Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 465 read with Section 471, Indian Penal Code in R. C. 27/63.
  • Section (195 of the Code of Criminal Procedure)
  • Section 195 (1) (a), Criminial Procedure Code
  • Section 417 and 471, Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 182, 417 and 471, I. P. C. ...........P. Ws. 1
  • sub-section 156, Cr. P. C. was provision
  • Sections 182, 417 and 471, I. P. C.
  • Section 182 and 471, I. P. C.
  • Sections 172 to 188. I. P. C.
  • Section 195 (1) (a), Cr. P. C.
  • Section 155 (2) Cr. P. C........I
  • 15. Section 156, Cr. P. C.,
  • Section 195 (1), Cr. P. C."
  • Section 155 (2), Cr. P. C.
  • Section 258 (1), Cr. P. C."
  • Section 195(1) (a), Cr. P.
  • Section 251 (b), Cr. P. C.
  • Section 537, Cr. P. C.
  • Section 190, Cr. P. C.
  • Section 195, Cr. P. C.
  • Section 182, 1. P. C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 465 read with Section 471, Indian Penal Code in R. C. 27/63.
  • Section (195 of the Code of Criminal Procedure)
  • Section 195 (1) (a), Criminial Procedure Code
  • Section 417 and 471, Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 182, 417 and 471, I. P. C. ...........P. Ws. 1
  • sub-section 156, Cr. P. C. was provision
  • Sections 182, 417 and 471, I. P. C.
  • Section 182 and 471, I. P. C.
  • Sections 172 to 188. I. P. C.
  • Section 195 (1) (a), Cr. P. C.
  • Section 155 (2) Cr. P. C........I
  • 15. Section 156, Cr. P. C.,
  • Section 195 (1), Cr. P. C."
  • Section 155 (2), Cr. P. C.
  • Section 258 (1), Cr. P. C."
  • Section 195(1) (a), Cr. P.
  • Section 251 (b), Cr. P. C.
  • Section 537, Cr. P. C.
  • Section 190, Cr. P. C.
  • Section 195, Cr. P. C.
  • Section 182, 1. P. C.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Superintendent-in-charge, Central Telegraph Office (C.T.O.), Vijayawada, filed a complaint on 13-11-1963 in the Court of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Vijayawada, alleging offences under Sections 182, 417 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code and invoking Section 195(1)(a) Cr.P.C. The complaint arose out of a requisition sent on 9-7-1962 requesting candidates for appointment as telegraph peons and concerned a transfer certificate (Ex. P.2) with an endorsement (Ex. P.3) which the accused reportedly produced.

The Magistrate took the case on file, examined seven prosecution witnesses (P.W.s 1–7), questioned the accused, and on 2-5-1964 framed charges under Sections 182 and 471 IPC. The accused pleaded not guilty and produced no defence witnesses. The Magistrate framed four points for consideration: (1) whether the Court could take cognizance; (2) whether police could investigate a non-cognizable case without Magistrate's orders; (3) whether the prosecution proved offences under Sections 182 and 471 IPC; and (4) relief. On Points Nos. 1 and 2 the Magistrate found against the prosecution and acquitted the accused under Section 258(1) Cr.P.C. The State (through the learned Public Prosecutor) appealed against the acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court can take cognizance of the offences alleged (i.e., whether the complaint complied with Section 195 Cr.P.C.).
  2. Whether the police could investigate a non-cognizable offence without the orders of a competent Magistrate (i.e., the effect of Section 155(2) Cr.P.C. on the investigation).
  3. Whether the prosecution had made out a case under Sections 182 and 471 IPC.
  4. What relief should be granted based on the findings on the above issues.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Daulat Ram v. State of Punjab Interprets Section 195 Cr.P.C.: the complaint must be in writing by the public servant "concerned" (the appropriate public servant occupying the relevant office), and courts shall take cognizance only on such complaint. The court relied on this decision to explain that the "public servant concerned" for Section 195(1)(a) is the holder of the office (Superintendent-in-charge, C.T.O., Vijayawada) rather than the individual civil name of a former holder; consequently the Magistrate's finding that no proper public-servant complaint had been filed was incorrect.
Rishbud v. State of Delhi, AIR 1955 SC 196 Explains Section 156 Cr.P.C.: empowers officer-in-charge of a police station to investigate cognizable cases without Magistrate's order; subsection (2) cures defects as to the officer's authority; investigation defects do not necessarily affect the competence to take cognizance. The court cited this authority to hold that defects or irregularities in investigation do not automatically vitiate the proceedings or affect the court's jurisdiction to take cognizance; such defects must be shown to have occasioned a failure of justice.
Munnalal v. State of Uttar Pradesh Approves the passage from Rishbud: irregularity in investigation does not render trials illegal unless miscarriage of justice is shown; absence of objection during trial undermines later challenge. The court invoked this to support the proposition that trial initiated by a complaint of the Superintendent-in-charge was not vitiated simply because the Circle Inspector had investigated without an order under Section 155(2) Cr.P.C., absent any shown prejudice or miscarriage of justice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court examined the Magistrate's findings on Points Nos. 1 and 2 and found them unsustainable for the following principal reasons, relying on statutory provisions and the cited precedents:

  • On Point No. 1 (Section 195 Cr.P.C.): The court explained that Section 195 requires a complaint in writing by the public servant "concerned." By reference to Daulat Ram v. State of Punjab, the court interpreted "public servant concerned" to mean the holder of the relevant office (the Superintendent-in-charge, C.T.O., Vijayawada), whoever occupied that office at the time the complaint was filed. The Magistrate's reasoning that there was "no evidence connecting the alleged complaint with the proceedings" and that the complaint had not been filed by the appropriate public servant was incorrect because the complaint had been filed by V. Sambandham, who was the Superintendent-in-charge when he signed and filed the complaint. The court also noted an inconsistency: the Magistrate himself had taken the case on file.
  • On Point No. 2 (police investigation under Section 155(2) Cr.P.C.): The Magistrate held that Section 155(2) barred police investigation into a non-cognizable offence without magistrate's orders and found no such orders on record. The appellate court observed that P.W.7 (the Inspector of Police) had deposed that he obtained orders from the IV City Magistrate, Hyderabad, and this statement was neither challenged in cross-examination nor queried by the Magistrate. If the Magistrate had doubts, he could have asked P.W.7 for the order or required it to be placed on record. Thus, the Magistrate's conclusion on Section 155(2) was not justified by the state of the record.
  • The court then addressed the legal effect of irregularities in investigation. Relying on Section 156 and on Rishbud and Munnalal, the court stated that an irregularity or illegality in investigation does not directly affect the competence of the Court to take cognizance or the validity of proceedings unless it is shown that such irregularity occasioned a miscarriage of justice. The court noted that the proceedings here were initiated by a complaint filed by the Superintendent-in-charge (a public servant) rather than by a police charge-sheet, and therefore it was not fatal that the police had investigated (even if without a properly produced Section 155(2) order).
  • The appellate court concluded that the Magistrate's acquittal rested solely on procedural findings concerning improper initiation (an alleged failure under Section 195(1)(a)) and improper investigation (an alleged breach of Section 155(2)), without adjudicating the merits (Points Nos. 3 and 4). The court held that such procedural defects, as found by the Magistrate, did not justify acquittal without examining the substantive evidence; therefore the Magistrate's findings on Points Nos. 1 and 2 were not tenable.
  • Accordingly, the court directed that the lower Magistrate should reconsider Points Nos. 3 and 4 (the merits and relief) in the light of the appellate court's findings on Points Nos. 1 and 2.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appellate court ALLOWED THE APPEAL, set aside the Magistrate's judgment of acquittal, and directed the learned Magistrate to dispose of the case on its merits after giving findings on Points Nos. 3 and 4 in light of the appellate court's determinations on Points Nos. 1 and 2.

Implications: The direct effect is that the accused's acquittal has been reversed and the trial court has been ordered to decide the substantive issues (whether offences under Sections 182 and 471 IPC were made out and the appropriate relief) after considering the evidence. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying and distinguishing existing authorities; it relied on established Supreme Court decisions (Daulat Ram, Rishbud, Munnalal) and statutory provisions to support its decision.

    The Public Prosecutor v. Mohammed Ali Accused-.

    JUDGMENT

    1. The learned Public Prosecutor has filed this appeal against the judgment of the Second Additional District Munsif Magistrate, Vijayawada, acquiting the sole accused altogether.

    2. The relevant facts are as follows.

    3. The Superintendent-in-charge, Central Telegraph Office, Vijayawada, filed a complaint on 13-11-1963, in the Court of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Vijayawada, in which he stated as follows:-

    "Complaint filed under Section 195 (1) (a), Criminial Procedure Code for offences under Sections 182, 417 and 471, I. P. C.

    The Superintendent-in-charge, Central Telegraph Office, Vijayawada, sent a requisition to the Sub-Regional Employment Officer, Vijayawada, on 9-7-1962 requesting him to send candidates for appointment as telegraph peons.................

    SD/- Complainant, Superintendent-in-charge, C. T. O., Vijayawada."

    4. The learned Magistrate, Sri G. Pulliah, took it on file making an endorsement as follows:-

    "Taken on file on 13-11-63 under Section 417 and 471, Indian Penal Code. Issue summons to the accused ..........."

    5. The prosecution examined seven witnesses. Of these, H. A. D. Monte (P. W. 1) was the Superintendent, C. T. O. Vijayawada, who called for application in July 1963 and before whom the accused is said to have produced transfer certificate (Ex. P. 2) with endorsement (Ex. P. 3) which is said to be the subject-matter of the charges. He deposed that he filed them in the office. Subsequently, one V. Sambandham became the Superintendent in the same office, in place of P. W. 1. He gave a complaint to the police, complaining of the offence. The Inspector of Police (P. W. 7) registered the crime under Section 465 read with Section 471, Indian Penal Code in R. C. 27/63. He deposed as follows:-

    "I obtained the orders from IV City Magistrate, Hyderabad on 7-8-83 to investigate in to the case under Section 155 (2) Cr. P. C........I submitted my report to S. I. S. P. F. Hyderabad........."

    Subsequently, on 13-11-1963 the Superintendent-in-charge of C. T. O. viz. V. Sambandham who had succeeded P. W. 1 (H. A D'monte) signed in complaint and filed it in Court. The learned Magistrate, who took the case on file examined the witnesses, P. Ws. 1 to 7. He questioned the accused on 22-1-1964 putting one single long question mentioning various items of evidence against him and the accused gave a single answer "I did not commit the offence". He examined P. Ws. 2 to 7 from 19-2-64 to 26-3-64. The learned Magistrate questioned the accused in detail and on 2-5-1964 the framed charges against him under Section 182 and 471, I. P. C. The accused pleaded "not guilty" and stated that he had no defence witness. Finally, the learned Magistrate delivered the Judgment on 30-6-1964.

    6. In the judgment, he framed four points for consideration as follows:-

    (1) Whether this Court can take cognizance of this case ?

    (2) Whether the Police can investigate into non-cognizable case without the orders of Magistrate ?

    (3) Whether the prosecution made out their case under Sections 182 and 471, I. P. C. ?

    (4) To what relief ?

    7. On point No. 1 the learned Magistrate held as follows: -

    "...........The charge sheet in this case was filed under Sections 182, 417 and 471, I. P. C. ...........P. Ws. 1 and w are the concerned officers who should have filed the complaint in this case. Neither of them nor their superior filed the complaint nor their superior file the complaint in this case. One V. Sambandham is said to have filed the complaint in the case. He is not examined as witnesses for the prosecution. There is no explanation as to why P. Ws. 1 and 2 who were the concerned officers or their superiors have not filed this complaint. There is no evidence connecting the alleged complaint with the proceedings of this case. Section 195, Cr. P. C. is mandatory provision which directs that Court shall take cognizance of the offences under Sections 172 to 188. I. P. C. only on the complaint of the public servant concerned or some other public servant to whom they are subordinates. There is no such complaint in this case as directed in Section 195 (1), Cr. P. C."

    On point No. 2, the learned Magistrate held as follows: -

    "The offence under Section 182 is a summons case which means a non-cognizable case as quoted above. Section 155 (2), Cr. P. C. bars the Police to investigate into a non-cognizable offence without the orders of the competent Magistrate. No such orders of the Magistrate have been filed and marked in this case. P. W. 7 is the Inspector of Police. He deposed that the obtained orders from the IV City Magistrate. Hyderabad on 7-8-1963 to investigate this case under Section 155 (2). Cr. P. C. No such orders have been filed in this case. Hence Section 155 (2). Cr. P. C. is a bar for the police to investigate into this case. I, therefore, find that the police shall not investigate into this case."

    He held on Points Nos. 3 and 4 as follows :-

    "Point No. 3:- In the light of the findings on points 1 and 2, there is no need to discuss and give a finding on this point.

    Point No. 4:- In the result, the accused is acquitted under Section 258 (1), Cr. P. C."

    Point No. 1:-

    8. The case of the prosecution was that the accused committed the offence with the accused committed the offence with which P. W. 1 was concerned in his official capacity as Superintendent of C. T. O. Vijayawada, and not in his personal capacity as an individual.

    9. If P. W. 1 had continued to be in office at the time of filing the complaint, and if he had filed the complaint, that complaint would have been in his official capacity as Superintendent and not in his individual capacity as Sri H. A. D'Monte. The public servant concerned under Section 195(1) (a), Cr. P. C.so far as this case is concerned was the Superintendent. C. T. O. Vijayawada, in his official capacity and not Sri H. A. D' Monte (P. W.1) in his individual capacity.

    10. The learned Magistrate has relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in Daulat Ram v. State of Punjab. . The learned Counsel for the accused in this Court also has sought to rely on that decision. In that case, one Daulat Ram, a patwari, was charged for the offence under Section 182, 1. P. C. for having given false complaint to the Tashildhar, his superior officer at Pathankot. Their Lordships observed in the Judgment as follows: - (at p. 1207)

    ".............The public servant who was moved by the appellant was undoubtedly the Thasildhar...........The question is therefore whether under the provisions of section 195, it was incumbent on the Thasildhar to present a complaint in writing against the appellant and not leave the Court to be moved by the police by putting in a charge-sheet .......... It was therefore incumbent, if the prosecution was to be launched, that the complaint in writing should be made by Tahsildar as the public servant concerned in this case. On the other hand what we find is that a complaint by the Tahsildar was not filed at all, but a charge-sheet was put in by the station house officer."

    Therefore, their Lordships referred to the public servant concerned as the Tahsildar and never referred to his name or to him in his personal capacity as a private individual. The decision is a direct authority to show that, in this case, the public servant concerned for the purpose of Section 195 (1) (a), Cr. P. C. was the Superintendent-in-charge of the C. T. O. Vijayawada. Whoever happened to occupy that post at the time of filing the complaint was the public servant concerned and could file the complaint. The post of C. T. O. was held at various times by persons as follows: -

    P. W. 2 M. J. Venkatesan - from 1-5-62 to 31-8-62.

    P. W. 1. H. A. D'monte - July 1963.

    Complainant V. Sambandham - Date of complaint (13-11-1963) and of filing of compliant.

    These passage relief upon by the learned Magistrate in the Judgment of the Supreme Court in Daulat Ram's case (supra) is as follows:-

    "There words of the Section (195 of the Code of Criminal Procedure) namely, that the complaint has to be in writing by the public servant concerned and that no Court shall take cognizance except on such a complaint clearly shows that in every instance the Court must be moved by the appropriate public servant....

    The words `no Court shall take cognizance' have been interpreted on more than one occasion and they show that there is an absolute bar against the Court manner provided by the section.............."

    This passage does not give any support to the view of the learned Magistrate. It has to be observed that the learned Magistrate himself had taken the case on file. The finding of the learned Magistrate on Point No. 1 is wrong.

    11. Point No. 2 : - P. W. 7 deposed that he had obtained order from the IVth City Magistrate, Hyderabad, for prosecution (vide portion extracted by me already from the judgment of the lower Court). This statement was not challenged up to cross-examination by the accused: nor any question was put by the learned Magistrate to P. W. 7 in the matter. If the learned Magistrate doubted the truth of the statement of P. W. 7, he could have put a question to him and if the learned Magistrate felt that a copy of that order should be filed in the Court, he could have called for such an order being filed or insisted on its being filed. If a valid order was filed in the Court or not. So, the action of the learned Magistrate in his finding on Point No. 2 is not justified and is untenable.

    12. When the learned Magistrate came to the conclusion on Points Nos. 1 and 2, the course adopted by him viz., acquittal of the accused was not correct or proper.

    13. In the present case, the proceedings were not initiated by the chargesheet filed by the Police but the Superintendent, C. T. O. who filed the complaint. As the complainant is a public servant, under the proviso (aa) to Section 200 Cr. P. there was no need for the complainant being examined on oath before taking the case on file. The learned Magistrate himself acted rightly on that basis by taking the case on file without examining the complainant, Sri V. Sambandham signed the complaint and filed it in Court as he was then holding the office of C. T. O. Each of Sri M. J. Venkatesan (P. W. 2) and H. A. D'Monte (P. W. 1) deposed as witness because he knew certain relevant facts as one who had occupied the office at certain relevant times. Therefore, the observation of the learned Magistrate `there is no evidence connecting the alleged complaint with proceedings of this case' has no significance. His observation that there was no explanation as to why P. Ws. 1 and 2 have not filed the complaint is based on a presumption which is wrong. There was no need for P. W. 1 or P. W. 2 to file the complaint. The proceedings were initiated by a complaint by some one other than police officer and not by a charge-sheet filed by police officer. The learned Magistrate himself accordingly followed the procedure which was not under Section 251-A but under Section 251 (b), Cr. P. C. In the circumstances, the fact that Police (P. W. 7) had made investigation was not of any importance and could not affect the validity of proceedings even if the Police (P. W. 7) had investigated without proper authority by way of order under Section 155 (2), Cr. P. C.

    14. The findings on Point Nos. 1 and 2 by learned Magistrate only related to defects by way of improper initiation, the complaint being filed by one who was not public servant under Section 195 (1) (a), Cr. P. C. and improper investigation, and as such the learned Magistrate ought not have acquitted the accused on those findings alone without going into merits of the case.

    15. Section 156, Cr. P. C., runs as follows: -

    "(1) Any officer in-charge of a Police Station may without the order of a Magistrate, investigate any cognizable case which a Court having jurisdiction over the local area within the limits of such station would have power to inquire into or try under the provisions of Chapter XV relating to the place of inquiry or trial.

    (2) No proceeding of a police officer in any such case shall at any stage be called in question on the ground that the case was one which such officer was not empowered under this section to investigate."

    16. In Rishbud v. State of Delhi, AIR 1955 SC 196, their Lordships of the Supreme Court have stated that sub-section 156, Cr. P. C. was provision empowering an officer in charge of a Police Station to investigate a cognizable case without the order of a Magistrate and delimiting his power to the investigation of such cases within a certain local jurisdiction and that it was the violation of this provision that was cured under sub-section (2). Under the explanation to Section 537, Cr. P. C. in determining whether any error, omission or irregularity in any proceedings under this Code has occasioned a failure of justice, the Court shall have regard to the fact whether the objection was taken by anybody up to the time of the judgment also does not state that such an objection was taken any time before the judgment was delivered.

    17. In (Supra.) it was observed by the Supreme Court as follows: (at pp. 203-204)

    "A defect or illegality in investigation, however serious had no direct bearing on the competence or the procedure relating to cognizance or the procedure relating to cognizance of trial. No doubt a police report which results from an investigation is provided in Section 190, Cr. P. C. as the material on which cognizance is taken. But it cannot be maintained that a valid and legal police report is the foundation of the jurisdiction of the Court to take cognizance........."

    18. In Munnalal v. State of Uttar Pradesh, , the above passage in Rishbud's case was extracted with approval and the following observation was made (at pp. 31-32).

    "In view of this decision, even if there was irregularity in the investigation and Section 5-A was not complied with in substance, the trials cannot be held to be illegal unless it is shown that miscarriage of justice has been caused on account of the illegal investigation. Learned Counsel for the appellant has been unable to show us how there was any miscarriage of justice in these cases at all due to the irregular investigation............

    In the present cases no objection was taken at the trial when it began and it was allowed to come to end......

    The appellant therefore cannot say that the trial was vitiated unless he can show that any prejudice was caused to him on account of the illegal or irregular investigation. We have already remarked that no such thing has been shown in this case nor was it possible to show any such thing in view of the alternative defence taken by the appellant............

    In the present case, there is no basis for holding that the trial which was held on a complaint by the Superintendent-in-charge C. T. O. (not a Police Officer) was in any way vitiated by the investigation of the Circle Inspector (P. W. &) even if his investigation has not been authorised by an order of the competent Magistrate under Sec. 155 (2), Cr. P. C.

    19. The findings of the learned Magistrate on Point Nos. 1 and 2 are, therefore, not tenable. Consequently, the judgment of acquittal which is based purely on the findings of the learned Magistrate on Point Nos. 1 and 2 is not tenable. In the light of the findings which I have given in this appeal on Point Nos. 1 and 2, Point Nos. 3 and 4 will have to be decided after going through the evidence. The learned Magistrate has not done that. Therefore, the proper course to be adopted by me now is to direct the learned Magistrate to give findings on Point Nos. 3 and 4 in the light of the findings which I have given on Point Nos. 1 and 2.

    20. In the result, I allow this appeal, set aside the judgment of acquittal and direct the learned Magistrate to dispose of the case on merits after giving findings on Points Nos. 3 and 4.

    HGP/ D. V. C.

    21. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Public Prosecutor v. Mohammed Ali Accused-.
    (Jun 30, 1967)