AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 41 of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 (hereinafter called the Act),
  • rules 5(1)(k) and 18(2), Madras General Sales Tax (Turnover and Assessment) Rules,
  • rule 18(2) of the Madras General Sales Tax (Turnover and Assessment) Rules,
  • section 5(iii) of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939.
  • section 5(5) of the Hyderabad General Sales Tax Act.13.
  • Madras General Sales Tax Act or the Rules
  • Sales Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 41 of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 (hereinafter called the Act),
  • rules 5(1)(k) and 18(2), Madras General Sales Tax (Turnover and Assessment) Rules,
  • rule 18(2) of the Madras General Sales Tax (Turnover and Assessment) Rules,
  • section 5(iii) of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939.
  • section 5(5) of the Hyderabad General Sales Tax Act.13.
  • Madras General Sales Tax Act or the Rules
  • Sales Tax Act
Smart Summary

Comprehensive Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a writ of certiorari (or any other appropriate writ) to call for and quash Notification No. 112, G.O.Ms No. 566, Revenue, dated nth March, 1960 (the "Notification"), issued under section 41 of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957. The Notification directed the addition of the following entry to Schedule III of the Act with effect from 1st April, 1960:

“12. Butter and ghee, at the point of purchase by the last dealer who buys in the State—4 naye Paise in the rupee.”

The petitioners are a registered partnership firm trading as G. Baliah Setty, B. Satyanarayana and Company, who export ghee outside Andhra Pradesh. They asserted that they purchased ghee largely from dealers who had earlier purchased butter and converted it into ghee, and that their vendors had already paid sales tax on butter. The petitioners contended that levying purchase tax on ghee at the point of last purchase would amount to double taxation of the same goods and would infringe their fundamental right under Article 19(1)(g). The State opposed the petition, disputed key factual assertions (including whether the petitioners' vendors had purchased butter and paid tax thereon), and defended the Notification as validly issued under section 41 of the Act.

The Court discharged the rule nisi, dismissed the petition with costs, awarded an advocate's fee of Rs. 100, and thereby upheld the Notification for the purposes of this application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Notification taxing both butter and ghee at the point of purchase results in double taxation contrary to section 5(5) (proviso) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957.
  2. Whether butter and ghee are the same goods (i.e., whether ghee is merely butter clarified/heated) such that taxing both would amount to taxing the same goods twice in the hands of different dealers.
  3. Whether the Notification issued under section 41 of the Act is ultra vires or otherwise unlawful so as to justify quashing by writ under Article 226.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Appellants') Arguments

  • The petitioners contend that ghee is effectively clarified butter produced by heating butter without altering its substance or quality, and therefore ghee and butter are the same goods.
  • Because their vendors had paid sales tax on butter, a further imposition of purchase tax on ghee purchased by the petitioners would be double taxation of the same goods.
  • The imposition of tax under the Notification threatens the petitioners with coercive recovery under the Sales Tax Act and amounts to infringement of Article 19(1)(g).

State (Respondent) Arguments

  • The State disputed the factual premise that the petitioners purchased only from dealers who had purchased butter and converted it to ghee; some vendors may have purchased ghee directly.
  • The assertion that ghee is merely butter and that taxing both would be double taxation was denied: butter and ghee undergo physical and chemical changes and have different properties; they are separate commodities for taxation.
  • The Notification was issued under the authority conferred by section 41 of the Act, did not contravene the Act, and did not offend public finance principles; the State maintained that taxing butter and ghee separately was permissible.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pullaiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh (1960 2 An. W.R. 39) The object of section 5(5) is not to tax a transaction twice; this does not imply a prohibition against levy of tax on products of the same commodity. The Court relied on this case to support the proposition that the proviso to section 5(5) does not forbid separate taxation of products derived from the same commodity (example: groundnut and groundnut oil); it informed the view that butter and ghee could be treated as distinct for taxation.
Kayani and Company v. Commissioner of Sales Tax [1953] 4 S.T.C 387; A.I.R. 1953 Hyd. 252 Illustration that a word denoting a commodity (rice) does not necessarily include a processed form (cooked rice). Cited with approval to support the position that processed products are not automatically the same as their raw form for purposes of the sales tax provisions.
Kosuri Subba Raju v. State of Andhra [1956] 7 S.T.C 479 That a product (nawar tape) could not be regarded as 'cloth' within the statutory definition; distinction between similar or derivative articles. Used as authority for treating manufactured/processed items as distinct from the raw article within the meaning of sales tax statutes.
Pithapuram Taluk Tobacco, Cigars and Soda Merchants' Union v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1958] 9 S.T.C 723 Country tobacco subject to single purchase point tax did not include cigars and cheroots produced from tobacco; manufactured articles could not be equated with the raw commodity. Relied upon to show that articles manufactured from the same raw material are not necessarily the "same goods" for the purposes of section 5(5) and related rules.
Berar Oil Industries v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Anantapur (citation in text) Authority cited in contexts considering whether processed powders or oils are the same as their raw ingredients. Grouped with other authorities to support the line that processed forms (e.g., powders, oils) may be treated as distinct commodities for taxation.
Anwarkhan Mehboob Co. v. State of Bombay (citation in text) Supreme Court authority distinguishing raw tobacco from bidi patti (processed form), supporting that processed articles are distinct. Relied upon in the Court's reasoning (via prior decisions) to support separation between raw commodity and processed product for sales tax purposes.
Kotak and Company v. State of Andhra Pradesh, T.R.C. No. 34 of 1961; [1962] 13 S.T.C 709 Held that cotton seeds (taxed at sale point) are not the same goods as cotton (taxed at purchase point); explained scope of clause (ii) of the proviso to section 5(5). The Court relied on this decision to illustrate that different dealers taxed on different products (cotton vs. cotton seeds) did not amount to double taxation of the same dealer, and to support the view that butter and ghee may be treated as distinct goods.
Chandramouleswara Oil Company, In re (referred to in text) Authority followed in prior decisions distinguishing processed products from raw materials for tax purposes. Used as part of the chain of authority confirming that products processed from a raw commodity need not be treated as identical with that raw commodity for taxation.
Tungabhadra Industries Ltd., Kurnool v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kurnool (Supreme Court decision; cited) Held that refined oil and hydrogenated groundnut oil continued to be 'groundnut oil' for the purpose of specified Madras rules because the statutory specification did not separately list refined/hydrogenated forms. The Court distinguished this case as inapposite: in that case the statute/rules did not separately list refined or hydrogenated oils, whereas in the present matter the Notification expressly lists butter and ghee as separate items.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court opened its analysis by examining the statutory scheme, focusing on section 5 (the charging section) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957, and particularly on the proviso to sub-section (5). The proviso contains two central clauses:

  • (i) In respect of the same transaction, either the buyer or the seller, but not both, shall be taxed as determined by prescribed rules;
  • (ii) Where a dealer has been taxed in respect of the purchase of any goods (in accordance with the rules), he shall not be taxed again in respect of any sale of such goods effected by him.

The Court interpreted these clauses to mean that they prevent taxation of the same transaction or the same dealer twice in respect of the same goods (i.e., one transaction one tax; and where a dealer has already been taxed as purchaser, he should not be taxed again on sale of the same goods). Critically, the Court observed that clause (ii) requires the same dealer to have been taxed both as purchaser and as seller of the same goods for the prohibition against double taxation to be attracted.

Applying that principle, the Court held that the present matter involved different dealers: purchasers of butter (some of the petitioners' vendors) and purchasers of ghee (the petitioners). Because different dealers were being taxed at their respective purchase points, the proviso's protection against taxing the same dealer twice did not apply. Therefore, under the literal operation of section 5(5) proviso, the identity of the goods between buyer and seller in different transactions was not decisive for the statutory bar against double taxation.

The Court further considered established authorities which had addressed whether processed products are to be regarded as the same goods as their raw materials for sales tax purposes. It reviewed prior decisions (including Pullaiah, Kayani, Kosuri Subba Raju, Pithapuram Taluk Tobacco, Kotak & Co., and others) that had recognized the legitimacy of taxing products and their derivatives separately unless the statute expressly provided otherwise. The Court concluded, following that line of cases, that butter and ghee—both of which were specifically enumerated as separate items in the Notification—could properly be treated as distinct commodities for taxation.

The Court also examined passages from the Encyclopaedia Britannica regarding the composition and preparation of butter and ghee. On that material the Court found that butter and ghee did not serve identical purposes in all respects—the passages described different preparation methods and different uses—reinforcing the legal conclusion that they need not be treated as identical commodities for tax purposes.

Procedurally and factually, the Court noted a key dispute of fact: the petitioners had not established that their vendors had paid purchase tax on butter in relation to all (or a sufficient portion) of the petitioners' purchases of ghee. The State disputed that factual premise, and the petitioners admitted that some vendors sold ghee itself. Because those factual issues (what proportion of purchases were from vendors who paid tax on butter) were unresolved and required investigation by the assessing authority, the Court declined to resolve them in writ proceedings under Article 226.

Finally, the Court observed that adequate alternative remedies existed under the Act if the assessing authority ignored the protections afforded by section 5(5), and that the petitioners had not availed themselves of those remedies. On these combined legal and procedural grounds the Court found no error of law or jurisdiction warranting issuance of the writ.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Rule nisi discharged; petition dismissed.

The Court rejected the petitioners' primary contention that the Notification amounted to unlawful double taxation and infringed Article 19(1)(g). It held that:

  • The proviso to section 5(5) of the Act bars taxation of the same dealer twice in respect of the same goods, but it does not prevent different dealers from being taxed on different transactions involving related or derivative products.
  • Given that the Notification expressly specified butter and ghee as separate items, the Court would not, as a matter of judicial policy, substitute its view for that of the Legislature and treat these two items as identical for tax purposes.
  • There existed unresolved factual disputes about whether the petitioners' vendors had in fact paid purchase tax on butter in relation to the petitioners' purchases; those disputes required inquiry by the assessing authority and could not be resolved in the present writ proceedings.

Direct consequences and practical implications:

  • The Notification was not quashed; the petitioners remain subject to the tax regime created by the Notification pending assessment and any statutory remedies.
  • The petition was dismissed with costs; an advocate's fee of Rs. 100 was awarded.
  • The Court emphasized that existing alternative remedies under the Act are available to the petitioners if, on assessment, the proviso to section 5(5) is not observed; the petition was therefore premature.
  • The decision applied and followed existing precedents rather than announcing a novel legal principle; no new broad precedent beyond the application of those authorities was created by this order.

    G. Baliah Setty, B. Satyanarayana & Co. v. The State Of Andhra Pradesh

    1. This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution for the issue of a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ calling for the records pertaining to the Notification No. 112, G.O.Ms No. 566, Revenue, dated nth March, 1960, and quash the same, and pass such other order or orders as this Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case.

    2. The relevant facts may briefly be noticed. The petitioners are a registered partnership firm doing business under the name and style of G. Baliah Setty, B. Satyanarayana and Company. They export ghee on a large scale to States outside Andhra Pradesh. The course of business adopted by them was to purchase ghee from dealers who purchased butter and converted it into ghee. The petitioners are the last purchasers of ghee in the State, and it is the petitioners' case that their vendors had already paid sales tax on their purchase turnover relating to butter, and, therefore, the ghee purchased by them cannot be subject to sales tax as it amounts to double taxation of the same goods. In other words, the petitioners' case is that ghee is only butter clarified to resemble oil, and is prepared by a process of heating butter without altering or changing the butter in substance or quality. The Government of Andhra Pradesh by a Notification G.O.Ms No. 566, Revenue, dated nth March, 1960, (hereinafter called “the Notification”) issued under section 41 of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 (hereinafter called “the Act”), directed the following item and the entry to be added to Schedule III of the Act, viz.,:

    “12. Butter and ghee, at the point of purchase by the last dealer who buys in the State—4 naye Paise in the rupee.”

    3. The said notification was made to come into force with effect from 1st April, 1960.

    4. It is contended that in and by means of this Notification both butter and ghee are subject to levy of purchase tax from the last purchaser of each of those goods, and that has the effect of double taxation, or taxing the same goods twice over, which is repugnant to the scheme of the Act, and opposed to law. The demand of tax from the petitioners on their purchase turnover under these circumstances is a threat by the State to realise it by using the coercive machinery of the Sales Tax Act and amounts to an infringement of their fundamental right guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution.

    5. The State resisted the petition contending, inter alia, that the allegation that the petitioners purchased ghee only from dealers who purchased butter and converted it into ghee is not a fact which is admitted, and there might be several cases in which the petitioners purchased ghee from their vendors, who might themselves have purchased ghee, but not butter. The statement of the petitioners that they purchased ghee from dealers who paid tax on purchase of butter is incorrect, and they are put to strict proof of the same. The contention that ghee is only butter, and that if ghee and butter are taxed it would amount to double taxation is unsustainable, and is a wrong and unwarranted assumption. Butter, on conversion to ghee, undergoes both physical and chemical changes, and properties in both of them are different and the taxation of those commodities separately would not amount to double taxation. Even assuming that some of the petitioners' vendors paid tax on butter, that did not prevent the authorities from taxing the ghee at the point of last purchase. The notification in question is under the authority of law conferred by section 41 of the Act, and does not contravene any of the provisions of the Act, nor is opposed to any notions of public finance.

    6. The only ground on which the notification in question is challenged as being illegal is that butter and ghee are one and the same goods, and that ghee is only clarified butter as a result of some heating. The tenability of this contention will be considered a little later.

    7. Sri Somasundaram further contends that as his vendors were taxed on their purchases of butter, the petitioners should not be taxed on their purchase of ghee. In order to fully appreciate this contention, the relevant statutory provisions imposing a restriction on double taxation may be considered.

    8. Section 5 of the Act, which is the charging section, lays down that (1) the dealers having a total turnover of Rs. 10,000 or more, (2) all casual traders, (3) all agents of non-resident dealers, (4) all dealers trading in goods specified in Schedule II (i.e, goods in respect of which a single point sales tax only is leviable), and (5) all dealers in goods specified in Schedule III (i.e, goods in respect of which a single point purchase tax only is leviable) irrespective of the turnover in cases falling under (2) to (5) shall be liable to tax. Sub-section (4) provides that the turnover on which a dealer shall be liable to pay tax shall be determined after making such deductions from his total turnover in the manner prescribed. Sub-section (5) lays down that the taxes shall be assessed, levied and collected in the manner prescribed, and then follows the proviso, which is material for the purpose of this case. It is as follows:

    “Provided that—

    (i) in respect of the same transaction, the buyer or the seller, but not both, as determined by such rules as may be prescribed, shall be taxed;

    (ii) where a dealer has been taxed in respect of the purchase of any goods, in accordance with the rules referred to in clause (i) of this proviso, he shall not be taxed again in respect of any sale of such goods effected by him.”

    9. The effect of this proviso may be stated thus. In respect of one and the same transaction, either the buyer or the seller, but not both, can be taxed; or, in other words, one transaction one tax. In every transaction of sale, one of the parties would be the seller, and the other would be the buyer, and, according to this clause, only one of them can be taxed, but not both. According to clause (ii), if the dealer is taxed in respect of the goods purchased by him in accordance with the rules referred to in clause (i) the same dealer shall not be taxed again in respect of any sale of the same goods effected by him. In order, therefore, that the inhibition in this sub-clause may be attracted, the same dealer must have purchased the goods, and paid the tax, and his sale turnover of the same goods is also sought to be taxed. Whether the goods purchased by him and the goods sold by him are identical or not, would therefore arise only in those cases, in which the same dealer is made liable for the tax twice.

    10. In the instant case, it is not the same dealer that is sought to be taxed twice, but different dealers, viz., purchasers of butter (assessee's vendors) and purchasers of ghee (the assessee) and the question of identity of goods would not therefore arise for consideration under the proviso to section 5. In this view, the question whether butter and ghee are identical commodities or goods need not be considered. The petitioner has not been able to establish that the notification offends section 5(5), proviso, in any manner whatsoever. Apart from this provision, he is not able to cite any authority for the proposition that an identical commodity cannot be the subject-matter of taxation in the hands of different individuals, On the other hand, the principle of multiple taxation is well-recognised in sales tax law, and under the Act that is the rule, and single point taxation, either on the point of purchase or sale, is an exception, and exists only where it is expressly provided for.

    11. In Pullaiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh 1960 2 An. W.R 39., a Bench of this Court considered the scope of section 5(5) and the proviso. The question for consideration in that case was, whether the Government order which permitted the imposition of tax both on groundnut as well as groundnut oil was valid. The contention was that the groundnut oil being the same commodity as groundnut, the oil extracted from the latter is not exigible to tax in view of section 5(5) of the Act. The learned Judges held that the object of section 5(5) of the Act is not to tax a transaction twice, but that did not imply a prohibition against the levy of tax on the products of the same commodity, and held that groundnut oil or cake would not answer the description of the same goods as groundnut within the enacting words of section 5(5) and followed the decision in Chandramouleswara Oil Company, In re2. They cited with approval Kayani and Company v. Commissioner of Sales Tax [1953] 4 S.T.C 387; A.I.R 1953 Hyd. 252., where it was held that rice could not be interpreted as meaning “cooked rice”. Reliance was also placed on Kosuri Subba Raju v. State of Andhra [1956] 7 S.T.C 479., where it was held that nawar tape (material woven in bands and used as mat for cots) could not be regarded as cloth within the definition of “cloth” under section 5(iii) of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939. They also relied on Pithapuram Taluk Tobacco, Cigars and Soda Merchants' Union v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1958] 9 S.T.C 723., where it was ruled that country tobacco which was subject to levy of sales tax at a single purchase point did not include cigars and cheroots; though produced from the same tobacco, the articles manufactured therefrom could not be regarded as tobacco. It was also pointed out that the fact that groundnut oil and groundnut or kernel are not one and the same commodity, is made plain by the fact that while groundnut oil is included in Schedule II as one of the goods in respect of which a single point sales tax was leviable at the sale point, “oil seeds” which include groundnut is one of the items enumerated in Schedule IV in regard to which a single point tax was leviable at the point of first purchase and that the Legislature would not have included these two commodities in two different Schedules if groundnut and groundnut oil constituted the same goods. On the other hand, it indicated that they are different commodities for the purpose of the Sales Tax Act.

    12. In W.P No. 183/5 of 1956, a Bench of this Court had to consider whether chillies and turmeric when powdered remain the same commodities, and attract the applicability of the second proviso. The learned Judges followed Pithapuram Taluk Tobacco, Cigars and Soda Merchants' Union v. State of Andhra Pradesh, Kosuri Subba Raju v. State of Andhra, Berar Oil Industries v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Anantapur, Kayani & Co. v. Commissioner of Sales Tax and Anwarkhan Mehboob Co. v. State of Bombay where the Supreme Court ruled that raw tobacco and bidi patti are distinct and different commercial articles, and held that the taxation of chilly powder and turmeric powder is not vitiated by the principle of double taxation, as they could not be regarded as the same goods, viz., chillies and turmeric respectively, within the range of proviso to section 5(5) of the Hyderabad General Sales Tax Act.

    13. We had to consider in Kotak and Company v. State of Andhra Pradesh T.R.C No. 34 of 1961 since reported at [1962] 13 S.T.C 709., whether a dealer who paid tax at the point of purchase on the cotton purchased by him could also be taxed at the point of the sale of cotton seeds. The contention raised was that cotton seeds formed part of the cotton, and that to tax the dealer on both the occasions amounts to double taxation. We held with reference to clause (ii) of proviso to section 5(5) thus:—

    “What is forbidden is, where a tax has been paid on the goods by the dealer as a purchaser, he shall not be taxed again in respect of any sale of such goods. It is, no doubt, true that the dealer as purchaser of cotton pays the tax on cotton at the purchase point under Schedule IV, item 5. But the goods taxed on the sale point is cotton seed under item 23 of Schedule II. As observed in the above case (Pithapuram Taluk Tobacco, Cigars and Soda Merchants' Union v. The State of Andhra Pradesh): ‘The policy of taxation is more appropriately the province of the statesmen and of the Legislature rather than of the lawyer or the Courts. It is a public policy dependent not only upon the necessities of administration but also implementation of the scheme to serve the public needs.’”

    14. We held in that case that cotton seeds cannot be said to be the same goods as cotton.

    15. Following these cases we hold that butter and ghee, which are mentioned in the notification as two different commodities, cannot be said to be the same goods.

    16. In support of his contention that butter and ghee are identical goods, Sri Somasundaram relied on the meaning of these words given in Encyclopaedia Britannica. In Volume 4, 1958 Edition, at page 468, the meaning of “butter” is as follows:

    “As the term is used most commonly, butter is the yellowish or whitish fat of cow's milk as flocculated or solidfied by churning. The commercial product contains not less than 80% and as much as 85% milk fat, 12% to 16% water, about 2% salt (mostly added) and about 1% milk curd. The fat consists of glycerides of perhaps eight acids, among them oleic, stearic, palmitic and butyric. The recognized high food value of butter depends predominently on high food energy, approximately 716 cal. per 100 grams, plus high vitamin A value of about 3,300 international units (annual average) per 100 grams, and substantial amounts of vitamin D. Protein is low, as are vitamins other than A and D, but about 20 mg. of calcium and 16 mg. of phosphorus are present per 100 grams.

    It has long been used and relished by man as a spread in tea and as a cooking fat.

    Much of Indian consumption is of a semifluid, clarified form called ghee.”

    17. In Volume 10 of Encyclopaedia Britannica, 1953 Edition, at page 323, it is stated thus:

    “Ghee, clarified butter used in India (Hindu, ghi). The best is prepared from butter of the milk of cows, the less esteemed from that of buffaloes. The butter is melted over a slow fire and set aside to cool; the thick, opaque, whitish, and more fluid portion, or ghee, representing the greater bulk of the butter, is then removed. The less liquid residue mixed with groundnut oil, is sold as an inferior kind of ghee. It may be obtained also by boiling butter over a clear fire, skimming it the while, and, when all the water has evaporated, straining it through a cloth.

    “In India, ghee is one of the commonest articles of diet, and indeed enters into the composition of everything eaten by the Brahmins. It is also extensively used in Indian religious ceremonies, being offered as a sacrifice to idols, which are at times bathed in it. Sanskrit treatises on therapeutics describe ghee as cooling, emollient, and stomachic, as capable of increasing the mental powers, and of improving the voice and personal appearance, and as useful in eye-diseases, tympanitis, painful dyspepsia, wounds, ulcers, and other affections. Old ghee is in special repute among the Hindus as a medicinal agent, and its efficacy as an external application is believed by them to increase with its age.”

    18. Even on a consideration of these passages, we cannot say that ghee and butter serve identical purposes, though as an article of food, ghee may be an equally good substitute for butter.

    19. Whatever it may be, when the Legislature has treated these two as two different articles in the notification for the purpose of taxation, it is not the province of Courts to question the policy of the Legislature underlying it.

    20. Reliance was also placed on behalf of the petitioners on the recent decision of the Supreme Court in Tungabhadra Industries Limited, Kurnool v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kunool. In that case, the assessee claimed deduction under rule 18(2) of the Madras General Sales Tax (Turnover and Assessment) Rules, on groundnut, and/or kernel purchased by him and converted into refined oil, or hydrogenated oil. As the raw groundnut oil is converted into refined oil, the processing consisted merely in removing from raw groundnut oil that constituent part of the raw oil which is not really oil, but consisted of free fatty acids, phospotides and unsaponifiable matter, and after the removal of that non-oleic matter the oil continues to be groundnut oil, and nothing more. In other words, the processing consisted in the non-oily content of the raw oil being separated and removed, rendering the oily content of the oil 100 per cent. and, therefore, refined oil continued to be groundnut oil within the meaning of rules 5(1)(k) and 18(2), Madras General Sales Tax (Turnover and Assessment) Rules, notwithstanding that such oil does not possess the characteristic colour or taste, odour, etc., of the raw groundnut oil. With respect to the hydrogenated groundnut oil it was held by the Supreme Court that there was no use to which the groundnut oil can be put for which the hydrogenated oil could not be used, nor is there any use to which the hydrogenated oil could not be put for which the raw oil could not be used, and that hydrogenated oil still continues to be “groundnut oil”, notwithstanding the processing, which is merely for the purpose of rendering the oil more stable thus improving its keeping qualities for those who desire to consume groundnut oil, and it was held that in respect of hydrogenated oil also the assessee was entitled to the deduction of the purchase price of the kernel or groundnut under rule 18(2).

    21. We fail to see how this case can be of any assistance to the petitioner. In this case, the Madras General Sales Tax Act or the Rules or Notification did not specify refined oil and hydrogenated groundnut oil as different commodities for purposes of taxation. The groundnut oil alone was the commodity specified, and the question for consideration was, whether refined oil and hydrogenated oil could also be treated as groundnut oil, or something different. But, in the instant case, butter and ghee having been specified as two different commodities by the Legislature for reasons best known to it, it is not open to the Court to canvass whether they are really different or identical.

    22. The contention that the implementation of the notification amounts to double taxation forbidden by the Act, therefore, fails.

    23. Apart from the above objections, there is yet another ground on which the writ petition should fail. The petitioners assert that their dealers had paid tax on butter at the purchase point. That fact is disputed by the State. Even the petitioners had to admit that their vendors did not purchase all the butter, and melt it into ghee. There are some who purchased ghee itself and sold it to the petitioners. That being the case, the facts require to be investigated as to what proportion of the assessee's purchase turnover was from dealers who paid tax on butter. All these have not yet been enquired into by the assessing authority. This Court is ill-suited for, and cannot enter into, an investigation of disputed questions of fact in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226. There is thus no error of law, much less of jurisdiction, justifying the issue of a writ.

    24. Further, the Act provides adequate and effective alternative remedies to the petitioner in the event of the provisions of section 5(5) of the Act being ignored by the assessing authority, and they have not been availed of by the petitioners. In this view, the petition is premature. For all these reasons, the petition fails. The rule nisi is discharged, and the petition is dismissed with costs.

    25. Advocate's fee Rs. 100.

    26. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    G. Baliah Setty, B. Satyanarayana & Co. v. The State Of Andhra Pradesh
    (Apr 20, 1962)