Hon'ble Bala Krishna Narayana,J.
Heard Sri Shambhu Chopra, learned counsel for the appellant.
This is an appeal under the Service Tax Act against the order of the Tribunal
dated 17.04.2009 by which the Tribunal has set aside the penalty.
The opposite party was acting as a agent, arranging the loan for the purchase
of vehicle as a marketing agent from I.C.I.C.I. Bank and received commission
from I.C.I.C.I. Bank. The Central Excise Authority, who was authorized to
levy the service tax was of the view that the opposite party was liable to pay
service tax from July 2003 under the Business Auxiliary Service for the
period from July 2003 to November 2004.
It appears that the assessee had paid service tax partly in the month of
December 2004 alongwith interest partly before the issue of show cause
notice and balance amount before passing of the adjudication order. There is
no dispute about the levy of service tax on the commission received by the
assessee from I.C.I.C.I. Bank. However, Central Excise Authority has levied
penalty under Section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994. Against the imposition of
the penalty the assessee filed the appeal which has been allowed by the
Tribunal. The Tribunal held as follows:
" After hearing both sides and on perusal of the records, it appears that there
was doubt regarding levy of tax on commission by the authorized automobile
dealers which working as " directing marketing agent" of I.C.I.C.I. Bank for
providing services to various customers for purchasing vehicles on loan, was
clarified by the Board's circular dated 06.11.2006. In the present case, the
appellants were engaged in providing service to different customers who were
purchasing vehicles by getting loan from financial institutions and the
appellants were receiving commissioner on the loan arranged by them. It is
seen that the appellants paid the tax in December, 2004 partly. There is no
mala fide on part of the appellants and, therefore, imposition of penalty under
Section 78 of the Finanace Act, 1994 is not warranted. It is noticed that
service tax was introduced on the activities of the appellants in July, 2003 and
the appellants paid the tax voluntarily in December, 2004 with interest. After
considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I find that the dispute
relates to new levy and the appellant paid the tax partly before issue of show
cause notice and the balance amount before issue of Adjudication Order.
Payment of tax was not disputed by them. Hence, it is a fit case to invoke
Section 80 of the Act. Hence, penalty imposed on the appellant are set-aside.
Demand of duty is upheld. Appeal is allowed with consequently relief."
Sri Shambhu Chopra, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that under
Section 80 of the Finance Act, 1984 the penalty can be waived only if the
assessee proves that there was a reasonable cause. In the present case, he fails
to prove the reasonable cause, therefore the Tribunal was not justified in
setting aside the penalty.
We do not find any substance in the argument of learned counsel for the
appellant. Having regard to the facts and circumstances as recorded and the
findings that the service tax was introduced for the first time in July 2003. By
the Boards Circular dated 06.11.2006, it has been clarified that the service tax
leviable on a marketing agent of I.C.I.C.I. Bank for providing service to
authorize customers for purchasing vehicles on loan and further that the
assessee has partly paid the amount alongwith the interest in the month of
December 2004 and there was no mala fide on the part of the appellant and
further the balance amount has been paid partly before the show cause notice
and partly before the adjudication order. We are of the view that Tribunal has
rightly held that this is a fit case to invoke Section 80 of the Act.
On the facts and circumstances of the case, we do not see any error in the
order which requires any interference by this court.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed.
Order Date :- 5.1.2010
YK