Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 161 Cr. P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 161 Cr. P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from the judgment and order dated 15-4-1978 passed by Sri S.K Verma, the then Vth Additional District and Sessions Judge, Bareilly, convicting the accused-appellants Hira Lal, Pathi Ram, and Bankey under Section 307/34 IPC and sentencing them to four years of rigorous imprisonment each. The appeal was heard on 24-3-1999, approximately 25 years after the original conviction. The trial court record was not available, and reconstruction was not possible; only the police case diary was accessible, which was insufficient for deciding the appeal on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of the accused-appellants can be maintained in the absence of the trial court record.
  2. Whether a remand for retrial is justified after a long delay of approximately 25 years.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The learned counsel for the appellants argued that without the trial court record, the conviction cannot be upheld.
  • He contended that even ordering a retrial would be unjustified given the 25-year delay since the appeal came up for hearing.
  • He relied on the Division Bench authority of Sita Ram v. State, 1981 Cri LJ 65, emphasizing the necessity of trial court records for a proper appeal and highlighting the prejudice caused by long delays in retrial.
  • The counsel also cited subsequent Division Bench decisions that followed the principles laid down in Sita Ram v. State.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sita Ram v. State, 1981 Cri LJ 65 Necessity of trial court record for hearing appeals; retrial may be ordered if delay is short; retrial unjust if record lost and long delay exists. The court relied heavily on this precedent to hold that without the trial court record, the conviction cannot be affirmed and that retrial is unjust due to the 25-year delay.
Ram Nath v. State, 1981 All Cri R 431 Followed the principles in Sita Ram regarding lost trial records and retrial. Cited to support the non-maintenance of conviction without trial court record and the impracticality of retrial after long delay.
Daya Ram v. State, 1992 Suppl ACC 219 Followed the Sita Ram principle on lost trial records and retrial considerations. Used as supporting authority for the court’s decision not to uphold conviction or order retrial.
Aziz Khan v. State of U.P, 1992 (29) All Cri C 223 Affirmed the approach to appeals where trial records are lost and delay is substantial. Reinforced the court’s conclusion that retrial would be futile and conviction cannot be affirmed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged the absence of the trial court record, which is essential for a proper appellate hearing to assess the merits of the conviction. The only available material, the police case diary, was insufficient for this purpose. The court analyzed the principles established in Sita Ram v. State and subsequent decisions, which hold that without the trial record, affirming conviction is impermissible. Furthermore, the court considered the extensive delay of over 25 years since the incident, which would render a retrial unjust and impractical due to the unavailability or fading memory of witnesses and loss of crucial documents like FIRs and statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C. The court concluded that ordering a retrial would impose undue hardship on all parties and would not serve justice.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The conviction of the accused-appellants Hira Lal, Pathi Ram, and Bankey under Section 307/34 IPC is set aside, and they are acquitted of the offence. Their bail bonds are cancelled and sureties discharged.

Implications: The decision directly affects the parties by acquitting the accused and negating the prior conviction due to procedural deficiencies and the impracticality of retrial after a prolonged delay. The court did not set any new legal precedent but applied established principles regarding lost trial records and appellate procedure.

    Hira Lal And Others v. State Of U.P

    1. This is an appeal against the judgment and order dated 15-4-1978 passed by Sri S.K Verma, the then Vth Additional District and Sessions Judge, Bareilly in S.T No. 396 of 1975, whereby he has convicted the accused-appellants Hira Lal, Pathi Ram and Bankey of the offence under Section 307/34 IPC and sentenced each one of them to undergo R.I for a period of 4 years.

    2. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants and the learned A.G.A

    3. In this case, as per the report of the District Judge, the trial Court record was not available and the record could not be reconstructed and only the case diary of the police relating to the case could be available which could be of no avail for deciding this appeal on merits.

    4. Learned counsel for the appellants has ar gued that in the absence of the record of the trial Court, the conviction of the accused-appellants cannot be maintained.

    5. He has further argued that in this case even a remand for retrial also would not be justified while the appeal has come up for hearing before this Hon'ble Court today on 24-3-1999 i.e after a period of 25 years. In support of his contention, he has placed reliance on the following observations of a Division Bench authority Sita Ram v. State, 1981 Cri LJ 65 in which it has been held (Para 11):

    “Where it is not possible to reconstruct the record which has been lost or destroyed it is not legally permissible of the appellant Court to affirm the conviction of the appellant since perusal of the record of the case is one of the essential elements of the hearing of the appeal. The appellant has a right to try to satisfy the appellate Court that the material on record did not justify his conviction and that right cannot be denied to him. We are further of the opinion that if the time lag between the date of the incident and the date on which the appeal comes up for hearing is short, the proper course would be to direct retrial of the case since witnesses normally would be available and it would not cause undue strain on the memory of witnesses. Copies of FIR, statements of witnesses under Sec. 161 Cr. P.C reports of medical examination etc. would also be normally available if the time gap between the incident and the order of retrial is not unduly long. Where, however, the matter comes up for consideration after a long gap of years, it would neither be just nor proper to direct retrial of the case, more so when even copies of FIR and statements of witnesses under Section 161 Cr. P.C and other relevant papers have been weeded out or are otherwise not available. In such a situation even if witnesses are available, apart from the fact that heavy strain would be put on the memory of witnesses, it would not be possible to test their statements made at the trial with reference to the earlier version of the incident and the statements of witnesses recorded during investigation. Not only that the accused will be prejudiced but even the prosecution would be greatly handicapped in establishing its case and the trial would be reduced to a mere formality entailing agony and hardship to the accused and waste of time, money and energy of the State”.

    6. He has also pointed out that this authority has been followed by three other Division Bench authorities of this Court:

    (1) 1981 All Cri R 431 (Ram Nath v. State).

    (2) 1992 Suppl ACC 219 (Daya Ram v. State).

    (3) 1992 (29) All Cri C 223 (Aziz Khan v. State of U.P).

    7. In view of these authorities, it is plain that the conviction of the accused-appellants cannot be affirmed in the absence of hearing of the appeal on merits with the help of the trial Court record. The case diary could be of no help without the Trial Court record.

    8. In the present case, even retrial cannot be justly and fairly ordered and would also be futile since the time gap between the occurrence and today's date when the appeal come up for hearing is more than 25 years.

    9. Consequently, the appeal is allowed. The conviction of the accused appellants Hira Lal, Pothi Ram and Bankey for the offence under Section 307/34 IPC is set aside and both of them are acquitted of the said offence. They are on bail from this Court. They need not surrender to it. Their bail bonds are cancelled and sureties discharged.

    10. Let a copy of this judgment be sent to the learned Sessions Judge, Bareilly for information and necessary compliance in the records.

    11. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hira Lal And Others v. State Of U.P
    (Mar 24, 1999)