature is presumed not to intend , and a construction which would lead to any of them is therefore to be avoided. It is always proper to construe any ambiguous provisions in the light of the mischief which the enactment is obviously designed to prevent, and in the light of the reasonableness of the consequences which follow from giving it a particular construction. It is the office of this Court to make such construction as will suppress the mischief and advance the remedy, and to suppress all evasions for the continuance of the mischief. To carry out effectually the object of a statute , it must be so construed as to defeat all attempts to do, or avoid doing in an indirect or circuitous manner that which it has prohibited or enjoined. We are therefore bound to construe the provisions of the Act and Rules in a manner which will facilitate the smooth working of the scheme of the legislation established by the Act and Rules thereunder.

    29. The construction which we have put on various provisions of the Act and the Rules in the light of the scheme of the Act is the only proper construction which would enable the authorities to work out the scheme of the Act smoothly and effectively.

    30. It is in this background that we must examine first the judgment of O. Chinappa Reddy, J., given in W. P. No. 5931 of 1972 on 14-3-1973 (Andh Pra). The learned Judge noticed the provisions of the Act as well as the Rules made thereunder. The learned Judge however , fixed his attention on the aspect of equitable or effective distribution of denatured spirit. He took the view that the Excise Superintendent is not at all concerned while granting licence with the question whether the stock of denatured spirit is available with the distillery. Nor is he concerned with fixing of the priorities . The attempt to regulate the distribution of denatured spirit by means of transport permits if nothing but a misuse of the excise act and the rules. He further observed that

    "It is difficult to comprehend how these rules justify the use of transport permits as a part of a scheme to control the distribution of the denatured spirit."

    31. With due respect to the learned Judge, we find it very difficult to share that view. First of all the preamble to the Act does not say that distribution of these commodities is the subject of control. On the other hand, the provisions of the Act relate to the production, manufacture, possession, transport, purchase and sale of intoxicants. And it is seen that the provisions of the Act and the Rules expressly control through the grant of licences and permits the said commodities at each of the said points. It is not correct to argue that the authority is concerned only with the grant of licence or a permit and it is for the licensee to get as much quantity as he desires from the distillery within the State or import from outside on permit. This is not warranted not only by the scheme of the Act but by the express provisions referred to above.

    It must be remembered that violation of the provisions of the Act or the Rules or terms and conditions of licence is made penal apart from entailing the suspension or cancellation of licence or permit. The Act therefore cannot be said to be a mere revenue legislation. Essentially the provisions are intended to control and regulate the said commodities. Such a power to control and regulate takes within itself not only the power to fix quotas but also fix priorities as is done. In case of rectified spirit fixation of quota or priority is expressly provided in Rule 23 and in case of denatured spirit it is by necessary implication provided by conditions Nos. 4 and 5 of D.S. XI made under Rule 12 read along with the provisions of the Act and the Rules. The scheme of the Act and the provisions referred to above not only empower the authority to fix quotas and determine priority but in order to effectuate such a policy the authority can impose cuts in the supply of these commodities.

    In other words from year to year the authority can determine the quotas while granting licences or renewing them keeping in view the total production of the commodities in a given year and the competitive requirements of the society. It may be that the alcohol from which these commodities are manufactured or the said commodities do not belong to the Government but that does not mean that the Government has no power to control and regulate scarce commodities such as we are concerned within the interests of social needs. The conception that the Government can control and regulate its own products and not products belonging to others is totally misconceived. Consequently such a control can be effectuated through both the devices of licences and transport permits.

    32. The learned Judge against whose judgment the present appeals are filed virtually adopted the same line of approach as was adopted by Chinnappa Raddy, J. With due respect to the learned Judge , we find ourselves unable to accept that view. Such an approach is bound to defeat the very purpose of the Act and the Rules. The commodities would be freed from control at many points. That will amount to flying in the face of the express provisions of the Act and the Rules.

    33. We are not impressed with the argument that the restrictions thus placed upon the freedom of trade in these commodities is violative of Art. 14 inasmuch as the provisions do not lay down any guidelines for fixing the quotas or determing the priorities. The scheme of the Act and the various provisions referred to above, in our judgment, clearly provide guidelines both for fixing the quota as well as the priority. After all the various requirements of the society for which these commodities are required are well known. There can be no difficulty in fixing their relative priority in view if their importance to the society. We do not think therefore that the provisions are bad in view of Art. 14 of the Constitution. We are also satisfied after examining the relevant date relating to the availability and their needs that the cuts imposed are not unreasonable and the priority fixed cannot be said to be based on no principle or is arbitrary or fanciful.

    34. It was finally contended that no specific authority has been fixed to determine the quota. We find no strength in this contention. When it is found that such quota is to be determined and mentioned in the licence or permit, it follows that it is the authority which issues licence an permit that is empowered to fix the same both in the licence as well as the permit.

    35. Since no other contention was raised , the result is that the appeals are allowed . The judgments of the learned Judge are set aside. The Writ Petitions are dismissed with costs. Advocate's fee Rs. 100/- in each case and in each Court.

    36. Appeals allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Commissioner Of ... v. B. Bhogeswara Rao An...
    (Aug 7, 1973)